TS initially gets 6% (for $18k, but that's irrelevant). The founders also take the $100k convertible notes at $3M cap and 20% discount.
Say the company closes a round of $1M at $3M pre = $4M post, i.e. the investors get 25%.
For me, it's always easier to think about shares. Say the initial pool is 1,000,000 shares, split in 940,000 to the founders, and 60,000 to TS. Pre-money, 1 share costs $3, and the investors get 333,333 shares, that are added to the pool.
TS has 20% discount, that makes the price $2.40. With $100k, TS can buy 41667 shares, that are also added to the pool. Overall, there are now the following shares: 940,000 to the founders, 101,667 to TS, 333,333 to the investors, so they respectively own 68.36%, 7.39%, 24.24%.
(Note: this may be a simplification, meaning that the investors can possibly work on pre-post to have exactly 25%, which means both the founders and TS will have a little bit less.)
Skipping the details, let me add a few more examples.
- Round of $1M at $4M pre = $5M post, i.e. the investors get 20% => founders 73.25%, TS 7.27%, investors 19.48%.
- Round of $500k at $1.5M pre = $2M post, i.e. the investors get 25% => founders 66.35%, TS 10.12%, investors 23.53%.
In conclusion, $100k for 7-11% equity seems pretty reasonable.
Edit: fixed formatting
The equity analysis you pointed out as well as the description of the LoI stuff made me reconsider that position, and by the end of the article I was glad I read it. It wasn't quite the muckraking I was expecting, and instead was a decent exploration of when a fit with an accelerator just didn't exit.
Matasano never did the incubator/accelerator thing, right?
Also, I think the section regarding TechStars success makes an assumption mistake:
"The national rate of failure for startups is 75-90%. So lets say it was a good year and Techstars Chicago received a 1000 applicants/startups to choose from. You know based on national averages that 750-900 of these companies will fail. That leaves 100-250 that will succeed. Techstars is only taking 1% of applicants, which is 10 startups. Unless Techstars is picking poorly, they are selecting companies that are positioned for success from day one. These startups would most likely succeed with or without Techstars."
The common assumption that 75%-90% of startups fail is usually regarding venture backed startups, not people who fill out the TechStars applications. I would wager that the if you looked at the failure rate of anyone who had an idea they wanted run through an accelerator, the failure rate would be much, much higher. What you should benchmark TechStars against VC performance.
(Disclaimer: I went through TechStars.)
Also important to control for cohort size. These are 10 company classes. A 100 million+ breakout seems to be somewhere between a 1 in 100 and a 1 in 50 occurrence.
They've crowd-funded over 125 million dollars toward medical expenses for people in need.
http://betaboston.com/news/2014/09/16/product-design-startup...
And the real answer to this is that getting large exits takes a long time. Unless I'm mistaken YC, which is older than Techstars and has 50% more portfolio companies, has 3 exits over 100 million, OMGPOP, Heroku and Twitch. Granted the last one was a big one.
(Disclosure: Hackstar in 2009, Founder in 2010)
The exit analysis is the first thing I think of when I think of Techstars, too. Ostensibly, the reason to sign on with an "incubator" is that the connection you get would enable you to obtain rapid growth. But I can't think of good examples of companies where that's happened.
That said - I think Excellerate Labs (before Techstars bought them) had a serious hand in getting several startups off the ground. The tech scene in Chicago specifically is newer (so companies are younger) which means less exits, but I think if you watch the Chicago scene for a bit - that's going to change very soon.
That said - good analysis here. Good to see a founder not just jumping at the opportunity for funding "just because it could."
I completely respect that you are in the bootstrap your business camp, and that 1871 isn't your scene. But this post has confirmation bias written all over it. TS Chicago has been a boon to many of the companies that went through it, and that is the only measure of success anyone should care about.
Frankly: I am skeptical of all but the first tier of startup accelerators, and I am especially skeptical of startup accelerators based in Chicago, a locale not conducive to funding. One argument the post made that I'm confident is correct is that the accelerator model, when it ever makes sense, does so only when the company is on a trajectory towards raising funds.
I also find the idea that Excelerate charges more than YC to be jarring. It shouldn't be controversial to say that YC is the more impactful of the two programs.
Again, if you aren't planning on fundraising, don't go through an accelerator. They are seed stage investment vehicles. Once you take investor money the clock starts ticking on an exit. Perhaps that should be in bold print somewhere, but we all read HN, this should be fundamentally understood by everyone.
I would counter argue that Excelerate/TS isn't expensive, given the stage that they come in they are severely diluted by the time you raise an A, and they have a business to run. I think you could make an argument that YC is by comparison cheap, not a bad thing considering their track record.
The "100+k for 7-11% equity" analysis is particularly damning.
I think they're taking the "Techstars accepts 1% of applications" thing much too seriously. Presumably, only a tiny fraction of the inquiries they get are from serious teams.
Also: I've been to 1871 a couple times, and I got exactly the same vibe these people got. I know some people with solid companies working out of there, but the space is practically the archetype of the "startup playing house" idea Paul Graham likes to write about. It's particularly sad because it's located in Chicago, where it's easy to get an inexpensive office lease.
Later: the equity math is apparently not as damning as it sounds, or, perhaps, not damning at all.