I bet they would have been more successful with less money. Money gives you freedom(to start over, to feature creep, to bikeshed, to grow faster than you can manage, etc) and security (which makes you less "hungry" and desperate).
I thought long and hard before posting this, because obviously hindsight is 20/20, but I went back and looked at the product description again and I stand by my opinion. IHMO it was a turkey from the word go.
The worst part is, I can buy 1Password for Mac for $50, and the iOS version is less than $20. Anybody interested in this sort of thing should really check out the alternatives already!
1. The actual project.
2. The rewards doled out to supporters of the project.
The Kickstarter rules are very clear about the following things: 1. The rewards are a contract. If you fail to deliver
the rewards on whose terms the backers supported
you, you're legally liable.
2. The rewards may be delayed, as long as regular
communication about the actual progress happens.
Thus the project itself can fail, as long as you make sure the rewards are given out.The fact that most project are confident/stupid enough to offer rewards that can only become reality if the project succeeds has muddled this reality in the mind of the average person, but the rules and legal realities are crystal-clear.
Example: $100 Dollar Level, tshirt + coupon for discount on items that we sell, available for use on target completion date (which just happens to be projected cost of baseline project item)?
Edit:
Found the answer...
> Discounts, coupons and gift certificates - Offering a reward at a lower price than what it may cost post Kickstarter is fine, but a future discount or coupon as reward is prohibited. Additionally, vouchers in exchange for a particular item (a meal, a book, etc.) are fine, but monetary gift certificates are prohibited.
A little disappointing, but I can understand why they'd take this stance. (Likely because of money transmitter laws.)
(It's possible you could still phrase it as equivalencies, eg, "one X, OR two Y, subject to availability")
However the rules state one thing clearly ( https://www.kickstarter.com/rules ):
Projects must be honest and clearly presented.
So i suspect that, as long as it is made abundantly clear that the coupons might end up as neat, but otherwise worthless souvenirs, it'd be legit.(You could even make mod versions with "failed" on them after the fact, and use the coupons to buy those.)
Naturally, you should have giant, red, all caps letters explaining you're funding development, and might never accomplish the project successfully. Coupons only cover items posted for sale in the store, etc etc.
I'm mostly just curious about it as a legal method to give the reward at a tier without promising the exact reward.
(Side note: is this also an end-run around the multipack rule?)
The problem here is that as much as kickstarter wants project owners to be clear about the risks, they themselves don't want to do anything site-wide that may reduce overall revenue. At some point they'll realize they can't have the cake and eat it too.
The reality of course is that projects do fail and there may be breathless rhetoric about lawsuits and such on discussion boards but there's typically no money to be had and the online temper tantrums don't go anywhere. So the Kickstarter requirement doesn't have any real teeth.
VCs back huge numbers of companies and expect most of them to fail, hoping that the few which succeed make back enough money to compensate for all the failures. Kickstarter backers pay money in exchange for a specific product of value roughly equivalent to the amount they paid. We can't expect people who back Kickstarter projects to accept VC-level failure rates because Kickstarters simply don't - and can't - give enough back when they succeed to make up for the failures.
The only differences between VC-invested projects and Kickstarter projects is that no one does due diligence on Kickstarter projects. Kickstarter backers should expect VC-level failure rates as a lower bound.
True, but it's even worse than that. VC funded companies sometimes have an upside. E.g. Oculus Rift got over $2 billion from Facebook. The Kickstarter "backers" received exactly zero percent of that upside.
(I know, it's rhetorical. VCs get a lot more information and have a lot more experience than Kickstarter backers.)
edit: I accept that that's entirely possible, I just think it's a better subject for a academic study than for a rule of thumb.
Another difference is a lot of Kickstarter projects are well below the scale that VCs would notice, and are offered by businesses that are going concerns as a way of mitigating risk -- there not all startup firms using Kickstarter as an alternative (or supplement) to VC funding.
Then they're doing it wrong. Supporting a project on Kickstarter is a donation. A vote of confidence. That people are using it as a store and a ridiculously high-risk low-return investment vehicle is completely absurd. The blame should probably be put on Kickstarter themselves for what seems to be a major failure to establish the right expectations.
Look at r/shutupandtakemymoney. Of the 25 posts on the first page right now, 11 are either kickstarter or indiegogo. Is it Kickstarter and Indiegogo's fault that individuals are using that form of venue to market and sell a product that doesn't exist yet? Is it reddit's? Or, is it the creator's fault for submitting the link?
I pose that it is inevitable that these sort of sites are used this way. People want to market their crowd funding opportunity to enable their company to get off the ground. It is easier to market a future product compared to a donation, so creators and marketers are going that route.
It actually is a promise. The Kickstarter terms of service require successfully funded projects to deliver the rewards that backers have paid for. If a project can't guarantee that they can deliver a finished hardware product, they shouldn't offer it as a reward.
Shouldn't that be:
If a project can't guarantee that they can deliver a finished hardware product if the project is successful, they shouldn't offer it as a reward.
Otherwise surely no project can offer the product as a reward to backers as success is never guaranteed.
Project Creators are required to fulfill all rewards of their successful fundraising campaigns or refund any Backer whose reward they do not or cannot fulfill.
from:
https://www.kickstarter.com/terms-of-use
So it talks about the fundraising succeeding, not the project.
But it also says that is one of the terms of the contract created between the project and backer, don't pester Kickstarter about it.
In their terms Kickstarter make statements suggesting it is a funding program but they also say in their "Acceptance of Terms" part that any policy expounded on the site is incorporated by reference. Kickstarter state on their /learn page for example "Kickstarter is a vibrant community of people working together to bring new things to life." making it clear that success on Kickstarter is bringing a making project to fruition. It _doesn't_ say "Kickstarter is a way to acquire funding", so that's not the goal of a Kickstarter project and thus not the measure of success.
To reiterate this point, in the FAQ accountability section it says:
> "On Kickstarter, backers (you!) ultimately decide the validity and worthiness of a project by whether they decide to fund it." //
Again highlighting that projects are not funding, projects are encouraged with funding.
There's little about unsuccessful projects, some details about how they're swept under the rug, but there is this in the FAQs:
> "If the problems are severe enough that the creator can't fulfill their project, creators need to find a resolution. Steps could include offering refunds, detailing exactly how funds were used, and other actions to satisfy backers." //
See that "could", why not "must"? Why not "creators are required by their assent to our contract to find a resolution"? It seems Kickstarter consider a report of how funds used to satisfy their requirements.
There is this, https://ksr-assets.s3.amazonaws.com/creator-responsibility.p..., which appears to contradict that FAQ.
[PS I'm not sure I've convinced myself but I do think someone could make this case, possibly make it stick. Kickstarter could tighten up their language in a few places but ultimately they are financially primarily motivated to get as many projects funded as possible whether they are successful or not, funded projects earn them money whilst shipped rewards don't. Kickstarters other motivations aside of course.]
I also wouldn't give money to a Kickstarter project if I thought I cared enough about the money that I would end up chasing it in court (that is, none of this is a practical concern for me personally).
It basically is, or at least a market -- a place where buyers and sellers meet and form contracts and where the sellers get the money from the buyers in exchange for the promise of some specified future delivery.
Sure, some sellers would like to have store-like inducements to the buyers to hand over money, but not store-like obligations to provide the offered goods to the buyers.
> Why is it a shock that Kickstarter projects fail?
Its not a shock when projects fail. Its a breach of contract when people accept money in exchange for a promise of future goods and then fail to deliver the future goods.
Sellers shouldn't be shocked that projects should fail -- and so shouldn't offer rewards that depend on success to be deliverable.
This is actually an excellent point, but...
The reasoning behind this "pre-sale" approach is about the perceived value of the reward. An traditional gift might be acceptable (T-Shirts, etc) but there is something unique about being offered something that's not on the market yet. It makes the customer feel special, something they might be able to brag about if the product is a success.
Something akin to the concept of "Collector Edition" in the game industry.
That will add value to a reward, will attract more customer an in turn increase the chances of a successful campaign (even though successful campaign does not mean successful product).
It is a good way to kickstart a business.
Riskier? Yes. Short sighted? Yes and no (Actually no).
Short term cost is 0 (great), long term cost is your manufacturing cost + distribution cost (ouch).
That doesn't seem right? Actually it is.
You're actually paying for: + User acquisition + Early product validation (Lean Startup) + Momentum + Beta testing for the whole product pipeline and the product itself
I think that as a company it is definitively worth the risk. You have to be able to take risks sometimes in order to be successful.
My 2 cents.
But let's not quibble over what Kickstarter is. There is obviously a lot of value in having some kind of market where people hand over money with the risk of project failure, in order to potentially get a new product that they want to exist built.
How would you create such a marketplace and communicate clearly that that's what it is? I ask because I thought Kickstarter was exactly this, but apparently you don't agree, so I wonder where our difference of opinion stems from..
My view is based on things like Kickstarter's terms of service and contract law.
And the complaints about failed delivery of rewards indicate that it is also consistent with the way many backers see Kickstarter.
Certainly, I can see why each individual project team would like the idea of getting funding without giving up either equity or an obligation to pay money later (as they would in traditional financing) or an obligation to provide product (as they would in a preorder, or in Kickstarters existing terms if they offer the product as a reward), while still using the product as an inducement.
> There is obviously a lot of value in having some kind of market where people hand over money with the risk of project failure, in order to potentially get a new product that they want to exist built.
And Kickstarter can be that without product-as-reward -- after all, if the project is for a product to be offered to the public, people who back the project can "potentially get" the product (contingent on project success) when it is offered to the public.
Competent technical people. The non-technical leaders of for example Google Wave did not really show any apparent competency, leading to a project that has been excitedly received to stall just because someone thought it a good idea to do a closed beta (the closed beta worked for Gmail because the early Gmail users could communicate with any E-mail user, but competent people would have anticipated that this would not work with Wave; they effectively created a super-nerd ghetto, which obviously no sane person wanted to be part of after the beta was over).
One of the problems with this is that our brain tricks us into believing that we're better guessers than other people, because hey, look at all the times we were right in the past! Except we weren't right - it's just our memory deceiving us.
All of this is to say - Google hires extremely smart people. I would really hesitate to call them incompetent, both because what you say was "sure to happen" is a big dose of hindsight, and also because you have no idea what their goals were - for all you know, they took a risk that the project would either stall or become super-successful, so they shot for the moon. That's a legitimate option.
So Kickstarter with product-as-reward makes a lot of sense for going concerns there because they have fairly good ideas what production costs are going to be like and what scale they need to reach to get a product with particular features out.
Its not the sexiest use of Kickstarter, but its probably the most sustainable, and it does enable things that would otherwise be too risky to produce.
I can't see that happening. Though, I'm not sure what if anything has changed since I was discussing this [1] on HN over a year ago.
Every VC backed company, or big company project that fails without any shock has shipped. If a kickstarter campaign ships the product and it falls short of expectations, no matter how short it is, it is ok. But if it says it is all set and done to ship, get the money and don't ship, that is a problem.
Kickstarter should really emphasize "The risk of failure is high, and you stand a good chance of never receiving anything for your money"
Because regular people aren't equipped to evaluate risk and projects go out of their way (often dishonestly, even if understandably) to minimize the perception of risk.
It's a system that takes advantage of suckers. Some folks find that to be okay, but it bothers me even as I consider using it (because of not having any other real choices for funding a game in 2014).
I mean, even if you don't agree with that sentiment, you can see that other do, right?
Why is it a shock that Kickstarter projects fail? No one is shocked when VC backed companies fail, and these projects are just as likely (if not more likely) to fail. There's no more due diligence than watching a video and reading over some text frequently in funding a project.
Even projects with competent people in well funded companies fail all the time and get shut down (see Google Buzz, Google Health, etc). There is no such thing as a promise that things will succeed.
I wish Kickstarter would put big lettering near the 'support' button that says in big red letters, "Kickstarter is not a store"