News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by ekianjo on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @09:09AM (#8589817)
Trademark has barely anything to do with IP laws. You are referring to patents, and trademark legislation has nothing to do with patents.
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by bad_user on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @09:28AM (#8589920)
Copyright, trademarks, patents, industrial design rights, trade dress, trade secrets are all lumped together under the intellectual property term. Yes, you can argue that the term itself is incorrect as property is used here in a way that contradicts the law itself, also lumping together different laws under the same umbrella, preventing rational discussions about specifics, but there you have it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intellectual_property

Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by maxlybbert on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @09:29AM (#8589924)
I didn't see any comments that applied to patents (e.g., that they cover inventions, that they require the inventor to disclose all relevant details of the invention, that they have definite lifetimes, etc.), so while I agree with you and Stallman that it's important to be explicit about when you're talking about copyright, trade secrets, patents and trademarks, I don't think anybody's created any confusion yet.

Besides, for amusement's sake, the USPTO stands for "United States Patent and Trademark Office."

Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by ekianjo on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @10:06AM (#8590111)
> I didn't see any comments that applied to patents

Well, when someone mentioned "fuel innovation", I assume they did not talk about trademarks, because trademarks have NOTHING to do with protecting innovation. That's what patents are for (in theory, while I don't agree with that, but that's a different topic).

Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by maxlybbert on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @10:27AM (#8590237)
You're right: I had overlooked that statement.
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by gavinballard on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @09:18AM (#8589859)
Trademarks are a form of intellectual property.
Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by misterbishop on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @09:42AM (#8589990)
'Intellectual Property' is not a legal classification, and shouldn't be. Patents, Trademarks, Copyrights, and looser-defined 'trade secrets' all have distinct purposes. Saying "Intellectual Property" when you mean "Trademark" gives the impression that the holder has all kinds of legal protections which don't actually apply.

Over the long term, there's danger that legal theories will change to further expand the rights of corporate publishers.

Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by dragonwriter on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @10:08AM (#8590121)
> 'Intellectual Property' is not a legal classification, and shouldn't be.

Intellectual Property isn't a classification defined in law, but it is an analytic classification used in law, the same way that various other subcategories of "property" are, to discuss related protections.

∀X : X ∈ { Copyright, Trademark, Patent, ... }, X ⊂ Intellectual Property ⊂ Intangible Personal Property ⊂ Personal Property ⊂ Property.

Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by dalke on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @10:56AM (#8590419)
Those are not true subsets like you suggest. Consider that moral rights, which fall under intellectual property law, don't fit into the "property" category. For example, the "right [of the author] to prevent the destruction of a work of art if it is of 'recognized stature'" is not something which is true of anything I know of outside of creative works.

In German law, the inventor of a patent has the right to a share of the profit even if developed as an employee of the company making the profit; again, something not shared with tangible property.

I think of the relationship between "intellectual property" and "property" is more akin to "Pluto is a dwarf planet, but it's not a planet."

Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by dragonwriter on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @11:09AM (#8590516)
> Those are not true subsets like you suggest.

Yes, they are.

> Consider that moral rights, which fall under intellectual property law, don't fit into the "property" category.

Moral rights absolutely fall under the property category.

> For example, the "right [of the author] to prevent the destruction of a work of art if it is of 'recognized stature'" is not something which is true of anything I know of outside of creative works.

Well, yes, the fact that element x is an element of set A and set A is a subset of set B, and set C is a subset of set B does not imply that x is an element of set C.

The whole point of named subsets of property (and, named subsets as analytic categories in general) is that the names come from features that are shared within the named subset that are distinct from other subsets in the broader set. So, yes, Copyright has features that are dissimilar to Patent or Trademark, IP generally has features that are dissimilar to other intangible personal property, intangible personal property has features that are dissimilar to tangible personal property, and personal property generally has features that are dissimilar to real property.

Re:Help the Gnome Foundation Defend the Gnome Trademark Agai... by dalke on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @11:33AM (#8590660)
You are right. My examples were not valid counter examples.

I think of a property right as something which is transferable. The two examples I gave were of rights that were not transferable. However, if "Personal Property" also includes non-transferable rights, then there's no conflict.

As a clear counter-counter-example of why my counter-example is wrong, tenancy rights are part of real property law, and may or may not include succession rights.

My comment then transforms to the (trivial) observation that intellectual property ⊄ real property.