Though basic individual usage is really not the problem, anyways. Households don't use all that much water, and most of it can be returned to the waterways after treatment. Water pricing is much more important for affecting the behaviour of businesses.
Will the government find out how many people live in a certain household and use that to arrive at a "basic personal amount" of water?
An acre-foot of water, the amount that some farmers are paying $20 for, is 325,000 gallons. At that price, a typical persons usage would be about $0.20/month. Raising that number by 10x, which is roughly the price San Diego pays for water, each person would be using about $2 of water per month. Even assuming the worst case, that 100% of the water had to be produced by desalination costing $2000 per acre-foot, that would only be $20 per person per month.
It's also not too expensive to err on the safe side and give out a generous personal amount. In the quantities that an individual uses, water is pretty darn cheap.
At the moment Irish Water is a semi state body, but there are large fears that it will be sold off to a private company in a few years, along with the PPS numbers and details of everyone in Ireland.
There was a large demonstration against it last weekend [1]
[1] http://www.thejournal.ie/water-charge-protest-in-dublin-1718...
"In May, for example, DWSD sent out 46,000 shut off notices. Of those, only 4,531 customers less than 10 percent of the total had their water service shut off for any period of time. Within 24 hours, 60 percent of the affected customers paid their accounts in full and had their service immediately restored. Forty percent of the remaining customers had their service restored within 48 hours."
The people who honestly can't afford it should have mechanisms to waive their water bill costs but the above quote clearly shows that's a tiny fraction of the people who actually got shutoff notices. The trick of course is that many of these small minority needs to be proactively contacted by the city government since they're likely mentally ill/severely disabled and possibly lack the ability to take the initiative on their own.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_Declaration_of_Human_...
> (1) Everyone has the right to a standard of living adequate for the health and well-being of himself and of his family, including food, clothing, housing and medical care and necessary social services, and the right to security in the event of unemployment, sickness, disability, widowhood, old age or other lack of livelihood in circumstances beyond his control.
IANAL and don't know much about international law, but I'm guessing that's what people mean when they talk about the right to water, since certainly water is necessary for health and on par with food and shelter, and it's reasonable to read water into that article. But it's hard to imagine that means the government can't use shutting off water as an enforcement mechanism for water prices. That would be largely the same as saying that right is actually not to have water, but to not pay for it. If you take that to mean "you don't have to pay for water", you're also saying you don't have to pay for clothes or housing. If I don't pay my rent, can the government enforce my eviction? Or does my right to housing supersede that? What if I have a huge house and piles of money?
I think it makes more sense to say that you have a right to access water on reasonable and affordable terms. If you can afford water but opt not to, you're not being deprived of water in the relevant sense.
And after you stop that person, who's to say you had the right to, and that the person's friends shouldn't come back and teach you the error of your ways?
My point is, if you can't have water because someone else claims they own it, their ownership claim is backed up by the positive effort of others just as much as your claim to the water is, if not more so.
"Stable ownership is the gift of social law, and is given late in the progress of society." — Thomas Jefferson ( http://press-pubs.uchicago.edu/founders/documents/a1_8_8s12.... )
It's worth noting that in some countries (Scotland, Norway) there is no such thing as trespass. So not only do you not have government assistance with preventing people walking on your land, you are not legally allowed to enforce that yourself either.
On the topic of land ownership:
A Scottish miner is walking home one evening with a brace of pheasants. He unexpectedly meets the landowner who informs him that this is his land and he better hand over the pheasants:
'Your land eh' asks the miner.
'Yes', replies the laird, 'and my pheasants.'
'And who did you get this land from?'
'Well, I inherited it from my father.'
'And who did he get it from?' the miner insists.
'His father of course. The land has been in my family for over 400 years' the laird splutters.
'OK, so how did your family come to own this land 400 years ago?' the miner asks.
'Well… well… they fought for it!'
'Fine,' replies the miner. 'Take your jacket off and I'll fight you for it now.'However, the general rule is that we do have a "right to roam" with the condition that people accessing land are sensible about it:
http://www.outdooraccess-scotland.com/
Land ownership in Scotland is incredibly complex - I can recommend the book "The Poor Had No Lawyers: Who Owns Scotland and How They Got it":
http://www.amazon.co.uk/The-Poor-Had-No-Lawyers/dp/178027114...
The freedom to roam doesn't include the right to hunt wherever you want though. =)
*yes, paid from the taxes, I feel like I need to point this out otherwise someone else will.
Given that water and sewage are closely related ( you can have sewage management without it, but it's riskier - we're talking outhouses, which require some management ), I'd be perfectly willing to help pay for poor people's water out of purest self interest.
There's the problem of identifying who might be eligible, but I'm ignoring that for now.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_Declaration_of_Human_...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_to_water
For this reason what happens when the price for water is raised and the consumers can't pay becomes a very interesting issue. Detroit has raised their prices and then started to cut off consumers that don't pay. Something UN has criticized Detroit for:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/06/26/united-nations-detr...
http://www.wnd.com/2014/06/u-n-to-intervene-in-detroit-water...