This argument doesn't make much sense to me.
What if I said,
> If you're giving your money freely to banks, I don't understand what kind of oversight mechanism could or should protect you.
I think the crux of the issue is that if I get a car ride with Uber, I have a reasonable expectation that I am paying for the service of a car ride. There is no reasonable expectation on my part that I'm giving them money for a car ride AND ALSO giving them the information about me/my ride to use freely, regardless of what the TOS may say.
The expectation on the customer's part is that ride remain private, much like anything that goes on in the doctor's office. The reality, of course, does not match that expectation, which is why I think there should be some hypothetical oversight mechanism that manages the differences between the customer's expectation and Uber's reality.
Just because Uber has data on me doesn't mean that I have given it to them to do whatever they want with it.
All I'm saying is that if you enact regulation to try to enforce this, you're going to cause a lot of unintended consequences. It may even prevent the Airbnb's and Dropbox's of the future from forming altogether.
Are you sure adding another law is the right response?
I'm not sure, but I do think that it would be beneficial to have an overarching framework that could be used to protect information that is commonly believed to be "private." I've thought about it a bit more and instead of simply "transportation companies may do this and not this in situations A, B, and C," I feel like we need a modern day "Bill of Information Rights" and a general reform in how anyone -- government included -- can collect, use, or distribute information without explicit permission.
Sure in this context it sounds like a great idea, but down the line it becomes a tool for the rich with time to censor information.
Well, not having one sure isn't working very well, now is it?
As far as I know, doctor/patient confidentiality is the exception - you have no expectation of privacy anywhere else.
No, but what I'm trying to get at is that you have a reasonable expectation that your rickshaw driver will not go out and try to find people to sell that information to or publish it in a newspaper or something.
Therefore Alice cannot be annoyed when Eve (a random third party) intercepts her communications?
1. Parents will not abuse their children.
2. There will be mechanisms in place to detect and deal with those kinds of incidents.
3. Child abuse is not acceptable, regardless of whether it happens in reality or not.
In a similar vein, I would like it if there were a framework in place such that:
1. Companies could not abuse my personal information.
2. There will be mechanisms in place to detect and deal with those kinds of incidents.
3. Abuse of collected personal information is not acceptable, regardless of whether it happens or not.
"If you're taking patent medicines freely, I don't understand what kind of oversight mechanism could or should protect you."
"If you're eating tainted meat freely, I don't understand what kind of oversight mechanism could or should protect you."
"If you're driving on roads used by other drivers in poorly maintained cars freely, I don't understand what kind of oversight mechanism could or should protect you."
Etc. etc. etc.
We'd rather have drugs that don't kill people more than we want the ability to start drug companies in our garages. The same probably can't be said for software companies and guaranteed total privacy.
Hence the not understanding what a valid mechanism could be that satisfies society.
If you're giving your data freely to companies, I don't understand what kind of oversight mechanism could or should protect you.
For example:http://ec.europa.eu/justice/data-protection/
It does neither hinder you to give private data to companies, nor does it hinder companies to work with your data for the purpose it was submitted.
It does hinder companies to abuse your data for purposes other than the operational use for which it was collected.
You are assuming people understand this and the implications.
The fact it is buried in a legalese ToS somewhere doesn't mean people know what information is sent and how it will be used.
People keep advocating that drug use should be an educational / health issue, not a legal issue. It's ironic that in this situation, people are calling for the opposite: For the government to step in and protect them, when it's unclear how the government can help without causing all kinds of unintended consequences.
This should be an educational issue, not a legal issue. We should educate users about the ramifications of uploading this data.
Remember, if we enforce regulation, users will still upload sensitive data, and the government will still be free to take advantage of it. Whereas if users are educated about what data they upload, then the data won't exist to begin with.
1. Limit what kind of behavioral data websites can store. When I say behavioral data, I mean the kinds of things computers notice about you in passing—your search history, what you click on, what cell tower you're using.
It's very important that we regulate this at the database, not at the point of collection. People will always find creative ways to collect the data, and we shouldn't limit people's ability to do neat things with our data on the fly. But there should be strict limits on what you can save.
2. Limit how long they can keep it. Maybe three months, six months, three years. I don't really care, as long as it's not fifty years, or forever. Make the time scale for deleting behavioral data similar to the half-life of a typical Internet business.
3. Limit what they can share with third parties. This limit should also apply in the event of bankruptcy, or acquisition. Make people's data non-transferable without their consent.
4. Enforce the right to download. If a website collects information about me, I should be allowed to see it. The EU already mandates this to some extent, but it's not evenly enforced.
This rule is a little sneaky, because it will require backend changes on many sites. Personal data can pile up in all kinds of dark corners in your system if you're not concerned about protecting it. But it's a good rule, and easy to explain. You collect data about me? I get to see it.
5. Enforce the right to delete. I should be able to delete my account and leave no trace in your system, modulo some reasonable allowance for backups.
6. Give privacy policies teeth. Right now, privacy policies and terms of service can change at any time. They have no legal standing. For example, I would like to promise my users that I'll never run ads on my site and give that promise legal weight. That would be good marketing for me. Let's create a mechanism that allow this.
7. Let users opt-in if a site wants to make exceptions to these rules. If today's targeted advertising is so great, you should be able to persuade me to sign up for it. Persuade me! Convince me! Seduce me! You're supposed to be a master advertiser, for Christ's sake!
8. Make the protections apply to everyone, not just people in the same jurisdiction as the regulated site. It shouldn't matter what country someone is visiting your site from. Keep it a world-wide web.
> What oversight mechanism can possibly protect users from themselves?
The idea isn't, to me at least, to protect users from themselves, but to restrict the ways that companies can use/distribute data collected from the user.
Personally (and I obviously haven't thought this through/deeply in the last 10 minutes or so), I think something like HIPAA for transportation information might be appropriate. It would apply not specifically to Uber, but to any kind of transportation data collected by any company (say, self-driving cars, public transportation, taxi companies, etc.) and would place restrictions on how they can distribute or publicize that data and what kind of permissions they would need from whom.
I'm summarizing heavily here, obviously - I haven't lived there for a while so this is neither a nuanced nor a fully current picture. Yes, it limits commercial upside in significant ways, but I think a lot of people here can relate to the idea of a muscular privacy regulator.
For example, around 2009 the US government introduced an act which mandated that whenever a customer pays against credit card debt, the highest interest balance needs to be considered paid first if there are multiple balances at various interest rates. This reduced costs for consumers.
Remember how competition is supposed to solve everything - it did not, all banks were doing the opposite as there was no regulation.
Never using VC backed services seems to be the first step.
But that doesn't mean what Uber is doing is appropriate. What we need is a market response. The NY Times is doing it wrong by asking for "oversight" when they should be using their bully pulpit to encourage Uber's customers to demand that Uber stop retaining this information. The press can be as much a check on the market as it is on the government and that's exactly what they need to be here.
Uber isn't Google. You're paying them money. Companies that think they should get your money and your data can go screw.
If the above does not speak sufficiently: think of the efficiency loss caused by everyone having to watch who's the latest culprit in any market they enter... I'd never thought I'd ever advocate compliance & legislation -- but this is just a perfect case for it, also from an economical perspective.
The government is like a lion. If you're having trouble with a pack of wolves, let loose the lion and the wolves will be no more trouble. But from then on you won't be able to own any small pets, you're responsible for feeding the lion and you'll spend the rest of your life having to fear that it will turn on you.
When you have serious trouble in the market (like an abusive monopoly or industries causing fatalities) then you call for the lion. When you spot a mouse in your house you put out some traps and get a terrier. And you're asking, wouldn't a lion be more effective at catching the mouse? Maybe it is, but then you've got a lion in your house. Effectiveness is not the sole criterion.
> think of the efficiency loss caused by everyone having to watch who's the latest culprit in any market they enter...
"The price of freedom is eternal vigilance."
Well, fuck them. It is always a few bad apples that ruin things for the rest.
Such as?
If you're giving your data freely to companies, I don't understand what kind of oversight mechanism could or should protect you.
Imagine a hypothetical oversight mechanism, then imagine the consequences to tech companies. Imagine the consequences to startups. Not Uber; I'm talking about tiny, early-stage startups.
Airbnb and Dropbox have enriched my life. I'd hate for regulatory burden to prevent such startups from forming in the first place.
This isn't a hypothetical concern. The finance industry is so regulated that you can't easily form a finance startup without having a lot of connections or a lot of money. Same for the healthcare sector, as far as I've heard.