That all seems unlikely in the case of 10x.
Contract programmers on the other hand, generally receive their compensation for a project in cold, hard cash, without any lucrative sidelines in selling T-shirts with pictures of their face to manage, or concerns over whether taking on a project for Yahoo will dilute their brand equity or boost their autobiography sales. It's difficult to see where 10X adds the value in cases where they're not finding the work. Interview coaching and advice on upping your rate is not hard to find; any recruiter that does have a position will offer it without wanting a piece of your existing income.
FWIW over at http://OfferLetter.io, we spent a lot of time figuring out the right pricing model - We let the candidate choose either %-contingency-on-increase, or flat-fee. This seemed to be the best route for incentive alignment. If you have any other ideas for pricing models that work well, do let me know! mallyvai-at-offerletter.io
[We discarded the %-of-net-compensation model - it felt too extreme, and it wasn't clear we could add sufficient value in every case.]
One thing we could do is work with more recruiters more aggressively for data and guidance - ping them every conversation for example, instead of for larger industry trends. But we'll have to see if that could truly add value.
Asking for a 15% draw against all income is ridiculous.
The problem is they charge 15% of ALL of my income for that privilege and don't make any guarantees. Why should I pay them over $2k a month for them to possibly make me new sales when I'm already capable of keeping myself booked the majority of the time?
The whole thing reeked of predation to me. If they're really able to provide more value than they take from me, then they should only be charging me a commission on the sales they bring in.