News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by sillysaurus3 on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:08PM (#8495957)
Why is every semi-pro athlete expected to get a decent GPA in order to play on a university's football team? It's a completely different skillset. I don't blame players for ditching classes to pursue their dreams. Quite the opposite, in fact. It's the same drive as an entrepreneur's: to test yourself, to excel. It's just a different context.

They are adults. If, as adults, they choose not to pursue academic studies, and instead choose to focus all of their energy on sports, then they should be allowed to do that without putting their sports career at risk.

I do blame everyone involved in the fakeness, though. Their decisions should stand on their own.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by rrrx3 on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:15PM (#8496001)
The problem is that they're being exploited. Choose to go to class or not, they are not being paid anything remotely close to the value that these schools get from them in terms of team gear sales, ad revenue, tv time, increased enrollment, etc etc etc.

This is especially true when they're turning in BS papers for crap degrees that can't and won't serve them once they leave school. A minuscule few make it pro. The rest - if they graduate, even - have only an AFAM degree to show for it and no real life skills.

I agree that if they want to be athletes, they should be allowed to be athletes. But they should be paid appropriately for it in kind.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by bo1024 on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @10:26PM (#8496422)
> The problem is that they're being exploited. Choose to go to class or not, they are not being paid anything remotely close to the value that these schools get from them in terms of team gear sales, ad revenue, tv time, increased enrollment, etc etc etc.

I'm tired of seeing this argument without data. If you sit down and think about the numbers, you'll see that for the vast majority of NCAA athletes, this is false. Most get a very sweet deal relative to their market value if the NCAA did not exist.

First, limit to the NCAA sports that actually produce revenue, essentially men's football and basketball. If the NCAA did not exist, these players would at best be in a minor league (again except for the top dozen or two in the country). Now look at a sport that has a minor league in America: baseball. Minor league baseball players, even toward the top, make how much? $2000-3000 per month. And that's only in-season.

Paid tuition is already worth higher in cash value than that. And the value of the student-athlete experience? You can't put a price tag on it. Ask any former NCAA athlete what they would trade to give up their experience.

But, you respond, NCAA sports make way more money than baseball minor leagues. Yes, that's true. But it's not solely because of the players. It's because of the schools. Schools bring almost everything important to the table: A huge fanbase, a connection to a physical location and community, an illusion of amateur-ness, rivalries, all of these things you can't get to nearly that extent outside the NCAA.

The players? They have no bargaining power because without the NCAA system, they'd be hosed. They'd be working even harder for essentially less money, living a tougher lifestyle, and not even get the degree to show for it. Hard to argue they should be paid when they bring very little to the table compared to the schools.

The point people miss is that it's the combination of the schools and the players together that generates so much revenue. Either without the other would be out of luck. And right now, if you think about the numbers, the current split is pretty fair. The exception might be the few star players who could make millions in the pros.

...

I want to say, I'm not saying that players aren't exploited currently. I think they are. But I think the exploitation boils down to your second paragraph: They lose a real education because they don't have their priorities in line at that point in their lives.

But the solution isn't to pay kids even more money/benefits to continue to masquerade as students while living as full-time athletes. The solution should be to divorce sports from education and create minor leagues. This will never happen because, as I stated above, it's the combination of schools and sports that generates so much money, and the people at the top won't give that up just to do the right thing.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by OvidNaso on Thursday October 23, 2014 @12:33AM (#8496700)
I'm sorry, but why would you compare revenue to minor league baseball? Collegiate basketball and football make significatly more money than collegiate or minor league baseball. America has clearly decided that they wI'ill spend just as much money on second tier leagues for these sports and any valuation would need to be based on this or be disingenuous.
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by jdminhbg on Thursday October 23, 2014 @01:02AM (#8496759)
He explained: the difference between minor league baseball and NCAA football is the fanbase and tradition the schools bring. A putative Ann Arbor Wolves minor league football team would not have a stadium that dwarfs all NFL stadia.
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by bo1024 on Thursday October 23, 2014 @11:31AM (#8498661)
Right, this is my contention. I admit that it's definitely speculative.
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by rrrx3 on Thursday October 23, 2014 @08:25AM (#8497748)
I understand your objections in the first part of your reply, but let me clarify - when I speak about this, I'm talking strictly about revenue sports. The other athletes in non-revenue sports who are lucky enough to get scholarships are indeed getting a bang-up deal. But, I'm not talking about those guys.

In fact, I agree with the latter part of your comment, where you say that divorcing sports and education is the long overdue solution to this problem. I personally don't believe playing sports (sports management is another thing) has anything to do with higher education. But, I also agree that it will probably never change. There's too much money at the top, and it's too easy to screw the athletes down at the bottom.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by brudgers on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:58PM (#8496163)
In the case of gridiron football the system is a subsidy to the NFL which avoids player development costs...often at taxpayer expense. Likewise, the colleges pass off youth development costs to the public high school systems...again at taxpayer expense.

For the players. this form of amateurism means they have no power to negotiate contracts to offset the risks associated with the sport.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by rrrx3 on Thursday October 23, 2014 @08:29AM (#8497764)
One could also make the argument that industry does the same thing with your average college student - offloading education and training cost onto the taxpayers and students and then reaping the benefits.

Doesn't make it right, I;m just saying the argument could be made.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by differentView on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:55PM (#8496157)
>they are not being paid anything remotely close to the value that these schools get from them in terms of team gear sales, ad revenue, tv time, increased enrollment, etc etc etc.

This is true for only a very small percentage of college athletes.

Most college sports don't generate a lot of money for their schools. Even the most popular sports, men's football and men's basketball, generate big money for a minority of elite programs.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by vinceguidry on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @09:07PM (#8496196)
Let's look at it another way. 40 out of 50 states' highest paid public employee is a head football or basketball coach.
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by ska on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @10:27PM (#8496424)
But isn't it this same minority of elite programs looking for ways to carry academically incompetent students?

Most student athletes are students first, not looking for an opening in a professional league.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by mbreese on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:46PM (#8496121)
Well, they are getting compensation in terms of free tuition, room and board, etc... these things do have significant value. If they complete school, they get to walk away with a degree without any debt. That's not trivial.

However, the athletes are only able to actualize this compensation if they can freely choose their majors, are able to take the classes they want, and actually earn their education. By creating a secondary tier of classes, the school was deliberately exploiting them.

I think that the value of a degree (for an athlete) will vary greatly depending on the school. Some schools are more academically rigorous for athletes than others... UNC apparently was on the low end of the scale.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by rodgerd on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @09:12PM (#8496209)
> Well, they are getting compensation in terms of free tuition, room and board, etc... these things do have significant value.

Compare and contrast with the money an 18-21 year old second team player at Real Madrid or Barcelona makes and get back to me on the "significant value". Especially when the athletes are being funneled through second-rate degrees to free up their time for sport.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by cafard on Thursday October 23, 2014 @06:09AM (#8497418)
A fairer comparison might be to the pay received in US minor league baseball. These can go as high as $90 thousand. But you can also play at the highest level of minor league ball, AAA, and get $2150 per month.

Having said that, I agree with you on the whole. They are being paid in kind: in room and board that they could get at home, and in tuition that doesn't seem to amount to much. I think that baseball's structure of minor leagues and Canadian hockey's junior hockey offer a better deal to the young athlete.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by cpwright on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @10:23PM (#8496415)
Or compare it to the AHL, where players make $70,000 (this is as of 2012-20130. The $70,000 figure is not hugely out-of-line with the cost of a year of tuition, room, and board at a good school. Once they make the leap to the NHL it goes up markedly to at least $525,000 (as of 2011-2012), and of course free agents make even more.

I do think that most public colleges should get out of the business of fielding sports teams. Except for the best schools, they will not be a net positive financially.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by enraged_camel on Thursday October 23, 2014 @01:30AM (#8496818)
>>Well, they are getting compensation in terms of free tuition, room and board, etc... these things do have significant value. If they complete school, they get to walk away with a degree without any debt. That's not trivial.

The actual number comes down to around $25,000/year for public schools and $35,000/year for private schools. This is out-of-state tuition combined with living expenses and school supplies. However, it goes down significantly once the student establishes in-state residency.

So basically, these college athletes are making working class wages while learning nothing of significant value. A few of them get into the major leagues upon graduation and the rest struggle with unemployment and underemployment for years. Being involved in college athletics costs them more in the long run than the paltry sum of expenses they get to waive over their college career.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by washadjeffmad on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @09:06PM (#8496183)
I think a brunt of the issue is that their exploitation is what is being used to generate that "significant value".

Here's an article about the latest NCAA reform vote on [edit: student-]athlete compensation: http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/08/06/us-ncaa-rules-idUS...

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by LanceH on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @09:52PM (#8496330)
If the athletes truly brought the value and it wasn't the schools and league itself, then the NBA's D-League would be raking in the billions and they could all play there.

It turns out that people want to watch their school beat another school, and they aren't particular about the athletes. You can say the individuals bring value, but they destroy an equal amount of value at some other school when they succeed.

Witness the last NBA lockout when the players had some all-star games and couldn't fill the seats. A mature competitive league is responsible for far more of the revenue than it gets credit for.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by SeanLuke on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @09:07PM (#8496195)
> Why is every semi-pro athlete expected to get a decent GPA in order to play on a university's football team?

Because they are not semi-pro athletes. They are university students first and amateur athletes second. Or at least that's what's being claimed. And as students, they have to pass the same general education curriculum as every other student in the university, and to the same standards.

> If, as adults, they choose not to pursue academic studies, and instead choose to focus all of their energy on sports, then they should be allowed to do that without putting their sports career at risk.

Sure. But this should be done outside of a university environment. The problem is not that athletes expected to be good students. The problem is that in the US they are expected to be students at all.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by dragonwriter on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:14PM (#8496000)
> Why is every semi-pro athlete expected to get a decent GPA in order to play on a university's football team?

Because there are semi-pro teams and university teams, and the two things are not the same thing.

> If, as adults, they choose not to pursue academic studies, and instead choose to focus all of their energy on sports, then they should be allowed to do that without putting their sports career at risk.

Sure, and if they choose to do that, they should do it somewhere other than an academic institution.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by alistairSH on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:35PM (#8496079)
In the case of American football, skipping college isn't an option. The NFL doesn't recruit out of high school, so a player's only option is to do 3-4 years indentured servitude at an NCAA institution.
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by ilamont on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @09:06PM (#8496185)
Maybe professional sports should change the way they recruit, and leave academic institutions out of the picture. The NFL has enough money to set up a more extensive farm league system, or maybe they could have a junior league based on smaller cities?

FWIW, I have heard of the NBA showing interest in kids in high school. I am not sure if they actually recruited any of them, though.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by philwelch on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @09:17PM (#8496222)
The NBA currently disallows drafting players straight out of high school, but for a decently long era it was allowed and a lot of the biggest stars who entered the NBA at that time were drafted from high school, including Kobe Bryant, LeBron James, and Kevin Garnett.
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by hsod on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @09:37PM (#8496284)
Also, some high school players who do not want to go to college (for whatever reason-- academic, financial, etc.) go play overseas at age 18 for a few years, getting paid all the while, then get drafted along with their HS graduating class a few years later.
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by alistairSH on Thursday October 23, 2014 @10:43AM (#8498348)
I don't disagree, but the NFLPA and NFL have a collective bargaining agreement that prohibits the NFL from recruiting until a player is 3-years removed from high school (roughly age 21).

Both the league and player's union benefit from this restriction in trade. Appellate courts have ruled in their favor. So, the NFL as zero interest in creating a farm system that competes with the NCAA. Obviously, the NCAA also likes this arrangement as it's a major source of revenue for college athletic departments.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by qq66 on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @09:17PM (#8496225)
They're not really playing sports at an academic institution... they're playing sports for a business that's got a joint branding contract with an academic institution.
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by cellis on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:19PM (#8496024)
I disagree. Playing sports at the highest levels is an academic activity, it's just not recognized as an academic activity today. You definitely have to study, recognize patterns, solve problems, etc. Just not so much reading books and writing papers.
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by cgearhart on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:50PM (#8496138)
By the modern understanding of the word "academic" it is more like a skilled trade.
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by jordanpg on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:55PM (#8496156)
> reading books and writing papers.

So you'd argue that football is an intellectual pursuit in the same sense that math, physics, philosophy, or history is?

That study of the nuts and bolts of the game is worthy of the attention of our finest minds (as a discipline unto itself)?

The "reading books and writing papers" you mention is a severe and tragic distortion of why universities exist. It has little to do with the academic activity that's occurring outside the undergraduate classrooms.

It might be the case that there is a lot of waste happening in universities due to the commodification of education, but that doesn't trivialize the serious work that's still happening, however underfunded it remains.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by Retric on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @09:09PM (#8496201)
It's at least on par with, literature, music, philosophy, history, sociology, psychology, art, or any other "soft" subjects lacking of direct impact on people's lives. It's held to a higher standard than economics, but has less impact.

As to math I would argue it's more meaningful than say topology, but less than other branches.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by Steuard on Thursday October 23, 2014 @01:20AM (#8496801)
If you're listing topology as "less meaningful", I'm guessing you haven't spent much time studying topics in physics that have been developed since the 1970s or so. Topology turns out to be a pretty big deal.
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by Retric on Thursday October 23, 2014 @03:34PM (#8500242)
There has been plenty of post 1970's physics advances, but the number of useful ones (for the average person) directly linked to Topology is much smaller.

EX: Fusion research is potentially extremely useful, but so far it's impact is basically nothing. Ditto Astrophysics.

Though, if you have anything specific in mind I would love to hear about it as I am really drawing a blank.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by wfo on Thursday October 23, 2014 @09:48AM (#8498066)
Your casual dismissal of half the central core of human intellectual enterprise over the last 4000 years raised my eyebrows, but when I got to your comment about topology it became clear you have no idea what you're talking about or are simply trolling. Either way, stop.
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by Retric on Thursday October 23, 2014 @12:43PM (#8499133)
It's not that I think they have low or zero value. Or even personally care about the sport. It's simply a numbers game and I rate Football rather highly as it's actively enjoyed by a large number of people. For comparison more people in the US watched an football game than read a book for fun last year.

Semi conductor design by comparison is something few people directly care about but it directly impacts their lives increasing it's value immensely.

PS: History for example is important, but the study of history has fairly limited impact outside of entertainment for most people.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by jdminhbg on Thursday October 23, 2014 @02:48PM (#8499968)
> For comparison more people in the US watched an football game than read a book for fun last year.

Not sure this is the case. Pew pegs the percentage of Americans who read a book last year at 77% [http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2014/01/the-decl...], and the Super Bowl drew 111 million viewers [http://www.cbsnews.com/news/super-bowl-2014-ratings-set-new-...]. I'd guess the number of people who watched a football game but not the Super Bowl last year isn't totally insignificant, but probably not huge (and I'm skeptical that the ratings aren't maybe a little inflated).

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by Retric on Thursday October 23, 2014 @03:18PM (#8500143)
Your assuming everyone who read a book did so for fun. Scroll down on your first link and the percentage is 55% of adults and 52% 18-24 year olds. Compared to 64% of americans watching an NFL game. http://tvbythenumbers.zap2it.com/2011/10/14/no-surprise-64-a...

Further, football goes beyond the supper bowl and beyond the NFL. Including collage, high school etc, and an estimated 200+ million people watched at least one football game last year.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by dragonwriter on Thursday October 23, 2014 @01:57PM (#8499644)
> It's simply a numbers game and I rate Football rather highly as it's actively enjoyed by a large number of people.

The question wasn't whether it was actively enjoyed by a large number of people, but whether it was "an academic activity".

The idea that was is an "academic activity" is defined by how widely enjoyed the activity is probably only defensible with a very unusual definition of "academic".

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by Retric on Thursday October 23, 2014 @03:30PM (#8500214)
My point is not to defend it as an academic activity, but to measure the impact.

"Game theory" is clearly an academic activity. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Game_theory

The study of football at a deeper level is a subset of that, but it covers a fairly wide area. From which plays to call in offence vs defense. Cost benefit of risking a player injury in a low win percentage game. Which players to sign etc. (Or even just the math around fantasy football.)

I mean just because your covering a specific WWI battle does not mean your doing something else and not studding history.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by cma on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:44PM (#8496109)
The replies are saying the schools provide prestige, visibility to scouts, and training/coaching/advice.

Change the terms in your post and theirs a bit, and I can't tell if we are talking about exploiting footballers or participants in the YCombinator program.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:09PM (#8495962)
Sure; but they shouldn't be playing on a college team. As in, if you don't work at a company you shouldn't play on the company team.
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by sillysaurus3 on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:11PM (#8495971)
Why not? (I ask this in hopes of being persuaded, not to defend a position.)
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:15PM (#8496002)
Because colleges have the stated goal of educating people. Its cynical (as the commenter above mentioned at the end) to join the college with no intention of actually getting educated. Its called a 'shill' or ringer - somebody you get from outside to represent you, that is not actually a member of your organization beyond the single task (sports).
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by Alex3917 on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:43PM (#8496106)
> Because colleges have the stated goal of educating people.

And do you suppose that people are just born being really good at sports? Of course not, it takes thousands of hours of learning/education. If we're going to treat things like math and economics as academic subjects, then I don't see how football is any different.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by cousin_it on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:56PM (#8496161)
Agreed! With one minor correction. If the main thing you're studying is football, you should get a degree in football. I'm a big fan of imagining reforms that don't change anything but just rename things to their proper names. It's an interesting way to see the world.
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by llamataboot on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:40PM (#8496097)
But this has nothing to do with how NCAA athletics have worked in the US, especially in football, for decades. You can't blame the players, when they are pursuing the sports path open to them, blame the colleges.
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by mbreese on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:49PM (#8496134)
The professional leagues are also complicit (baseball less so). Both the NFL and NBA have age limits on their draft picks. At least the NBA has a development league, but the NFL has no farm system to speak of (outside of the NCAA).
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by maxerickson on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:17PM (#8496011)
A different take on it is that the schools shouldn't advertise them as student-athletes that are there on "scholarships" (scare quotes because taking a fake class isn't very scholarly).
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by dragonwriter on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:17PM (#8496013)
Colleges are academic institutions. If you want to be semi-pro athlete rather than a student-athlete, you should join a semi-pro team rather than an academic institution.
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by frandroid on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:33PM (#8496074)
The students would have to be paid something in order for them to be semi-pro. They are amateur athletes. Ironically, the teams themselves have to be considered professional, considering the amount of income they generate.
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by sehr on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:50PM (#8496135)
There are no semi pro football teams. Simplifying it all down to that is naive and ignorant, the athletes are using the system that's been put in place for them to succeed.

Ignoring the NCAA route in favor of anything else at this point isn't just career suicide, it's career abortion.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by dragonwriter on Thursday October 23, 2014 @01:10AM (#8496781)
> There are no semi pro football teams.

Yes, there are.

True, they aren't a good way to get into the NFL, because the NFL prefer to recruit from college teams.

But the question then shouldn't be "why are college athletes expected to meet the academic sstandards that go with being in college" but "why do major professional sports teams in certain sports prefer to recruit from colleges rather than lesser professional leagues in the same sport"?

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by sehr on Thursday October 23, 2014 @02:15AM (#8496909)
That's exactly my point, in the spirit of semi pro baseball & soccer leagues, semi pro football does not exist.

And great, that's a completely different argument. One that I think we really should be having soon, though I'm not sure if anything will be changed.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by wavefunction on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @09:18PM (#8496229)
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by sehr on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @09:29PM (#8496260)
That means absolutely nothing.

Looking at the lowest level of college football, there are only 11 active roster NFL players from a D3 school. [0]

There are 1,696 active NFL players, that's a 0.6 percent chance of 'making it', at the lowest level of the game.

Again, absolute and utter career suicide because of some moral grievance.

[0] - http://www.d3football.com/interactive/faq/general#14

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by wfjackson on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @09:07PM (#8496194)
Why do academic institutions need to have sports teams?
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by droopyEyelids on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:21PM (#8496029)
You're questioning the fundamental purpose of an institution in such a way that it's hard to answer. Why shouldn't universities also run all sorts of other businesses, and then make money from their student consultants?

Because the institution of a university exists to provide an academic education that will help them function in the world after school. Because offering a degree in Football would be more predatory than most for-profit colleges Audio Engineer courses.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by JoeAltmaier on Thursday October 23, 2014 @09:29AM (#8497973)
Still a little off: colleges don't make money from football. The football program is generally a separate corporate entity, with its own profit and loss. Our coach makes $7M while the president of the university makes $300,000. If the college owned the football program that might be different.
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by dllthomas on Thursday October 23, 2014 @05:55PM (#8500975)
One argument I hear is that colleges make money from football because football inspires donations to the college. I have heard various things as to whether this actually reflects reality and I haven't investigated the matter myself.
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by jordanpg on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:45PM (#8496116)
The GPA requirement is incidental. It happens to be the barrier to playing ball.

There is a straightforward economic incentive (money) for both the school and the athletes to practice more and win more, and it plainly has nothing to do with academics, whatever the grand rhetoric about student athletes. As with all such situations, when there is a barrier to economic success, the system will gradually evolve to short circuit those barriers (cheating) as much as is possible within the confines of the rules. This is well documented by now. I have to imagine that UNC was just unlucky enough to get caught.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by wolf_cook on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:27PM (#8496051)
While I agree with this perspective on athletics at a university, it does seem like it ought to be an issue with the school's academic accreditation. I don't believe that a university that practices this should have their degrees recognized this way.

I will say that I'm not really sure who values this certification though.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by pXMzR2A on Thursday October 23, 2014 @07:02AM (#8497543)
> get a decent GPA

A 2.0 is not a decent grade nor GPA, it means you're failing at most of your classes and will probably be expelled.

Btw, your argument is "leave the school and pursue sports." I just found that interesting, that's all.