Your language betrays your cognitive dissonance. It it not your chat log. It was never your chat log. You typed characters into Facebook’s chat log, and the chat log is Facebook’s. There is no “permitting” needed. When you use Facebook (or Google, or whatever), you live in a glass house, an aquarium, with overseers who do not consider you a person with integrity, but more as a kind of pet to be inspected and analyzed at will. Facebook distracts you with “privacy settings”, but those apply to other pets in the aquarium, not its overseers. It might be discomforting to think of yourself as a pet in an aquarium, but you have chosen this yourself, by using Facebook.
The question if Facebook is permitted to scan your chat logs is therefore meaningless; there is no such concept. Facebook “scans” all its chat logs, all the time. (That’s why they have their chat logs.) The “privacy settings” have nothing to do with actual privacy from Facebook — like Monopoly money, it has no validity outside the tiny world of its own. Like “deleting” things, it appears to you to delete things, but does not actually delete them as far as Facebook is concerned — it is all logged and saved, forever. I could go on, but I’d better not.
(The same goes for Google and all the other cloud and social services.)
See also: People who believe they can disable the face recognition.
Folks desperately want to deny the physical nature of cloud services, and pretend that its the same as storing something on your hard drive at home. They want to believe that the software abstraction that shows local and cloud documents together is real. But you can't will away reality.
When I rent a safe deposit box from a bank, and store my valuables in it, my valuables do not become the property of the bank.
Likewise, just because I store some data on someone else's computer system does not make that data theirs.
Now, we may not yet have a good enough legal framework for protecting our data; in Europe, laws about this are better, while in the US you are expected to just use contract law for this purpose, and of course with online services you have no way of negotiating the contract and they always claim the right to do anything they want with the data.
But that does not make it "their data"; it just means that our laws need to be updated to better protect our data and not allow companies to simply claim they can do anything they want in non-negotiable user agreements.
You can argue that things should be different. What I am talking about is how things are.
The law around physical property in someone else's hands is on the other hand well established, and is referred by English speaking lawyers as "bailment". If you entrust people with your stuff and they misbehave, they are then liable for their negligence about it. So the legal theory should be simple, but "on the internet" is masquerading the issue. If I send some clothes to the dry cleaners to get cleaned, it is still my clothes. If I send some emails to be cleaned by a spam filter service, it suddenly is no longer my emails anymore. There is no reason why we need any new law to correct this, but there is political work to make it enforceable.
It's only when you add a shared construct like some system of ethics or law that your definition of data ownership make sense.
It's the difference between ownership defined by abilities and ownership defined by rights. It's a failure of the English language.
Computer security, especially, encourages you to think in base, practical (there must be a better word for this) terms. Since you can't guarantee other actors will respect your rights, you fall back to "If I don't want X done then I must make it physically impossible to do X rather than just wrong to do X".
Depends on the T&C [1]. Two things here, (1) you agreed to the FB terms and (2) took no steps to ensure your privacy despite these ever changing terms. More applicable digital lockbox hypo: when you put a gig of encrypted data on S3, AWS doesn't scan it and try to sell it to advertisers because you didn't agree to that. Further, they'd have to crack your encryption (i.e. PGP) as well if they wanted to violate those terms.
With AWS you get what you paid for. With FB, advertisers get what they paid for you.
(The set of things they can do with the data is subject to change, with notification, but if those changes are "adverse" to you, you have the right to revoke that consent. What happens to your data after that consent is revoked is something that probably needs to be explored legally, but it's pretty widely known that Facebook never actually deletes anything. And the TOS do say "irrevocable", after all...)
All that said, it's not their data. (Effectively) unlimited access, yes; ownership, no.
Actually, I disagree on that detail. An account on a Unix computer, accessible by SSH, is a known thing with known cultural implicit privacy guarantees. I have servers, which I can certainly call “mine”, with users, who have SSH access. I would absolutely not consider any file they type into to be “mine” — it is theirs.
But... that's just a cynical observation of the current, wild-west-style situation of data abuse. Society will slowly grasp the significance of what's going on and restore some sanity, ...right??
They will always have the ability to do what they like with the data they have control over.
1) messages sent through chat are not specifically covered by Facebook's TOS, as such, the individual's premise that it is is false
2) whether or not the content is Facebook's property is irrelevant, privacy laws in QC forbid publication of this content under most circumstances (exceptions being public safety etc
finally, anyone who honestly thinks anyone working for Facebook has any occupational need to look at their chat logs has a rather inflated opinion of themselves
Also, the idea that the danger is that Facebook employees should read any chat logs is also a straw man argument – a distraction. Nobody except straw men actually puts forth this as a major problem. You would have been right to dismiss it, except that nobody made that argument. To be fair, it might happen, but the scale at which it even could happen is by definition limited, since Facebook cannot have that many employees with the time and inclination to do it. The real issue is the above procedure of eternal storage and analysis – on behalf of external parties and/or for internal use.
Your arguments are highly diversionary, and seem to be aimed at confusing the issue.
There is the intellectual ownership (the ideas contained in the logs), there is the right to consult and have access to the logs, there is the publication right etc. These rights are also independent of one another, someone may have the right to consult the logs, but not to publish, or may have the right to publish, but only once someone who has the right to consult this information has given it to them
Also, it bears mentioning that simply claiming my argument is a straw man argument without actually telling me how that is so does nothing to show that it is so the issue of ownership was discussed in the first half of my commentary where i mentioned that Facebook's TOS allowed them do do what was described as such I addressed and confirmed OP's position
I then added that there were implications with what was being discussed and proceeded to give an example. Taken alone, yes it would be a straw man argument on my part, however, the point behind my commentary was to show that the practical damage that could be done by such a practice as monitoring and storing the information of chat logs would be minimized by the fact that not everyone can consult and publish that content
Indeed. I have argued before that the "privacy settings" are actually harmful. You should be making everything publicly available, because why would you give facebook access to this data but not your friends? Unfortunately this is contrary to what most people think. Of course, facebook doesn't actually allow users to make all the data available, in fact it's not even available to the user himself.
There are reasons to give private entities information that you don't want shared with the world.
Today, the technology to scan everything and keep it forever is trivial, and storage is very cheap.
And you can self host your own XMPP servers or use any other peer to peer chat client like SIP.
1. AdBlock Edge (or Plus, but Edge doesn't have loopholes): https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/adblock-edge/
2. Disconnect: https://disconnect.me/disconnect
3. Ghostery: https://www.ghostery.com/en/
And I'm sure others….
The second part of your comment strikes me as a bit ridiculous though. I cant invision a scenario in which someone would attempt to narrow down a group of users, given the provided selectors, to the point at which they know their 'target'(your son in this case) is in that group, and then(based on some boolean value (such as homosexuality)), figure out which ads are being served to that user in order to discern something about the user. (In this case seeing a certain ad would allow you to discern sexual orientation).
MarkCuban's post below (marked dead now) seems relevant, despite being decidedly offensive/inflammatory.
Why would _anyone_ go through all of that trouble when logging into the account directly or passively collecting network activity would yield the same answers?
If you're going to somehow attach the ads being served to a physical human (watching your sons computer screen to see what ads show up? Monitoring his traffic to see which ads are served?) you've already broken Facebook's model.
I _strongly_ believe that advertising is the wrong way to go about yielding revenue from a webapp in terms of the value it adds to our society(not that it isn't profitable for one entity). I just think your second statement/argument is a weak one.
There's evidence of scanning private updates & comments, going back to 2012 [1]. We could assume chat messages would be fair game in Facebook's eyes, though I haven't seen any confirmation.
[1] http://allthingsd.com/20120112/facebook-gives-politico-deep-...
Example here: http://dangillmor.com/2014/04/25/indie-web-important/
There are several rational responses, but when some other entity keeps drinking your privacy milkshake, maybe the best way to respond is to poison the well.
Make any or all of the valid profile data fake. Potentially change it once in a while to something else also false. Don't invite people you normally would friend. Definitely don't use the profile for anything important.
aboutthedata[0] by Acxiom is headed in that direction I think - just specifically for the ads they control, I think. I interned there, but I wasn't involved with aboutthedata.
If you're really upset, then just quit FB. Otherwise, keep baa-ing with the rest of the sheeple. I quit 3 years ago when their abuses got to be too much. Amazing, I still have the same friends and enjoyable life. I suspect most people would discover the same.
I am still on GPlus since it doesn't have any noise (and going by the trend, it's not likely to replace facebook anytime soon) - only tech oriented people use it, and I am fine with it.
The way I see it is the raw information itself isn't secret/private, but Facebook is the one who busted their collective asses collecting and organizing it. Similar to how companies don't have unlimited rights to Craigslist's data, the company owns the database. Facebook can't come sue you for sharing your personal information with other people- it's still YOUR information- but their catalog is theirs to do with as they see fit.
A (probably poor) analogy is a calculator. You, oh holder of the calculator, do not own mathematics. You don't have a license on the numbers that go in, nor the numbers that come out. Numbers belong to everyone. But you do own the calculator, and it is entirely within your rights to control who uses it and how.
But there is also data that I may not want to be public knowledge. If Facebook scans my chat logs, then Facebook knows a lot about me that I would not want some of my friends and family knowing. And I wouldn't be surprised if their TOS permits them to scan my chat logs.
And you can also do interesting oracle attacks with this. Let's say I'm trying to figure out if my son is homosexual. (Substitute for any fact Facebook may know, and for any person you want to investigate). I already know a ton of things about my son. Age, where he lives, what sports he plays, his favorite foods, etc. So I create one really specific ad that's guaranteed to include only my son and maybe a few other people. This one is only shown to homosexuals. Then I create an alternate ad that targets the same group, but only heterosexuals. Then I just need to watch which ad appears on my sons computer, and I suddenly know what Facebook thinks his sexual orientation is.