News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by pmalynin on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @10:48PM (#8727584)
It'd be interesting to see a system where a government had a GitHub and people could submit laws as pull-requests
Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by timothya on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @01:51AM (#8727996)
Unfortunately, such a system would be very difficult for U.S. law. See this previous discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3968653
Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by vezzy-fnord on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @11:01PM (#8727622)
Has a body of theory, but is still in very early stages: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E-Government

That said, there would have to be some guarantee of an active political process behind it. Most likely scenario is that it becomes a largely ignored dumping ground, similar to your average petition site.

Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by gelatocar on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @11:16PM (#8727661)
I think Open-source governance is pretty relevant here as well: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open-source_governance
Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by oscargrouch on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @11:44PM (#8727728)
And if you think that we (coders) use it to control a source code, that will be turned into a program, or platform..

Now, if the "source code" is projects, laws, discussions, and once this process reach some goal, this could be "compiled" and the resulting platform would be a full State managed in digital form..

Now imagine all this together with automation, the compiled platform (which is "The State") can launch given its program (legislation) not only a way humans control themselves but how automated systems can help us with that..

I mean besides something like robots, a police car would receive the new "program", so the cops would abide to the current legislation.. the car could have cameras and detect if crimes or other things happens, according to the program it has, the federal constitution, etc.. this is just a glimpse

In a IOT world, a government that had automated all of its platforms, machines, etc.. given a current state of a Government platform, a binary, that could flow and update everywhere, with the current laws

Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by jsprogrammer on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @12:23AM (#8727818)
Yeah, let's please not automate the cops, or anything with a weapon.
Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by sebastianavina on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @11:51PM (#8727747)
Only if laws were redacted in org-mode.
Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by johnnyg on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @10:55PM (#8727600)
This is a serious and important idea.
Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by j2kun on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @11:00PM (#8727617)
Could you explain why? It seems like just as strange a technological barrier (for the average citizen) as the current process of proposing a law.
Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by Abundnce10 on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @11:38PM (#8727717)
Imagine if we could analyze a current law (ex. Computer Fraud & Abuse Act) and tweak the parts that are being abused or used in a way that they weren't intended. Or each time a law is added (merged with Master branch) we could see who voted in favor of that law (i.e. greater transparency). Other countries could take our constitution/laws up to a certain point (commit) and then branch off and implement their own approach. There are many ways we could utilize git to improve how laws are created/modified/deleted.

Laws are just rules and processes humans have come up with in a best effort to guide society in the right direction, no different than code is just logic programmers come up with to direct servers and clients to interact in a desired way. We've realized the importance of version control in the software realm, it's time to take it's powerful properties and apply it to the political sphere.

Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by desas on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @03:35PM (#8731518)
Wait, isn't there already a website which lists who voted which way in the united states? If not that's astounding.
Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by toomuchtodo on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @11:11PM (#8727647)
The average citizen can use Twitter, which has been pivotal in recent revolutions. The Github/git process and format brings something that is crucial to the political process we've been missing: transparency.
Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by alfiedotwtf on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @11:21PM (#8727679)
And to add, it would be cool to put them in a repo when introduced, see history of where they are amended and by who, and then after they are passed see links beside each passage every time they are referenced in court.
Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by toomuchtodo on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @12:18AM (#8727804)
Also, have the entire thing versioned/archived into the Internet Archive.
Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by johnnyg on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @12:03AM (#8727772)
I'll try.

I think the founders got an impressive amount of the "free and open nation" concepts right.

I think the Sears and Roebuck Catalog was an effective tool in its time.

I would rather order from an online store than the Sears and Roebuck Catalog. It'll be faster, more responsive, more transparent experience. The store owners intend it and the internet as a medium allows it to a greater extent than was previously possible.

I wouldn't want to run a company without the internet and I think the core and true functions of our government are not run at web speed or with web transparency.

I feel very disconnected from my elected representatives. I suspect this is a shared feeling. It is hard for me to see them "put out work" and hard for me to understand how good a job they do at anything past staying visible.

This is because we still use the best system available to us 150 years ago. What is the best system used today to collaborate? Git. What's the best place to use it? Github.

Look at the crazy stuff we are able to build using that tool. Truly we're living the buzz words and "harnessing the internet".

I'd rather have 100 OSS project leads deciding government policy than our current 100 senators. I value the culture and medium by which they arrive at decisions so much that I'd make that choice "blind", meaning if I didn't know how red or blue they were, I'd still do it. I think the process/medium/culture is strong enough to override any level of partisan feelings.

Were this to occur. Were laws github repos on various topics and proposals were pull requests and amendments were patches we'd have a few core changes.

1. We'd move from fixed terms to respect based terms. Instead of power brokers and entrenched incumbents it'd be about output and the share of a community that continues to be willing to line up behind your vision.

2. Forks. Governments as currently implemented don't allow iterations. Wouldn't it be interesting to declare your county a fork of the "MIT Common Government License" or to yearly declare which license you will abide by. Too hard? Depends on the delivery medium.

3. Education. I increasing hear leaders calling people "folks". I'm a citizen. You're a citizen. I'm obligated to be educated for our democracy to work. When the medium changed we got Khan Academy, CodeSchool and 100s of similar things. I think the impact of this great good is yet to be felt but it gives me hope that these new medium skills can be learned to an extent where they form a basis of participation.

Right now a political party is strong if it can get people out to check the right box or out in the street to yell. Wouldn't it really be something if strength was in number of upvoted feature pushes? Number of accepted patches?

4. Voting. It is hard to vote with your feet. It is easy to vote with a +1. I trust upvotes for my products (amazon), jokes (reddit) and computer news (HN). We can't evaluate new ideas on a technical and work flow basis the same way? Seems like we can and should. Seems like checking one box every 4 years or even every local election seems grossly slow.

Today I'd like to upvote the "stop torturing people" pull request. I feel like this is reasonable and we could get traction on this. I feel like tomorrow morning the draft could be ready and public viewable. The patch could be vetted and merged next week. In public. At the speed of OSS.

Instead, this will be today's news item. Tomorrow it'll fade into the next one. The senators will ultimately decide behind closed doors and the decision will be the wrong one, influenced in the wrong way - not because they're evil or even ill intentioned, but simply because we work in the wrong medium.

Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by jsprogrammer on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @12:22AM (#8727811)
I think you're on the right track, but it's a bit more complicated than just 'moving to github'.

For example, majority voting isn't always the best solution to every problem. Should court cases be decided like a reddit link where most people don't read the content, or the highest comment is a stupid pun?

I have no doubt that our institutions need to be updated and/or replaced, but it will likely have to be done piecemeal to minimize negative disruptions.

There are a lot of (technical) problems that will need to be solved to support such a system.

Don't forget that you'll need to convince everyone else in the country to switch to the new system.

Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by johnnyg on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @09:23AM (#8729244)
Good points.

I think the jury system works so well because 12 people in a room eliminates the need for web speed to a large extent.

Court cases should not be decided but facebook upvotes.

On the other side, I work in the medical field and I see decades of lost progress because "this is so important it should be heavily regulated" which has the opposite effect.

So...what's so important that is shouldn't be facebook upvote decided and will the "super important issues" system we replace it with be scalable and transparent enough to do the job?

I'll think on this. It seems like both answers aren't good enough.

Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by random8799 on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @11:09AM (#8729865)
Reddit is a perfect example on why democracy fails. If you culture/condition humans to behave/act stupid to appeal to one another for affection, you garner no substance or value. Their deltas are null.

Perhaps a new society/culture/civilization derived from a categorical intelligence is needed. Then we could analyze our resources, grow our culture based off this data, and evolve ourselves out of the current stupidity that exists today.

Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by j2kun on Thursday December 11, 2014 @10:58AM (#8735433)
I think you're saying "the current system is antiquated, and we need a new one," but I'm not convinced Github is the right one. Sure, Github has great ideas like forking and transparency, but it also has a ton of barriers, like memorizing a bunch of terminal commands/flags or using a relatively buggy UI. You could also argue that Github reduces the weight of a (citizen) vote or a comment. Just because we trust anonymous feedback for products on Amazon and news stories does not mean we should have the same trust in legislation.

I think what's needed is a new system designed from the ground up, using the good ideas that git has but avoiding the limiting ones.

Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by johnnyg on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @12:10AM (#8727788)
And even more on this.

We citizens are abstracted from the process of making law now. There is no meaningful way through the hole to participate as it stands today.

The barrier of a pull request would be high, but it would be like water breaking over a dam. What we need is a punch through and then iterations and use to smooth the edges and make participation easier and available to an ever wider group.

We basically need what has happened with OSS to be what happens in government.

I'm worried about the barriers too, but I'm even more worried about today's impossibilities of meaningful participation not changing.

Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by Fuzzwah on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @02:01PM (#8730955)
I watched this TED Talk last night which I found very interesting:

http://www.ted.com/talks/pia_mancini_how_to_upgrade_democrac...

> Pia Mancini and her colleagues want to upgrade democracy in Argentina and beyond. Through their open-source mobile platform they want to bring citizens inside the legislative process, and run candidates who will listen to what they say.

Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by bdcravens on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @11:21PM (#8727678)
Probably easier than the current way of directly influencing legislation (for the average citizen)
Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by bhousel on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @12:24AM (#8727820)
Git blame, for starters.
Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by xux on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @11:33PM (#8727706)
If you look here, he's already doing that:

https://github.com/PresidentObama?tab=activity

Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by Everlag on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @11:50PM (#8727744)
I'm almost certain that's a bot.

See https://github.com/sunlightlabs/us-laws/issues/135

Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by jey on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @12:01AM (#8727765)
And it reveals a complete misunderstanding/misuse of GitHub Issues: the issue is filed after the law has been passed and signed into effect, so the issue is "opened" only after we would have closed the issue, and it appears that it will never get closed.
Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by apendleton on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @01:00AM (#8727898)
Sunlighter here (though this isn't my project). This was mostly done to test our IFTTT channel (https://ifttt.com/sunlightfoundation), so I think we were limited in terms of what actions we could trigger. We've talked about doing a non-IFTTT version that would extend the metaphor way further, but haven't (yet) actually made it happen.
Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by pan69 on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @12:36AM (#8727853)
Sorry, I don't understand what you're saying, are you implying that once a feature (law) has been pushed into production (signed off) there can be no issues filed against such feature?
Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by skndr on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @12:58AM (#8727892)
For this analogy, a bill should actually be a pull request and a signed law is a merged request. I think the problem is that an 'issue' should be a proposal, a bug report, etc. In this case, none of the 'issues' being created are intended to be closed.
Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by iancarroll on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @12:03AM (#8727773)
It's not intended to provide a medium of discussion (at least pre-vote) - it's intended to be a directory of laws. I would assume Issues is only used for IFTTT compatibility.
Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by shogun21 on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @11:22PM (#8727680)
I would love to use git blame and git cherry-pick!
Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by fineIllregister on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @12:59AM (#8727894)
They do. Type up a bill and mail it to your Congresspeople.

I don't see how the medium changes proposing laws.

Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by jonalmeida on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @01:45AM (#8727988)
I think the difference is that with a PR it's public knowledge if the government responds/acknowledges/denies the request. It's also easier to type a bill and email it rather than use snail mail (I'm assuming that's what you meant).
Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by fineIllregister on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @11:27PM (#8733190)
You could e-mail a bill you wrote to your Congressman right now. Congress may be out of touch, but they do have e-mail.

The transparency angle is interesting, but I still don't think anything would change. Pull requests would be ignored like petitions, or receive canned responses like letters.

The primary problem here is not technological.

Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by fiatjaf on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @06:56AM (#8728732)
The laws would never pass the Travis CI tests.
Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by RoboTeddy on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @12:28AM (#8727829)
I bet we'll see this in virtual worlds.
Re:PresidentObama on GitHub by joeyspn on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @04:04PM (#8731679)
Doable with Ethereum and Smart Contracts..