However, I don't think this is a "fix" any more than legal alcohol is a fix for alcoholism. Legal or not, there will be user and there will be addicts. Legality might be an improvement but it doesn't solve the problem.
I don't know if there is a solution. An effective treatment for addiction is the only thing I can think of. We don't even have effective treatments for eating disorders.
Is it too much of a stretch to suggest that legal alcohol IS a fix for alcoholism, at least if you're speaking of the sort of alcoholism that might exist is a world where alcoholics are all destitute and social pariahs? I think we live in a world where many functional alcoholics exist, for better or for worse. But I would rather have more functional alcoholism and legality, than live in a society that views alcoholics as criminals and condemns them to destitution.
In the same way, while i dont necessarily want more heroin addicts, i think i want to live in society where functional heroin addicts can lead the semblance of a normal life as we coolectively sort out how to help them recover.
Prohibition doesn't make all addicts destitute social pariahs. There are plenty of rich & popular addicts of illegal drugs now, just as there were plenty of rich & popular people who were also alcoholics when alcohol was the subject of Prohibition.
It does make more addicts destitute social pariahs, though, and the stigmatization complicates treating addiction.
The lesson is that the harsh punishments don't solve the problem.
Drug addictions should not be blamed on the addict, there is still a huge problem here. I think they can be treated if they are accepted, the addiction approached like a mental disease, with counseling and honesty.
"If you realize addiction is simply a symptom of a deeper underlying mental illness. Treat the illness, you solve the addiction."
But yes there will be addicts.
Consider addiction to smoking. There are plenty of people who picked up smoking for no other reason than 'fitting in' or 'curiosity'. Which I'd hardly call a mental illness. Many of these people kept smoking, and sadly probably many of them died from smoking.
Similarly, I suspect there are many alcoholics who slowly became so because they entered a culture of alcohol.
Addiction is a powerful thing in itself, and while the solution to many might be uncovering the underlying mental illness, for many it might 'just' be a matter of unlearning a powerful, destructive habit.
Of course in both cases professional help is necessary, but treating an 'underlying mental illness' in cases where there are none can also have bad consequences.
Among the many addicts and ex-addicts I've known, there have been more than a few that were actively treating a 'deeper underlying mental illness' that I suspected didn't really exist in the first place. And while that's probably better than being an addict, it's still not good.
in fact, this is one reason I have issues with the approach Alcoholics Anonymous. They seem to treat all alcoholics as sufferers of a lifelong disease, and I cannot help but wonder if being constantly reminded of a thing you don't want to do anymore is a good solution for all people. For some, sure. Some people might have the 'alcoholism gene'. But I don't think that's always the case.
The former can be very nasty and serious. It didn't mean to belittle it, or people who've fallen prey to it.
Regardless, I was primarily thinking about the psychological side of addiction in the above post, and I think my point still stands. There are many examples of (almost) purely psychological addictions that people suffer from, and also in those cases I think it can be an interplay of habit formation, personality characteristics, and environment, that 'maintain' it, and not always 'deeper issues' (although I suppose one could consider environment a deeper issue...).
It seems to me the whole problem stems from a misunderstanding of what needs to be prevented.
What you don't want is people addicted to drugs. Allowing heroin to be sold at Walmart for $1 would be no problem whatsoever if nobody was using it. Where the stupidity comes in is that the laws and law enforcement are targeted at sale and distribution rather than consumption, the theory apparently being that if people can't buy drugs then they can't use them.
Which, of course, doesn't work, and instead leads to the rise of organized crime and violence.
What we need is for sale and possession to be legal, which kills the drug cartels instantly, but then do everything we can to discourage usage. Make the penalty for drug use a fine and instant mandatory rehab, and make drug possession legal but probable cause for a drug test.
The idea is to make distribution legal and therefore unprofitable, and make usage as safe as possible but so inconvenient that nobody wants to do it. And then use the revenue generated from taxing it to pay to help the people who are already addicted.
Let people buy and use heroin legally, but make the process like the DMV or a welfare office. That is to say, it takes hours, it's boring and uncomfortable, you can't play on your phone, and is so lacking in romance or mystique that it could be a synonym for mundane inanity. Plus they can only get a limited amount at a time and there is a cooldown period.
You're absolutely, 100% right in that sentence alone.
The solution to heroin addiction is technically quite easy, and it's called Iboga.
Part of what can help this is education. To most people, heroin is a mythical creature. It's either glamorized or demonized, but neither of these things have any grounds in reality. There's obviously nothing glamorous about being so broken that you need to turn to powerful opiates to solve it. And there's obviously nothing so demonic about it, either: it's some sort of cognitive or emotional failure on the user's part, but it's not evil.
While I share some of the concerns of others about it, I think "safe heroin or similar to addicts for free / low cost at addiction treatment centres" is still worth consideration. I think "not heroin" is the reasonable choice, though picking something (eg opiate replacements) completely devoid of pleasure fails to solve the real problem.
People tend to neglect that money is a big part of the reason that drugs turn up in a community. We're a society built on money and illicit drugs are a profit area that huge corporations, by law, cannot capitalize upon. But that doesn't mean that people won't, and those people have profit motives to do things that encourage use of their product.
It's clear that killing these people or putting them in prisons doesn't help. This is why the "war on drugs" is a failure: it just opens up the market for new players.
In truth, heroin is no more strange or evil than alcohol. In fact, they're fairly similar: they both feel good, hobble your senses, and dull "pain." But drugs carry with them certain cultures, and the culture of alcohol is a reasonable one. An obscure and "dangerous" substance like heroin carries with it an obscure and dangerous drug market. That is what's truly dangerous; moreso than even the drug.
So some combination of (1) educating the public in a sane way rather than fearmongering and (2) using the newly-earned social support to open doors for tactics that destroy the black market are my idea of a solution.
I could be wrong, though. I'm just one data point.
On one hand, I see your point. There's a lot of merit in allowing various mental and emotional illnesses to be treated as illnesses rather than moral failings.
On the other, this seems orthogonal to the AA/NA approach. "I am an addict. I am no different from other addicts." Own the problem. Make it your primary mission. Many members give "recovering addict" a very central place in their identity.
Do you think it's better to encourage addicts embrace the label or allow them to wear it lightly?
Also, regarding the "drug culture." I don't know much about the heroin culture but the prescription painkiller culture seems to be very different. Recreational users seem to treat it like a party drug. A lot of addicts seem to treat it like medicine. There's an obvious compulsiveness to it, but it's not incompatible with a normal life the way heroine seems to be. I don't know if it's mostly stigma and culture or properties of the actual substance, but using heroin and going to work and then picking up the kids seems like a total contradiction.
I know as a smoker that smoking and exorcise (and healthy eating) feel incompatible. If you do this self destructive thing 10-20 time a day, going into a gym or playing soccer seems ridiculous. This is something that changed over the last generation. In the 50s, you could see professional athletes take smoke breaks between training sessions. But now, with the current cultural treatment of cigarettes, relapsing on smoking usually means relapsing on exercise too.
Again, I think there's a contradiction between AA/NA approach and another approach. One is to encourage the oxy culture in heroin. Shooting heroin doesn't mean your whole life is derelict. The NA/AA approach is the other way, oxy addicts need to see that they're addicts just like the bum with a needle in his arm. Thoughts?
True, and as a side point it's sad that people are willing to discard the person under the bridge any more than the person in their middle-class neighborhood. The person under the bridge is far more vulnerable and more likely to need help.
But I used to be a heroin addict.
Before then, I used Oxycontin - crushed up and snorted - which was a great kick and very, very easy to fall in love with when you first try it.
The Oxycontin pill formula switch had ominous effect. In short, my pusher had no clients anymore and switched straight to heroin. Turned from kids snorting pills for highs into a shooting gallery almost overnight. The last "classic" Oxycontin I remember hearing about went for $160 a pill.
Like Scudo, I started with brown heroin. Snorting it also. And under the same delusion that somehow snorting it made me "not a heroin addict."
Nothing like the cognitive dissonance of a dozen middle-class white kids making their first casual acquaintances with heroin.
But drug has a noxious, subtle allure. One night, with only a few $20s in my pocket and the ATM just out of walking distance, I chased down a bit more rush. Someone showed me how to shoot it.
"You put the needle in your arm." Casually as ever. Like explaining how to pull a good espresso. "You're new to this so your veins are easy to find. Not like mine. When you pull back the plunger - like this," drawing blood, "you know you've found it." Had it done for me, because I was scared and couldn't hit.
I threw up a lot and felt better than uninitiated will ever comprehend.
Months passed. Then something started happening, something I hadn't dealt with before: People started dying. Kids who had futures started dying.
I won't bore you with the howls of addiction and disaster that followed, nor with my own personal triumph of escape. But I will leave with one point:
This article is spot-on; the elephant in the room for many a community of parents who can't stomach much longer watching more of their kids die.
Heroin is not just in the underbelly of the world anymore. We need to stop treating it like a pariah and start actually trying to fix it.