News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by skratlo on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @08:11AM (#8589599)
I don't get it either. If GNOME (the desktop environment and the foundation) have a trademark on GNOME, why do they need $80k to defend it? Shouldn't the trademark office then simply reject any further application for GNOME name related to computers, software and operating systems? Is this because of the idiotic defunc. justice system the US is imposing on themselves? Where you can sue mall owner for millions because you slipped on his floor? sigh
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by Cthulhu_ on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @08:15AM (#8589608)
IIRC, the rule is that if you don't step up yourself to defend your trademark whenever someone else tries to use it, your trademark becomes void.
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by skratlo on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @08:20AM (#8589620)
Could you kindly explain me then what's the point of registering a trademark? Is it something you can then wave with in front of jury? Do you really need $80k for that? Do you need $80k to print out your accepted trademark application, and prove that you're in the business for 17 years? Sorry this is just complete non-sense and failure of the system.
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by bad_user on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @08:56AM (#8589752)
Not only that, but those $80k could have paid for quite a few months of development, but instead those will be money going down the drain because of a broken justice system. And they have the nerve to say that IP laws are fueling innovation.
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by Alphasite_ on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @09:25AM (#8589904)
Well, without these IP laws GNOME wouldn't have any recourse, would they?
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by zanny on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @10:36AM (#8590288)
Without IP GNOME would not care. GNOME users would know not to associate Groupon with GNOME, and without IP you could call all your stuff anything you want, and that does not mean anything to anyone else, unless you manipulate people into seeing the wrong brand in the wrong place. IE, deception.
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by quadrangle on Thursday November 13, 2014 @06:26PM (#8604842)
Your misunderstanding highlights why we need to demolish the term "Intellectual Property".

Patents and Copyright stifle innovation and should be reformed or abolished. Trademark is essential consumer protection against fraud and manipulation and is extremely important to keep, although it needs to be fixed not to require prohibitive costs to defend one's trademark.

Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by zanny on Friday November 14, 2014 @01:06AM (#8606021)
There was no misunderstanding. Trademarks, as you yourself have said, are also an exploitative tool of abuse by entrenched interests. Impersonation and slander should still be illegal, but the claiming of ownership of a name is only rife for abuse. I'm against IP in general.
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by ekianjo on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @09:09AM (#8589817)
Trademark has barely anything to do with IP laws. You are referring to patents, and trademark legislation has nothing to do with patents.
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by bad_user on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @09:28AM (#8589920)
Copyright, trademarks, patents, industrial design rights, trade dress, trade secrets are all lumped together under the intellectual property term. Yes, you can argue that the term itself is incorrect as property is used here in a way that contradicts the law itself, also lumping together different laws under the same umbrella, preventing rational discussions about specifics, but there you have it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intellectual_property

Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by maxlybbert on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @09:29AM (#8589924)
I didn't see any comments that applied to patents (e.g., that they cover inventions, that they require the inventor to disclose all relevant details of the invention, that they have definite lifetimes, etc.), so while I agree with you and Stallman that it's important to be explicit about when you're talking about copyright, trade secrets, patents and trademarks, I don't think anybody's created any confusion yet.

Besides, for amusement's sake, the USPTO stands for "United States Patent and Trademark Office."

Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by ekianjo on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @10:06AM (#8590111)
> I didn't see any comments that applied to patents

Well, when someone mentioned "fuel innovation", I assume they did not talk about trademarks, because trademarks have NOTHING to do with protecting innovation. That's what patents are for (in theory, while I don't agree with that, but that's a different topic).

Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by maxlybbert on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @10:27AM (#8590237)
You're right: I had overlooked that statement.
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by gavinballard on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @09:18AM (#8589859)
Trademarks are a form of intellectual property.
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by misterbishop on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @09:42AM (#8589990)
'Intellectual Property' is not a legal classification, and shouldn't be. Patents, Trademarks, Copyrights, and looser-defined 'trade secrets' all have distinct purposes. Saying "Intellectual Property" when you mean "Trademark" gives the impression that the holder has all kinds of legal protections which don't actually apply.

Over the long term, there's danger that legal theories will change to further expand the rights of corporate publishers.

Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by dragonwriter on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @10:08AM (#8590121)
> 'Intellectual Property' is not a legal classification, and shouldn't be.

Intellectual Property isn't a classification defined in law, but it is an analytic classification used in law, the same way that various other subcategories of "property" are, to discuss related protections.

∀X : X ∈ { Copyright, Trademark, Patent, ... }, X ⊂ Intellectual Property ⊂ Intangible Personal Property ⊂ Personal Property ⊂ Property.

Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by dalke on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @10:56AM (#8590419)
Those are not true subsets like you suggest. Consider that moral rights, which fall under intellectual property law, don't fit into the "property" category. For example, the "right [of the author] to prevent the destruction of a work of art if it is of 'recognized stature'" is not something which is true of anything I know of outside of creative works.

In German law, the inventor of a patent has the right to a share of the profit even if developed as an employee of the company making the profit; again, something not shared with tangible property.

I think of the relationship between "intellectual property" and "property" is more akin to "Pluto is a dwarf planet, but it's not a planet."

Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by dragonwriter on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @11:09AM (#8590516)
> Those are not true subsets like you suggest.

Yes, they are.

> Consider that moral rights, which fall under intellectual property law, don't fit into the "property" category.

Moral rights absolutely fall under the property category.

> For example, the "right [of the author] to prevent the destruction of a work of art if it is of 'recognized stature'" is not something which is true of anything I know of outside of creative works.

Well, yes, the fact that element x is an element of set A and set A is a subset of set B, and set C is a subset of set B does not imply that x is an element of set C.

The whole point of named subsets of property (and, named subsets as analytic categories in general) is that the names come from features that are shared within the named subset that are distinct from other subsets in the broader set. So, yes, Copyright has features that are dissimilar to Patent or Trademark, IP generally has features that are dissimilar to other intangible personal property, intangible personal property has features that are dissimilar to tangible personal property, and personal property generally has features that are dissimilar to real property.

Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by dalke on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @11:33AM (#8590660)
You are right. My examples were not valid counter examples.

I think of a property right as something which is transferable. The two examples I gave were of rights that were not transferable. However, if "Personal Property" also includes non-transferable rights, then there's no conflict.

As a clear counter-counter-example of why my counter-example is wrong, tenancy rights are part of real property law, and may or may not include succession rights.

My comment then transforms to the (trivial) observation that intellectual property ⊄ real property.

Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by dragonwriter on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @09:57AM (#8590051)
> Could you kindly explain me then what's the point of registering a trademark?

---

* Public notice of your claim of ownership of the mark;

* A legal presumption of your ownership of the mark and your exclusive right to use the mark nationwide on or in connection with the goods/services listed in the registration;

* The ability to bring an action concerning the mark in federal court;

* The use of the U.S. registration as a basis to obtain registration in foreign countries;

* The ability to record the U.S. registration with the U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) Service to prevent importation of infringing foreign goods;

* The right to use the federal registration symbol ®; and Listing in the United States Patent and Trademark Office’s online databases.

---

from http://www.uspto.gov/faq/trademarks.jsp#_Toc275426681

Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by akmiller on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @09:10AM (#8589820)
The system is a mess. I have a small side project and I trademarked the name, yet a competitor of mine used my trademark to promote their site and after speaking with several people about my situation they made it clear that unless I was willing to put up about six figures to fight it there isn't much I could do.
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by parfe on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @09:30AM (#8589927)
None of those people you spoke to sound like lawyers. It won't cost six figures to have a lawyer send a letter. Your competitor might not like the six figures prospect of defending themselves.
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by akmiller on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @10:23AM (#8590212)
Actually they were business people who have been through this battle before spending in the six figures to defend their marks (along with my brother who is a patent attorney). But yes, you are correct that sending a letter is the first step but if that step is ignored then the next step will cost money...and too much money for a single developers side project!
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by jabbernotty on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @08:24AM (#8589642)
Yes, it is a disappointment. And yet, it is the reality. As a result, the GNOME team does still need to pay their lawyers.
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by crorella on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @08:53AM (#8589743)
This is really disappointing and could be use to harass a company, what stops a malicious group of people do a "copyright ddos" by just forcing a company to pay 80k each time they need to defend it's trademarks?
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by maaaats on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @09:04AM (#8589787)
That's how patent trolls operate. Cheaper for companies to pay their fee than to fight the battle.
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by vec on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @12:00PM (#8590830)
No, you need that 80k to argue that Groupon's proposed product would infringe your trademark.

US trademarks are only good for the line of business I'm in. If I were to publish a software product called Mustang, for example, Ford wouldn't be able to sue me for copyright infringement. My product shares a trademark with one of theirs, but it's in a different enough market that the two trademarks don't conflict with each other.

It sounds like Groupon's proposed product is point of sale hardware. That's different enough from a desktop window manager that Groupon can quite possibly get a lawyer to convince a jury that they're different businesses. Therefore GNOME Foundation has to pay a lawyer to stand up and argue the other side of the case.

Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by voidz on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @08:22AM (#8589635)
Well what they say is "if it costs less we will put the rest into our product"...
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by weavie on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @09:27AM (#8589915)
Surely though, if Gnome win the case then Groupon would become liable to pay the costs?
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by matt_morgan on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @10:03AM (#8590088)
Not necessarily. There are a lot of circumstances in which the case could end in Gnome's favor, without that judgment.
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by weavie on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @11:14AM (#8590547)
Do you have an example of such a circumstance?
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by matt_morgan on Sunday November 16, 2014 @10:29AM (#8614390)
I'm not going to Google it for you. But they could settle the case, e.g. Groupon could agree not to use the name after it becomes clear that Gnome has spent enough to assemble a legal defense. And Gnome decides that the cost of pursuing further action makes it too risky.
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by icebraining on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @08:27AM (#8589662)
Could you kindly explain me then what's the point of registering a trademark?

Mostly so that you can get (triple) damages and lawyer fees from the infringer in case you win the lawsuit.

Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @10:50AM (#8590382)
This is widely believed and wrong.

Your registered trademark fails when you stop paying your renewal fees. The only other way is for it to become genericised, which is about public use and not about others using it for doing business [1].

Previous commercial use however is an absolute defence in trademark law, making it also impossible to steal a trademark (another oft repeated falsehood): just to anticipate the idea that "Groupon will get an RTM and sue GNOME".

[1] - http://digitalcommons.law.scu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?articl... - Elliott v Google, trademark genericisation.

Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by philipn on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @08:39AM (#8589701)
That's if someone is using it, not someone trying to register it. I always imagined that the US Patent and Trademark Office had a period where people could file complaints about pending trademarks, which is a different process.
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by listic on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @09:35AM (#8589957)
What is the rationale behind that?
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by grabeh on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @10:06AM (#8590113)
The rule is not a strict requirement although broadly speaking a trade mark owner is required to enforce their trade marks in relation to third party use which is likely to confuse the public.

The rationale is that trade marks are designed to be a badge of origin & to guarantee to consumers that the goods are from a particular entity. If I do not show due regard for maintaining that distinction by taking action against third parties making confusing use of an identical/similar mark then I should not have the right to continue making use of the mark, or at the very least could be said to have consented to the third party use and cannot subsequently stop them.

Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by samspot on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @11:22AM (#8590595)
I believe the idea is that if I register "Bruiser's Cars", that name doesn't automatically become unavailable to others for hundreds of years. I need to prove that I am still using the trademark somehow. Unfortunately that results in me needing a lawyer, which really sucks for a small business.

Note that the patent system (in theory) works the way you describe, but it hasn't eliminated the need for lawyers.

Finally, in the mall example, what usually happens is the judge finds that the mall saved millions by never cleaning their floors, so the company is punished by losing all the money they made. It is extremely rare for someone to get millions over something small.

Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by rayiner on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @10:57AM (#8590431)
The issue is, of course, "how related is related?" The USPTO will do a trademark search to see if an application conflicts with an existing mark. The $80k the foundation is spending isn't for that, it's to convince the USPTO that "GNOME" for a point-of-sale system is unacceptably close to "GNOME" for a desktop shell.
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by FooBarWidget on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @08:17AM (#8589613)
It's because lawyers are that expensive.
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by lucb1e on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @08:29AM (#8589667)
Let's assume they cost $500 an hour, which is probably enough to pay three of them but I have no idea about the price so let's assume it's that. Then $80k / 500 = 160 hours. Does it take 160 hours, or 4 work weeks full-time, to write a letter or fill out some form saying that "hey, we registered this back in 2006, you should reject these applications"?
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by valarauca1 on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @08:37AM (#8589690)
You are assuming that is all that it would just take sending a letter. Likely they want to put a single lawyer on retainer for the duration of the copyright battle to ensure that a longer legal battle does not draw from other sources in the gnome project.
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by ekianjo on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @09:10AM (#8589822)
Seriously have you ever worked with lawyers? If not, you should probably think twice before commenting :)
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by lucb1e on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @09:16AM (#8589847)
No I haven't which is why don't understand why they need the money. If someone could explain, that'd be nice...
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by zimpenfish on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @11:23AM (#8596297)
I think it's basically "because doing the lawing is a lot more complicated than most people think"

e.g. http://blogs.findlaw.com/law_and_life/2013/03/why-do-lawyers...

And another view: http://abovethelaw.com/2011/10/why-are-lawyers-so-expensive-...

Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by jforman on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @09:00AM (#8589775)
$500/hr is the price of 1.5 IP lawyers, based on the median hourly rate in Oregon:

https://www.osbar.org/_docs/resources/HourlyRatesSurvey/Inte...

On the other hand, it only affords 1/2 a lawyer if you're talking white shoe partner in SF or NYC.

Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by iancarroll on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @08:34AM (#8589686)
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by nodata on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @08:53AM (#8589741)
I'm not sure what you are suggesting here..
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by lucb1e on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @09:18AM (#8589860)
That I have no idea what in this whole process takes so much money. If trademarks take this much money to defend, you might as well just sue anyone trying to use your name without filing a trademark.
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by outworlder on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @09:34AM (#8589950)
And then lose spetacularly, since you don't own the trademark.
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by lucb1e on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @09:40AM (#8589983)
At least in Europe you're not required to register a trademark to be able to use it. If I've been selling red toy cars in Dutch toy stores for five years and they all had a clearly recognizable logo on them, then someone else uses a logo that is almost identical to sell orange toy cars in the same or nearby toy stores, I might very well win that lawsuit.

It is geographically limited and limited to the market segment, and I'm not sure about international laws, but technically they just stole something you've been using for years. If the trademark system is this expensive for legitimately protecting a registered trademark, I see no use for the whole registered trademark system.

Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by toyg on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @10:06AM (#8590110)
The laws you mention are long-standing, but the trademark system was developed to sort out all border cases that this approach inevitably fails to address. Does it matter if toy cars are orange or green? What if they are toy trucks? Etc etc. Trademark is not compulsory, but it's advantageous in most cases.

Without trademarks, each doubtful claim would require a full run through the courts; and depending on whether you do or don't use Common Law (i.e. in France, Italy, Spain etc), legal precedents wouldn't even hold in most cases, so every single time you'd have to repeat it. That's expensive for everyone involved, including the State.

With trademarks, you have to specify fairly-precise categories at registration, and then there is no dispute. If you file for "BestCars" in "toys", that's it, nobody else gets to make any toy with your name, regardless of whether your cars are red or yellow or even look like a car; if they try, you first threaten them (which will solve 90% of cases right away), then easily slap them in court with a quick process (judge looks at trademark filing, looks at toys, and rules for infringement).

Trademarking works, to be honest. It's one of those things you only ever hear when they fail, which they do, occasionally. In this case we all believe Groupon should have been told "your name is too similar to another in category 021" by an automated system while filing, rather than being allowed to file and wait for a challenge, right? Except companies file trademarks and then they die, and what happens to their trademarks then? Should the state actively scan the business market, going door-to-door telling people "you can't do that because the other guy was doing it first"? That's a huge burden, especially in a global marketplace. It's much more efficient to just timestamp files (which is basically what the office does, by accepting a request) and then deal with the few complaints when they arise -- which they likely will only if the two companies really occupy the same marketplace, incidentally. Believe it or not, most people would rather stand out for originality and won't willingly try to steal someone else's trade name; it's better to just wait for the occasional sociopathic Groupon and then slam it like it deserves (hopefully).

Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by Tombone5 on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @10:55AM (#8590412)
The state already needs to keep track of companies for tax purposes, so it seems strange that it couldn't simply void any trademark owned by a company that died.

Then define point of death as a company not paying taxes for two years and not declaring the company to be in some special tax-exempt state.