The problem is they charge 15% of ALL of my income for that privilege and don't make any guarantees. Why should I pay them over $2k a month for them to possibly make me new sales when I'm already capable of keeping myself booked the majority of the time?
The whole thing reeked of predation to me. If they're really able to provide more value than they take from me, then they should only be charging me a commission on the sales they bring in.
That all seems unlikely in the case of 10x.
Contract programmers on the other hand, generally receive their compensation for a project in cold, hard cash, without any lucrative sidelines in selling T-shirts with pictures of their face to manage, or concerns over whether taking on a project for Yahoo will dilute their brand equity or boost their autobiography sales. It's difficult to see where 10X adds the value in cases where they're not finding the work. Interview coaching and advice on upping your rate is not hard to find; any recruiter that does have a position will offer it without wanting a piece of your existing income.
FWIW over at http://OfferLetter.io, we spent a lot of time figuring out the right pricing model - We let the candidate choose either %-contingency-on-increase, or flat-fee. This seemed to be the best route for incentive alignment. If you have any other ideas for pricing models that work well, do let me know! mallyvai-at-offerletter.io
[We discarded the %-of-net-compensation model - it felt too extreme, and it wasn't clear we could add sufficient value in every case.]
One thing we could do is work with more recruiters more aggressively for data and guidance - ping them every conversation for example, instead of for larger industry trends. But we'll have to see if that could truly add value.
Asking for a 15% draw against all income is ridiculous.
You can train and optimize your negotiation skills all you want, but in my opinion it is extremely valuable to separate the "talent" from the "money". Top performers, no matter in what industry, are usually extremely passionated about their craft and undervalue the monetary value they can bring to the table.
Having a third party represent them puts a "neutral" monetary evaluation on them. Good management allows a much more strategic long-term development that focuses on value building and not just opportunity hopping.
Also, our fee structure is much more reasonable than an agent's - we're charging 20-30% of the cash increase, or a $2k flat fee, whichever folks feel is more reasonable. Incentive alignment is important, but there are also cases where candidate may get a huge bump in equity they can't can't necessarily pay us out of.
It'd be interesting to consider derivatives-based model in the future to align incentives better by capturing the value of the equity increase, but that's a long ways off, and not terribly important to us at the moment.
I wrote about this, and I think it's a useful idea, although it has some ethical issues (around whether one can trust the consultant to deliver) that need to be nailed down: http://michaelochurch.wordpress.com/2013/05/07/fixing-employ...
Well, from experience in the music industry, it seems that the person doing the hard work (the artist) most often is on the bad end of the deal, while all the middle-men are laughing their way to the bank.
I'm just saying that analogies are not always to be relied upon.
(Also, a 15-20% management fee is totally not reasonable, except if it is time-limited.)
No, the person assuming the most risk, the label pushing large sums of money in promotion in a high risk investment, gets the most money.
But the DoE, CIA, and NSA will always pay better, have greater challenges, and have a much wider net to cast than twitter, The Zuck, or Google ever will. Why? Capitalism doesn't work at the end of tank barrels.
It not google that twitter is really competing with, its the Air Force and DoD.
Also, thank you very much for pointing out the gender wage gaps here. It is an obvious and clear example of sexism distorting market capitalism.
There is an enormous psychological component to this, and just knowing market rates and ranges for various companies is enormously important, but is only part of the problem (otherwise WealthFront and Glassdoor would have solved this problem already). Getting the right counteroffers and navigating the personal psychology here are enormously important too. That's where we differentiate ourselves with our expertise and guidance :-)
First, it was conducted by Dice, which is a "career hub" that is going to have some sort of subset of overall users. It wasn't a group that was carefully selected to represent the overall market. It's not a scientific survey.
Second, these are for "tech positions", not engineer positions. No technical job is even on the list for women!
Third, this survey only counts employed people. What about all the women who can't find work in their field? Given the fact that engineering is not a top-five "tech job" for women, I'd wager that many female engineers have trouble finding pure engineering jobs and must find something that people believe they're qualified for.
On a semi-related note, I strongly recommend that everyone on HN listen to this: http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2014/10/21/357629765/when-wom...
I want to specifically address 1) Sam Altman and 2) Chris Fry's respective points about the problems with regards to models that align with the candidate more directly (like ours):
1) Much respect for Sam, but he's dead wrong with respect to the 'negative selection' problem - yes, good people have no problem finding work, but the key problem is that the opportunity cost remains phenomenally high for suboptimal decision making. We have actually worked with outstanding engineers who are at YC portfolio companies, simply because they wouldn't have known how to get what they're worth otherwise and push for more. And Sam is missing the point entirely with regards to worth - people in the industry are not getting paid based on their merit - not at all. The gender wage gap is perhaps the most stark example of this, but we see it, starkly, along many other demographic slices as well.
2) With respect to Chris Fry's comments - I was actually in Twitter's eng org when Chris raised the internal engineering referral bonus from 2.5k to 10k because the company wasn't getting the volume of quality people it wanted. Chris is a really great guy, but I find his point about "[at] Twitter, you get the best résumés on your desk already [via recruiting department, referrals, etc]" somewhat misleading - there's no way he would have raised the referral bonus as sharply as he did if he really felt that. In fact, there wouldn't have to be an referral bonus structure at all. Twitter is wonderful, and I loved my time there, but even there we weren't getting all the high-quality people we wanted.
[#plug: check out http://OfferLetter.io - we all deserve to get what we're worth]