One interesting "hack" I would see clients do regularly as owner/employees, they would minimize their own salary to avoid payroll taxes, maximizing their distributions (distributions are not subject to payroll taxes). Unfortunately for them the IRS accounts for this hack, and if an IRS audit finds the salary isn't reasonable then those amounts will be subject to payroll, social security, medicare, potentially higher income tax, and moving forward affordable care act taxes plus penalties and interest. I personally hate this because there is no bright line rule as to what a reasonable salary is subjecting all business owners to the mercy of the IRS.
I am surprised this would happen to a YC company, not that YC is in anyway responsible, but I figured YC would be in a position to offer various business services (payroll, legal, tax, insurance, ect...) at extremely low cost. For example, I personally solicited YC and offered to provide Delaware incorporation/registered agent/annual compliance services to any YC companies at a discount which without the discount is already cheaper than legalzoom.
It works fine and is very common for small businesses in the UK. I guess this goes to show how contextual accounting advice can be.
On that note, I'll add that I'm ever so glad that in all my interactions with them HMRC have been polite, friendly, supportive, helpful and nothing like the abusive business murderers that the IRS appear to aim to be - even when I fucked something up that was obviously my fault. I don't understand why the IRS feels that they need to be such assholes about everything. They should see their job as what it is: an essential part of the infrastructure that supports the economy and, indirectly, supports businesses. Their role should be to make business easier, not harder.
I say this as someone who once had a pretty decent unexpected 5-figure liability that I had to work out with them.
I also don't feel like zealous enforcement of unremitted payroll tax is particularly abusive, since that's essentially describing companies stealing from their employees.
I had a run in with the labor department at my first company. I wouldn't exactly call them jerks (or nice) but I was able to get them to cut in half a 5 figure amount they assessed me (a lawsuit was filed) by having a personal meeting with the local office head. Without an attorney. After I cut the deal I then said "oh one more thing can I have 5 years to pay this back?". And he agreed (I didn't need the 5 years, it wasn't a large amount, but I thought why not?)
From what you describe, they sound much like HMRC.
And yes, withholding payroll tax (or VAT) and not passing it on to the government is pretty crappy. HMRC is typically understanding if this is a few months or even a year down the line and they think the business will be able to pay up - they frequently agree payment plans for such things - but three years without noticing kinda takes the piss.
However the US government wants you to also pay Social Security and Medicare tax, which you only pay on employment income. Therefore they force you to take a "reasonable"[1] salary from the company. Everything else left in the company's account at the end of the year is your non-employment income.
It avoids double taxation. It doesn't put you in a lower tax bracket.
1. Reasonable is determined by them.
For people in our industry, it's hard to see a definition of "reasonable" that would be financially beneficial. You start a tech company. You pull $100k out every year, putting you right smack in the middle of the income distribution for experienced tech people. But because of a loophole, you get to reclassify $50k of that $100k as a distribution, and not pay FICA on it. To support that (sorry) scam, you claim $50k is your "reasonable" salary --- putting you way on the low side of the industry. How convenient.
People obviously do it and get away with it. I'm glad it's an audit flag.
I operate as an s-corp and pay myself a reasonable salary, matching that of the salary I could get in the current job market in the area I live in. Anything I clear above this is only taxed with my regular taxes.
If I was running a C-Corp instead of an S-Corp, I'd get my $100k salary, and any extra would have been taxed at the 30% corporate rate when it was taken in, then the 20% capital gains when it's distributed to me as profit.
I don't know. What salary would you take for your honest-to-god dream job?
Many people will take a pay cut for their dream job, but very few are willing to be exploited in the process.
If a company owner is taking a very low salary in order to maximise company profit (and minimise tax) then they (as an employer) are exploiting themselves (as an employee) to do so.
Is there some difference between the type of corporation which makes it acceptable, or could the IRS potentially go after all of those individuals?
If the business is not doing well you can negotiate that down to ridiculously low levels provided you do not borrow from the company at the same time. That last bit is the bit that bites, many business owners already have a line of credit with their company from the founding days and they'd have to pay that back before they can reduce their salary.
On the whole that arrangement works well though, and the one time that I needed it I found that the tax people were very much understanding of the situation and offered a few suggestions that helped making things easier.
If all government institutions were as reasonable as the tax office in my dealings with them this would be a much better country.
That is the floor, it's not a 'bright line'. If the field of that particular business the 'usual salary' is higher, you have to pay yourself that, and you're at the mercy of the tax office in the same way, because they decide what is the 'usual salary'. Also, a director is not allowed to pay themselves less than their employees, for example.
That said, it is true that it is fairly easy to get into contact with an inspector and get advice on how to proceed.
http://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc751.html
So people doing high value software type consulting are probably playing games if they take that much compensation but oops on fully paying those particular taxes.
I would assume that companies like Apple and Facebook have competent tax teams that make sure their obligations are fulfilled, even if that means paying payroll taxes on a portion of the stock-based compensation to their executives.
What they report to the IRS and what they show on financials could be 2 totally different things. Entirely possible that they are paying taxes on a higher salary.
Equity constitutes towards almost 99 percent of an exec's salary. There are short term equity plans and long term equity plans. The equity payouts are generally in millions.
Companies have to release a DEF14A (30-40 pages) each year to show Shareholder's how much the Top5 Execs were paid each year.
My experience over time with many business people has shown that since we are not talking about a criminal action but an action that will result in only penalties, interest etc. it is probably a chance worth taking.
This is a frequent occurrence in business in other areas. You have to take your chances and you determine the chances that you take by looking at your comfort level (which is different for everyone) with the potential downside and probability of that downside happening.
Moving in and out of W-2/Corp-to-corp status many years ago, we set some consultants up on W-2. Then we changed up the mix, went back to just me, and I went on W-2 with another consulting firm for a while.
Got a letter from the state tax guys. Even though nothing was owed, we were supposed to file forms with all zeroes on them. There was a fine, yadda yadda.
Unfortunately, logic, reason, and common sense are not a reliable guide here.
Yep. I recently got a Texas sales tax certificate for my unincorporated side business. Even though I am not doing anything yet, because I have the certificate every quarter I have to log in to a state website and check a box that says I had no sales. Not doing to on time will cost me $500 per incident (I think).
However, are you sure that this doesn't work? The B of A system I am using (in California) calculates payroll taxes, and then even lets you submit them electronically. It also nags me constantly for forms I am supposed to submit to both CA and the US IRS.
There are actually all sorts of gotchas in business that happen as a result of some assumption that you make as far as a process being carried out that never has happened. Using BofA wasn't the sole problem here it was being asleep at the switch and not checking that something had actually happened that didn't.
When I pay my taxes (various real estate, business, personal etc.) I typically will actually look for and printout the cancelled check from the bank showing that the check actually arrived at the destination and was deposited.
The example I would use is the long standing thought in backups that you need to actually test your backups, [1] and not assume that they will work when you need them.
[1] For a certain Mac that I am backing up I just bought, for example, 2 - 3tb hard disks. One will be offsite, one will be onsite. One will be a disk clone (super duper) one will be done by Apple's time machine. Also, the two different 3tb disk were purchased from two different vendors. One is WD and is Seagate. [2] I will periodically test both backups to make sure I can boot from either if needed. This isn't for super critical data but for a large collection of photos and videos. (And there are more than one clone of the data for that matter).
[2] Theory being that buying 2 of the exact same 3 tb's (at the same exact time) could come from the same batch and be defective.
No matter how small your business you should at least have a general ledger and a liquidity forecast running 6 months to a year into the future.
Really good point. As it happens one day recently I questioned my wife why our personal account had so much money in it.
It turned out that she had transferred her money into it that should have went into another account.
This was after correcting problems where she had payed some personal bills out of our account because the bank bill paying "default" for her was set to our joint account rather than her own account.
So she switched it so default bill payment now = her account. So now I have a different problem. She pays our bills out of her account. Which (in addition to the above mentioned wrong deposit) has created even more havoc.
Don't you think the ease with which you can get into this kind of trouble (which may not be dischargeable in bankruptcy, and which may IIRC become a criminal matter) should factor into the "business friendless" score of the US? In every other tax regime I'm familiar with (several European and the Israeli one), everything which is not outright fraud gets you no more than a small fine.
Although Internal Revenue Code Section 6672 includes officers, partners, and
employees, it does not exclude other individuals or firms that that can be
held liable. The IRS will first try to recover payment from the responsible
persons with the most liquid assets, but will also concurrently hold as many
people as possible liable, each with joint and several liability for this
100% penalty. There is no presumption of innocence in trust fund tax
situations. In Skouras v. United States, the court determined the assessment
on a responsible party is presumptively correct and issues relating to
willfulness could be resolved at the summary judgment level. The individual
has the burden of disproving by a preponderance of the evidence, the
existence of one or both of the elements that is willfulness or
responsibility. [1]
here [1] are some interesting horror stories: Aside from the persons normally thought of as being responsible for these
taxes (CEO, CFO, President, Secretary, Treasurer, partner), the courts have
given fairly wide latitude as to which entities or individuals the IRS can
assign responsibility to. In 1987, the United States Supreme Court held that
the third party liability for trust fund taxes was affirmed against a lender
who paid employees’ wages with the knowledge the firm did not intend or
would not be able to make timely deposits of the trust fund taxes. In 1985
the courts found that a lawyer, who had power of attorney from the owner to
operate a car dealership, was found liable for the 100% penalty. In another
case the IRS determined that workers were incorrectly classified as
independent contractors and assessed the 100% penalty to the principals of
the firm. In a 1984 Revenue Ruling, the IRS stated that a volunteer member
of a board of trustees for a charitable organization can be held liable for
the 6672 penalty. In 1978 the United States Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals
determined that a general contractor was responsible for the trust fund
taxes not remitted by a subcontractor. An accounting firm was held liable as
a responsible party because it had failed to remit a client’s trust fund
taxes and paid creditors other than the Internal Revenue Service. The IRS
deemed the friend of a business owner responsible because he paid some
utility bills for the company, extended loans or pledged collateral on loans
to the company.
Imagine the shock when the IRS levied the Individual Retirement Account
(“IRA”) account of an officer of an S corporation and then included the
proceeds of the levied funds in the taxpayer’s Adjusted Gross Income for the
purpose of determining his earned income. The IRS used the constructive
receipt doctrine to conclude the amount levied from an IRA was a
disbursement – it had to be included as income. The taxpayer was further
refrained from deducting it as a pass through loss or a necessary business
expense. This is just a sampling of the many cases involving withholding tax
liability and the long arm reach of the IRS’ “responsible party” strategy. [1]
Like I said -- you can pretty fairly characterize this as, "Fuck you, pay me." Where I to own a business, I would strongly consider creating segregated accounts to hold the funds owed to the government. In fact, it would be nice if I could create a way to just pay the government every other week along with payroll so I would have no owed-to-the-government funds on hand to create temptation...[1] http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/Delivery.cfm/SSRN_ID2306636_code...
It works just like a bank account (except you can't withdraw money from it). They have an online service where you can check the tax account's status and activity, so it's easy to keep it in balance.
This eliminates the need to retain any money that is actually owed to the government. When you pay an employee, you can pay the withheld tax and social security fees at the same time into the tax account.
Early on in the days of the Internet, I would actually call up spammers and try to help them understand why they should stop. 80% of the people were confused small businesspeople who were glad somebody gave them the straight scoop. 20% were weasels who would say or do anything as long as it got them what they wanted.
After a few decades of bullshit excuses from irredeemable idiots, I would also end up in the "fuck you, pay me" category. Because nothing short of being as inevitable as death would be enough to get inveterate weasels to actually pay, and nobody wants to be jerked around by weasels.
It sucks for the rest of us, though, because it turns reasonable mistakes like this into land mines.
If you're not saying yes to one of those, then I'm not seeing what category applies other than "reasonable mistake". I agree it's a noob mistake, but a lot of businesses are started by noobs.
Given the rest of the story and his replies, I'm also inclined to believe that the mistake was ultimately due to lying to himself about the importance of bookkeeping and how fast funds should have been spent. But even absent that, "unreasonable" is a totally reasonable word for this.
It is not unusual for new or small businesses to just wing it on accounting for a while and then hire an accountant who has to tidy things up. (If you don't believe me, ask any small business accountant; my pals have story after story like this.) If we take him at his word, him thinking that the payroll service was handling the withholding is also reasonable. And him assuming everything was jake unless somebody was yelling at him is not just reasonable but typical of first-time entrepreneurs. The main unusual thing here is the scope of error and consequences, but startups are all about rapid increase in size, so that's not unusual in context.
Of course, this could also be fraud: he could have known for years that he wasn't paying withholding, hoping to make it up later. It could be that he actively avoided thinking it through or was willfully careless, which would make it negligence. But as he presents it, it's a reasonable mistake. You can see more about exactly what this means if you look in legal sources for "mistake of fact".
That said, I think your skepticism about his story is reasonable. That his partners have both quit after losing confidence in him would make me unsurprised if this turned out to be fraud, not just an honest but titanically stupid mistake.
The fee is around $40 per month (per employee, I suspect) and it is money well spent. There are pains associated with the service - the reporting is not entirely transparent, and when things go wrong with the automated systems I have gotten odd letters from my tax authorities which needed to be turned into support tickets (which were then handled promptly). But I would never use anything less than a payroll service. If my payroll gets more complex I might upgrade to a bookkeeper with well-documented payroll experience (at a cost which would, I suspect, be considerably higher than $40 a month), but I'd never try to do payroll myself, for reasons which are amply attested in this thread.
Also, accountants. +1 for accountants.
The thing to do is to use separate accounts for reserves like these and to pay directly into the coffers of the tax man, lest the party that you do business with unexpectedly goes bust (they do) and you end up being liable again for the same amount of tax that you already paid to the payroll company. Don't for one second think that you're off the hook because you paid the payroll taxes to some other company.
The best arrangement is where they tell you exactly what is to be reserved and when it is due and you do the payments. That's how I've been doing it and it works flawless, never a problem (so far!).
As an extra bonus, you get to check the amount against the last couple of payments you made and you'll spot any big fluctuations before things get out of hand.
(segregated accounts per client, accounts only usable for remittance of the salaries or taxes with the payroll company then taking out its slice when everything else has been done?)
I remember the Accupay affair and that took a lot of employers by surprise, and even though 'best common practice in the US' may be that payroll firms are the norm, at least in that particular case the culprit was definitely the payroll company and not any one of their multitude of clients. And there were strong indications that Accupay was not the only company that pulled that particular stunt.
All of the companies affected were held liable and had to pay (again).
If that's the kind of firm you're talking about, I agree. Don't use tiny fly-by-night payroll firms. Just use SurePayroll or someone like them.
I'm serious: that's a good point you have. When I said "the norm is to use a payroll firm", I should have said "big payroll firm". There are a lot of little firms out there, and I wouldn't feel safe using them either.
Having a ton of friends in the US means that sometimes I get requests if I can help someone out on short notice, in that particular case there wasn't anything I could do. (I was relatively short on cash at the time but even if that had not been the case I probably would not have stepped in.)
Yes, dealing with the tax authorities directly is usually more complicated (might be simpler for a sole proprietor/small number of employees)
This is known as "borrowing against payroll tax" and is pretty much universally known as a terrible idea! It does happen, though and a business might be dangerously low on cash, but has big amount coming in (from a consulting job, investment, etc). It's just very risky because if you get yourself into a position where you can't pay the bill, then you will be screwed just like one of those companies you mention.
But - if you just simply use a payroll service and always pay the withholdings without fail then you won't have that temptation and won't get yourself into trouble. No need to try to hide your money or something so the IRS can't get it.
The smart thing to do is just withhold the tax with each paycheck. But, if you're a small business you do have until the end of the quarter to come up with the money. As I said, it's risky and generally a terrible idea. I was just explaining how companies come to find themselves in this position.
What's worse, minor versions of this mistake turn out to be easy to make; I've seen (much smaller, much more easily fixed) incidents in multiple companies with things like state taxes and unemployment insurance. So: you can't assume this is a mistake that won't happen to you.
Without making any value judgements about the operations of this particular company, one valuable lesson from the post is: do not ever use the Bank of America Payroll feature.
Unremitted payroll taxes can come with a one hundred percent penalty, and you can be liable for that penalty even if you had no knowledge of the failure to remit. Payroll tax screwups are the scary story big startups tell to baby startups at bedtime. Shudder.