I share your two hypotheses to the point I consider them ansatzes. Most of my peers have Ph.D.'s in hard sciences or engineering as I do. Most of them wasted their time on their thesis research; it's just a certificate meaning "certifiably smart, persistent, and able to do self guided study." I don't particularly regret getting my underwear drawer liner autograph from the governator. It was a poor financial decision, but I had fun playing with big toys, and it provided enough meaning to my life I avoided ending up a glue sniffer or drunkard.
Attempting to convince more people to do this is a fool's errand: we can't even employ the ones we have. I've been lucky in that I have mostly worked on interesting things and been reasonably well paid for it, but doubling or tripling the number of science people in the world is foolish unless you give them something useful to do. My last job hunt, I ended up talking to an awful lot of people who thought a good use of my time would be building data pipelines to some Hadoop atrocity. You don't need a Ph.D. in physics or machine learning to do that. Yet a lot of Ph.D. types are doing this sort of plumbing for a living, because there are not enough jobs doing actual science.
In any case my impression is that the article was about different strategies for improving achievement. I'm not a psychologist, but I've seen some pretty convincing articles that show that praise for how smart a kid is versus praise for how hard they work affects how they handle failure. Increasing perseverance would be a good way to be more successful in academia, I would imagine.
Nowhere in the article does it say anything about PhDs. A Bachelor's degree is more than sufficient to do the sort of "plumbing" you mention. And it is exactly that sort of thing where the employers are chronically complaining that they can't find any qualified candidates without getting more H1B visas.
Someone may not need a PhD to do this sort of thing, but they DO need more than the remedial Algebra II class that qualified as a math prerequisite for their Communications degree, which they went into because they were told in 2nd grade that they're "not a math person".
You don't even need a high school diploma to do data plumbing. You don't need H1Bs to do it either: you simply need to train and pay people adequately.
I used this as an example of what working scientists (you know, the article is about encouraging people to study STEM) are confronted with on the job market thanks to nincompoops who believe we are short of STEM degreed individuals. I'd rather drive a bus. Fortunately, I don't have to.
When these "scientists" spend most of their time massaging data to get that golden 0.049 p-value, I think a bit of derision might be deserved.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7143630 [2]
[2] Before you go all "grr, journanists, grr", I first heard about that one on both the Science and Nature podcasts.
What is your position then? That nothing can be learned about human behavior by applying the scientific method? That there's no inherent patterns or cause and effect behind how humans act? Or just that not one single psychologist in the history of the field has yet successfully performed an experiment that has demonstrated such, or even made an attempt in good faith to do so?
Certainly, it's much harder to remove all confounding variables from psychological experiments. That doesn't mean that there's nothing to be learned about human behavior by applying the scientific method.
Now, as some one poorly paid and pursuing science you would be particularly vulnerable to this risk. The bad thing is you have worked yourself into a corner, and there is nothing that you can immediately do, to improve your situation, should you fall into bad times. If you are working for a contractor for a big IT company, you can work long hours for increased pay. You, as a scientist, will not find a similar outlet.
Personally, I think the whole thing sucks. It is not that we need more people in science, rather, we need more investment in science; People/Institutions with big money taking big risks. Like Elon Musk.
If you want to back up this claim, back it up. The entire rest of your comment is totally orthogonal.
The claim being made by the self-esteem expert is not "psychobabble." It's simple enough for you to think about directly. It's not a langauge you can't understand, written in abstract terms you can't understand.
Having experienced firsthand what happens when people treat intelligence as an "innate talent," I actually know that what he is saying is correct, from personal experience.
What would you rather be doing with your higher education credentials? What is the hiring process for doing that?
Everything in life boils down to perspiration at some point.
There are loads of professional teachers, professional medics, professional sanitation workers, etc. who just turn up, do the job and go home. Some may and do work long hours for little reward, but a lot don't. There is a culture in academia that you may, sometimes, when you really need to, you may take the weekend off. Or Sunday, at least.
That said, we are producing far more Ph. D.s than we can employee. I have had a 30+ year career in industry. I have watched margins tighten and good friends get laid off as more and more is offshored. I doubt that this will end well for the next generation. Not everyone will be a "winner." But those who invest in developing their skills will, on average, do much better than those who do not.
I think one cause might be that "the enterprise" has very little to offer in terms of ideals. Those jobs that actually change the world and help a lot of people usually are out of your reach if you choose the wrong education (like computer science). Being "the man that uncovers the truth" (a scientist) seems much more appealing than "earn a lot of money being a cog in a machine that competes with other machines".
I admit, it's just anecdotal. When I see my friends who work at Microsoft, it doesn't seem like the fact that they're working at such a large, influential company excites them. After all, the "up or out" system either drags them out of the company or to some managerial position where there's even more of the "cog in a process" feeling as you spend most of your time presenting your team's results to your superior and the other way around.
So compare: in one field, you start earning a median $65k at age 22 with only a bachelor's degree, and in the other, you start earning $65k in your mid to late thirties, after a bachelor's, a PhD, and often at least one post-doc. Everything before that is "low-pay grinding", except that the academic definition of "low-pay" ranges from lower-middle class ($25k-$30k for the better-paid grad-students and worse-paid post-docs) to taking on debt (the humanities).
A median means that half the CS grads made less than 65k. Tenure track also comes with some eventual benefits you won't receive with a bachelor's in CS. Let's be clear about what we're actually comparing.
This is false.
For example, X% could make exactly 65k and only the lower ((100 - X) / 2)% would make less.
...where X \in (0, 100]
However I also doubt that many CS grads at all are making significantly less than $65k. Those that are making appreciably less than that are almost certainly not working in the field, or they are not working in the US. I wager that the salary distribution of CS grads working in the field in the US is pretty damn tight.
Granted, the job market was crap and I make 6 figures now, but there are still plenty of sub 40k programming jobs out there and people happy to take them.
That's not how medians work
Your assuming salaries are not inflated and that the ratio of people reporting salaries is constant at all income ranges and the reported numbers are accurate. I doubt any of those are true. So, IMO to observe a 65k median suggests the actual median is below 65k.
PS: Don't forget grad students count as recent CS grads and there generally not making anywhere close to 65K.
My experience is that professors in "pure maths" are very bright and showed exceptional reasoning skills from an early age.
> It's not brilliance that defines a professional scientist; it's a willingness to be bored and work weekends for very little compensation.
That's quite a generalisation! obviously, not all professional scientists are geniuses and it takes perseverance to get a decent permanent position. But to get a position in a decent institution isn't only a matter of political connections and stubbornness. Look up some coursera classes for instance. The people teaching those classes aren't just there because they're the only ones willing to do some "extraordinarily boring" legwork.
No one should go into most sciences (including physics) if they a) intend to stop at the undergrad level and b) expect it to be of non-trivial value in the job market.
Engineering degrees are economically useful at the undergrad level. Science degrees are not, at least not any moreso than English or philosophy degrees. So there is absolutely no need to promote STEM degrees as a career choice. They are a very bad one, outside of engineering (and even there it depends on field and timing).
Are there any good ways to teach stubbornness to very-non-stubborn kids in a student-teacher relationship?
Too often stubbornness is attributed to some quirk in the child's history/family life that leads them down a self-reinforcing path of self-motivated stubbornness. That's not useful for the vast majority of kids who are surrounded by constant, quick distractions and have parents who lack the knowledge/motivation to instill stubbornness into them.
There are no universal rules when it comes to people. But, what I've observed and what I've had reported to me by those who have studied the issue has pretty consistently shown people who pursue their goals more stubbornly achieving those goals more reliably. And conversely, people who are more easily distracted/dissuaded struggling more and having a more difficult time.
If I cared about a kid that seemed easily distracted/dissuaded, I would do what I could to set that kid up to achieve his/her goals more reliably with less struggle and difficulty. (please don't take this into a discussion the value of achievement vs struggle and difficulty)
Many students I've met in high school or college don't even realize that there are cool things to understand in math. They think math is just a collection of rules. Once the rules are mastered/test is over, done. What's there to understand? And hence why be stubborn? What is there to be stubborn about?
A healthy disregard for authority is also important in stubbornness, and hard to teach in school (as it's against the self-interest of the harried teacher who needs a "well-controlled" classroom).
I've long believed doing a PhD is very similar to being an entrepreneur. Discipline and maintaining motivation are by far the hardest things. Little pay and no guarantee of reward. You have an idea and you have to do your best to see it through, but it's tough, utterly exhausting and very isolating. It's a wonder anyone manages it at all really.
It is very difficult for people to appreciate how grueling an academic career can be, from grad school on. I put together this list to make the point: http://www.tjradcliffe.com/?p=1588 (needs to be read to the end to see what I mean.)
Good point. The opportunity cost of getting a PhD can generally be pretty soul crushing if measured in terms of dollars, years, and rungs on the career ladder (although a lot of things can be soul crushing if measured by those metrics).
All that effort to do some research that, at the end of the day, probably won't matter to anyone. I don't take that as a huge personal failure, because most research doesn't really change the world. That's the nature of research. It's like the world of startups, where most of the time you fail to make an impact, and occasionally you succeed.
But unlike in the start-up world, success isn't measured in $XM IPOs or buyouts. It means getting your foot in the door as a non-tenured professor, so you can work fiendishly at a below-market salary for the next few years trying to secure tenure. Or taking a job at an industrial research lab, and possibly discovering you don't actually enjoy working at industrial research labs.
Ah, now I'm too old to work as a programmer at your social media company? Sweet.
>There's loads of kids going to graduate school to become servants for mediocre, yet politically-connected scientists.
The first part is true, but the mediocre scientists aren't necessarily politically-connected. More often, they're just busy, so consistently busy doing their own research and supervising their own students that one day some new and improved methodology, instrument, or statistical tool leaves them in the dust. This happens because, frankly, nobody pays them to keep their methodology, instruments, and statistical tools up to date, and it's not like anyone will refuse to publish their papers if they don't keep up-to-date. They get grants because they publish papers, and they publish papers because they keep doing experiments and/or proving theorems -- the fact that they could be learning more and quicker by working some other way isn't built into any incentive structure except their personal hopes and dreams (which are the first thing any young scientist learns to repress).
There is especially no shortage of scientists in the sense that, simply put, there are not enough permanent jobs for the PhDs and post-docs we already train. http://www.phdcomics.com/comics/archive/phd030909s.gif
>Then, once they have spent the X years and $Y in opportunity costs to get a PhD, they have to figure out a career for themselves. This is a bad, not a good, thing. It reduces early-stage career experimentation and encourages low-quality science.
This is quite true. I find the advising structure in graduate school strange with respect to its stated purposes. The definitional requirement of a PhD is that it be a large piece of original research (stereotypically, about three papers' worth) that charts the course for the young scientist's early career. The best PhD dissertations open up whole new subfields, and those are the young scientists who get the good jobs. But how do we allocate labor to produce these "brilliant new ideas"? Largely by assigning the graduate student to work on their adviser's existing research program, which they can slowly transform into something at least partially their own depending on their level of supervision.
(The worst PhD dissertations are basically just longer MSc dissertations: fully supervised research work done in total peonage with little to no original input by the apprentice graduating to become a real scientist.)
>There are loads of theories and ideas in any given field about the way that things may be. What you need, as a minimum, is the ability to stick the course to figure out a way of testing those theories and ideas and do the (extraordinarily boring) legwork to get it done. I know a lot of scientists (physicists and mathematicians) and all of them are stubborn, but not particularly brilliant. 99% of physics and mathematics are made up of people who will do drudge work for years with very little recognition or reward. Very, very occasionally, one of them hits the jackpot. It's not brilliance that defines a professional scientist; it's a willingness to be bored and work weekends for very little compensation.
clap clap clap http://media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m6odkq8jNo1qbolbn.gif
Absolutely, completely, entirely, 100% true. The vast majority of professional science is legwork. Theoreticians can spend plenty of time constructing models or proving theorems to feel brilliant, but ultimately, they mostly just do legwork as well. Experimentalists and engineering researchers have to actually do experiments and actually produce artifacts. Mind, many of us find even the drudgery and legwork plenty fascinating to set-up and do, but almost never so much that we'd object to your taking it away somehow.
Also mind: some scientists are brilliant. They're just not the mode, or even always the shining stars of the field, since professional scientists are mostly selected (and therefore optimized) for tenacity (being bored and working weekends for very little compensation) and consistency (producing 110% the desired results, from elementary school through grant applications).
I would add only one quality: a professional scientist is defined not only by religious devotion to doing loads and loads of legwork for little compensation, but also by an emotional ability to withstand being constantly graded, measured, and stack-ranked against everyone else in your field, in time periods ranging from each semester to every few years. From the beginning of undergrad through tenure and up until you move from doing research to mostly teaching or administrating, you basically never stop having to pass yet another set of exams (each one calibrated to fail some percentage at the bottom, forcing them to find other careers) to continue doing your existing job or to receive a promotion that other skilled professionals would usually get by virtue of experience alone.
While I've heard that many decades ago, funding and positions were plentiful, and so the system was not nearly so burdensome as today, now I am always a little amazed that scientific advancement manages to happen at all, since almost everything a scientist does professionally is connected to keeping his job instead of actually getting and sharing research results.
I got my PhD at an international research lab. I was a research fellow in nuclear physics at a Russell Group (i.e. top-16) university in the UK for 7 years. I was a guest scientist at CERN. I know whereof I speak ;-)
[EDIT: Let's assume that if you are mediocre and not politically-connected, you don't get tenure and you don't stay long. You don't supervise students in an official fashion. This is mostly true, I think.]
I can assure you that when (if!) you come to apply for tenure, it will matter more who your friends are and whose bags you carried than the papers that you produced or the students that you mentored. I agree that most scientists are incredibly busy. Sadly, because they are all incredibly busy, it's the extra stuff (the handshakes, the dinners, etc.) that come to matter. The technical stuff (the tooling, the methods) don't matter precisely because the group heads don't understand them - but they do understand who they had dinner with last week, or who gave a nice talk at that pleasant conference. They do understand that their friend was their prospective employee's supervisor, and they do understand the concept of political favours. They understand prestige and status and how to obtain it, almost by definition. That speaks to your last point too.
> Also mind: some scientists are brilliant. They're just not the mode, or even always the shining stars of the field, since professional scientists are mostly selected (and therefore optimized) for tenacity (being bored and working weekends for very little compensation) and consistency (producing 110% the desired results, from elementary school through grant applications).
I disagree slightly, with the benefit of experience. The most brilliant people I knew all left science. They (we, now) went to draw larger salaries in industry, working half the hours and with more pleasant colleagues. The people that were left were those without brilliance but with the tenacity to hold on and without the skills to get a decent job in a mid-career switch. That's not to say that there aren't exceptions, but they're rare (again, only in my experience).
> up until you move from doing research to mostly teaching or administrating
Well, at this point you've failed, you see - you've given up doing science :-) But you still get graded - there are departmental quotas and budget forecasts and student surveys and now you're a middle manager. But you get paid less.
For us, an M.S. thesis was supposed to be largely independent, publishable work. Is it that different in different fields?
At least in the geosciences, M.S. research is basically your adviser saying "Here's an idea/interesting problem that I haven't thought much about but looks promising. Have at it."
You do your M.S., publish, switch schools and start a Ph.D. (Or go into industry... An M.S. is a very common working degree in geology.)
A Ph.D. is "Come up with three different, relevant, original ideas that work* and see them through". (*Obviously, most don't work, so it's largely an exercise it trying different things until something does.)
I know we have a different academic culture than CS (and a wildly different industry culture), but is it really that different at the M.S. level?
I don't want to sound like an "internet tough guy" but rising up above that level is laid on the student to pursue.
Sorry, I had to edit this again. I have a PhD in physics. My dire warning to graduate students is: You might be given a degree even if you didn't do PhD level work. I hope that's sobering, but at the same time motivating.
On the other hand, my experiences have been weird, in that I had near-total independence for my BSc thesis (which, as a result, simply was not very good even though it was accepted with honors) (because my undergrad thesis advisors were involved in administration and I was doing a topic politically disfavored in that department), and an uneven degree of supervision for my MSc research (I've had a lot of guidance on what experiment to do and what statistics to run, but my advisor has never told me how to find the previous literature on our subject, even when I ask).
From one graduate student to another, do we decide to keep sucking toes and complain about it later or do we actually do something about it?
Frankly, I've watched the cheapening happen for the past 15 years, and at first it was schadenfreude. Me, a person with a liberal arts degree, was having a really hard time getting my career going, getting a living wage - and even with a Masters, 10 years of solid work experience, references, technology skills and no piercings, tattoos or felonies. Basically I'm a textbook employee on paper, and it still took me something like 200 applications to "earn" my first career gig.
All the while, people in STEM put me down for having a useless degree. Well, after watching the 2000s tech bubble pop, watching H1-Bs come in and drive down the wage faster than 50 somethings trying to take any job they can just to keep up with their lifestyle (and thereby rob a 20 something of the chance to start gaining the requisite experience), I no longer take solace in how hard it is to be in STEM. It's a family thing now, but fortunately, my experience and my "take no bullshit, this is fucking business" attitude toward employment is very helpful.
I am a creative and intellectual mercenary. I fight for myself. I did not choose this path.
I had
a) physics professors at the previous school (UCSB) willing to write letters, make phone calls b) solid unpublished work that raised some eyebrows c) professors on the admitting end willing to shepherd my application
1) There is not a shortage of scientists.
There's loads of kids going to graduate school to become servants for mediocre, yet politically-connected scientists. Then, once they have spent the X years and $Y in opportunity costs to get a PhD, they have to figure out a career for themselves. This is a bad, not a good, thing. It reduces early-stage career experimentation and encourages low-quality science.
2) You don't need to be smart to be a scientist; you need to be stubborn.
This is similar to the argument that ideas don't matter for entrepreneurship. There are loads of theories and ideas in any given field about the way that things may be. What you need, as a minimum, is the ability to stick the course to figure out a way of testing those theories and ideas and do the (extraordinarily boring) legwork to get it done. I know a lot of scientists (physicists and mathematicians) and all of them are stubborn, but not particularly brilliant. 99% of physics and mathematics are made up of people who will do drudge work for years with very little recognition or reward. Very, very occasionally, one of them hits the jackpot. It's not brilliance that defines a professional scientist; it's a willingness to be bored and work weekends for very little compensation.