News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mistakes You Should Never Make by tptacek on Thursday July 24, 2014 @01:55PM (#8081126)
It's a hack, and it's also unfair. S-corp company owners get to inhabit a very small part of the economy that, due to a loophole, gets a dial that turns some of their liquid compensation from "salary" to "investment income". That's baloney. I'm glad it's an audit flag.
Re:Mistakes You Should Never Make by swombat on Thursday July 24, 2014 @03:16PM (#8081553)
It's not much of a problem in the UK. A great many of our clients (and ourselves) use the standard dividends + minimum wage method of paying themselves - that is, the ones who own their businesses, i.e. have not taken funding. HMRC accepts this method as a way for business owners to minimise their taxes. As I recall, the argument is something along the lines of "I am paying myself a salary for the basic director duties but effectively working for free on the company day to day, and collecting parts of the earnings as an owner."

It works fine and is very common for small businesses in the UK. I guess this goes to show how contextual accounting advice can be.

On that note, I'll add that I'm ever so glad that in all my interactions with them HMRC have been polite, friendly, supportive, helpful and nothing like the abusive business murderers that the IRS appear to aim to be - even when I fucked something up that was obviously my fault. I don't understand why the IRS feels that they need to be such assholes about everything. They should see their job as what it is: an essential part of the infrastructure that supports the economy and, indirectly, supports businesses. Their role should be to make business easier, not harder.

Re:Mistakes You Should Never Make by tptacek on Thursday July 24, 2014 @03:20PM (#8081576)
I've never had an unpleasant interaction with the IRS. Unlike virtually any other creditor I've ever dealt with, the people I've talked to who actually work for the IRS have been courteous and helpful. I'm not the only person who's said this. The IRS has acquired a personalized reputation for being jerks, not unlike that of Customs, but which totally doesn't square with how the agency actually acts.

I say this as someone who once had a pretty decent unexpected 5-figure liability that I had to work out with them.

I also don't feel like zealous enforcement of unremitted payroll tax is particularly abusive, since that's essentially describing companies stealing from their employees.

Re:Mistakes You Should Never Make by larrys on Thursday July 24, 2014 @04:54PM (#8082130)
I think I'm a bit older than you. They were "jerks" back when I started in business. But things have changed as you've pointed out.

I had a run in with the labor department at my first company. I wouldn't exactly call them jerks (or nice) but I was able to get them to cut in half a 5 figure amount they assessed me (a lawsuit was filed) by having a personal meeting with the local office head. Without an attorney. After I cut the deal I then said "oh one more thing can I have 5 years to pay this back?". And he agreed (I didn't need the 5 years, it wasn't a large amount, but I thought why not?)

Re:Mistakes You Should Never Make by swombat on Thursday July 24, 2014 @03:28PM (#8081614)
Well, that's good to hear! This reputation the IRS has makes me worried about the idea of some day operating in the US. It's good to know that they actually employ human beings rather than attack dogs.

From what you describe, they sound much like HMRC.

And yes, withholding payroll tax (or VAT) and not passing it on to the government is pretty crappy. HMRC is typically understanding if this is a few months or even a year down the line and they think the business will be able to pay up - they frequently agree payment plans for such things - but three years without noticing kinda takes the piss.

Re:Mistakes You Should Never Make by mikeash on Friday July 25, 2014 @09:15PM (#8088472)
I get the impression (and I could be woefully wrong) that the IRS, kind of like the USPS, has an awful reputation that was justified some decades ago, has turned it around because of that awful reputation, but inertia means the reputation persists long after the underlying reasons have been remedied.
Re:Mistakes You Should Never Make by bravo22 on Thursday July 24, 2014 @03:18PM (#8081566)
Actually as an S-Corp owner all the corporate income is taxed as REGULAR INCOME. It doesn't become a capital gains tax -- which is what I assume you mean by investment income.

However the US government wants you to also pay Social Security and Medicare tax, which you only pay on employment income. Therefore they force you to take a "reasonable"[1] salary from the company. Everything else left in the company's account at the end of the year is your non-employment income.

It avoids double taxation. It doesn't put you in a lower tax bracket.

1. Reasonable is determined by them.

Re:Mistakes You Should Never Make by tptacek on Thursday July 24, 2014 @03:26PM (#8081604)
It's taxed as regular income, but the premise under which it's exempt from the payroll taxes every other worker has to pay is that it's not normal income, but rather the return from an investment in the company.

For people in our industry, it's hard to see a definition of "reasonable" that would be financially beneficial. You start a tech company. You pull $100k out every year, putting you right smack in the middle of the income distribution for experienced tech people. But because of a loophole, you get to reclassify $50k of that $100k as a distribution, and not pay FICA on it. To support that (sorry) scam, you claim $50k is your "reasonable" salary --- putting you way on the low side of the industry. How convenient.

People obviously do it and get away with it. I'm glad it's an audit flag.

Re:Mistakes You Should Never Make by cullenking on Thursday July 24, 2014 @04:24PM (#8081973)
Sure, but you just mentioned an unreasonable salary. If the median is $100k, then that's reasonable, and the person only gets to avoid SS and medicare on any additional profit.

I operate as an s-corp and pay myself a reasonable salary, matching that of the salary I could get in the current job market in the area I live in. Anything I clear above this is only taxed with my regular taxes.

If I was running a C-Corp instead of an S-Corp, I'd get my $100k salary, and any extra would have been taxed at the 30% corporate rate when it was taken in, then the 20% capital gains when it's distributed to me as profit.

Re:Mistakes You Should Never Make by bravo22 on Thursday July 24, 2014 @05:54PM (#8082517)
Exactly. You could pull in sometimes 250-500K as a consulting company, specially if you outsource some aspects of projects. S-Corp is ideal for that.
Re:Mistakes You Should Never Make by tptacek on Thursday July 24, 2014 @06:04PM (#8082573)
The FICA cap is 115k.
Re:Mistakes You Should Never Make by cullenking on Thursday July 24, 2014 @07:52PM (#8083030)
The SS side of FICA is 115k. Medicare has no limit and is at 1.45%
Re:Mistakes You Should Never Make by jasonwocky on Thursday July 24, 2014 @08:15PM (#8083127)
> To support that (sorry) scam, you claim $50k is your "reasonable" salary --- putting you way on the low side of the industry. How convenient.

I don't know. What salary would you take for your honest-to-god dream job?

Re:Mistakes You Should Never Make by timv on Thursday July 24, 2014 @10:54PM (#8083571)
Is your "dream job" one where you are paid a pittance while the company owner makes a tidy profit from your endeavours?

Many people will take a pay cut for their dream job, but very few are willing to be exploited in the process.

If a company owner is taking a very low salary in order to maximise company profit (and minimise tax) then they (as an employer) are exploiting themselves (as an employee) to do so.

Re:Mistakes You Should Never Make by mikeash on Friday July 25, 2014 @09:19PM (#8088489)
I might take a $50,000 salary to fly gliders all day. But no matter how nice of a job it is, I'm not going to take a $50,000 salary to program computers all day, because I can get a job in that field that's only marginally less nice and pays way more.