I saw this sort of thing a lot when I tutored physics in college. My students would crank through the formulas and come up with an answer. I would point out that their answer says the roller coaster is seventeen light years tall, or the bowling ball weighs less than a grain of sand, and this couldn't possibly be right. I always tried to get them to look at the shape of the problem first, and then look at the details. Otherwise you're just pattern matching, and don't know when you've gone horribly wrong.
It's tricky, though, because you need to strike a balance. Seeing the big picture really well doesn't get the job done if you don't have the mechanics to back it up. If the goal is a precise answer, then knowing that 7/12 is around 0.5 and is definitely not greater than 1 doesn't get you there. But it seems that schools have gone way too far the other way, focusing on the mechanics almost exclusively. The "word problem" seems to be the one concession to the big picture, but even those are taught as pure pattern-matching exercises.
Not really, no.
1. Students have to have a good concept of division, as you suggest.
2. Students have to know a method of division that accurately gets a precise answer. (whether this is via an algorithmic method or via a calculator)
3. Students have to know that their answer to (2) should correspond to their concept in (1)
4. Students have to recognise that they can check their answer using (3), and then remember to actually check this.
A good teacher will teach all four parts of this process. However, it's not possible to teach part 4 without first teaching parts 1 and 2. Every single child makes this same mistake at some point in their learning. This is not really a "problem" and it doesn't indicate a failure of teaching - in fact, the opposite here: the important thing is that the teacher has identified it and can advise the child on how to improve their understanding.
That's what teaching is. As you say, many adults have not consistently achieved part 4 - in fact, it's not immediate at all: it has to be learned.
Most of us are well served by the physicist approach to estimation, because even in the rare case we do need the precise answer our estimate will prevent obvious errors. And having a "feel" for OOM estimates is handy almost everywhere.
And, actually, the approach even gives you a short cut to the precise answer. It's about 1/2, because it's so close to 6/12. In fact, it's only 1/12 away from half. Which means the answer is 1/2 + 1/12 (which is actually a better answer for, say, a carpenter). Note also that this problem is really crappy to do in decimal, as 1/12 yields a repeating decimal (.08333...), which is natures way of saying "use fractions".
This doesn't seem right. What algorithm did you learn in school that would produce 1.5 from 7/12?
When you see "7/12 is 1.5", is your first thought "one sec, let me calculate that and see if the answer is correct"? Or do you just know, without any computation, that the statement must be false?
If you understand division, it's far easier to explain why this answer is wrong without appealing to an algorithm than by appealing to an algorithm.
And besides, the very example we're discussing proves this isn't the case!
The student was able to use the algorithm correctly; his error was at the boundaries of the standard algorithm -- correct input and interpreting output properly.
Simply practicing arithmetic will not prevent you from ever making a silly (or not-so-silly) mistake. Rote practice of the algorithm without also acquiring an intuition for the meaning of division won't help.
With correct guidance, practicing the algorithm can help students form this intuition, but that requires an a priori realization that we need to teach something other than just the rote algorithm, even if we teach it by discussing executions of the algorithm on specific inputs and outputs.
That's a profound lack of knowledge, he does not understand decimal notation. If you do not know what these number symbols mean, how can you communicate using those symbols? It all degenerates into futile pattern matching.
I understand what you're getting at but some kids don't get all of this all at once in a blinding flash - they become more and more familiar with it over time.
which, again, is a symbol misunderstanding. it's extremely presumptuous of you to say that two chained symbol misunderstandings by a fifth grader new to a subject are "the problem [of] rote learning of algorithms [by someone who] does not connect classroom learning with the real world [or] understand what the answer means"
when you're a hammer, everything looks like a nail
You see this often, even in university students. The problem isn't solved with more accountability or more teacher autonomy. The only solution is better teacher training and a different syllabus.
Also this: http://www.inference.phy.cam.ac.uk/sanjoy/benezet/