News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Wikipedia's reaction to sudden popularity is causing ... by owenmarshall on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @01:44PM (#8597333)
Wikipedia has so many rules and restrictions around editing an article that the only people who can invest enough time to learn them are people whose time is otherwise worthless.

I once saw a great example when a notable athlete was traded from one team to another... I think it was a famous basketball player, but can't remember who. On a whim I checked the article history page and saw the same pattern: a new user to Wikipedia would make the edit, and it was quickly reverted by one established editor.

When I looked at the talk page, the WP editor made it clear that it was Official Wikipedia Policy that even though both clubs had announced the trade, and news was being carried on multiple outlets, the trade wasn't official enough until the NBA released a daily transfer list with his name on it. All five new editors were threatened with WP:3RR and WP:yaddayadda instead of encouraged. But hey, when the list was officially released twenty-five minutes later the editor who got the page locked got to make the edit. Great job guys! Way to add value to the project!

This same behavior happens on every site where authority is meted out based on activity, not ability. I once tried to correct an elisp entry on a Stack Overflow answer: my edit was autorejected because it had less than five characters difference. So I added a fairly pointless comment to get past the automatic rejection, only to have someone reject it because the comment wasn't sufficiently useful (go figure). I was finally able to get someone to make a correction by going into the Stack Overflow chat and trying to explain things... except the user, who freely admitted to never using emacs before, messed up and made things worse. Whatever. My give-a-fucks were all out. It's probably still wrong!

Re:How Wikipedia's reaction to sudden popularity is causing ... by diminoten on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @02:58PM (#8597768)
I had something similar happen, where I offered details on a fix, and provided a link to more details. Someone removed part of my fix text, then someone else removed my link (it wasn't relevant without the fix text), and then a third person removed the comment entirely because it didn't offer a fix (without the link and the text, it was basically worthless).

So stackoverflow went from "having a useful answer" to "having no answer at all" because folks abused their use-granted power.

I am personally fond of the "king for a day" form of crowd-sourced moderation, where folks who are granted moderation say don't get to keep it long enough to get used to it, and learn how to abuse it.

Re:How Wikipedia's reaction to sudden popularity is causing ... by syntern on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @04:20PM (#8598265)
Why do you think that the "king for a day" won't be abused either?
Re:How Wikipedia's reaction to sudden popularity is causing ... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @04:28PM (#8598326)
Folks who are granted moderation say don't get to keep it long enough to get used to it, and learn how to abuse it.
Re:How Wikipedia's reaction to sudden popularity is causing ... by commandar on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @04:58PM (#8598523)
I've said this before, but it's always funny to me how many proposed fixes end up sounding a lot like /.'s metamoderation system.

Slashdot was far from perfect, but I still think the system of temporary moderators followed up by temporary metamoderators is pretty elegant compared to most of the alternatives I've seen.

Re:How Wikipedia's reaction to sudden popularity is causing ... by sameerds on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @11:22PM (#8599914)
Slashdot was ... ???
Re:How Wikipedia's reaction to sudden popularity is causing ... by flexie on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @01:59PM (#8597435)
I experienced the same thing. Nothing is as demotivating as seeing an edit you spent hours researching and writing deleted for some obscure reason and then rewritten a few days later by the very same guys who deleted your entry.
Re:How Wikipedia's reaction to sudden popularity is causing ... by spiritplumber on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @02:06PM (#8597472)
Citizendum experienced this early on, which is why it's a ghost town now.
Re:How Wikipedia's reaction to sudden popularity is causing ... by smackfu on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @04:09PM (#8598194)
The counter argument would be that 100 people are going to go to wikipedia and try to update the team for a popular player. But who's going to do it for the last man off the bench? A system that makes sure all updates are made properly, if a little less timely (and we are probably talking one day later), is not a bad thing.
Re:How Wikipedia's reaction to sudden popularity is causing ... by 1ris on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @05:46PM (#8598779)
I don't see how making sure are made properly should forbid that 100 people are going to go to wikipedia and try to update the team for a popular player.

The Problem with Wikipedia is that Wikipedia does not want to reflect truth, or reality or facts or objectivity however one might call it, but verifiability.

That is why they revert to false statements, even if they know so.

Re:How Wikipedia's reaction to sudden popularity is causing ... by Golf_Hotel_Mike on Thursday November 13, 2014 @12:40AM (#8600108)
Is that such a bad thing really? Wikipedia already has a terrible reputation in research and academics, most people simply refuse to accept any information off it because "anyone can edit it."

Insisting on verifiability is a necessary evil if Wikipedia wants to have even a modicum of credibility. Maybe the standards are far too stringent, but verifiability is tangible, and the 'truth' isn't.

Re:How Wikipedia's reaction to sudden popularity is causing ... by 1ris on Thursday November 13, 2014 @10:53AM (#8602134)
Wikipedia will never, ever be accepted by the academic community, no matter what kind of rules are implemented, als long as it stays a wiki.

And once one accepts that one can drop this stupid principle. For me it seems the only reason it exists is to pander the academic community. But it's a hopeless and one sided love.

It does not improve quality, it does not improve credibility, the best thing about it that is produces funny feedback loops.

Re:How Wikipedia's reaction to sudden popularity is causing ... by Golf_Hotel_Mike on Friday November 14, 2014 @12:35AM (#8605947)
What other system would you propose that would ensure that articles are as uniformly objective and factual as possible? It's all right to claim that anyone should be allowed to edit an article, but the fact is that internet communities have consistently shown that without extremely heavy-handed moderation to uphold standards, they can quickly devolve into echo chambers where only one opinion or one set of facts is heard.

Articles about NBA players are not a good example of this, but I can easily think of plenty of other topics which would involve extremely loud and opinionated fringe communities who are very motivated to broadcast their views to the world. I can't think of any way to limit the influence of these communities except by insisting that every article have impeccable sources.

The cost of this insistence on sources is that sometimes utterly obvious edits may be reverted unless they can be properly sourced, but I think it is an acceptable price for maintaining consistent standards of quality across the wiki.

Also, I don't agree that the system only exists to pander to academia. Every encyclopedia in the world has standards of quality to which their articles must conform. The only difference between these other encyclopedias and Wikipedia is the speed with which they are updated.

Now I don't know about you, but I don't go to Wikipedia to get the latest news. I go there to learn stuff with the belief that this stuff will be correct. I don't care if players' teams are updated hours instead of seconds after a trade. I care much more about whether this information is correct. Verifiability builds trust, and I don't see how Wikipedia could continue to exist without it.

Re:How Wikipedia's reaction to sudden popularity is causing ... by NoMoreNicksLeft on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @04:42PM (#8598405)
This works for the NBA articles. But there are other more obscure subjects that if you stifle the edits when they happen, they may not be attempted again for a long time. Or never.
Re:How Wikipedia's reaction to sudden popularity is causing ... by e12e on Thursday November 13, 2014 @01:57AM (#8600290)
How is that a counter argument? You're saying that at any given time either the entire team rooster is wrong, or it is more correct, except for the unpopular players.

Maybe WPs process (speaking as someone that's not edited WP here) need to change more towards the distributed VCS workflow: everyone can make changes, but changes gets voted in. Not sure if that is scalable either -- but perhaps what is need is a three-tier system: default to open (like any wiki, just make the change, done); somewhat moderated (anyone can suggest an edit, votes (with comment field) need to pass/accept the vote [essentially making the talk page a vote to pass/fail], and locked (protecting popular articles against spam, as today).

Or maybe what is needed is to accept that WP is "everone's wiki" (eg: it's a great source for tv series episode dates and synopsis -- not really something that should go in a traditional encyclopedia) -- in other words, classify some pages/sections as "not encyclopedia grade". It's hard to see how one can have one process that both accommodates NBA transfers, tv series episode synopsis, modern history of Palestine and Ukraine, and articles that document the current state of photovoltaics and quantum physics.

Re:How Wikipedia's reaction to sudden popularity is causing ... by DanBC on Thursday November 13, 2014 @02:21AM (#8600342)
You really need to participate in WP to see how dysfunctional small parts of it are.

I notice you use --. Discussion around dashes is extensive. Here's just one example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Village_pump_(policy...

That single discussion is around 15,000 words. Here's a search for some more: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Search?search=dash&pre...

Note the search results helpfully give a word count - there are several hundred thousand extra words there.

Dash-discussion was not limited to the style guide and its talk page, or to the village pump. Disputes were escalated to ANI (a notice board where incidents for administrator attention can be raised); finally ending up at arbitration. (This is pretty severe level of dispute.) https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Arbitra...

PEDIT: I mean, just look at the article talk for "Mexican-American War" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Mexican%E2%80%93American_... - roughly 21,000 words.}

And that's about –,— and -. Now imagine how editors behave over contentious issues. (What are those islands called and who do they belong to? is a good example.)

Re:How Wikipedia's reaction to sudden popularity is causing ... by owenmarshall on Thursday November 13, 2014 @09:28AM (#8601641)
Jesus Christ.

Wikipedia stopped being an encyclopedia long ago: now it's just Bureaucracy Simulator 2015 with the AI cranked up to nightmare.

Re:How Wikipedia's reaction to sudden popularity is causing ... by ww520 on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @03:08PM (#8597826)
When people get petty power, they will use it for pettiness.
Re:How Wikipedia's reaction to sudden popularity is causing ... by a_gentle_autist on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @07:15PM (#8599192)
Hacker news commenter with a lot of karma...
Re:How Wikipedia's reaction to sudden popularity is causing ... by NoMoreNicksLeft on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @04:40PM (#8598390)
I have privs on the Scifi SE... I've never rejected edits for lack of comments or minor corrections.

Anything that resembles good faith effort and isn't flagrantly wrong gets ok'd (though others have complained about me doing that... I'm supposed to at least verify it or something).

Re:How Wikipedia's reaction to sudden popularity is causing ... by tsotha on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @06:45PM (#8599067)
With all the rules I'm amazed at the amount of stuff that's simply wrong. And it's pointless to try to fix anything, because your edits will be rejected on technicalities (like the NBA trade you mentioned) or at some later point in time the section will be rewritten with incorrect information added back by people referencing the same erroneous sources.
Re:How Wikipedia's reaction to sudden popularity is causing ... by serve_yay on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @02:55PM (#8597752)
Yes, I remember reading that they prefer info that can be referenced, even when the reference itself doesn't have references. I suppose I understand why, but it leads to situations like what you describe.

Overall it seems to be pretty fiercely territorial, so no surprise why they have trouble attracting new contributors.

Re:How Wikipedia's reaction to sudden popularity is causing ... by yuhong on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @10:24PM (#8599739)
There is an emacs stackexchange in beta now: http://emacs.stackexchange.com/
Re:How Wikipedia's reaction to sudden popularity is causing ... by a_gentle_autist on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @07:14PM (#8599185)
You know the same thing happens here, right?

Not everyone can down vote, flag, etc.

Irony isn't lost on me.