News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by TheAceOfHearts on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @04:39PM (#8494967)
Why don't these people just move to more affordable places?
Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by astrocat on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @05:06PM (#8495144)
Many may interpret this as victim blaming but I think it's a valid question: why have we as a country/culture become so much more resistant to moving? I know I've read more comprehensive literature on this before a but a quick google brought up these starting points:

http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2013/05/11/declining_ame...

http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2012/03/generati...

I understand that we develop local support networks of friends and family and it's easy to understand why moving comes with the fear of having to start in a new place with no such network. But it seems that this fear has become limiting - that we are now refusing to relocate to places where greater opportunity exists because we can't stand the thought of leaving our current network behind. We're stuck, effectively. And it exacerbates the conditions in places like SF.

Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by HarryHirsch on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @05:43PM (#8495366)
it seems that this fear has become limiting

A network of friends and family for such things as childcare and temporary accomodation is worth dollars. If you can leave your son/daughter with their grandmother while at work or can find a couch at a friend's house while between jobs you can put up with lower local wages. To move elsewhere, the new job would have to pay enough for childcare and to allow to build a cushion of savings.

A sympathetic ear and a can of beers is also worth a lot. Often, on this board, we read of burnout and nervous breakdowns.

The decision not to move doesn't seem to come from fear, on the contrary, it's rational, elsewhere life isn't going to be better, and very possibly worse. At the low end of the wage spectrum there is no opportunity left anywhere in the nation.

Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by astrocat on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @09:02PM (#8496174)
All this is true, and very understandable. But the question remains, why is it NOW more common to stay put rather than relocate? What is it about the modern environment that makes people so much more reluctant to pick up and move? With all the benefits of modern communication and technology that makes maintaining social connections over distances and receiving financial support from anywhere so easy, you'd think it'd be easier to move than before when leaving really meant "leaving."
Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by tedunangst on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @09:26PM (#8496249)
Families used to live together, so when you moved to a new city, grandma came with you. What's new is splitting a household into many households, such that "leaving" is actually possible.
Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by smsm42 on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @07:40PM (#8495857)
I personally seriously don't get it. I mean, the article describes a guy who is out of job, fails to find a job anywhere around after multiple attempts, but it still adamant on remaining in a city where, for example, I - being fully employed and pretty handsomely paid professional - would not live because prices there are freaking insane. Why? I'm not even saying move to Arizona desert or something - but even moving to San Jose - which is not exactly the middle of nowhere either - would be cheaper. And moving further from the epicenter of crazy would make it even better. I mean, I get it if you have to commute to a job, or want to keep close to an active job market. But for that poor person, there's no job market to talk about in SF. Why he insisted on staying in SF and spending all his savings on his landlord, and after getting that wonderful deal and losing all his money - still wanting more of it? Please explain it to me, I can't understand it. I, personally, wouldn't want to live in SF, for a number of reasons, but I get it when some people do. There's a lot of nice things in the city (not like a short BART ride wouldn't get you there... but I digress) but if it just doesn't make sense for you to live there and you can't afford any of the nice things anyway and it brings you only suffering - why?
Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by malyk on Thursday October 23, 2014 @12:16PM (#8498980)
Twoo things come directly to mind.

1- every place here requires first and last months rent as a security deposit at a minimum. Even I a "cheap" place that's a lot of cash when you don't have a job.

2- credit/background checks make it unlikely that he would ever be approved by a landlord.

Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by smsm42 on Thursday October 23, 2014 @02:31PM (#8499852)
True, upfront costs is a huge problem. Credits may be less so, I've rented with literally no credit at all - just came to the US - and I've seen landlords not checking credit at all. Not all of them but some. After all, credit score doesn't guarantee I won't lose my job tomorrow and stop paying. For upfront costs, it is a big hurdle. But staying in most expensive place in the area doesn't make it any better.
Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by anigbrowl on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @05:54PM (#8495425)
places where greater opportunity exists

like where? You might as well ask why tech companies don't set up elsewhere and start their own little versions of Silicon Valley instead of spending $$$ to headquarter in SF.

Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by scott_karana on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @06:48PM (#8495666)
Most people don't require the startup connections and capital of SV; they just want to survive and do their job, not start a speculative business venture.

Working as a firefighter/waiter/mechanic/nurse is roughly the same in the Bay as it is in (say) Oklahoma, but prices of living are proportionally much more favourable.

Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by smsm42 on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @07:50PM (#8495888)
North Dakota? http://www.aei-ideas.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/walmart.... [1]

Don't know how the prices are there but doubtfully it's worse than in SF, and the pay seems to be about double of what the same pays in SF.

[1] http://www.aei-ideas.org/2014/10/north-dakota-sets-more-oil-...

Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by eqdw on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @06:21PM (#8495559)
I actually do ask that. Pretty regularly. It was pretty shitty that I had to move to another country 2000 miles away just to find employment, when anywhere with internet is more than capable of employing me. And back home I had 250 down/50 up for $75/mo, so clearly that's not the blocker
Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by DannyBee on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @04:47PM (#8495015)
Because people believe that once they've lived somewhere long enough, they have a right to live there forever.

There are a lot of issues with this article. It talks about the Ellis act as if it isn't standard in every other part of the country.

(in fact, the only thing non-standard is the state of the world pre-ellis act, where landlords in california could never evict people and decide to stop being landlords)

Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by warfangle on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @05:16PM (#8495208)
The Ellis Act is kind of fucked up, dude. It's _not_ standard in every other part of the country. It pegs the buyout price of a unit by law, and hasn't been increased in quite a while.

Compare to how it works in Brooklyn:

If your landlord wants to evict you without cause, they must purchase your lease from you at a price which you can negotiate. It's much more difficult (and can be costlier) to evict you _for_ cause here. In a gentrifying area, tenants have been known to negotiate lease buyouts at upwards of six figures - and there have been some lease buyouts in the $MM range.

> never evict people and decide to stop being landlords

This is a pretty huge misconception. It's evicting people _in order to_ stop being landlords. E.g., converting a rental building to condos or single-family housing. It's a cheap way to cash in on skyrocketing real estate: the most you'll ever pay to evict someone is $18,000 a unit.

In most sane places, if a landlord wants to go out of business / quit being a landlord, they must sell the property to another landlord. They can't just say "oops, you guys need to all leave now!" For good reasons.

Even red states like NC have pretty strict restrictions on when you can evict a tenant, and "'Cause I'm shutting down the LLC" is never one of them.

Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by JamesBarney on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @05:44PM (#8495369)
I don't think the Ellis Act allows you to break a lease. It just allows the owner to not have to conform to certain aspects of the rent control law. In most places that aren't rent controlled the leasee doesn't have the option for perpetual renewal in the contract. If the leasee meets all of the stipulations of the contract then he is entitled to live there until his lease expires. The landlord is obligated to perform certain services in regard to the lease and entitled to rent as long as he performs those services. Seems to work everywhere else without the problems listed in the article.
Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by warfangle on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @07:28PM (#8495802)
It allows landlords a way to go out of business without selling the property they own.

It's often used to evict tenants who live in units that are regulated.

SF requires a compensation of $5,153 to $18,000 per tenant evicted.

NYC requires that tenants not be evicted unless they have violated provisions of their lease. If the landlord wants a tenant to move out, they can _buy_ the tenant out, at a price the tenant agrees to. If they want to stop being a landlord, they have to sell the building to someone who is willing to be a landlord. This effectively prevents tenants from being screwed with their pants down by their landlords.

Occasionally an asshole landlord will go through one of their buildings while the tenants are away and, say, rip up all the floors. As a nasty way to try and get their tenants to move out so they can renovate and flip the building.

But those guys typically end up in jail.

The reason it tends to work out fine in other places, is because other places are sane about allowing developers to build new units. SF ... not so much.

Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by JamesBarney on Thursday October 23, 2014 @01:37PM (#8499515)
I am confused. Is the landlord evicting them in the middle of their lease. Example: Landlord signs year long lease with tenant and then evicts tenant mid lease to sell property or are they not renewing the lease at the end of the year when lease contract expires.
Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by msandford on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @05:26PM (#8495275)
So what happens when the company that owns the property goes bankrupt because, say, it can't raise rents? Does the state step in and buy the property so everyone can live there?

If the company goes bankrupt then the building is probably put up for sale, and could get sold to a developer rather than another landlord right?

Seems like a fairly straightforward end-run around the law. You go bankrupt in your building and I'll buy it at auction for some price, and the reverse.

Unintended consequences are everywhere as a result of laws like this.

Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by warfangle on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @07:22PM (#8495782)
> So what happens when the company that owns the property goes bankrupt because, say, it can't raise rents?

The building becomes foreclosed and bank-owned, or is sold to a new landlord.

Most landlords can raise rent. Less than 2.8% of units are controlled, though 48.6% of units are stabilized. Only 31.9% of units in this city are not regulated - and landlords tend to do pretty well here. Occasionally you'll read about a shitty one that ruins their tenants' apartments to try and force them out instead of buying their leases, but that doesn't happen very much anymore -- and when it does, the city stomps on their necks.

Rent control is almost entirely phased out. When one becomes vacant, it becomes rent stabilized - or is removed from the program entirely.

Rent stabilization is much more common, and has some limitations: the amount the landlord _may_ increase the rent is limited per year; if a unit becomes vacant, the landlord may raise the rent by a larger percentage; if the landlord renovates / improves the unit, they may raise the rent by a number based on the cost of renovation. Renovation typically only happens during vacancy.

A unit becomes deregulated once rent becomes higher than $2,500 and either 1) becomes vacant or 2) the adjusted household income of the tenant is over $200,000/yr for two consecutive years.

Stabilization entitles the tenant, in good standing, to lease renewal (in other words, landlord can't kick you out unless you break the terms of the lease).

Some landlords voluntarily put units under stabilization, in return for a break on their property taxes.

> If the company goes bankrupt then the building is probably put up for sale, and could get sold to a developer rather than another landlord right?

Yes. However, the developer would then gain the responsibilities of being a landlord and could not evict tenants that are in good standing. The stabilized/controlled status of each unit stays with the unit, and is not determined by who owns the building. Units exit the program based on vacancy, legally raised rent level, and tenant income. New units enter into the program when landlords decide to get property tax breaks when they build new properties.

> Seems like a fairly straightforward end-run around the law. You go bankrupt in your building and I'll buy it at auction for some price, and the reverse.

Why, when you could just sell the building to another landlord/capital investment firm for 120% of what you bought it for two years ago? ;) A lot less risky, considering you don't need to go through bankruptcy court and the whole several-years-in-jail-for-fraud thing.

It's a pretty good system. Sometimes it screws the landlords. But it almost never screws the tenants.

Which is kind of the opposite of the Ellis Act, it seems: it gives landlords carte blanche to screw the bejesus out of their tenants as soon as the market winds blow their way.

Don't get me wrong: we definitely have a housing crisis here as well. Some neighborhoods have seen (because units have vacancies often - some people move every freaking year in this city) rent increases from 600sq ft @ $800/mo to 600sq ft @ $2100/mo in a matter of five years.

Of course, the smart tenants in those neighborhoods haven't moved, and are only paying $900/mo.

Either way, landlords interested in purchasing a building know how much each lease is for. They know the stabilization status of a unit. And many of them purchased the buildings they own decades ago for less than 10% of the current market price. It's not like they get surprised by the regulation status on the units they own.

Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by msandford on Thursday October 23, 2014 @04:10PM (#8500463)
Those are some really foreign concepts to me, but OK. Thanks for explaining!

Given all that the SF rent wars make a lot more sense.

Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by tptacek on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @05:22PM (#8495244)
NC has a restriction on evicting a tenant at the end of a lease term? It has mandatory lease renewal?
Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by DannyBee on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @10:15PM (#8496393)
"In most sane places, if a landlord wants to go out of business / quit being a landlord, they must sell the property to another landlord. "

Actually no. This is not really true.

There are plenty of states/places where you can simply evict the tenants at some prorated rate, and then go about your life. You mention it yourself a few paragraphs up.

Additionally, for the specific case of condo conversions, which is the largest claim of ellis act "violations", most states are friendlier than you claim.

Let's take maryland (A state I am barred in, so very familiar with property law for): http://www.peoples-law.org/conversion-condominium-ownership

You get 180 days, an offer to purchase the unit at the same price as the best price the unit gets offered for in the next 180 days, and moving expenses. That's it.

"Even red states like NC have pretty strict restrictions on when you can evict a tenant, and "'Cause I'm shutting down the LLC" is never one of them."

Source? AFAIK, this is completely incorrect for "most states"

Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by yaks_hairbrush on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @06:23PM (#8495566)
Other parts of the country don't need an Ellis Act type framework. Most places, you can evict tenants when their lease is up.
Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by drivingmenuts on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @05:01PM (#8495111)
> Why don't these people just move to more affordable places?

It's not a viable solution to just "go somewhere more affordable" when you don't have the money to leave and there are no jobs where housing is more affordable. What you save in housing costs would be eaten up or exceeded by the cost of just getting to a job.

If you're rich, moving is always an option. If you're not rich or have no financial cushion, you are well and truly stuck.

I just went through a bout of homelessness. What money I did have, I had to spend on gas, food and minimal rent to stay in the area, because the option was going back home where the high-paying job is Walmart or a prison.

And by high-paying, I mean around $28K a year, if you're lucky.

Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by bequanna on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @05:11PM (#8495174)
>It's not a viable solution to just "go somewhere more affordable" when you don't have the money to leave and there are no jobs where housing is more affordable. What you save in housing costs would be eaten up or exceeded by the cost of just getting to a job.

This just doesn't make any sense to me.

So, you're homeless and jobless. You're saying I shouldn't somewhere else because 'it's too expensive to find a job'?

These people have an emotional attachment to SF, I get that and absolutely sympathize. The reality is there are many, many jobs in the Bay Area and plenty of them are close to affordable housing. Additionally, if they want to spend time downtown, most places in the bay are no more than an hour via public transport.

Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by squidbot on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @06:00PM (#8495452)
I think what the parent was saying was that you literally can't afford to go elsewhere to find a job. When you don't have money to pay your rent, you likely don't have the money to:

- Pay for airfare and a hotel to go out for a job interview (these types of jobs aren't flying you out and putting you in a hotel)

- Have living expenses to cover you for the time it takes to find a new job in the area (the types of jobs we're talking about here don't give you a relocation allowance)

- Rent a truck and gas to move a long distance (certainly not to pay a moving company)

- Pay first and last months rent and deposit

Moving is often "free" for the types of jobs the typical HN reader would have, the company trying to recruit you would pay all of the above. These aren't the types of jobs people discussed in the article have or can get. They are effectively stuck unless they take a huge, potentially even more devastating risk, or are fortunate enough to have some sort of a support network where they are hoping to move to, like family or good friends willing to let you couch surf for a while.

Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @06:07PM (#8495494)
Thousands of years ago a Chinese gentleman wrote "The wise man must be prepared to abandon his luggage". Still true. Most of the behaviors discussed are 'conservative' meaning they try to keep what little you have and risk nothing. Its often an alternative to just 'get up and go', risking all. You can eat at the Salvation Army, stay with a friend or sleep in the park in a tent. I've known now-successful Engineers that moved to Silicon Valley with their wife and 6mo old child, slept in the national park in a tent while interviewing.
Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by GauntletWizard on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @04:46PM (#8495006)
Because they have roots and history in SF and the valley. They've got friends, family, and memories there. It's hard to give up your home.

It's those tech upstarts that're causing all the trouble; Moving there en-masse, with their strange ways and disrespect for the local culture. Always trying to "disrupt"; they're obviously troublemakers!

Really, it's no different from casual racism, but you've got to understand the roots: Fear of the unknown is a powerful motivating factor for most people.

Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by pessimizer on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @04:57PM (#8495089)
>with their strange ways and disrespect for the local culture. Always trying to "disrupt"; they're obviously troublemakers!

This is a straw man. It's the "tech upstarts" money and their willingness to spend it like water that's disruptive, and not because it makes them "troublemakers" but because it makes local rents rise to multiples of what they were before. It's very much different than casual racism.

edit: it's very silly and reality TV drama to think of this as a personality conflict. It's a rent going from $2K to $5K in 5 years conflict.

Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by Kalium on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @05:18PM (#8495219)
The attitude is little different. How dare those outgroup people challenge the way things are done!
Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by potatolicious on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @05:01PM (#8495116)
Because cost are going up across the board throughout the Bay Area, and the transportation infrastructure - both automotive and otherwise - hasn't kept up.

Moving further means increased commuting cost. For drivers this comes in the form of massively increased fuel costs. For transit users this comes in the form of increased fares, since BART practices distance-based pricing.

Commuting daily from Fremont to SF costs $12, that's over 1h of minimum wage. Imagine if you had to pay 10-15% of your total income (pre-tax!) just to get to work. More if you're unable to get a full 8h of work a day.

Moving further also means a large reduction in disposal free time. Free time is a bit of a misnomer when it comes to the poor though - since the time isn't actually free. The article touches on this at a few points - the working poor require a lot of government subsidies and aid organizations for survival, all of which takes time, and most of which are located in SF.

One of the key inhibitors in helping people out of homelessness is, to be simplistic, lining up for things. The basic services they need to survive have huge lines to access them, making a large proportion of their lives idling in a waiting room, waiting for one necessary thing after another. Imagine the DMV, but every day, and multiple times a day.

All of this exacerbated by living far away. Not only are you waiting around forever for basic things, you're now spending more time to get there in the first place.

Even to a rational, completely-informed actor (an unsafe assumption, to say the least), the economics of living further away may not actually work.

Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by Oculus on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @05:07PM (#8495154)
I don't think they mean move to a place more affordable out side of SF, but move away from SF to another part of the country.
Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by potatolicious on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @05:10PM (#8495167)
Where though? At the end we're really talking about arbitrage. Places with jobs are expensive to live in, places that are cheap to live in don't have jobs.

There's no way to win, except maybe temporarily exploiting an arbitrage opportunity (i.e., a place with jobs but the cost of living hasn't caught up yet). Expecting people to do this is unreliable at an individual level, and disastrous as public policy.

Ultimately the only mid- to long-term solution is to help make job centers cheaper to live in.

Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by DamnYuppie on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @05:21PM (#8495238)
There are many affordable and large and fast growing cities with great pay. Dallas, Houston, Boise, and SLC to name a few.
Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by x0x0 on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @05:45PM (#8495375)
And long commutes mean you're very exposed to gas prices. When our next little middle east adventure starts, or isis wins in iraq, or putin uses oil prices to negotiate with the EU, or whatever it is, the same folks whose FYIGM attitude means people who can't handle their housing prices doubling in 5 years have to leave -- will be saying, "They should have known not to get a long commute and expose themselves to gas prices like that."
Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by curun1r on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @05:42PM (#8495354)
I think you're reading more into his comment than what was intended. He didn't ask, "Why don't these people just move to more affordable places and still work in San Francisco?"

I live in SF and I find it to be a really nice place, but if I was making minimum wage or anywhere near it, I'd never choose to live here. Those kinds of jobs are available in other parts of the country.

Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by DanBC on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @04:43PM (#8494988)
How does a homeless person afford the travel to a "more affordable" place? (What does more affordable mean when they have no money?)

Where do the nurses, teachers, security guards, waiters, shop assistants etc etc live?

Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by clarkm on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @04:55PM (#8495078)
Well, the first guy profiled could've used his "his savings and his investments" and his "daughter's college fund" to move instead of spending it all on rent. Downsizing is a pretty common occurrence in most parts of the country, but in SF there's really not much to downsize to.
Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by ReadyCollective on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @06:01PM (#8495463)
If you're connected to the community you live in (coaching, etc), your child's doing well in a good school, it becomes easy to extend yourself "one more week" in order to maintain that, hoping things will change - and then past the "oh shit" moment you realize you're past the point of effectively affording to move and restart life. Plus, in 2009, i don't think there were places to move to to get an easy job. The guy did apply to 800 places...
Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by johnny_utah on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @05:43PM (#8495365)
One example -> the city of San Francisco offers bus tickets home for homeless people who have relatives or friends in another town who are willing to take them in. The program is called "Homeward Bound."

Source: http://www.sfhsa.org/79.htm

Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by panzagl on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @05:30PM (#8495293)
I don't know how the homeless travel, but they do. After all, they get to SF somehow.
Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by smutticus on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @04:52PM (#8495056)
Why don't people in the bay area allow cheap housing to be built in their community? Why can't we have giant apartment complexes in the bay area?
Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by pcwalton on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @05:05PM (#8495140)
Any or all of (a) because it keeps housing prices high, working to the advantage of those who own property; (b) because low density is easy to tie into environmental/quality of life concerns; (c) because the culture is deeply distrustful of market-based solutions, such as market-rate housing.
Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by jseliger on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @05:09PM (#8495162)
Why don't these people just move to more affordable places?

In many cases, they are: most often to Sunbelt cities like Dallas, Houston, and Phoenix, which are the fastest growing in percentage terms in the nation (See Matt Yglesias at http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2012/06/14/in_the_future... or http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2013/05/23/fastest_growi...).

Yglesias also details some of this in The Rent Is Too Damn High (http://www.amazon.com/dp/B0078XGJXO?ie=UTF8&tag=thstsst-20&l... -- a must read on these issues, and I usually post a link when discussions like this one arise).

Anyway, lots of cities have dysfunctional political and legal systems that prevent the supply of housing from growing. San Francisco's problems are particularly acute: http://www.citylab.com/housing/2013/10/san-francisco-exodus/... and are exacerbated by rent control, which discourages owners from even utilizing existing space.

Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by jmaha on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @04:53PM (#8495059)
It's not exactly that straight forward...

As mentioned in the article, many who work full time in SF can't afford to live in the city. "Affordable places" generally means far east or south of their workplace, meaning that they have to spend an enormous amount of money and time commuting to their jobs. With time and money being a finite resource [for most], the commute time comes at the cost of family time and the cost of transportation comes out of their meager earnings (a fact that, if you live in SF or work at a company that provides a private bus, take for granted). Living outside of the city is still unaffordable for many people because of these costs.

The real problem is the scarcity of overall housing resources. With the boom in tech drawing more and more people into SF, it's only going to become more of an issue unless building picks up significantly. This is also true of salaries, which will have to increase in order for companies to hire people who can afford to live here, further driving a wedge between those who can and those who cannot live here.

Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by remarkEon on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @04:43PM (#8494986)
Ok. Where?
Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by bequanna on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @04:56PM (#8495086)
If you're looking for affordable housing, it would probably be wise to look anywhere other than SF:

http://www.businessinsider.com/san-francisco-is-more-expensi...

The East Bay is only a 45 min BART ride away from downtown, and considerably cheaper.

Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by selectodude on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @05:04PM (#8495131)
Only coming from personal experience, that $1737 number for a 1bed in Chicago is very high and makes me question the rest of their numbers.
Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by remarkEon on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:02PM (#8495928)
Currently living in Seattle and their numbers seem pretty spot on anecdotally for what people are paying now, though a few of my friends are looking and they have found nothing under $2500 for a 2 bedroom. Seattle I think is going to be a city to watch closely the next few years for similar types of housing strife we see in SF. Once all the Amazon construction is complete it's going to get awfully crowded awfully fast.
[deleted]
Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by bequanna on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @05:05PM (#8495137)
Having lived in other large US cities, I am always astounded by the number, brazenness, and aggressiveness of SF's homeless population.

From my (anecdotal) observations, poor police enforcement appears to be a motivator for homeless people to gather and remain in SF. Walk a couple laps around City Hall and count the number of misdemeanors you can spot in the open and homeless 'tents'. Most other cities don't allow anything of the sort.

Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by anigbrowl on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @05:59PM (#8495449)
Yes, they send their homeless people to SF instead. http://www.ksby.com/news/san-francisco-suing-nevada-for-alle...
[deleted]
Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by DannyBee on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @04:50PM (#8495036)
While the desire may be rational, believing society can make this desire can come true is probably not rational.

At some point, you run out of places to put all the people who want to live in a given place. You have to have some way of deciding who gets to live there, and to be honest, "blood right" doesn't do it for me.

Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by tptacek on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @05:00PM (#8495106)
San Francisco does things to make the desire even less rational, in the name of maintaining civic character and political status quo. Not just building restrictions, but management of core services (particularly transit).

It's hellaciously expensive to live in Manhattan, but viable for many low-wage workers with jobs in Manhattan to live in NY Metro.

Re:Inside San Francisco's housing crisis by baddox on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @04:55PM (#8495072)
Weird. I didn't stay where I was born.