News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Questions about Nasa's space drive answered by tobinfricke on Thursday August 07, 2014 @08:52AM (#8147412)
Here are two nice posts by physicist John Baez with some reasons to be skeptical about the "reactionless drive":

https://plus.google.com/117663015413546257905/posts/WfFtJ8bY...

https://plus.google.com/117663015413546257905/posts/C7vx2G85...

Re:Questions about Nasa's space drive answered by mnl on Thursday August 07, 2014 @11:20AM (#8148145)
I'd never understand how intelligent and educated people lose it completely when it comes to Physics. They've been exposed to some PopSci tales not meant to be accurate at all and then feel entitled to be right when they figure out some nonsensical consequences by themselves -no proper maths involved ever-. It's depressing.

Baez is right, of course. I've been checking the (Word-generated) "papers" from this guy's group at NASA, they're extremely shoddy: There's another report with their unstable calibration for the torsion pendulum which shows their complete lack of undergraduate lab report skills. And a poster from them where they say: "Q-thruster test articles are going to be tested in a vacuum to reduce possibility of air currents polluting the thrust signal during testing, but electrolytic capacitors in signal amplifier are not vacuum compatible"... Awesome.

I've also checked the Chinese Physics B paper. Their device is completely different from this one. It's an open cavity and they only use classical EM. I don't understand very well how their thrust measurement set-up works so I hold my judgement on their claims, but at least they're trying to be legit.

Violation of momentum is an extremely serious claim (in words of D.J. Griffiths, "there is no principle in Physics more sacred than that"). The Universe would look nothing like this if that were true and all the Physics that we've discovered consistent with thousands of experiments would be gone. The way they use the quantum vacuum has nothing to do with the formalism that made it possible. Several detailed QED calculations backed up by experiments to astounding precision would be completely wrong and we know that's not the case.

BTW, the fundamental principle is conservation of momentum, Newton's 3rd law of motion is a consequence that sometimes doesn't hold, for instance forces between charged particles in electrodynamics don't follow the 3rd law (but approximately at low speeds). If you take into account momentum carried by the fields you get conservation of momentum back, quite nicely as well.

Re:Questions about Nasa's space drive answered by forgotketchup on Thursday August 07, 2014 @01:13PM (#8148838)
> I've been checking the (Word-generated) "papers" from this guy's group at NASA, they're extremely shoddy.

Not defending this particular paper, but I'm curious why you highlighted the fact that it's written in Word. Just about everybody in physics these days uses Word to compose papers (Word + Mendeley is a dream, by the way). Maybe you think he's not a 'real man' because he doesn't sling raw LaTeX?

Re:Questions about Nasa's space drive answered by shoyer on Thursday August 07, 2014 @04:17PM (#8149902)
"everybody in physics these days uses Word to compose papers"

What subfield of physics have you worked in?

In my experience, this is not remotely true. Almost paper I read in grad school (e.g., on arXiv/quant-ph) was written in LaTeX. The exceptions written in Word were indeed quite likely to be the work of crackpots...

Re:Questions about Nasa's space drive answered by forgotketchup on Thursday August 07, 2014 @07:06PM (#8150594)
>What subfield of physics have you worked in?

Experimental condensed matter physics (free molecular beams). Never met anyone in my research group, or any other research group that anyone in my group collaborated with, who recently (in the past five years) composed a paper in LaTeX. I'm sure my thesis advisor did so when he was in grad school back in the dark ages, but even he uses Word.

> (e.g., on arXiv/quant-ph)

Yes, well, that is where the crackpots tend to like to hang out, isn't it?

Re:Questions about Nasa's space drive answered by TTPrograms on Thursday August 07, 2014 @04:32PM (#8149978)
What university is publishing papers in Word?
Re:Questions about Nasa's space drive answered by forgotketchup on Thursday August 07, 2014 @07:07PM (#8150599)
I don't know of anyone who publishes in Word (and universities don't publish papers, except for dissertations), but everyone composes papers in Word.
Re:Questions about Nasa's space drive answered by TTPrograms on Thursday August 07, 2014 @11:58PM (#8151404)
What research group composes papers in Word?

EDIT: Oh, you mean research groups that don't do math.

Re:Questions about Nasa's space drive answered by forgotketchup on Friday August 08, 2014 @01:27AM (#8151591)
That's right. We like to do science.
Re:Questions about Nasa's space drive answered by jcfrei on Thursday August 07, 2014 @12:03PM (#8148420)
The issues raised by Baez are quite substantial. I'm surprised the report was still published by NASA.
Re:Questions about Nasa's space drive answered by spingsprong on Thursday August 07, 2014 @09:02AM (#8147453)
"They're claiming to see a force one thousandth as big as the Chinese - probably because they are doing the experiment one thousand times more accurately. And still, some people are excited about this. "

I think he's slipping from skepticism to cynicism here.

Re:Questions about Nasa's space drive answered by crusso on Thursday August 07, 2014 @11:38AM (#8148250)
Disagree. He's being prudent and rational to hold these experiments to the same standards that we hold other more mundane ones.

Hoax phenomenon and devices always seem to fail in precisely the way that this one has. As you more carefully examine the test setups, suspicious conditions of the experiment persist (like the lack of using a vacuum in the vacuum chamber), and observed phenomenon continue to diminish as the accuracy of the test equipment improves.

And I use the word "fail" knowing full well that they claimed that they had positive results. If they couldn't use best practices in performance of the experiment like evacuating the vacuum chamber and they couldn't even show that their null device that wasn't designed to produce the same effect didn't work, then they have some serious problems.

Re:Questions about Nasa's space drive answered by snowwrestler on Thursday August 07, 2014 @03:01PM (#8149469)
I think it's great to express detailed skepticism about experiments like these, but I find the high levels of attitude to be tiresome. It doesn't add anything of substance to the skepticism, and it seems like an anti-pattern for good science. Scientists need to maintain some level of humbleness about their certainty. Not be credulous, but not be sarcastically smug either.

NASA is not universally populated with geniuses, but they're not high school idiots. I don't think they should be ridiculed for reporting a best-effort attempt to test surprising or controversial results. Otherwise how would surprising results ever be found?

Re:Questions about Nasa's space drive answered by cookiemonster11 on Friday August 08, 2014 @09:21AM (#8152619)
The skepticism is very substantiated. Read John Baez' posts maybe? Or the Paper in question?
Re:Questions about Nasa's space drive answered by snowwrestler on Friday August 08, 2014 @11:11AM (#8153149)
I'm talking about the mockery and sarcasm, which add nothing to the substance of Baez's posts.
Re:Questions about Nasa's space drive answered by readerrrr on Thursday August 07, 2014 @09:04AM (#8147461)
He seems to be makings some mistakes as well. He says: This is baloney too - but now it's graduate-level baloney. "Quantum vacuum virtual plasma" is something you'd say if you failed a course in quantum field theory and then smoked too much weed. There's no such thing as "virtual plasma". If you want to report experimental results that seem to violate the known laws of physics, fine. But it doesn't help your credibility to make up goofy pseudo-explanations.

The original description might be clumsy, but the idea of empty space being full of virtual particles is not wrong.

Here is Dr. Laurence Krauss's description of empty space:

especially the idea that what we think of empty space is really not empty, correct?

KRAUSS: That's exactly right. Empty space is a boiling, bubbling brew of virtual particles that pop in and out of existence in a time scale so short that you can't even measure them. Now, that sounds of course like counting angels on the head of a pin; if you can't measure them, then it doesn't sound like it's science, but in fact you can't measure them directly.

But we can measure their effects indirectly. These particles that are popping in and out of existence actually affect the properties of atoms and nuclei and actually are responsible for most of the mass inside your body. And in fact, really one of the things that motivated this book was the most profound discovery in recent times, and you even alluded to it in the last segment, the discovery that most of the energy of the universe actually resides in empty space.

Re:Questions about Nasa's space drive answered by idlewords on Thursday August 07, 2014 @10:54AM (#8147993)
Are you trying to suggest here that Baez isn't aware of the existence of virtual particles? He's done lots of work in quantum field theory.
Re:Questions about Nasa's space drive answered by readerrrr on Thursday August 07, 2014 @11:30AM (#8148198)
He dismissed the idea in a very arrogant way, just look at the wording, because someone used a incompatible word. Yet, the experiments gave a result; but he doesn't like that, and instead of using arguments he used ridicule, which doesn't show any credibility.
Re:Questions about Nasa's space drive answered by idlewords on Thursday August 07, 2014 @03:12PM (#8149542)
If you find his tone objectionable, try to look past it. Baez is a fellow worth listening to. He makes a number of substantive arguments why this looks and smells like crank science (for example, the contradictory statements about whether the experiment was done in a vacuum). It's perfectly legitimate of him to point out some social cues that you would not expect from a serious scientist making this kind of claim.

The faster-than-light neutrino experiment gave a result, too, but in these cases the onus is massively on the people making the wild claims, and rightly so.

Re:Questions about Nasa's space drive answered by TTPrograms on Thursday August 07, 2014 @04:31PM (#8149973)
The wording used indicates that the writers have no understanding of the current state of the field, which is extremely highly correlated with crackpottery in physics. It's not a comment on the experiment, it's a comment on the fact that the hand-wavy theoretical explanation doesn't pass the sniff test to anyone who's taken QFT.
Re:Questions about Nasa's space drive answered by cousin_it on Thursday August 07, 2014 @09:07AM (#8147475)
Baez is right, there's no such thing as "virtual plasma". Just Google the phrase.
Re:Questions about Nasa's space drive answered by tobinfricke on Thursday August 07, 2014 @09:14AM (#8147504)
To expand on that a little:

http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/outthere/2014/08/06/nasa-v...

>>In the paper by White et al, they also write that the Cannae Drive “is producing a force that is not attributable to any classical electromagnetic phenomenon and therefore is potentially demonstrating an interaction with the quantum vacuum virtual plasma.” That last bit stopped me. What’s a quantum vacuum virtual plasma? I’d never heard the term, so I dropped a note to Sean Carroll, a Caltech physicist whose work dives deeply into speculative realms of cosmology and quantum theory.

Carroll wrote back immediately, with a pointed message: “There is no such thing as a ‘quantum vacuum virtual plasma,’ so that should be a tip-off right there. There is a quantum vacuum, but it is nothing like a plasma. In particular, it does not have a rest frame, so there is nothing to push against, so you can’t use it for propulsion. The whole thing is just nonsense. They claim to measure an incredibly tiny effect that could very easily be just noise.” There is no theory to support the result, and there is no verified result to begin with.<<

Re:Questions about Nasa's space drive answered by lnanek2 on Thursday August 07, 2014 @12:36PM (#8148647)
Pretty strange response, there are lots of things that prove virtual particles are a legitimate model, even for things like generating force: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casimir_effect
Re:Questions about Nasa's space drive answered by JoeAltmaier on Thursday August 07, 2014 @09:23AM (#8147547)
Huh. I thought the OP experiment WAS verification.
Re:Questions about Nasa's space drive answered by scott_s on Thursday August 07, 2014 @11:42AM (#8148280)
Because lots can go wrong, one experiment is not a verification. Particularly when the measurements are so sensitive. And I'm aware this is the third experiment, but with a result that is so counter to basic theory, we need many more.
Re:Questions about Nasa's space drive answered by readerrrr on Thursday August 07, 2014 @09:16AM (#8147511)
You missed the point. Someone probably used a different phrase trying to describe a physical phenomena, which exists, under a different description.

You can take a look at some popular lectures of Dr.Krauss where he describes empty space in more detail, which is full of virtual particles.

Re:Questions about Nasa's space drive answered by jdmichal on Thursday August 07, 2014 @11:08AM (#8148071)
It's not a missed point. The term "plasma" means something very specific. You can't just take an existing thing (virtual particles) and slap the term "plasma" to the end of it and necessarily be correct.
Re:Questions about Nasa's space drive answered by cousin_it on Thursday August 07, 2014 @02:40PM (#8149358)
Imagine you're reading a paper about programming, and suddenly it mentions "refactoring the abstract megabyte". A non-programmer might insist that replacing "megabyte" with "class" makes the phrase kinda sorta meaningful, so the paper is totally legit. But I don't think you'd buy it.

When you're unfamiliar with some field, and insiders to that field tell you that misuse of technical terms is a strong red flag, you'd better believe them. Their words come from painful experience.

Re:Questions about Nasa's space drive answered by tomp on Thursday August 07, 2014 @09:51AM (#8147675)
Isn't that a reference to this:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virtual_particle