All I'm saying is that if you enact regulation to try to enforce this, you're going to cause a lot of unintended consequences. It may even prevent the Airbnb's and Dropbox's of the future from forming altogether.
Are you sure adding another law is the right response?
I'm not sure, but I do think that it would be beneficial to have an overarching framework that could be used to protect information that is commonly believed to be "private." I've thought about it a bit more and instead of simply "transportation companies may do this and not this in situations A, B, and C," I feel like we need a modern day "Bill of Information Rights" and a general reform in how anyone -- government included -- can collect, use, or distribute information without explicit permission.
Sure in this context it sounds like a great idea, but down the line it becomes a tool for the rich with time to censor information.
Well, not having one sure isn't working very well, now is it?
As far as I know, doctor/patient confidentiality is the exception - you have no expectation of privacy anywhere else.
No, but what I'm trying to get at is that you have a reasonable expectation that your rickshaw driver will not go out and try to find people to sell that information to or publish it in a newspaper or something.
Therefore Alice cannot be annoyed when Eve (a random third party) intercepts her communications?
1. Parents will not abuse their children.
2. There will be mechanisms in place to detect and deal with those kinds of incidents.
3. Child abuse is not acceptable, regardless of whether it happens in reality or not.
In a similar vein, I would like it if there were a framework in place such that:
1. Companies could not abuse my personal information.
2. There will be mechanisms in place to detect and deal with those kinds of incidents.
3. Abuse of collected personal information is not acceptable, regardless of whether it happens or not.
This argument doesn't make much sense to me.
What if I said,
> If you're giving your money freely to banks, I don't understand what kind of oversight mechanism could or should protect you.
I think the crux of the issue is that if I get a car ride with Uber, I have a reasonable expectation that I am paying for the service of a car ride. There is no reasonable expectation on my part that I'm giving them money for a car ride AND ALSO giving them the information about me/my ride to use freely, regardless of what the TOS may say.
The expectation on the customer's part is that ride remain private, much like anything that goes on in the doctor's office. The reality, of course, does not match that expectation, which is why I think there should be some hypothetical oversight mechanism that manages the differences between the customer's expectation and Uber's reality.
Just because Uber has data on me doesn't mean that I have given it to them to do whatever they want with it.