FWIW, I have heard of the NBA showing interest in kids in high school. I am not sure if they actually recruited any of them, though.
Both the league and player's union benefit from this restriction in trade. Appellate courts have ruled in their favor. So, the NFL as zero interest in creating a farm system that competes with the NCAA. Obviously, the NCAA also likes this arrangement as it's a major source of revenue for college athletic departments.
So you'd argue that football is an intellectual pursuit in the same sense that math, physics, philosophy, or history is?
That study of the nuts and bolts of the game is worthy of the attention of our finest minds (as a discipline unto itself)?
The "reading books and writing papers" you mention is a severe and tragic distortion of why universities exist. It has little to do with the academic activity that's occurring outside the undergraduate classrooms.
It might be the case that there is a lot of waste happening in universities due to the commodification of education, but that doesn't trivialize the serious work that's still happening, however underfunded it remains.
As to math I would argue it's more meaningful than say topology, but less than other branches.
EX: Fusion research is potentially extremely useful, but so far it's impact is basically nothing. Ditto Astrophysics.
Though, if you have anything specific in mind I would love to hear about it as I am really drawing a blank.
Semi conductor design by comparison is something few people directly care about but it directly impacts their lives increasing it's value immensely.
PS: History for example is important, but the study of history has fairly limited impact outside of entertainment for most people.
Not sure this is the case. Pew pegs the percentage of Americans who read a book last year at 77% [http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2014/01/the-decl...], and the Super Bowl drew 111 million viewers [http://www.cbsnews.com/news/super-bowl-2014-ratings-set-new-...]. I'd guess the number of people who watched a football game but not the Super Bowl last year isn't totally insignificant, but probably not huge (and I'm skeptical that the ratings aren't maybe a little inflated).
Further, football goes beyond the supper bowl and beyond the NFL. Including collage, high school etc, and an estimated 200+ million people watched at least one football game last year.
The question wasn't whether it was actively enjoyed by a large number of people, but whether it was "an academic activity".
The idea that was is an "academic activity" is defined by how widely enjoyed the activity is probably only defensible with a very unusual definition of "academic".
"Game theory" is clearly an academic activity. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Game_theory
The study of football at a deeper level is a subset of that, but it covers a fairly wide area. From which plays to call in offence vs defense. Cost benefit of risking a player injury in a low win percentage game. Which players to sign etc. (Or even just the math around fantasy football.)
I mean just because your covering a specific WWI battle does not mean your doing something else and not studding history.
Because there are semi-pro teams and university teams, and the two things are not the same thing.
> If, as adults, they choose not to pursue academic studies, and instead choose to focus all of their energy on sports, then they should be allowed to do that without putting their sports career at risk.
Sure, and if they choose to do that, they should do it somewhere other than an academic institution.