However the rules state one thing clearly ( https://www.kickstarter.com/rules ):
Projects must be honest and clearly presented.
So i suspect that, as long as it is made abundantly clear that the coupons might end up as neat, but otherwise worthless souvenirs, it'd be legit.(You could even make mod versions with "failed" on them after the fact, and use the coupons to buy those.)
Naturally, you should have giant, red, all caps letters explaining you're funding development, and might never accomplish the project successfully. Coupons only cover items posted for sale in the store, etc etc.
I'm mostly just curious about it as a legal method to give the reward at a tier without promising the exact reward.
(Side note: is this also an end-run around the multipack rule?)
The problem here is that as much as kickstarter wants project owners to be clear about the risks, they themselves don't want to do anything site-wide that may reduce overall revenue. At some point they'll realize they can't have the cake and eat it too.
The reality of course is that projects do fail and there may be breathless rhetoric about lawsuits and such on discussion boards but there's typically no money to be had and the online temper tantrums don't go anywhere. So the Kickstarter requirement doesn't have any real teeth.
Example: $100 Dollar Level, tshirt + coupon for discount on items that we sell, available for use on target completion date (which just happens to be projected cost of baseline project item)?
Edit:
Found the answer...
> Discounts, coupons and gift certificates - Offering a reward at a lower price than what it may cost post Kickstarter is fine, but a future discount or coupon as reward is prohibited. Additionally, vouchers in exchange for a particular item (a meal, a book, etc.) are fine, but monetary gift certificates are prohibited.
A little disappointing, but I can understand why they'd take this stance. (Likely because of money transmitter laws.)
(It's possible you could still phrase it as equivalencies, eg, "one X, OR two Y, subject to availability")