If the above does not speak sufficiently: think of the efficiency loss caused by everyone having to watch who's the latest culprit in any market they enter... I'd never thought I'd ever advocate compliance & legislation -- but this is just a perfect case for it, also from an economical perspective.
The government is like a lion. If you're having trouble with a pack of wolves, let loose the lion and the wolves will be no more trouble. But from then on you won't be able to own any small pets, you're responsible for feeding the lion and you'll spend the rest of your life having to fear that it will turn on you.
When you have serious trouble in the market (like an abusive monopoly or industries causing fatalities) then you call for the lion. When you spot a mouse in your house you put out some traps and get a terrier. And you're asking, wouldn't a lion be more effective at catching the mouse? Maybe it is, but then you've got a lion in your house. Effectiveness is not the sole criterion.
> think of the efficiency loss caused by everyone having to watch who's the latest culprit in any market they enter...
"The price of freedom is eternal vigilance."
But that doesn't mean what Uber is doing is appropriate. What we need is a market response. The NY Times is doing it wrong by asking for "oversight" when they should be using their bully pulpit to encourage Uber's customers to demand that Uber stop retaining this information. The press can be as much a check on the market as it is on the government and that's exactly what they need to be here.
Uber isn't Google. You're paying them money. Companies that think they should get your money and your data can go screw.