I agree with your general point, but SR was being used for all kinds of things including selling Cocaine and Heroin (and also for not selling drugs but services). Those are very addictive drugs by almost any definition. Fine if you want to argue they are less harmful than, say, alcohol, but they are definitely addictive. Do not allow your point to be weakened by stating something that is clearly incorrect.
Not really true;
http://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-67...
Wiki actually sums it up pretty well;
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Substance_dependence#Dependence...
I've tried cocaine myself on two occasions. Not addictive whatsoever.
There is a nice description of the risk of cocaine dependence on Wikipedia.
No drug is addictive. Addiction is a weasel word to try and shift the blame of habit forming away from the person and onto the activity.
Is the beach fun? Some people find it fun, they go as much as possible. I don't find it fun. Can we then say "well, fun is not that simple. would you argue hiking is not fun? I've tried hiking and I don't hike all the time but that does not prove hiking does not have fun properties. I go to the beach and when it's not available I don't miss it. Is the beach more or less fun than hiking?"?
No drug is addictive just as no activity is fun. A person will feel fun or will form a habit around an activity depending on their predisposition to do so, based on brain chemistry.
Cocaine only manages to convert 4% of the people that try it. That means only 4% of people are prone to forming habits around Cocaine. What percentage of people are prone to forming habits around watching sports? Should watching sports be considered addictive and become illegal, if more than 4% of people form habits around it?
> "In no sense do I advocate evading or defying the law, as would the rabid segregationist. That would lead to anarchy. One who breaks an unjust law must do so openly, lovingly, and with a willingness to accept the penalty. I submit that an individual who breaks a law that conscience tells him is unjust and who willingly accepts the penalty of imprisonment in order to arouse the conscience of the community over its injustice, is in reality expressing the highest respect for law."
You claim:
> You think a law is unjust, fight the law, don't break it and try to get away with it.
So you and MLK are claiming that a non-Jew in Nazi Germany who violates legislation by helping a Jew is morally culpable unless they do it publicly?
Seems pretty questionable, and I even agree with the strict Kantian maxim of not lying to the murderer at the door!
Perhaps you and MLK are confusing a strategy with morality. Perhaps it is strategically valuable to violate unjust legislation openly and suffer the consequences. That shouldn't mean that it is morally wrong to violate them in secret.
To me, it seems like there are two claims that are being tied together unnecessarily. 1) one has no obligation to obey unjust legislation 2) one has an obligation to disobey it openly to bring public awareness of the unjustness and increase likelihood of reform.
To me, you're just as culpable for not doing #2 whether or not you do #1. In other words, if you're morally culpable for not violating unjust legislation in public, then you bear that culpability whether or not you violate the legislation in private or not, and violating unjust legislation in private entails no culpability on its own.
[edit: I completely rewrote when I realized MLK really did say that]
It was not just a place of victimless crime. It would be nice if just ONE of you DPR-loving sociopaths would be honest enough to admit this.
But you will never get a sociopathic state worshiping authoritarian to admit they don't have the moral high ground. Letalone that their treasured institutions are practically identical to the terrorist organisations that they say they exist to protect the innocent from.
Couldn't have said it better myself. You would do well to consider your own criticism. I will not be holding my breath waiting for the penny to drop for you, though. You have that self assured idiocy I instantly recognise from hackneyed talking heads spinning nonsense about topics they don't grasp purely to make those more questioning abandon their pesky skepticism and critical analysis about all things conventional.
Keep it up, your attacks serve merely to convince me I'm on the right path.
I understand that you are unwilling to admit this (instead trying to make this an argument about something other than SR), but he did.
I find it completely unsurprising that you are incapable of admitting this.
p.s. there is a lot of research indicating that extremists become more strident when presented with facts that undermine their ideology. As such, your final sentence is completely predictable.
My point was the relative culpability of the two actors in question. You're not presenting any new facts, you're just sounding off on the righteousness of the state without consideration to the crimes on that rap sheet to which I have taken exception. It is you who are doubling down on your idiocy absent understanding of the actual point being made.
Congratulations, you are a retard.
And then I hope that you see a bunch of so-called Libertarian assholes praising the people who helped make that happen.
Because maybe then your tiny little broken brain will see why the US government is completely irrelevant to the question of the morality of DPR.
Until then have fun thinking you're right, you utterly fucking wrong moron.
If you're willing to post this level of stupidity then just come out with "OBAMA IS HITLER" without mincing words so we can tell you're deluded and ignore your posts.
(I agree with "hncomplete"'s point, minus the "sociopath" remark)
He tried to have people killed. You are defending this. What the hell is wrong with you?
I don't support drug laws. I ESPECIALLY don't support attempted murder.
Do you have any proof of that? It looks like the government doesn't.
Guilty of breaking non-sense, victim-less laws. Laws that restrict usage of non-addictive mind-altering substances that are much less harmful than other, legal drugs (alcohol, tobacco, medical drugs). Laws that shouldn't even be on the books! Laws that cause millions of dollars of damage and thousands of deaths each year. Laws that power organized crime.
The drug laws.
I totally support him, and I hope he comes out a free man, albeit his business will probably be ruined.