News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by carlisle_ on Monday November 10, 2014 @02:41PM (#8585751)
>There was no concern for his vegan diet

I can't be the only one that thinks it's ridiculous for a prison to accommodate voluntary diets like this.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by mikeyouse on Monday November 10, 2014 @03:04PM (#8585910)
Is it really much different than Jews keeping Kosher or Muslims keeping Halal? Prisons are for punishment for crimes that we consider significant enough to jail people, they don't have to dehumanize the prisoners.

The cost of 'specialty' food for a few tiny percent of prisoners is a minuscule figure in the total cost of imprisonment, and could easily be accommodated within the wider food offerings. If every meal had Kosher / Halal / Vegan offerings as a subset of the total meal, we could both imprison people and treat their ethics and morals with respect. Seems like a win-win.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by MichaelGG on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:29PM (#8586603)
It's still unelegant and inconsistent. If I claim my diet requires high-quality food determined by me daily, that gets ignored.

I understand Kosher for commercial enterprises like airlines: with a minimum of effort, they can satisfy many customers. But governments should have consistent treatment of citizens.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by rudolf0 on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:40PM (#8586682)
Even if a diet choice is voluntary, if the choice is grounded in religious or ethical reasons then it is an infringement of personal freedom to deny that. Yes, prison itself is an infringement of freedom, but some believe that certain freedoms should remain permanent.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by Alupis on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:53PM (#8586768)
Well, religious diets are arguably not voluntary. I'd say it's far different to allow a Kosher meal than it is to plan, purchase, prep, and serve a special diet to one inmate who has a preference of diet because that is how they chose to eat on the outside.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by rudolf0 on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:58PM (#8586803)
I'm going to have to disagree with you there.

Religious diets are not voluntary, but choice of religion is voluntary.

Vegetarian/vegan diets adhering to an ethical philosophy are not voluntary, but choosing to accept an animal rights philosophy is voluntary.

Either both are a choice or neither are a choice, depending on how you define your terms.

Now, if the vegan diet was for personal taste or even for health reasons (as long as there was no significant health impact from going off of it), then it's a different story.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by fru2013 on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @12:27AM (#8588467)
>Religious diets are not voluntary, but choice of religion is voluntary.

Care to elaborate on this? Perhaps I am misunderstanding, but I cannot see how a religious diet is not voluntary. Surely someone on a religious diet could eat certain foods if they choose to or not, no?

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by Alupis on Monday November 10, 2014 @05:14PM (#8586933)
> Religious diets are not voluntary, but choice of religion is voluntary.

Agreed

> Vegetarian/vegan diets adhering to an ethical philosophy are not voluntary, but choosing to accept an animal rights philosophy is voluntary.

Not agreed. Your right to accept certain philosophies while in prion is forfeited upon conviction. This means, if you are not eating meat because you simply feel it's wrong -- well, the prison has no obligation to oblige you. If you are not eating meat because of your religion, that is different. Sure - one may "convert" to a new religion to obtain a certain preferred diet, but that is still applying the rule evenly and fairly.

> Now, if the vegan diet was for personal taste or even for health reasons (as long as there was no significant health impact from going off of it), then it's a different story.

This would be the foundation for an awful law which would be enforced with bias and randomness. How do you actually determine if a diet is being followed for pure taste reasoning, or if it's something based on personal ethics? You cannot, and therefore this cannot be a rule. Rules and laws must be based on a foundation that can be applied evenly and fairly to all, not left up to judgement by a sometimes-in-a-nice-mood-sometimes-in-a-bad-mood warden.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by rudolf0 on Monday November 10, 2014 @05:37PM (#8587054)
Where are you drawing this line between religion and ethics? Jews believe it is wrong to eat pork, vegans believe it is wrong to eat animals. What makes one of these beliefs a protected status and one not?

>How do you actually determine if a diet is being followed for pure taste reasoning, or if it's something based on personal ethics?

One can also lie about religious affiliation, or magically "convert", to get better or alternative meals, and in fact some prisoners do this. I don't see your point.

Religious belief and ethical belief both reside in someone's mind and nowhere else.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by DanBC on Monday November 10, 2014 @05:21PM (#8586968)
> Not agreed. Your right to accept certain philosophies while in prion is forfeited upon conviction.

There are a bunch of international covenants and agreements that disagree with you.

This document talks specifically about food: http://www.prisonersabroad.org.uk/uploads/documents/prisoner...

Your misrepresentations of the reasons some people are vegan or vegetarian are so severe it makes the conversation pointless. Some people have beliefs about eatig meat that are equivalent to religious belief.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by Alupis on Monday November 10, 2014 @05:48PM (#8587129)
The document you linked to does not protect personal choice of diet.

> 2.3.9 European Prison Rules

> See para (1.2.4) above for an explanation of the European Prison Rules. Rule 22 states “Prisoners shall be provided with a nutritious diet that takes into account their ... religion, culture ..."

> 2.4 Vegetarian and Vegan diets

> In some countries, the food provided to all prisoners may be vegetarian (non-vegetarians may have to buy meat).

So the inverse is true with prisons that serve meat.

> Receiving vegetarian or vegan meals in prison may not be an easy process. In some countries, you may be required to show that your request for a vegetarian or vegan diet is based on ethical or religious beliefs.

Again, the EU portion of this document does not protect ethical beliefs, only religious ones.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by meowface on Monday November 10, 2014 @09:45PM (#8588003)
The argument isn't about whether they do (clearly they don't, based on the article), it's about whether they should.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by Alupis on Monday November 10, 2014 @10:06PM (#8588086)
Not really -- the direct parent of my comment was making the point that ethics are indeed a reason to obey prisoner's dietary desires. As I pointed out -- they are not.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by zanny on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:49PM (#8586739)
Well obviously the prisons disagree, and since they are fundamentally rooted in the denial of freedom then I don't think anyone involved in the prison industrial complex (even in Sweden) is going to care to hear arguments about how they should be nicer to prisoners.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by DanBC on Monday November 10, 2014 @05:06PM (#8586875)
http://www.prisonersabroad.org.uk/uploads/documents/prisoner...

There are plenty of people workig on makig prisons nicer for prisoners. This includes respecting their religion (as guided by the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR).

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by PhasmaFelis on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:43PM (#8586698)
> It's still unelegant and inconsistent. If I claim my diet requires high-quality food determined by me daily, that gets ignored.

Wardens are not robots and are capable of applying common sense and judgment. If a prisoner claims that his morals require him not to eat animal products, he's likely to be telling the truth. If he claims his morals require Kobe beef daily, he's probably lying.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by MichaelGG on Monday November 10, 2014 @05:49PM (#8587135)
Why is my claim that I must have Kobe beef (because I'm divine, and I say so) any less valid than the claim I can't eat pork because God said so?
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by PhasmaFelis on Monday November 10, 2014 @11:34PM (#8588315)
Because one of them is an earnestly held belief and the other is you lying to get special treatment, and humans are capable of telling the difference. See the bit above about using common sense and not being a mindless rule-applying robot.

Also, because people who request kosher, halal, vegetarian, or vegan diets in prison aren't generally demanding higher-quality food, just different food. When accommodated, they generally still get low-grade prison fare. Thus there's little motivation to lie about it.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by MichaelGG on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @12:11AM (#8588419)
So before I go to prison, I should earnestly develop a sincere desire for, say, pancakes every day, then it'd count?

I understand that law interpreters are not mindless robots. However it seems very arbitrary to support kosher and halal, but not Pastafarian diets.

It's as silly as only granting conscientious objector status to "real" Mennonites.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by PhasmaFelis on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @12:45AM (#8588508)
As soon as you develop an honest and genuine belief that your moral system requires you to eat pancakes, I'll consider the notion that prisons should be required to serve you shitty, leathery pancakes.

The thing is, you're not going to do that, and neither is anyone else. Policy should not be guided by ridiculous hypotheticals.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by emidln on Monday November 10, 2014 @06:54PM (#8587436)
Higher weight is given to mass delusions compared to acute delusions.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by boomlinde on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @12:19PM (#8590939)
> It's still unelegant and inconsistent.

Yes, what a shame in such an otherwise elegant and consistent system.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by wamatt on Monday November 10, 2014 @05:14PM (#8586931)
>The cost of 'specialty' food for a few tiny percent of prisoners is a minuscule figure in the total cost of imprisonment, and could easily be accommodated within the wider food offerings.

Agreed, this would seem to be manageable without much burden on the system.

On the other hand however, this reasoning discounts scenarios where inmates are pushing these subjective demarcations, for furthering their own needs, at the expense of being fair to everyone.

For example, in many states prisoner's may earn exemptions based off their religious practices.[1] If, an atheist prisoner, was denied sex, just because of their beliefs, I suspect they would have a right to be upset.

One should keep in mind, that it's quite possible to be supportive of increasing prisoner's rights and benefits, whilst also pushing for prisoner equality.

[1] http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/2014...

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by jsemrau on Monday November 10, 2014 @10:01PM (#8588070)
Well said. Basic human rights.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by r00fus on Monday November 10, 2014 @02:58PM (#8585874)
> I can't be the only one that thinks it's ridiculous for a prison to accommodate voluntary diets like this.

Well, it all depends on whether you think a prison is meant primarily for rehabilitation or punishment.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by paulhauggis on Monday November 10, 2014 @03:24PM (#8586076)
on HN, it depends.

a greedy corporate fat cat that cheated people? punishment. Drug or copyright infringement related crimes? rehab.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by jackvalentine on Monday November 10, 2014 @03:51PM (#8586308)
And why so you think that is? (I'm withholding my opinion/explanation until I feel I understand yours and can provide a more valuable response)
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by ChuckMcM on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:17PM (#8586510)
I don't know paul, and his comment reads like a counter-troll, but the implicit statement that the audience of the statement incorporates their own perspective on the morality of the crime into their perception of the remedy is valid.

The question about diets for prisoners that accommodate the needs of the prisoner is generally a 20th century concept[1]. And generally case after case has sided with the prisoners[2].

[1] I've yet to find a case prior to the treatment of prisoners of war in WW 1 that discussed diet but I haven't looked particularly hard so I offer this opinion with confidence but not certainty :-)

[2] Recent example -- https://www.prisonlegalnews.org/news/2014/may/19/florida-pri...

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by tedunangst on Monday November 10, 2014 @05:17PM (#8586942)
The things I want to do shouldn't be crimes. The things I don't like other people doing should be crimes.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by angersock on Monday November 10, 2014 @03:50PM (#8586295)
It would help all of us, I imagine, were we to actually use separate institutions for those purposes.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by crazypyro on Monday November 10, 2014 @03:53PM (#8586321)
Are you implying that the distinction the grandparent poster made is correct?

(I'm almost positive it was sarcastic)

All prisons should be about rehabilitation. Anything else is simply a multiplier to an already existent drain on society.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by baddox on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:00PM (#8586382)
When you say "punishment," are you also including the deterrent effect of the threat of punishment?
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by baddox on Monday November 10, 2014 @03:58PM (#8586358)
Why does it depend on that?
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by Someone1234 on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:01PM (#8586383)
Because the only goal of forcing someone to eat something they consider immoral is to punish. It certainly won't help rehabilitation efforts (likely hurt them, in fact).
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by baddox on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:04PM (#8586413)
That need not be a goal, and it certainly wouldn't be the only goal. The primary goal would be cost and logistics. I don't think prisons have chefs custom making meals for each prisoner.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by Someone1234 on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:21PM (#8586539)
Short term savings for long term costs. How much is recidivism costing the US right now? They have made massive savings per prisoner but their reoffending rates are 60% Vs. 30% for Sweden.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by Alupis on Monday November 10, 2014 @05:04PM (#8586862)
I seriously doubt quality of food is a factor in reoffending rates.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by kmm on Monday November 10, 2014 @08:44PM (#8587793)
And you're wrong. Food quality is a small piece of the big puzzle of how prisoners are treated, which obviously affects how they will reintegrate in society, which is something that recidivism rates measure.

Prisons should not be about punishing people. Punishment would lead to just more drain on society. I would have hoped we'd have outgrown this childish yearn for revenge in the 21st century.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by baddox on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @02:36AM (#8588745)
You, like many people in this thread, seem to imply that punishment only serves to take revenge, or to balance the cosmic scales of justice. But you miss the obvious purpose of punishment: that it deters crime.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by pluma on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @07:43PM (#8593297)
... which doesn't work. And if the victim's family is allowed to observe the execution of the prisoner, for example, that has nothing to do with deterring crime. There are countless other examples, especially in how both public officials and law enforcement agents, and the media portray court cases.

All the talk about justice being served is missing the point: if punishment is meant to deter crime (either by subduing/rehabilitating the prisoner or by serving as an example to would-be criminals), the feelings of the victim or the victim's family are irrelevant.

But we can actually measure whether punishments are a useful deterrent. Harsher punishments aren't better deterrents. In fact, they may even have the opposite effect: if you're already committing a crime that incurs the practical maximum (i.e. life-long imprisonment or the death penalty), the potential punishment for further crimes can not provide any deterrent at all. What can you practically add beyond that? Torture? Mutilation? A slow and painful death?

I'm not going to argue that the complete absence of punishment would be better. But in order to serve as a useful deterrent punishments often would have to be comically disproportionate to the actual harm of the crime. And that's exactly what we have in the US.

There are exactly three possible explanations to why the US is beating the entire Western world in terms of prison population: a) every other country in the Western world is overrun by criminals because we don't lock up enough of them, b) Americans on average are much more likely to be criminals or c) American prison terms are absurdly disproportionate. I know the right-wing media (or by non-American standards: the far right-wing media) likes to promote a) and Hollywood might be sold on b), I think we both know the answer is c).

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by Alupis on Monday November 10, 2014 @10:06PM (#8588091)
I still doubt good quality macaroni causes people to get out of prison and not steal more cars.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by tedunangst on Monday November 10, 2014 @05:04PM (#8586860)
And you think recidivism in the US is based on the food? Prison food is so good people can't wait to commit more crimes and get back inside?
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by na85 on Monday November 10, 2014 @05:17PM (#8586947)
Oh please.

Parent post argues that forcing inmates to eat food they consider immoral contributes to their "fuck the Man" mentality, and contributes to the recidivist mentality.

By spinning that into an argument about prison food being so good as to attract reoffenders, you are being childish and dishonest.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by zak_mc_kracken on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:19PM (#8586525)
> Because the only goal of forcing someone to eat something they consider immoral is to punish.

Prison is punishment first, rehabilitation second (and it's pretty bad at that considering the percentage of recidivists).

Of all the consequences of breaking the law, being forced to eat something you don't like certainly sounds pretty mild.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by TomGullen on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:25PM (#8586569)
Only because YOU consider it mild, probably because you're happy to eat anything.

Do you not understand that perhaps other people might feel differently? And are you unable to empathise with that point of view?

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by zak_mc_kracken on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:27PM (#8586589)
There are a lot of things I don't like to eat and I'm pretty sure that I would find eating in prison quite troublesome, regardless of what the food is.

It's one of the many prices you pay for breaking the law, but surely losing your freedom and seeing the world move on without you should dominate this unease?

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by UrMomReadsHN on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:50PM (#8586754)
Well there is a major distinction here. We aren't talking about "i don't care for meat." We are talking about someone's deeply held convictions on morality. Oftentimes vegetarianism is a major part of their identity and culture.

A vegetarian diet can be part of a relgious practce. Plenty of Indian religions emphasize a vegetarian diet - Jainism, Hinduism and Buddhism. As well as well as the Seventh-day Adventist, a Christian religion.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by baddox on Monday November 10, 2014 @05:27PM (#8587007)
How do you test the depth of one's convictions on the morality of various diets? Do you think that people can willfully choose their own convictions?
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by UrMomReadsHN on Monday November 10, 2014 @09:48PM (#8588019)
People can willfully choose their own religion too but it is considered unethical to force a group of people to convert to your preferred religion. In fact that can be considered a form of ethnic cleansing in some situations.

FYI - i personally am a vegetarian (for over a decade) for ethical reasons and being forced to eat meat would be extremely horrific for me. And i don't think that i would be able to eat fish at all without vomiting. Feel free to make fun of me or whatever.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by baddox on Monday November 10, 2014 @10:35PM (#8588156)
> People can willfully choose their own religion too but it is considered unethical to force a group of people to convert to your preferred religion.

That's why I asked for a test procedure. Someone can claim that they genuinely believe in the Flying Spaghetti Monster and therefore must wear a colander on their head, and without a test, how do you distinguish that from a clothing restriction from a major world religion? You either need some internal test on the mindset of the individual (e.g. a polygraph, if those worked), or an external test on the claimed religion (e.g. a minimum number of global followers).

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by JoeAltmaier on Monday November 10, 2014 @05:30PM (#8587022)
"A fixed or firm belief" - hm, sounds like religion all right. So, just like a person can't choose a religion, neither can they willfully choose a conviction?
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by TomGullen on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:30PM (#8586606)
> I'm pretty sure that I would find eating in prison quite troublesome

Because you don't like the quality, or because it goes against your ethics?

Do you not see the distinction?

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by zak_mc_kracken on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:50PM (#8586748)
I see the distinction, I'm just saying the prisoner's ethics are irrelevant: the society decides what rights and privileges prisoners get in prison, regardless of what they think they are entitled to.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by rudolf0 on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:41PM (#8586689)
Religion and/or ethics are completely different from distaste.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by schoen on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:31PM (#8586612)
I think it's significant that you switched the parent commenter's "something they consider immoral" to "something you don't like". It does sound pretty mild if it's something you just don't like for mild aesthetic or taste reasons. That's definitely not the way many people think about some of the things that they don't eat.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by baddox on Monday November 10, 2014 @05:12PM (#8586918)
> I think it's significant that you switched the parent commenter's "something they consider immoral" to "something you don't like".

I'm not the parent commenter, but I think those two phrases imply only a difference in scale.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by zak_mc_kracken on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:43PM (#8586699)
How the prisoner perceives this deprivation is irrelevant:

"I need to eat filet mignon once a week"

"No"

"But it's immoral for me not to"

"Oh okay then"

Prisoners are granted privileges based on how society and its laws perceive their demands. Nothing gets automatically granted just because of morality or religious choices by the prisoner.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by delecti on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:27PM (#8586591)
That's really just a difference of opinion. As far as I'm concerned, the loss of freedom from being in prison is punishment enough, what happens to you there shouldn't be unnecessarily cruel or punishing.

The fact that our punishment-heavy system doesn't help recidivism should be a sign that purely punishment isn't effective at rehabilitation.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by PhasmaFelis on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:49PM (#8586737)
> Prison is punishment first, rehabilitation second

That's certainly how it is now, yes. You think that's how it should be?

Most prisons suck are incompetent and ineffective and need reforming. Accommodating vegans is one of the many things that needs to be reformed.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by DanBC on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:50PM (#8586742)
Entomophagy - eating insects - provides cheap protien. Would you be happy if you were forced to eat insects?

I don't think you understand how ingrained some of these "voluntary" diets are; how strong taboo is.

EDIT: also, forcing people to eat a certain diet is disproportionately punishng them. Do we give those prisoners reductions in their sentence just because they were life-long vegans before they went to prison?

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by chc on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:26PM (#8586578)
Just because you don't happen to share their values doesn't make this the same thing as being a picky eater. I don't think you'd be so cavalier if the prison were doing something that goes against your values — for example, if the prisoners were forced to eat human meat.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by zak_mc_kracken on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:33PM (#8586630)
You're in prison because you disregarded the values that society put in place, surely the society has no obligations to respect your values in prison (although it still goes to some length to do that).
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by chc on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:40PM (#8586673)
"You shoplifted an expensive purse, so now we can force you to eat your late mother" is a positively medieval stance to take. Prisoners are still human beings, and forcing them to do horrible things like that is a violation of both the general idea of human rights and several parts of the US Constitution.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by zak_mc_kracken on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:57PM (#8586795)
You're committing the slippery slope fallacy.

My point still stands regardless of the extreme example you decided to illustrate it: you disregarded society's values and in return the society will disregard some of your values.

The prisoner doesn't get to decide what is cruel and unusual punishment to them.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by kmm on Monday November 10, 2014 @08:51PM (#8587823)
Of course the prisoner doesn't, society does, but that's just being pedantic, nobody's arguing that!

The point is that a society that forces a diet on a prisoner , which that prisoner finds immoral, is wrong.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by knutsen on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:46PM (#8586716)
> Prison is punishment first, rehabilitation second

That is not a society I want to live in. Prison should protect the remaining population and rehabilitate, punishment should be a consequence of the means necessary to do so. Prioritizing in that order (protect -> rehabilitate). In my opinion anyways..

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by baddox on Monday November 10, 2014 @10:32PM (#8588150)
I think you dismiss the deterrent effect of punishment too hastily. I actually think that should be the primary purpose of prison (apart from forcing criminals to work to compensate their victims, but that one's probably too radical).

Rehabilitation should obviously be another goal, but for violent crimes I don't think there's a good way to predict recidivism that couldn't be gamed. If someone could theoretically be rehabilitated in a year for mass murder, should they be released? I don't think so, because that would drastically reduce the deterrence against murder.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by jsmthrowaway on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:50PM (#8586750)
It is the society you live in. The entire point of prison is to suck, so as to be a deterrent against going there.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by DanBC on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:57PM (#8586793)
But thise prisons are stupid. They're very expensive and they just don't work.

And by removjg diets you are disproportionately punishing some people. A Muslim given the same sentence as someone with no religion will suffer more as a result of imprisonment purely because of the lack of dietary choice.

"Prison should suck" is a horrible sentiment, and runs contrary to the UDHR. I understand that American hasn't ratified that, but that's not because they disagree with it.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by jsmthrowaway on Monday November 10, 2014 @05:08PM (#8586890)
I didn't say it was right. I said it is the society we live in. Subtle difference but a key one, since you ran with it and ascribed things to me I didn't say (I'm not sure where you read -- and quoted -- me saying "prisons should suck," so this is a really crucial misread). It is very important to understand that I did not share an opinion with that observation.

To that end, I've been there. You think I'd come out and go "gosh golly, that was sure an effective means of handling my situation?"

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by knutsen on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:58PM (#8586806)
Living in Norway, I don't feel that to be the truth. You have a great point though! But I think removal of freedom, and in some cases isolation, suffices as deterrent.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by fnordfnordfnord on Monday November 10, 2014 @05:03PM (#8586855)
>Prison is punishment first, rehabilitation second

Says who? Punishment (beyond the punishing nature of the denial of one's freedom) need only be a part of prison because some peoples' (defective) morality demands it.

The first priority of a prison is to protect the people at large from the expected behavior of convicted criminals.

>Of all the consequences of breaking the law, being forced to eat something you don't like certainly sounds pretty mild.

What reason do you have to believe that forcing vegan prisoners to eat a non-vegan diet (or starve) will have any rehabilitative effect? Or are you happy to mete out punishments arbitrarily based upon individuals' personalities?

Prisons already accommodate a multitude of diets for various (mandatory) reasons. It really isn't expensive to accommodate one more.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by baddox on Monday November 10, 2014 @05:11PM (#8586907)
It sounds like many of us in this thread might be talking past one another confusing normative and positive claims about the purpose of imprisonment.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by fnordfnordfnord on Monday November 10, 2014 @05:24PM (#8586985)
I think you might be on to something. Good time for a walk outside. Cheers.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by ddod on Monday November 10, 2014 @03:07PM (#8585940)
This sort of thing is pretty off-topic, but at least in the US, some states (like Florida) have laws requiring prisons offer kosher meals. Considering both diets are voluntary, it does seem unfortunate that certain ideologies are state sanctioned while others are not.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by chunkstuntman on Monday November 10, 2014 @02:52PM (#8585828)
Well if (I assume) you're coming from the mindset of how US prisons treat their inmates, expecting prisoners to be treated with any kind of humanity at all would certainly seem rediculous.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by MrSlo on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:01PM (#8586392)
Heres a short program that the Finnish Broadcasting company did with an American visiting Nordic prisons/correctional institues, just to show a different thinking. Punishment or Rehabilitation. http://arenan.yle.fi/tv/2428667
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by sejje on Monday November 10, 2014 @03:59PM (#8586367)
Well if (I assume) you're talking about the prisons that aren't max-security, it's not very ridiculous at all.

Most of the inmates in our prison system are treated "with humanity."

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by jsmthrowaway on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:26PM (#8586577)
As a former minimum security inmate, you couldn't be more wrong. Security status has nothing to do with treatment. Just from your comment, I know that you've never so much as been detained.

Prison is a lot better than county detention; in prison, there is a loose respect structure between COs and inmates (you live there, they don't). In county, inmates are dehumanized beyond nothing as a form of control and a mechanism to encourage plea bargains. It happened to me when I spent four months in county: "just accept this plea deal and you can go home," and when I refused I got "lost" in the system on the way back to jail. For 48 hours or more (I lost track). With no food or bathroom facilities. Twice.

All pretrial detention comes with a deadline, for the most part (beyond which you must be sentenced or released), and another tactic they use is to get you to "waive" that time so they can "better investigate your case," they say. One dumb individual I spent time with accepted this offer and had spent nine years in county jail without a sentence. I'm not making this up.

I became a much more cynical person during that experience and hate when I see people defending that system in any way. Whatever you think you know about our detention system, you don't. Whatever you think you know about minimum, you don't, too, and I have several scars to show you if you don't believe me.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by sejje on Monday November 10, 2014 @05:33PM (#8587032)
I appreciate your reply.

You are not incorrect, and most of my "knowledge" came from one person, who was incarcerated for ripping off a casino--not via my own experience.

He did 17 years in a really lax place. Pool tables and ping pong and TV and community rooms, stuff like that.

A bit of a knee-jerk response on my part.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by king_jester on Monday November 10, 2014 @05:20PM (#8586964)
> Most of the inmates in our prison system are treated "with humanity."

This is not true whatsoever. Fundamentally, if the system that feeds prisons treated people with humanity, a large number of people would never be prisoners in the first place.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by geofft on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:10PM (#8586456)
My vegetarian friends say that they literally can't eat meat any more, in the sense that their stomach physiology (acids? bacteria? not sure) isn't capable of digesting it. Yes, it was voluntary at some point, but it's not clear that you can still apply that label.

As someone with food allergies, I could understand (and be unhappy) if a captor decided to feed me allergens as intentional punishment, but I'd be pretty upset and feel pretty dehumanized if a captor just did so because it was the cheapest way to prepare a meal.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by VLM on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:44PM (#8586704)
"in the sense that their stomach physiology isn't capable of digesting it"

Its a very popular strightdope urban legend discussion topic. You'd die pretty quickly if you couldn't adsorb complete proteins. Astrologically speaking, iron ions from spinach are dramatically different than iron ions from a steak, but your biochemistry won't know the difference.

You can get three interesting effects:

1) Any time you mess with your diet you mess with your gut flora and ... residue. Not to mention the "feel" in your stomach before its all broken down to constituent molecules indistinguishable from plant sources (other than less fiber) So minor tummy ache is theoretically possible. Less fiber intake = less... output the next day, etc.

2) From my M-i-Ls adventures in gallbladder problems, its theoretically possible for vegan types to chug olive oil especially in the form of salad dressing, but to really consume huge quantities of oil/fat all at once you need a greasy triple cheeseburger with bacon. So you can have some bile / gallbladder related fun (whoa I just ate three days worth of oils/greases in one meal, totally freaking out my gallbladder type of reaction). You'll be fine.

3) Psychologically you can get really messed up. Try eating some dog sometime in a foreign country and then focusing on your stomach (assuming you're standard American) is going to be all messed up. Still meat is meat and if they told you it was pork you wouldn't have blinked, but here you are feeling like you're gonna hurl. Its really not as much fun as my description sounds. Think of that soy stuff instead of cows/chicken/fish/pigs/dogs and you'll be just fine as long as you can avoid getting all anxious. Being anxious is never fun, no matter if due to diet or relationships or tiny enclosed spaces or public speaking or whatever.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by hiou on Monday November 10, 2014 @05:17PM (#8586941)
It's actually for the same reason people get sick when the visit countries with poor water quality and drink the water. They aren't used to the pathogens.

Check page 2 of this Consumer Reports article[1] for an example.

> Enterococcus was the most common bacterium we found, occurring in 79.8 percent of our samples. Next was E. coli, in 65.2 percent of them; campylobacter, 43 percent; klebsiella pneumoniae, 13.6 percent; salmonella, 10.8 percent, and staphylococcus aureus, 9.2 percent.

It's part of the reason that only some people experience the problems as a lot of it depends on how long you have not eaten meat, at what age you stopped eating meat, the overall strength of you immune system and just if you were unlucky the first time you resumed eating meat and ate something with higher percentage of pathogens present. Also, if you regularly cooked and ate from a kitchen that was mixed use or non meat.

[1] http://www.consumerreports.org/cro/magazine/2014/02/the-high...

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by thaumasiotes on Monday November 10, 2014 @05:43PM (#8587110)
> Astrologically speaking, iron ions from spinach are dramatically different than iron ions from a steak, but your biochemistry won't know the difference.

In general, this is not true. In particular, we can read the straight dope ( http://www.straightdope.com/columns/read/696/why-was-spinach... ):

> Spinach's star dimmed once more research was done. It turned out the iron in it couldn't be readily absorbed by the body.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by Carrok on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:15PM (#8586495)
I don't believe your friends. They may notice the meat in their stomachs and feel more 'full' than usual, even feel bad. But 'incapable of digesting it'? Not likely. What, the toilet has whole hotdog pieces in it?
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by GFK_of_xmaspast on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:22PM (#8586547)
I stopped eating meat as a regular part of my diet nearly four years ago, and now eating more than a little tiny bit will make me physically ill with severe stomach distress. I would certainly count that as 'not capable of digesting', and to say otherwise is pure pedantry.

And if you're putting whole hotdog pieces in your stomach you might want to consider chewing a little more carefully, that way leads to choking.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by Blaaguuu on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:47PM (#8586723)
I think the point is that 'not capable of digesting' is an inaccurate description of the issue. Most likely it would just take some time to integrate meat back into their diet... I've made much smaller changes to my diet which caused discomfort, but it lasted a week or two, and my body was fine with it. Likely this friend's transition would be more uncomfortable, and lengthy, but I can't imagine that if for some reason they HAD to eat meat again, their body would completely reject all meat indefinitely.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by DanBC on Monday November 10, 2014 @05:14PM (#8586928)
To counter your anecdote: I was vegetarian for 26 years (and had been vegan for 5 of those years) and I had no problems eating beef, mutton, lamb, or pork.

Anecdotal evidence is stupid and pointless (includng my anecdotal evidence) and it's weird to see it so often on HN.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by geofft on Monday November 10, 2014 @05:50PM (#8587139)
Wait, why is it stupid and pointless in this case?

We have multiple anecdotes indicating people have had problems; we have at least one indicating people don't. This is, to me, clearly evidence against both "Everyone has problems" and "Nobody has problems" and in favor of "Some people have problems", and for the specific policy question at hand, we're trying to evaluate "Some people have problems".

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by jacquesm on Monday November 10, 2014 @10:26PM (#8588135)
I suspect - but can't be sure without some form of experiment - that just like it took time to get you to adapt to not eating meat it will take time to re-adapt to eating meat again. The only way to be sure is by sticking to a meat diet for a longer time after going vegetarian for long enough that you're no longer supporting a set of bacteria that can easily digest the meat.

I'm not sure how long that would take and if it would happen with all people but just like it takes a while before newborns can digest food properly I suspect that a similar adaptation would not happen overnight in adults that radically change their diet from one set of foods to another.

Apropos: vegetable matter is far harder to digest in general than meat (due to plants having cell walls that need to be broken down first).

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by Goopplesoft on Monday November 10, 2014 @08:41PM (#8587779)
No in fact with questions of religion, psychiatry, diets, etc it usually comes to 'large bodies of populations' or even 'majorities of populations', you're going to find 'some' of everything.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by geofft on Monday November 10, 2014 @09:13PM (#8587898)
Sure. The question is whether your body can sufficiently adapt to voluntary dietary choices that it would be cruel for a prison to feed you food that you can no longer tolerate. If you can find "some" of it, then I would say yes, a mature society should be inclined to treat this as a legitimate concern.

Whether there's any particular guarantee of this happening is another question entirely and completely irrelevant. It would be relevant if you could determine that there is a guarantee this won't happen, but that's it.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by UrMomReadsHN on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:23PM (#8586554)
Any new diet can cause digestive issues at first. People generally aclumate over time.

[Note: i personally am in full support of prisoners being allowed to keep their diet while being incarcerated. Especially as someone who has a special diet myself. ]

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by Johnny_Brahms on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @02:59AM (#8588798)
Well, you would have to introduce it slowly. I lived in an anarchist separatist vegan collective in my time in germany (long story), with the result of me not eating any animal products for over a year. The first time (after 11 months) that I ate meat after that (a steak. bleu) I puked my guts out and had the runs for over a week.

It took about a month of slowly introducing meat before I was back to normal. There are others that made the switch cold turkey without problems though.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by ohyesyodo on Monday November 10, 2014 @02:45PM (#8585782)
I'm sure you are not the only one, but why wouldn't the prison do that?
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by Goronmon on Monday November 10, 2014 @02:51PM (#8585822)
Why should a prison accommodate a prisoner who is a vegan any more than one who wants to eat filet mignon for every meal?
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by pcthrowaway on Monday November 10, 2014 @02:56PM (#8585856)
Why should a prison accommodate people who don't eat certain things based on religious guidelines? People are rarely vegan because they associate a vegan diet with one of luxury. They choose not to eat animal products because they have an ethical objection to them.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by bdcravens on Monday November 10, 2014 @03:07PM (#8585938)
Vegan doesn't mean higher quality. It can mean a large serving of beans and broccoli.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by VLM on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:25PM (#8586575)
Which makes the whole discussion rather bizarre. So you don't want meat slop on beans and rice, fine, take two scoops of rice and beans instead without the slop. Don't want pancakes and bacon, fine, take an extra pancake instead. If the servers won't cooperate, trade a slice of bacon to your neighbor in exchange for a pancake.

I suppose you could intentionally sabotage someone by putting bacon in with the beans, so just avoid mixing expensive bacon in with the cheap beans and I think everyone will be happy?

My guess is dietary sabotage is intentional, even if it takes more money and more effort, as a kind of psychological torture. "The guards will beat you if you don't put bacon bits on your salad because they know you're a vegan" type of thing.

(edited to explain, I ate years of institutional food in school lunches, then the Army, and then at University, pretty much my first quarter century of life, and I assumed its "about the same" in prison. Which is very interestingly, apparently, completely wrong. Prison is apparently more like every inmate gets "the" TV dinner today and there's no sharing/trading allowed.)

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by jsmthrowaway on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:42PM (#8586690)
Someone's been watching too much Hollywood. That's not how food inside works. Your meal is selected for you and given to you in a container, depending on facility. Some prisons have a system similar to what you describe, but inmates' hands are not on the serving equipment and you're only saying "yes"/"no" to things. The facility has strict counts of calories to maintain and putting a serving spoon in the hand of an inmate is a good way to throw a budget away.

In almost all cases in county, the food is already prepared in a plastic container and if you refuse what is offered to you, you do not eat, which means even kosher folks go without for a couple days until the records "catch up."

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by bdcravens on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @12:38AM (#8588486)
Not true in Texas, one of the large prison systems in the world.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by pcthrowaway on Monday November 10, 2014 @09:48PM (#8588016)
> trade a slice of bacon to your neighbor in exchange for a pancake

That's what I did when I spent a week in jail (as a vegetarian). I ate fine, but had I been strictly vegan it may have been a different story.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by MichaelGG on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:32PM (#8586616)
Vegan diets are much more difficult than that. Pancakes might use eggs, which aren't vegan.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by adamnemecek on Monday November 10, 2014 @02:55PM (#8585851)
Probably because filet mignon is more expensive than a vegan meal.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by baddox on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:02PM (#8586393)
In the scheme of things, the cost of losing economies of scale by providing many custom diets is probably the dominant cost factor to consider.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by saalweachter on Monday November 10, 2014 @11:12PM (#8588258)
From a purely practical point of view, food is something it's very easy to hunger-strike over.

I'm willing to bet there have been a number of hunger strikes over a lack of kosher of halal foods. It wouldn't surprise me if there have been a few prisoners who have refused to eat animal products behind bars, even when the vegetarian products were not nutritionally sufficient.

I would be highly surprised if there were any sustained hunger strikes over lack of gourmet food.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by abandonliberty on Monday November 10, 2014 @03:26PM (#8586098)
Or one who refuses to eat pork.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by scoofy on Monday November 10, 2014 @02:59PM (#8585878)
Because there is little or no downside to providing it, and to do otherwise is basically cruel.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by a3_nm on Monday November 10, 2014 @03:15PM (#8586013)
I agree with the fact that it is problematic to say that prisons should accommodate any kind of voluntary diets (vegetarian, vegan, halal, kosher, etc.). I do not say this because prisons should "punish" inmates, but because it would require to draw a line between "common" or "reasonable" voluntary diets, and other diets. (Of course, this does not apply to special diets required for medical reasons.) In fact, I have the same problems with voluntary diets being honored in other State-run facilities such as school canteens.

However, I do not see why, as a general principle, prisoners should not be allowed to buy food and have it shipped to them, using their own money.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by DanBC on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:20PM (#8586536)
The lines are pretty clear:

Vegan; vegetarian; Halal; Kosher; medical; none of the above.

These rules cover most religions and most lifestyle diets; these do exclude wishy-washy bullshit.

Not providing foods guided by a person's religion is probably a violation of article 5 and is a violation of article 18 of the universal declaration of human rights.

You can ask that the prisonor provides evidence of adherance to the restricted diet in their lofe before they became a prisoner. For example, a prisoner who claims to be vegetarian could show that they had been a member of the vegetarian society in their life outside prison.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by a3_nm on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:55PM (#8586775)
> These rules cover most religions and most lifestyle diets; these do exclude wishy-washy bullshit.

What about people who only want to eat free-range eggs (and not any products derived from eggs from caged hens?); or do not want to eat fish from non-sustainable fishing? Sure, they can stick to the vegan diet, but isn't it discriminatory that their specific preferences are not taken into account, and that they are mixed with a larger group? (In the same way that, I guess, you would not find it acceptable if people who want to eat halal or kosher were directed to eat vegan food; although note that kosher can be more restrictive than vegan due to requirements on checking for possible insect infestation of certain vegetables.)

What about people who refuse to eat GM food? People who refuse to eat food that wasn't produced locally, because they want to cut down on pollution? What about fruitarians? (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fruitarianism) Jain vegetarians? (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jain_vegetarianism ; note that it excludes onions so vegan diet is not OK). Sarbloh bibek for Sikhs? (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diet_in_Sikhism#Sarbloh_Bibek)

Who is to make a decision about which practices are "bullshit" and which ones are "serious"? or whether one was "sufficiently" committed to a practice in the past? If you specifically accommodate some of these practices but not others, you are discriminating against people following practices which are too rare or not sufficiently established. In this spirit I think your original list would be discriminatory relative to the other practices I have listed above.

My claim is that a prison has to manage the practical life of the inmates and feed them (with a default option; I do not object them buying different food items from external suppliers), and when you have to do this you cannot satisfy all preferences. Then, it is discriminatory to satisfy some preferences and disregard others because they are more common, or they have an established name ("vegetarianism" vs "not eating pineapples shipped by air freight"), or they are motivated by religious reasons. As long as the diet cannot be justified by a medical necessity, you are accommodating a personal preference, no matter the underlying reason; and it is discriminatory to favor some at the expense of others, and impossible to rate whether preferences are "valid" or "serious" (except by a doctor, for the medical cases).

It is probably a good idea to offer diverse food options to increase the odds that people find something that suits them, but as soon as you go out of your way to satisfy a specific observance, I think it has the potential to be discriminatory.

> Not providing foods guided by a person's religion is probably a violation of article 5 and is a violation of article 18 of the universal declaration of human rights.

If you interpret the "right to observance" as implying that the State, when detaining you, must accommodate your beliefs, then as I have argued it is practically impossible to do this in a non-discriminatory fashion.

(To give more background about my opinions: I am quite influenced by French laïcité https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/La%C3%AFcit%C3%A9 whose current interpretation is often that, to avoid discriminating against any religious creed, as you cannot recognize them all, you should endorse none.)

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by blacksmith_tb on Monday November 10, 2014 @05:03PM (#8586853)
Plus it's easy to cover more than one group with the same meal, that is, a vegan meal would be fine for a vegetarian inmate to eat. Kosher and Halal are theoretically very close, presumably some meat producers must comply with all the handling and prayers to certify as both, etc.

Or, since it doesn't seem have been suggested previously, why not a Kosher, Halal vegan meal plan for all inmates? If it was nutritionally complete, it should be cheaper than even the presumably cheap meat-based diet most prisoners are currently fed...

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by chrisbennet on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:19PM (#8586524)
I had a US jail as a client for my long ago RFID business and they had 4 types of meals: 2 kosher (jewish and islamic), "normal" and medical/special as I recall.

I used to tell people our app tracked inventory that was trying to escape.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by boomlinde on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @12:17PM (#8590928)
What is ridiculous about it? One of the primary goals of prisons, at least here, is to rehabilitate the inmates. Whether that works in practice or not, it's recognized that if you can't practice your most basic beliefs, whether those are religiously founded or otherwise, your mental health and general well being is going to suffer.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by PhasmaFelis on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @12:49AM (#8588521)
So what happened to the votes here, BTW? Earlier today, this and quite a few other comments descended from it were downvoted to invisibility. A few hours later, I checked in and they're all back in black. Are the Million Moms Against Vegetarians running a sockpuppet campaign, or what exactly?
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by adnam on Monday November 10, 2014 @03:03PM (#8585906)
You're possibly not alone, but yourryou're certainly not right.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by vacri on Monday November 10, 2014 @03:32PM (#8586152)
Religion is voluntary, reading books is voluntary, using exercise equipment is voluntary, using a phone or room to talk to your family is voluntary. A prisoner doesn't have to do any of those things, and plenty of prisoners get by without doing each one of those. Do you have a problem with these voluntary activities as well?
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by fleitz on Monday November 10, 2014 @07:28PM (#8587558)
No you're certainly not alone, however the vast majority of prison systems have very high recidivism rates.

You have to ask yourself whether you want prisons to punish people or to get them to not commit crimes in the future, if your goal is to punish people, then sure, feed them the opposite of their preferred diet.

If your goal is to change their behaviour then the breaking of bread can be instrumental in creating change. By showing respect for their culture you can begin to bridge the gap and help them respect yours.

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by JoeAltmaier on Monday November 10, 2014 @02:42PM (#8585763)
How about his Tuesday lunch with his mother? And his yoga lesson? Prison sucks.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by UrMomReadsHN on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:17PM (#8586506)
Prisoners are actually practicing yoga.

http://prisonyoga.com/why/

>The Prison Yoga Project was founded in the belief that yoga, taught specifically as a mindfulness practice, is very effective in releasing deeply held, unresolved trauma, allowing us to address the resultant behavioral issues

>Our objective is to provide prisoners with a mindfulness tool to draw on their yoga practice when they’re not doing yoga. If they’re tangled in a confrontation on the yard, or upon release, or tempted to go back to using, they can draw on what they have learned from yoga for practical solutions. They can do it without actually having to do a yoga pose to get the value. That’s the transformational, rehabilitative value of yoga.

Video - http://youtu.be/cmiAtV5zAmw

Re:Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Released from Prison by jevinskie on Monday November 10, 2014 @03:20PM (#8586046)
Lunch with family (in the prison) sounds like a great way to improve recidivism rates. I'd bet that yoga or another form of meditation would also be beneficial.