News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Piratebay strikes back by anApple on Friday October 09, 2009 @07:25AM (#871118)
To be honest, I hope these guys are going to jail.

You must be a fool to believe that they don't own the pirate bay anymore, or are not associated with the keyman islands shell company running the company.

Alone mininova disclosed making > 1 million of profit a year, piratebay's profit must be much bigger, all from the copyrighted works of others.

Most of you wouldn't support piratebay anymore if your program/source code showed up there, except if it's opensource.

Re:Piratebay strikes back by tjogin on Friday October 09, 2009 @11:47AM (#871636)
I understand your position, but the thing is that there is no proof for either of the claims you are making:

* Not that they own TPB (the Swedish IRS have even concluded that they do not.)

* Not that TPB are making any money. While they must have some revenue (from banner clicks), it is not at all certain that it exceeds the costs of running the website.

It's possible for both claims to be true, but it's not proven. I, for one, do not wish people who haven't been proven guilty to go to jail. I certainly don't think that your hunch that they probably do own it should suffice.

As a bonus, keep in mind that the crime they're charged with is is something as flimsy as "aiding" unspecified crimes against copyright — that's right, the copyright crimes that they are supposed to have aided are unspecified, and nobody has been accused of committing those.

Re:Piratebay strikes back by anApple on Friday October 09, 2009 @12:15PM (#871711)
- The Swedish IRS can claim whatever they want. They don't have access to the bank accounts on these islands, so how should they know if some of them are affilated to that company. - It is completely irrelevant if the TPB is making money or not. And I bet it does a hell lot, or otherwise they wouldn't been so keen to go to jail.
Re:Piratebay strikes back by pyre on Friday October 09, 2009 @03:56PM (#872313)
> And I bet it does a hell lot, or otherwise they wouldn't been so keen to go to jail.

No offense, but sometimes people are willing to stand up and fight for what they believe in. Just because what they believe in is something that you disagree with doesn't make them any less willing to possibly sacrifice themselves for their cause.

I don't believe that the Middle East should be ruled over by Muslim 'overlords' that use the religion as a form of governance, but that doesn't mean that there are no suicide bombers out there willing to further that cause.

Re:Piratebay strikes back by tjogin on Friday October 09, 2009 @12:32PM (#871745)
The Swedish IRS aren't making any claim. They just can't find any proof that the TPB has anything to do with the accused. And without proof, they don't.

What? That makes no sense what so ever. How does TPB's hypothetical revenue increase the chance that the accused own TPB?

Re:Piratebay strikes back by trafficlight on Friday October 09, 2009 @10:56AM (#871508)
I'm disappointed they are gone. I used the Pirate Bay as my primary tracker for distributing my music free of charge.
Re:Piratebay strikes back by eli on Friday October 09, 2009 @09:10AM (#871266)
It's disappointing that so many people are downvoting this comment just because they disagree with you.

I think the truth is more nuanced than that, but you have a perfectly valid opinion.

Re:Piratebay strikes back by anApple on Friday October 09, 2009 @09:28AM (#871292)
Thanks, I don't write comments to harvest karma, but just to state my opinion. :-)
Re:Piratebay strikes back by doki_pen on Friday October 09, 2009 @12:54PM (#871799)
I think you wouldn't find many "coders" that give a shit if their code is "pirated". For most of them, it's a day job.
Re:Piratebay strikes back by rimantas on Friday October 09, 2009 @07:29AM (#871124)
except that source code couldn't possibly show on piratebay.
Re:Piratebay strikes back by Torn on Friday October 09, 2009 @08:57AM (#871238)
Of course it could. You/your svn/ftp could be hacked, your code could be decompiled...
Re:Piratebay strikes back by ErrantX on Friday October 09, 2009 @11:26AM (#871582)
he means in a purely technical sense it would "show" on TPB - they just host the torrent not the content.

It was, I think, a distinction.

Re:Piratebay strikes back by eru on Friday October 09, 2009 @08:01AM (#871166)
Why?
Re:Piratebay strikes back by Quarrelsome on Friday October 09, 2009 @08:08AM (#871178)
With source code the major economic benefit is understanding and being able to modify that code, less so the code itself.

Source code available on pirate bay is useless unless someone spends a lot of time / money on figuring out how it works. This is why people can write in scripting languages without worrying about the "openness" of the source.

Re:Piratebay strikes back by Quarrelsome on Friday October 09, 2009 @10:38AM (#871464)
I think it would more apt if both sides go to jail, neither is the answer to the future of artistic works. On one side a bunch of cartels that IMO should be investigated by the monopolies and mergers commission and on the other freetards that don't provide a realistic revenue model for artists.
Re:Piratebay strikes back by doki_pen on Friday October 09, 2009 @12:52PM (#871792)
I can't resist. I'm a freetard and here is my proposal:

* Artists(haha, really? is Spears and "artist"?) perform live to earn income

I know... it's earth shattering.

If people don't think it's worth the trouble of recording, then they shouldn't do it. See how many people come to your live performance without the free advertising that recordings provide.

Oh, maybe they won't make hundreds of millions of dollars. Should I give up my rights so "recording artists" can be filthy rich? I think not. And also, I don't give two shits about all the administrative ppl in the recording industry. They can all live in the streets for all I care. The current system is worse then welfare.

Re:Piratebay strikes back by tedunangst on Friday October 09, 2009 @03:17PM (#872245)
How about authors? How much money have you spent, lifetime, to hear an author read his books to you?
Re:Piratebay strikes back by pyre on Friday October 09, 2009 @04:15PM (#872355)
Books are horrible about copyright. There are many books tied up in copyright that are completely out of print, and if I wanted to buy a copy I would have to buy a used copy at an exorbitant price (due to scarcity).

At this point the author (or the publisher) is seeing NO money. Is there a real reason why I can't just take a copy of the book, put it to PDF and distribute it for free? The people that were involved in the production of the book have essentially abandoned it, but they will definitely jump out of the woodwork to try and cash in on it if someone were to 'make it profitable again' (which includes suing a person for distributing it).

I see these as the moral equivalent of submarine patents. (Patents where you wait until something becomes popular, and then pop out of the woodwork to sue the biggest companies that you can find for millions or billions of dollars)

Re:Piratebay strikes back by tjogin on Friday October 09, 2009 @04:12PM (#872346)
You've got a point, but the e-book market is vanishingly small compared to the regular paper-book market. Paper-books don't get pirated. You can pretty much write that off as advertising.

Of course, their market will implode once we get thin and light screens that can deliver the crisp of type printed on paper.

Re:Piratebay strikes back by LogicHoleFlaw on Friday October 09, 2009 @05:45PM (#872524)
I just go to the library.

(Interlibrary Loan is awesome.)

Re:Piratebay strikes back by omail on Friday October 09, 2009 @03:59PM (#872321)
By selling their services to others. Musicians can sell live performances. Authors can ghost write, edit, etc. This isn't a big leap of imagination.
Re:Piratebay strikes back by stumm on Friday October 09, 2009 @04:37PM (#872393)
>> Oh, maybe they won't make hundreds of millions of dollars. Should I give up my rights so "recording artists" can be filthy rich?

It's a fallacy that most recording artists are "filthy rich", not mention how much they make is irrelevant to the discussion at hand. What "right" are you giving up?

Re:Piratebay strikes back by doki_pen on Thursday October 29, 2009 @02:50PM (#910577)
The follow rights:

* The right to share * The right to modify * The right to use in anyway I want

Re:Piratebay strikes back by unalone on Friday October 09, 2009 @11:33AM (#871605)
The pirates aren't freetards. I resent your accusation.

The current model isn't working if it's so easily subverted. The solution is to figure out a model that's pirate-proof. They exist.

Re:Piratebay strikes back by tjogin on Friday October 09, 2009 @11:49AM (#871646)
Spotify is huge in Sweden, TPB's home. According to a survey, [the vast majority] of Spotify users have stopped pirating. I think this proves you are right.
Re:Piratebay strikes back by thunk on Friday October 09, 2009 @11:52AM (#871654)
Pirate-proof in the sense that works can't be pirated? Or pirate-proof in the sense that piracy is unnecessary because works are already free? I'm pretty sure the former is impossible.
Re:Piratebay strikes back by unalone on Friday October 09, 2009 @12:03PM (#871676)
The former's impossible in the paradigm where the only way to make money off music is to sell songs. That's not true, though.

A few of the models I'm going to be experimenting with: Raising money before you release an album, with certain perks given to people that pay the money for release. Offering special exclusives that people can choose to pay for, that most people interested in just music won't bother pirating. That's why I'm excited for the iTunes LP: It's an idea that's worth money even after you own the music, that appeals to fans and less to casual criminals.

I'm currently thinking of launching an ARG with a future music project. I think that launching a video game through an album distribution would be really fun and potentially really profitable.

Re:Piratebay strikes back by Quarrelsome on Friday October 09, 2009 @12:00PM (#871669)
Sorry, I probably wasn't very clear there.

Not all pirates are freetards, i'm talking about the two ends of the spectrum here. I am a pirate for example but I also subscribe to EMusic and make a point of buying direct from artists when I can and seeing bands live. Some people however are loathe to do this as well and believe that content should always be free.

As it stands both models are somewhat flawed and neither are the way forward in their present state.

Re:Piratebay strikes back by unalone on Friday October 09, 2009 @12:07PM (#871695)
Okay, that makes sense. :-)

My policy is, I buy from artists who I feel aren't big. I bought Joanna Newsom's album for a friend of mine after I downloaded it, and I just got a song from Pomplamoose, which is a crazy duo I found on Youtube. When I feel like my money's going to a good cause, then I pay.

Re:Piratebay strikes back by praptak on Friday October 09, 2009 @04:03PM (#872329)
> ... and on the other freetards that don't provide a realistic revenue model for artists.

Gee, I didn't know this "intellectual property" war has gone this far! Is it now a crime not to provide a realistic revenue model for artists?

Just in case it's actually true (I haven't been following the news recently) I am hereby providing a realistic revenue model for artists: get a job.

No, really. I don't believe that being an artist (or an author in general) entitles you to anything. Copyright is a privilege, not a god-given right. Its original purpose was to "promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts", a social contract designed to provide fair compensation for contributing to the public pool of ideas.

Then the suits came and fucked this up with their concept of intellectual "property" and perpetual copyright term extensions. Copyright doesn't serve its original purpose anymore, we should just drop it. If you don't like it, don't publish. It had been this way for most of human history and it worked fine.