I've got mote sensors in every room in my house, including the hall. When my kids leave the front door open in winter for a few minutes, as kids tend to do, I can see the temperature in the hall dive on the graphs. But close the door again, and the temperature is right back up very close to where it started in just a few minutes - even when the heating is off.
Thermal density (specific heat) of air is going to be ~1000x less than that of solid objects.
The specific heat of gypsum (the primary constituent of drywall) is 1.09 kJ/kg.K
For dry air it's 1.0 kJ/kg.K
Air's density is 1.225 kg/m3.
A 6m x 9m x 2.3m (20' x 30' x 7.5') room has a volume of about 130m^3, so a 10% exchange would be 13m^3, or 16kg.
That's about 15 kJ of heat energy per degree C, or roughly 0.0004 liter (0.0001 gallon) of heating oil equivalent.
The drywall would be (in feet) 20x7.5x2 + 30x7.5x2 + 20x30 ft^2 (I'll assume the floor is some perfect insulator for now, and that the room has no doorways), and 1/2 inch thick, or 1.6 m^3. That's about 3600 kg of gypsum, which has a heat capacity of about 4000 kJ per degree C, or about 0.1 liter (0.027 gallons) of heating oil equivalent.
If I'm doing my maths right.
Sources:
Specific heat of gypsum: http://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/specific-heat-solids-d_154...
Specific heat of dry air: http://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/air-specific-heat-capacity...
Density of gypsum: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gypsum
In winter in particular, the rate of through-roof air leaks is also greater when temperatures are warmer due to the stack effect. The author is completely wrong on this front - it's far better to let your house cool down and then re-heat.
The only time this isn't true is if you have a two-mechanism heating system such as a heat pump with resistance heat backup, where a large temperature swing invokes the more expensive resistance heater. The author doesn't.
We adopted the fan always on with scheduled temperature adjustment here at our office, it is more comfortable for sure and less dusty. I do not know if it affected energy costs. When I tried this at home it was more comfortable but my electric bill went up by ~$20
Your #3 point strikes be as fairly valid: large electric motors do impose a very high load, and the current draw could be harmful to the motor (and switching / control circuits), while the imposed load might also be hard on other equipment. I doubt the energy usage argument (for cycling the motors off) really carries much weight, and it should be possible to idle such systems at low power. For most commercial buildings, you've got systems for heating, chilling, and air handling which are pretty much all operating simultaneously: you have a need for hot and cold air in different places, there are mixers which will deliver what's needed where it's needed (at least in theory), and the fans blow all the time.
Though I've only a pretty glancing familiarity with HVAC in general, not particularly my area of expertise.
A new motor will cost hundreds of dollars, more so if the blower and fan cage are a single assembly. You'll need to amortize that cost into your comfort level.
It will also quit at the least convenient time, following a combination of Tuttle's and Murphy's Laws. Again, ask me how I know this.
Starting a motor is not something you do lightly for bigger motors (but big like a subway or a car) but I doubt they're that heavy for it to be a big concern.
My bet is that it'll spend the starting power in around 5s of running, tops.
In my limited experience the run/start capacitors fail more often than the motor itself.
A 10 percent increase over atmospheric pressure might not seem like that much, but it's enough to notice, and would probably be uncomfortable. It's like being under 1 meter of water. It's also enough to break large windows.
This is, by the way, why hard drives have filtered air holes rather than being completely sealed.
No, the ideal structure should minimize heat loss from air exchange.
I'm not fully up on my air exchange rates, but it's fairly typical for ranges to be in the 4-20 range, that is, the interior air is exchanged with the exterior 4-20x per hour.
In my Thorsten Chlupp references elsewhere you'll find he makes extensive references to heat exchangers which minimize thermal losses. He does this by a twofold process for his Fairbanks, AK, homes: entering air is routed first through the ground where it's heated from very cold ambient temperatures of as low as -40C / -40F to a temperature closer to freezing (~0F). It's then passed through a heat exchange where the exiting warm air transfers much of its heat to the entering cold air.
The purpose of tightly sealed windows and other possibly entry/exit points isn't to eliminate air exchange so much as to control it: you want air entering and exiting through your designated ventilation systems and transferring heat properly, not traversing the envelope arbitrarily.
See:
Chlupp discussing this issue: http://www.greenbuildingadvisor.com/community/forum/general-...
http://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/air-change-rate-room-d_867...
Another way of putting it: A well-designed structure should minimize random, unintentional air exchange, but provide sufficient deliberately-engineered ventilation to keep the air and people happy. For efficiency, that ventilation should go through a heat recovery ventilator (HRV) or energy recovery ventilator (ERV) as appropriate to the climate and budget. (An energy recovery ventilator also exchanges moisture).
Beyond Chlupp, Lstiburek is a great engineer and writer on these topics.
With regard to letting a house cool down at night, that's impossible. If you heat a quantity of air from 273 K to 300 K at constant volume, the pressure increases from 1 atm to 1.1 atm. That may not sound like much, but it's better expressed as a pressure differential of 10 kilonewtons per square meter, and the surface area of your house is such that it could severely damage the walls and blow the door open -- popping it like a balloon.
(The fundamental mathematical error made by those who minimize this effect is ignoring the surface area of the building)
There was an article about this in the American Journal of Physics [1, 2] a couple years back, and the authors calculated that heating a room from 273K to 300K (32F to 80F) causes it to expel about 10 percent of the air inside it.
Somewhat surprisingly, the authors don't comment on how relevant this is to the question of when to turn your heater off. The fact that allowing a room to cool draws in cold air from the outside means that the practice is worse than you would naively think, but I don't know when if ever that actually suggests leaving the heater on a constant setting. I'd be very curious to see someone extend the calculation to give an answer.
[1] http://scitation.aip.org/content/aapt/journal/ajp/79/1/10.11...
[2] http://www.stat.physik.uni-potsdam.de/~pikovsky/teaching/stu... [PDF]