Re:Questions about Nasa's space drive answered
by readerrrr on Thursday August 07, 2014 @11:30AM
(#8148198)
He dismissed the idea in a very arrogant way, just look at the wording, because someone used a incompatible word. Yet, the experiments gave a result; but he doesn't like that, and instead of using arguments he used ridicule, which doesn't show any credibility.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Questions about Nasa's space drive answered
by idlewords on Thursday August 07, 2014 @03:12PM
(#8149542)
If you find his tone objectionable, try to look past it. Baez is a fellow worth listening to. He makes a number of substantive arguments why this looks and smells like crank science (for example, the contradictory statements about whether the experiment was done in a vacuum). It's perfectly legitimate of him to point out some social cues that you would not expect from a serious scientist making this kind of claim.
The faster-than-light neutrino experiment gave a result, too, but in these cases the onus is massively on the people making the wild claims, and rightly so.
Re:Questions about Nasa's space drive answered
by TTPrograms on Thursday August 07, 2014 @04:31PM
(#8149973)
The wording used indicates that the writers have no understanding of the current state of the field, which is extremely highly correlated with crackpottery in physics. It's not a comment on the experiment, it's a comment on the fact that the hand-wavy theoretical explanation doesn't pass the sniff test to anyone who's taken QFT.