News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Secrets of amazing teachers: What both sides of the educa... by mikeash on Sunday August 10, 2014 @01:23AM (#8158940)
Excellent point. It happens again in the article with the 55MPH example. The original answer of 18 miles in 15 minutes is clearly wrong because it's more than a mile a minute, and a mile a minute is 60MPH.

I saw this sort of thing a lot when I tutored physics in college. My students would crank through the formulas and come up with an answer. I would point out that their answer says the roller coaster is seventeen light years tall, or the bowling ball weighs less than a grain of sand, and this couldn't possibly be right. I always tried to get them to look at the shape of the problem first, and then look at the details. Otherwise you're just pattern matching, and don't know when you've gone horribly wrong.

It's tricky, though, because you need to strike a balance. Seeing the big picture really well doesn't get the job done if you don't have the mechanics to back it up. If the goal is a precise answer, then knowing that 7/12 is around 0.5 and is definitely not greater than 1 doesn't get you there. But it seems that schools have gone way too far the other way, focusing on the mechanics almost exclusively. The "word problem" seems to be the one concession to the big picture, but even those are taught as pure pattern-matching exercises.

There are no comments on this comment yet.