News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:09PM (#8495962)
Sure; but they shouldn't be playing on a college team. As in, if you don't work at a company you shouldn't play on the company team.
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by sillysaurus3 on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:11PM (#8495971)
Why not? (I ask this in hopes of being persuaded, not to defend a position.)
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:15PM (#8496002)
Because colleges have the stated goal of educating people. Its cynical (as the commenter above mentioned at the end) to join the college with no intention of actually getting educated. Its called a 'shill' or ringer - somebody you get from outside to represent you, that is not actually a member of your organization beyond the single task (sports).
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by Alex3917 on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:43PM (#8496106)
> Because colleges have the stated goal of educating people.

And do you suppose that people are just born being really good at sports? Of course not, it takes thousands of hours of learning/education. If we're going to treat things like math and economics as academic subjects, then I don't see how football is any different.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by cousin_it on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:56PM (#8496161)
Agreed! With one minor correction. If the main thing you're studying is football, you should get a degree in football. I'm a big fan of imagining reforms that don't change anything but just rename things to their proper names. It's an interesting way to see the world.
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by llamataboot on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:40PM (#8496097)
But this has nothing to do with how NCAA athletics have worked in the US, especially in football, for decades. You can't blame the players, when they are pursuing the sports path open to them, blame the colleges.
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by mbreese on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:49PM (#8496134)
The professional leagues are also complicit (baseball less so). Both the NFL and NBA have age limits on their draft picks. At least the NBA has a development league, but the NFL has no farm system to speak of (outside of the NCAA).
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by maxerickson on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:17PM (#8496011)
A different take on it is that the schools shouldn't advertise them as student-athletes that are there on "scholarships" (scare quotes because taking a fake class isn't very scholarly).
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by dragonwriter on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:17PM (#8496013)
Colleges are academic institutions. If you want to be semi-pro athlete rather than a student-athlete, you should join a semi-pro team rather than an academic institution.
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by frandroid on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:33PM (#8496074)
The students would have to be paid something in order for them to be semi-pro. They are amateur athletes. Ironically, the teams themselves have to be considered professional, considering the amount of income they generate.
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by sehr on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:50PM (#8496135)
There are no semi pro football teams. Simplifying it all down to that is naive and ignorant, the athletes are using the system that's been put in place for them to succeed.

Ignoring the NCAA route in favor of anything else at this point isn't just career suicide, it's career abortion.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by dragonwriter on Thursday October 23, 2014 @01:10AM (#8496781)
> There are no semi pro football teams.

Yes, there are.

True, they aren't a good way to get into the NFL, because the NFL prefer to recruit from college teams.

But the question then shouldn't be "why are college athletes expected to meet the academic sstandards that go with being in college" but "why do major professional sports teams in certain sports prefer to recruit from colleges rather than lesser professional leagues in the same sport"?

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by sehr on Thursday October 23, 2014 @02:15AM (#8496909)
That's exactly my point, in the spirit of semi pro baseball & soccer leagues, semi pro football does not exist.

And great, that's a completely different argument. One that I think we really should be having soon, though I'm not sure if anything will be changed.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by wavefunction on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @09:18PM (#8496229)
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by sehr on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @09:29PM (#8496260)
That means absolutely nothing.

Looking at the lowest level of college football, there are only 11 active roster NFL players from a D3 school. [0]

There are 1,696 active NFL players, that's a 0.6 percent chance of 'making it', at the lowest level of the game.

Again, absolute and utter career suicide because of some moral grievance.

[0] - http://www.d3football.com/interactive/faq/general#14

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by wfjackson on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @09:07PM (#8496194)
Why do academic institutions need to have sports teams?
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by droopyEyelids on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:21PM (#8496029)
You're questioning the fundamental purpose of an institution in such a way that it's hard to answer. Why shouldn't universities also run all sorts of other businesses, and then make money from their student consultants?

Because the institution of a university exists to provide an academic education that will help them function in the world after school. Because offering a degree in Football would be more predatory than most for-profit colleges Audio Engineer courses.

Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by JoeAltmaier on Thursday October 23, 2014 @09:29AM (#8497973)
Still a little off: colleges don't make money from football. The football program is generally a separate corporate entity, with its own profit and loss. Our coach makes $7M while the president of the university makes $300,000. If the college owned the football program that might be different.
Re:U.N.C. Investigation Reveals ‘Shadow Curriculum’ to Help ... by dllthomas on Thursday October 23, 2014 @05:55PM (#8500975)
One argument I hear is that colleges make money from football because football inspires donations to the college. I have heard various things as to whether this actually reflects reality and I haven't investigated the matter myself.