News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by kazinator on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @03:06PM (#8423267)
> Solid-state lighting won't supplant the lightbulb until it can overcome the mysterious malady known as "droop"

Counterpoint:

"Incandescent lighting will never make a come back against solid state until it can overcome the mysterious maladies known as 'the fizzle and the pop', and its voracious power consumption."

(We shouldn't forget fluorescent, by the way. And that's not solid-state; it's tubes. In residential lighting, the competition now is really only between CFL and LED.)

Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by DanBC on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @05:25PM (#8424112)
The submission is from 2009. LED lighting from that long ago was either not very good or was very expensive.

LED lights are now much better.

Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by toomuchtodo on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @03:27PM (#8423391)
Fluorescent is more than likely on its way out, considering how fast the cost of LEDs are coming down, their efficiency continues to increase, and their longevity is many times that of their fluorescent counterparts (not to mention you don't need to handle LEDs as carefully as fluorescent bulbs/tubes).
Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by kazinator on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @04:27PM (#8423806)
Speaking of that, laims of LED longevity are troubling.

You better save your original receipts carefully. What if you get something that is supposed to last 25,000 hours but in reality it only lasts 15,000? I can imagine getting a refund, even a partial one, will be difficult, even with the original receipt.

Firstly how do you prove it was only used 15,000 hours? It depends on how many hours it was lit per day. How do you prove that the bulb you have in your hand is the one for which the receipt was issued? A newer receipt could be used to return an old identical item.

Is the store even around where you bought it? It's 30 years later now (so at least your receipt is credible, by the date printed on it), but you have nowhere to go. You only used that bulb 10,000 hours in its deployment location, by your calculations, and it turned into toast. You have to turn to the manufacturer for a refund. (A good argument for sticking to name brand LEDs like Phillips.)

Many LED bulbs claim outrageously long lifetimes, but as of now, this has not actually been tested; no deployed LEDs are anywhere near that many hours old. Basically, it's a matter of faith. People are gambling that if they pay more for and LED, it really will last as long as it claims.

(Don't get me wrong; I use LEDs. I have eight LED flood-lights, one LED room light, and two LED range hood lights! I just wonder about the longevity. I write the installation date on every bulb and try to save the receipts.)

Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by HeyLaughingBoy on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @04:38PM (#8423875)
How is that different from incandescents? I switched my garage to LED lighting because I never get anything remotely close to the claimed lifetime of incandescent bulbs in the ceiling lights, no matter what brand I try.

In any event it doesn't matter whether or not the actual life testing has been done. Product manufacturers do accelerated life testing to estimate the lifetime of the product. It's similar to asking how they know that a new car shouldn't need warranty service for 6 years when it's only just been released.

Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by sentenza on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @04:49PM (#8423942)
Right before the EU banned light bulbs, there were big sales everywhere and people (including my parents) bought carloads of them.

Of the bulbs purchased by my parents in those last days, so far about half don't make it to the 6 month mark. I'd say that the companies manufacturing those bulbs offloaded their throw-outs on EU consumers right then and there.

Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by Crito on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @05:57PM (#8424256)
Incandescents tend to be cheap enough that nobody cares. Even if they are longer in the long run, the per-burn-out cost is cheap enough that it will rarely hurt somebodies wallet. Easier to stomach 10 $1.00 burnouts than 1 $10 burnout.

See also: the reason why poor people tend not to shop at Costco.

Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by Crito on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @08:32PM (#8424753)
s/longer/more expensive/
Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by Shivetya on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @06:41PM (#8424404)
when it comes to garages two things conspire against the life of lights, vibration caused by garage doors and powered openers, and temperature variations.
Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by HeyLaughingBoy on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @09:13PM (#8424861)
That's the weird thing. The light in the garage door opener lasts forever (and it's not the high vibration type) and it's constantly being vibrated. OTOH, the ceiling lights only last a few months at a time.

I tried CFLs, but this is Minnesota. And when it's -25F outside, there is essentially no light out of those things :-(

Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by jhallenworld on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @07:20PM (#8424544)
I bought a bunch of Phillips' "alien-head" bulbs. One died after two years. Phillips replaced it even without a receipt and without having to return the broken bulb. They also replaced one which worked, but was buzzing. Their newer glass ones look nicer, so I'm very satisfied.

I'm surprised they didn't want them back for failure analysis, but perhaps they have plenty already.

Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by m4x on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @05:36PM (#8424159)
Would you even bother trying to get a refund on a $12 lamp after "only" ten years of life?

Manufacturers should definitely change their stated lifetimes if they turn out to be incorrect, but even if their stated figures turned out to be 50% too high I wouldn't be concerned. You're still getting many years of service per lamp.

Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by kazinator on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @05:49PM (#8424217)
Yes I would! I could have bought a $5 lamp of comparable efficiency, and also have had ten years life; I specifically paid more to get the longer life, damn it! :)

Maybe the vendors are banking precisely on your thinking; that people in the future will lose their receipts, forget the dates, or consider $12 from ten years ago a trifle matter that isn't worth their time and so on, and yet that people can be conned into coughing up more cash today.

By the way, how long an LED lamp will last depends on multiple factors. It's not just the silicon itself, but all of the components in the complex power supply that is integrated into it. It could be zapped by a power surge. (Do these things incorporate TVP's?)

Notice how no electronic appliance that you can buy claims to be good for 25,000 hours of continuous use. No smartphone, no television, no home theatre receiver, no computer. Typically you get a 1 year from the date of purchase, whether it's used or not and you can pay extra for more coverage. One year gives you a little over 8000 hours if you fire it up right away and leave it on continuously.

Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by aortega on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @04:37PM (#8423868)
It is more easy than you think. If the lamp only last 15000 hours instead of the advertised 25000, you never buy from the same brand again.
Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by judk on Wednesday October 08, 2014 @01:00AM (#8425387)
Unless the competition only lasts 1500. That's the case with LED's competition.
Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by ctdonath on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @03:56PM (#8423606)
...and the realization of the reality of toxicity when one breaks on tile right in front of your toddlers.

Methinks if CFLs were promoted by one political party instead of another as a tactic for a particular sociopolitical strategy, we'd be hearing loud denunciations of promoting a product which uses a toxic & environmentally-unfriendly gas encased in a fragile housing.

Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by hackuser on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @04:14PM (#8423736)
How does one respond to subjective characterization of a hypothetical response of a 'straw' group of people to a hypothetical situation? The only factual statement is this one: "Methinks".

If we are politicizing light bulbs and global climate, have we gone too far?

Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by kefs on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @12:56PM (#8422288)
Cursory search revealed this from April 2013..

http://engineering.ucsb.edu/news/699

Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by TheCapn on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @01:30PM (#8422540)
The author's reasoning for this posting is likely due to the Nobel Prize announcement:

http://www.nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/physics/laureates/201...

Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by ChuckMcM on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @01:49PM (#8422692)
Thanks for that link, I had missed it apparently. Not sure how they would 'fix' it though, perhaps different materials with different valence electron configurations. It seems it would create an upper limit on the current through an LED, where any additional current would just result in more heat and no additional photons.
Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by hackuser on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @02:51PM (#8423143)
Does anyone know if droop is still a problem? Also, how much current causes how much droop?
Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by anigbrowl on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @03:08PM (#8423285)
I don't know if a 5 year old article is helpful really. Certainly in the film world, things have moved on since that was written; large LED light panels are common on sets now and throw out a huge amount of light relative to their size and power consumption, eg http://www.litepanels.com/1x1_ls_bicolor.php
Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by hackuser on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @03:21PM (#8423364)
I had thought LEDs produced a poor color spectrum for film. I see the linked site advertises a color temperature "from daylight to tungsten and anything in between". How is that accomplished (or is my memory of LED's spectrum poor)?
Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by anigbrowl on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @03:48PM (#8423558)
They have both elements and allow you to dial in a ratio between them (just as multicolor LEDs are actually made up of very very small primary LEDs sandwiched together). They're not as good as HMIs or incandescents in terms of quality or power output capability, but they're 'good enough' for many situations where you just need a little extra light and it's more important to get a good shot than to go to a lot of logistic expense to get a perfect one - on a film set, time is money and there are literally hundreds of cost decisions that have to be made every working day.

The other thing they have going for them is that almost every film now comes under the hand of a colorist who adjusts the elements of every scene to favor a particular color palette - ideally one that was chosen in advance of photography and that is supported by lighting, costume, and production design. A tightly constrained color palette provides thematic unity and makes a big contribution to a film's 'atmosphere,' and generally takes precedence over photographic realism. The extreme example of this is making a film in black-and-white for aesthetic reasons; although that's a bit extreme for most mainstream audiences, many popular films are almost monochromatic with a strong tint. This creates visual tension and where the plot revolves pretty clearly around heroes and villains, strong visual contrasts underline the moral contrasts of the narrative. Comedies generally have broader colors palettes and colors are more saturated, reflecting the dramatically unpredictable and chaotic interactions of the characters.

Anyway, since shooting features on digital media became practical, and high quality digital scans of film stocks became affordable, filmmakers have exerted more and more control over the color of a film Because They Can, and the increasingly minor deficienices of LEDs are that much more likely to be smoothed away in post anyway because the white balance of a scene can be so easily manipulated in the digital realm.

Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by caf on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @05:21PM (#8424088)
Once you've seen the Teal And Orange, you can't unsee it.
Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by clarry on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @03:35PM (#8423459)
The diode itself produces only a peak in the spectrum. Phosphors are used to convert the light to a wide spectrum. There are different kinds of phosphors, and there can be multiple coatings of different types. So you can also have different qualities -- and the quality can be very good.
Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by hackuser on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @04:04PM (#8423666)
> The diode itself produces only a peak in the spectrum. Phosphors are used to convert the light to a wide spectrum. There are different kinds of phosphors, and there can be multiple coatings of different types. So you can also have different qualities -- and the quality can be very good.

Thanks for the explanation. I've been learning a little about light sources; based on my limited knowledge, I wouldn't expect that the full spectrum (or spectral power distribution (SPD)) of daylight could be replicated by hacking together LEDs and phosphors, though perhaps the untrained eye would not be cognizant of the difference. Can they really pull off 'daylight'?

Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by aidenn0 on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @04:13PM (#8423730)
They've made fluorescent tubes with daylight spectrum for a long time (I recall seeing them available, but expensive in the 90s). Those work with phosphors, so I don't see why an blue LED pumped phosphor couldn't work as well as one driven by a near-UV mercury vapour lamp.
Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by aortega on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @04:42PM (#8423893)
To exactly match daylight you would need all the visible light, plus infrared and UV, and a total power of 1 KW/square meter. The good thing is that the lamp would also work as a space heater.
Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by slashink on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @05:03PM (#8423995)
True! Worked a lot in building broadcast studios and i usually went for http://www.bbslighting.com/products/area-48-soft-remote-phos... due to the Phosphor filter. Wonderful color representation from a small, efficient fixture.
Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by toomuchtodo on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @03:27PM (#8423396)
Have a Home Depot near by? Go in and look at their Cree bulb displays (both warm and daylight colors).
Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by tokenadult on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @02:06PM (#8422836)
This article is a very good background explanation of the rationale for this year's Nobel physics prize and a good overview of LED technology and its history. I learned a lot here about the economic and manufacturing trade-offs involved in promoting use of LEDs for indoor lighting rather than incandescent bulbs. A worthy read for a day when LEDs are very much in the news.
Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by andrewflnr on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @04:34PM (#8423850)

  At the current levels needed for general lighting, droop 
  kicks in, and down you go, below 100 lm/W.
In other words, at their worst efficiency they still kick incandescents out of the park, and are competitive with fluorescents without the toxic chemicals. Wake me up when they solve the problem, but don't expect me to panic in the meantime.
Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by evanrelf on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @05:16PM (#8424058)
Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by myrryr on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @06:53PM (#8424447)
The answer was to have lots of little LED elements.

None of which put out a lot of power, but in parallel gave the light that was needed.

in 2009, they were trying to replace a lightbulb with a single led.

Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by jhallenworld on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @01:29PM (#8422537)
What's wrong with multiple LEDs per chip, each operating at their most efficient range?
Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by r0bfelty on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @02:18PM (#8422917)
Nothing, as far as I am concerned. That is what all the LED light bulbs on the market are currently doing. The price has come down substantially in the last 2 years. I am replacing all my bulbs as they build out with LEDs.
Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by ctdonath on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @04:03PM (#8423659)
Yup, prices have become quite palatable: still high, but between longevity (1 LED ~= 10 incandescent) and eliminating replacement hassle (obviate 9 climb-on-something replacements), and that the color issue is resolved to my satisfaction, they're preferable.

Only issue now is consistency in group replacements. While I'm replacing independent bulbs as they burn out, things like a vanity with 12 bulbs means dropping some $150 at once to replace all the bulbs so they will all be exactly the same model. Styling & performance is still changing rapidly enough that occasional replacement of a burnout in a group will result in inconsistent bulbs, looking sloppy.

Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by mjevans on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @06:17PM (#8424324)
Your vanity is probably specked for something similar to 30 or 40 watt bulbs. You could replace with half as many bulbs (leaving old dead bulbs in place or using some other socket filler) that produce equivalent light to reduce the costs.
Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by twistedpair on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @04:10PM (#8423708)
It will be $15 or less once the LED's on your vanity give out in 10 years.
Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by mnw21cam on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @01:37PM (#8422590)
Price.
Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by gone35 on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @11:48PM (#8425231)
[Spoilers]

Each theory has its champions. Theoreticians at Philipps-Universität Marburg support Auger recombination [...]. Meanwhile, Hadis Morkoç’s group at Virginia Commonwealth University seconds Schubert’s support of electron leakage [...].

Well, the consensus has progressed quite a bit since: In recent years there's been increasingly convincing evidence that Auger recombination is the dominant effect behind droop after all (see for instance [1]).

[1] http://spie.org/x108666.xml

[/Spoilers]

Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by monochromatic on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @05:47PM (#8424214)
> Today’s garden-variety incandescent bulbs aren’t much different from the ones Thomas Edison sold more than a century ago. They still waste 90 percent of their power, delivering roughly 16 lumens per watt. Fluorescent tubes do a lot better, at more than 100 lm/W, but even they pale next to the best LEDs. The current state-of-the-art white LED pumps out around 250 lm/W, and there’s no reason why that figure won’t reach 300 lm/W.

If 16 lm/W is 10% efficiency, why isn't 300 lm/W an impossible 187.5% efficiency?

Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by jacobolus on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @08:06PM (#8424683)
One guess: incandescents pump out lots of infrared radiation, compared to LEDs, and also a lot more red light.

Lumens, as a unit, are normalized to the sensitivity of human cone cells, so the same amount of radiant flux in the green part of the spectrum is “more luminous” than in the red or violet parts of the spectrum, and infrared doesn’t count at all.

As a result, I’m not sure there’s any obvious way to measure an efficiency percentage in terms of lumens/watt.

Re:The LED's Dark Secret (2009) by matmann2001 on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @06:30PM (#8424361)
Quantum tunneling