News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Economy by klunger on Monday June 30, 2014 @02:46PM (#7966791)
He just suggested a basic income for everybody.

I just wanted to point this out in case people missed it when skimming.

Re:The Economy by sama on Monday June 30, 2014 @02:56PM (#7966854)
oops, i accidentally published an earlier draft. i added a bit more of my thinking here--my sense is that it would probably lead to less waste than current systems.

i'm also not sure it's the right approach, but i haven't heard any better ideas yet.

Re:The Economy by gautambay on Monday June 30, 2014 @03:08PM (#7966945)
i prefer universal essential services (healthcare, education, etc.) over a guaranteed basic income.

with basic income, you run the risk that the receivers spend it on shiny objects (especially in an economy like ours with rampant consumerism) instead of things that benefit them and their families long-term.

of course, what constitutes "essential services" can be the subject of a lengthy debate.

Re:The Economy by roc on Monday June 30, 2014 @03:51PM (#7967239)
> "i prefer universal essential services (healthcare, education, etc.) over a guaranteed basic income."

If we believe in the market's ability to efficiently find the path forward, identifying "essential services", even if it were possible, is wasteful at best and more likely counter-productive over time.

Twenty years ago we'd have locked in home phone service and missed internet. 10 years ago we might have locked in cell service, but missed mobile data. We'd have propped up "bad" products, at massive profits for the benefactors, for years beyond their relevance, instead of allowing the market to evaluate and react to changing conditions.

And while we might agree that it's logically possible for efficient and effective government to correct mistakes like those, the "money is speech" reality in the US gives such outsized power to lobbying interests that even an optimist has to rate effective "steering" of any definition of "essential services" as "unlikely".

Never mind the basic question of whether it's at all desirable to force a youth from an underprivileged family to "buy" government-guaranteed education, instead of allowing him to spend even a fraction of the equivalent on a laptop, smartphone and developer tools -- or a 3d printer and amazon hosting services. Or even allowing him to look outside the box of lobbiest-approved education providers, and allowing him to "spend" his assistance on developer conferences or workshops or online learning or just moving to another town that has a better local program.

Would some people inevitably spend a guaranteed income poorly? Of course they would. They also sell food stamps for cash -- at 50% of their face value -- to make their bad decisions regardless of what we might prefer.

It isn't worth the cost to try to enforce "essential services" spending at the micro level. It's too rich a target for corporate lobbyists to define approved services at the macro level. And at the economic level, there's little reason to believe it will give us better outcomes.

Re:The Economy by gautambay on Monday June 30, 2014 @04:18PM (#7967437)
Fair points, all.

However, markets fail when there is a misalignment of incentives and/or lack of information/education. I view the government's job primarily as aligning people's incentives with the desired long-term direction.

In India (where I'm from), there have been decades of dole-outs for the poor (especially farmers), but it has failed to create any long-term economic benefits for those communities. On the other hand, education (both for the farmers and their children) has been far more effective in uplifting people out of poverty.

I realize that the average American is more educated and has better access to information that the average Indian farmer. But still, you can be assured that some of that "basic income" will be going into a slot machine.

Perhaps the solution is a basic income with some restrictions / incentives around how to spend it?

Re:The Economy by scarmig on Monday June 30, 2014 @04:53PM (#7967634)
I doubt that the basic income bears much resemblance to the dole-outs for the poor in India. "For the poor" is the kicker: by far the most economically appealing aspect of the basic income is that it's provided to everyone. If it's only provided to a particular type of person, that offers opportunities for corruption, administrative costs, and, most importantly, a very sharp disincentive against improving yourself and working harder, sometimes amounting to implicit marginal tax rates that are higher than 100%.

Another aspect is simplicity of administration. Providing some restrictions is a bit paternalistic, though I wouldn't dismiss it out of hand: for me the biggest issue would be how you can implement that with a minimum of cost, administrative overhead, and opportunities for corruption. And there's a bunch of areas that'd result in vindictive political debate. Sure, slot machines and vodka might be things we'd agree to restrict. But liberal arts MA programs? For-profit colleges? MLM schemes? Online class certificates via Coursera? Internet connectivity? Reddit gold? Gym memberships?

If you doubt that this kind of item by item trench warfare is what would happen, just look at the furor in the USA over something as obviously {good,bad} as providing {cost-effective,immoral} birth control to the insured.

I have difficulty imagining a system where the government picks and chooses what's good and what's bad for people to use that's not rife with corruption, sclerotic from past decisions and bureaucratic rules, and easy to use for the actual citizen it's intended to enable. The value recovered from preventing "bad spending" would almost certainly be outweighed by the cost of policing the billions of purchases that happen every day.

Re:The Economy by gautambay on Monday June 30, 2014 @06:54PM (#7968186)
Valid points on the complexity and the ensuing corruption.

I suspect that as real-time data-gathering becomes cheaper and more prevalent, the costs of policing will become trivial. That's certainly some years away though.

Re:The Economy by ef4 on Monday June 30, 2014 @03:37PM (#7967152)
Ah, the classic paternalistic argument. It's deeply appealing to many people's preconceptions. But a growing body of experimental results call it into question.

When you actually conduct the experiment -- a randomized controlled trial where you give some poor people cash and others in-kind services, the cash group outperforms.

Re:The Economy by matthewmacleod on Monday June 30, 2014 @03:49PM (#7967219)
I'd be interested to see any of the research on this, if you have references. I suspect that in practice it's exceptionally hard to draw realistic conclusions from any such research, simply due to the confounding factor of "the wider social structure of the country".
Re:The Economy by budu3 on Monday June 30, 2014 @04:12PM (#7967395)
NPR had a brilliant episode where they discussed an experiment where money was given to a control group of people on Kenya. http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2013/11/08/243967328/episode-...
Re:The Economy by timr on Monday June 30, 2014 @04:03PM (#7967338)
Re:The Economy by ef4 on Monday June 30, 2014 @05:40PM (#7967901)
Thank you for responding before I could and saving me the link gathering effort.
Re:The Economy by kevinskii on Monday June 30, 2014 @06:01PM (#7968009)
You made a very specific claim:

When you actually conduct the experiment -- a randomized controlled trial where you give some poor people cash and others in-kind services, the cash group outperforms.

None of the above links appear to support it. Please let me know if I'm mistaken, otherwise please do provide a relevant citation. Like many others here, I'm genuinely interested in learning about such a study.

Re:The Economy by gautambay on Monday June 30, 2014 @03:52PM (#7967245)
Very interesting (and certainly plausible)! Could you link to any of the experiments?
Re:The Economy by tg3 on Monday June 30, 2014 @04:15PM (#7967410)
Here is an article giving high level overview of a few of the experiments: https://decorrespondent.nl/541/why-we-should-give-free-money...
Re:The Economy by callmeed on Monday June 30, 2014 @04:35PM (#7967533)
Sources on that?
Re:The Economy by mwilliamson on Monday June 30, 2014 @03:23PM (#7967052)
This article has a few examples of basic income experiments, with encouraging results. For instance, when the town of Dauphin had basic income implemented, hospital visits went down by 8.5%, which suggests real benefit rather than just frivolous spending.

https://decorrespondent.nl/541/why-we-should-give-free-money...

Re:The Economy by VLM on Monday June 30, 2014 @03:39PM (#7967158)
"you run the risk that the receivers spend it on shiny objects"

The problem is, what is a shiny object?

For me it might be going to grad school without a care in the world how I'll feed my kids.

For another it might be a car. Well, that's OK, car sales are imploding on a decade or so scale.

For another, housing. Anytime housing goes up thats trumpeted as an inherent good. It isn't, of course. But no one will say that in public.

Usually "wasted money" is just whatever someone doesn't personally like, its not actually bad. The problem with central planning, including of what everyone will have to invest in, is lack of flexibility.

Re:The Economy by ThomPete on Monday June 30, 2014 @04:20PM (#7967449)
We have that in Denmark and it holds it's own problems.

Personally I believe that a UBI is the way forward for the very simple fact that it always pay off to work and it will remove a huge control system and free those people to do better things with their lives than controlling other people.

Re:The Economy by ahoy on Monday June 30, 2014 @03:58PM (#7967288)
The counter to that is that I understand what services and goods are essential to me better than the government does (or anyone that isn't me, for that matter). If the goal is to do the most good with the least waste, basic income is probably better than a hodgepodge of universal services.

That said, I'm all for either or a combination of approaches. Anything to catch the US up with the rest of the developed world socially.

Re:The Economy by marcosdumay on Monday June 30, 2014 @04:42PM (#7967570)
That. I think a combination is the way to go, for no other reason than the fact that some desirable services have huge scale gains (transportation), and some services have huge positive externalities (health). It would be unwise not to incentive people to use those.
Re:The Economy by enjo on Monday June 30, 2014 @03:18PM (#7967015)
There are a couple ways to view this. By covering "essential services" you really are just guaranteeing a lot of inflation in those sectors (they are now on a fixed minimum income as a group). Some would argue that many of the same cost run-ups we've seen in university education (with government loans and other programs) will affect those essential service sectors in the same way.

One of the benefits of a basic income is that it serves as a really effective wealth redistribution program. It is partly a social safety net, but it's also something that can potentially give the economy as a whole a boost thanks to a lot of spending on the bottom (as opposed to income hoarding at the top).

I'm not sure I agree with those positions. I think I lack enough knowledge of economics to form a good opinion. I have definitely seen both of those arguments made in support of a simple basic income, however.

Re:The Economy by rmc on Monday June 30, 2014 @04:00PM (#7967313)
i prefer universal essential services (healthcare, education, etc.) over a guaranteed basic income.

What about countries in Europe that have that, and yet aren't doing great?

Re:The Economy by jbellis on Monday June 30, 2014 @05:53PM (#7967972)
Some interesting thoughts on better ideas here: http://bleedingheartlibertarians.com/2014/06/why-living-on-t...
Re:The Economy by chillingeffect on Monday June 30, 2014 @03:07PM (#7966934)
> any better ideas yet

Progressive tax on incomes >$1,000,000. This won't slow anyone down except the ultra-wealthy.

As of 2009, it's 236,883 people. That's less than 1 in a thousand. With more income in a single year than most people in the U.S. earn in a lifetime, they'll certainly still be much more than quite comfortable.

Re:The Economy by exelius on Monday June 30, 2014 @03:33PM (#7967119)
Most of the people in this class are able to hire accountants and re-classify much of their income in such a way as to avoid the taxes.

Part of the problem when you start talking about massive tax bills is that the higher the tax, the higher the return on investment from avoiding it. So if you can pay an accountant $500,000 to set up a bunch of shell corporations and trusts as legal tax shelters that will save you $5,000,000, you'll do it in a heartbeat.

Add in Citizens United to the mix and you can see where this is going. If it's suddenly a great return on investment to lobby Congress to introduce a tax loophole, people will do it. The entire premise of modern corporate finance is that if you don't like what a company is doing with your investment, you are free to cash out your investment and invest in something else. That doesn't work with governments; but it doesn't prevent people from trying to apply the same attitudes.

Re:The Economy by at-fates-hands on Monday June 30, 2014 @03:33PM (#7967117)
>>> Progressive tax on incomes >$1,000,000. This won't slow anyone down except the ultra-wealthy.

What do you think happens to anybody, let alone people who are really rich when you continually increase their taxes? They stop spending, they start hiding their money, they it send it to foreign countries, they will find ways around the taxes you're trying to levy against them.

It doesn't matter who you tax, they're going to try and avoid paying taxes regardless. People have this notion that since they're super wealthy, they have money to burn - which is hardly the case. Most people making over $1 million per year live a lifestyle that's congruent to the money they're making. You think those people are thinking , "Aye, it's only 10K more to the governmnet, no big deal?", right?. Hardly. They want to hold onto their money just as much as the next guy.

Re:The Economy by virtue3 on Monday June 30, 2014 @04:44PM (#7967586)
I'm 99% sure rich people don't get rich by "spending money". Just saying.

"Trickle down" is fucking bullshit.

Re:The Economy by sanderjd on Monday June 30, 2014 @03:30PM (#7967091)
Unfortunately, the article isn't very clear about what the problem statement is for which basic income is the proposed solution. But assuming it is something like "people are having trouble participating in the economy, which is a drag on our society's standard of living", I don't see how "increased federal income" is a solution. What do you propose the government do with its newfound wealth to solve these problems? "Tax the rich" might be a decent tactic, but it certainly isn't a good strategy.
Re:The Economy by larrys on Monday June 30, 2014 @03:01PM (#7966897)
I actually missed that because I essentially scanned this.

I didn't know Sam had any particular expertise in economics something that confounds people with pretty deep intellectual understanding and academics. That have been observing things for many many years. It's a black art.

And I tend to pass on anything that starts to mention facts and figures which can be made to achieve any point you want.

I did note that it ended with this of course:

"I think the path from our troubles will involve finding a way for economic growth to continue." Obviously a rising tide lifts all boats. But finding "a good lawyer" (to go all cliche here) is the problem.

Re:The Economy by oniTony on Monday June 30, 2014 @02:54PM (#7966835)
The actual quote was

> In addition to thinking about new sorts of jobs to replace lost jobs that aren’t coming back, we should probably think about things like a basic income.

So not necessary "basic income", and certainly for everyone. The reality is that many of the emerging economies are better (as in "cheaper") able to fulfill low-skill/high-labor positions, and not everyone will be able to transition into higher skill jobs.

Re:The Economy by VLM on Monday June 30, 2014 @03:41PM (#7967174)
Another thing to think about is eventually the higher skill jobs are leaving. There's nothing inherently American about, say, programming, and there's a heck of lot more of "them" than "us".

The only real hope for natives is high skill service jobs perhaps ER doctor.

Re:The Economy by at-fates-hands on Monday June 30, 2014 @03:37PM (#7967155)
I'm wondering at point do we stop relying on the government to provide us with everything we need.

What happens when we have too many unfunded liabilities and the government runs out of money and all the millions of people who suddenly depend on government from everything from medical care, income, employment, and other forms of support?

All you have to do is take a good, hard look at countries like Greece and Argentina for examples to see what happens when countries go bankrupt.

Re:The Economy by marincounty on Monday June 30, 2014 @03:59PM (#7967301)
When the government stops making it illegial, or charging fees for---Living. If Jesus Christ reappeared; what would his first few days look like? He couldn't fish without a license. He couldn't hunt without a license. He couldn't light a fire without a permit. He couldn't sleep unless in a sanctified Homeless Shelter. He would probally get a loitering ticket while preaching to the masses, or worse-- thrown in jail over inciting a riot? So, we live in a society where government regulates pretty much everything we do; until they back off--they need to help the people who can't "work" in their system. (God--please forgive me, I was just trying to make a point. I didn't use your name in vain.)
Re:The Economy by at-fates-hands on Monday June 30, 2014 @07:43PM (#7968385)
I wholeheartedly agree that we need to help those less fortunate, but not in a way that promotes aheavy reliance on the government.

All my Liberal friends conveniently forget that Bill Clinton took millions off of welfare and brought them out of poverty. Not from relying on government, but through incentives and job training.

Interesting to note that this was a bipartisan bill, introduced by a Republican, and heavily endorsed by Clinton himself. And yes, it went through two veto's before getting signed.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personal_Responsibility_and_Wor...

Re:The Economy by wslh on Monday June 30, 2014 @04:04PM (#7967343)
Argentina did pretty well after it defaulted its obligations in 2001 and the commodities prices significantly increased. The issues in Argentina are more related to poor infrastructure (transport, Internet, mobile, financial) and corruption.

There is a saying in Argentina that we should stop stealing for at least two years [and the country will flourish].

Re:The Economy by baddox on Monday June 30, 2014 @03:01PM (#7966894)
What surprising or remarkable about that? Basic income has been an extremely trendy topic lately.
[deleted]
Re:The Economy by MarioSpeedwagon on Monday June 30, 2014 @03:20PM (#7967030)
It also calls Lenin a Leninist and Marx a Marxist. When will the insanity STOP?!!1!
Re:The Economy by johnward on Monday June 30, 2014 @02:50PM (#7966811)
" Personally, I think that current levels of entitlement spending are ok (thought maybe the spending should be distributed differently), and we should probably do more. But I think we need to plan for it. In addition to thinking about new sorts of jobs to replace lost jobs that aren’t coming back, we should probably think about things like a basic income."
Re:The Economy by moblahbl4hblah on Monday June 30, 2014 @02:52PM (#7966821)
A basic income is a great idea...it would also be a good idea to completely remove the profit motive from health care. A social safety net that includes a living wage, guaranteed higher education, and retirement is completely possible if you don't spend so much on defense and intelligence.
Re:The Economy by johnward on Monday June 30, 2014 @02:56PM (#7966856)
I'm no economist but at some point aren't we going to become so productive that there won't be enough need for workers. Are we maybe at that point now? If every single person wanted to work there would not be enough jobs to support that. So what happens in the future? Some people have jobs and are rich while the rest are in poverty and can't eat? I don't think society could function with that many people not having an income. If it came down to it and I had to kill you for my family to survive then I'd hate to tell you which one I would choose.
Re:The Economy by ef4 on Monday June 30, 2014 @03:55PM (#7967268)
This same argument has been repeated for literally centuries now, and it always turns out wrong in the long run.

Imagine if we could run the entire world economy with only 5% of the workers. Pandemonium? No, it has already happened before. Agriculture was the whole economy, the rest was rounding error. Virtually all workers worked in agriculture. Now we produce all that and much more with something less than 5% of the workforce.

Having no more work to do necessarily means that everybody already has everything they want. It's not a meaningful risk.

Most of already do work so esoteric that our ancestors wouldn't possibly believe you could base a real economy around it. Yet here we are. Our descendants will do things that similarly boggle us.

Re:The Economy by scarmig on Monday June 30, 2014 @04:30PM (#7967499)
It turns out to be right, often enough.

In the 19th century, for instance, there was a class of physical laborers whose numbers in the USA reached the tens of millions. But as technology--particular the combustion engine and fossil fuel refining--took off, they became surplus unusable labor that literally was more valuable being turned into glue, or letting them starve to death.

Yeah, horses.

"But it's different this time! Horses aren't people!" you say. Sure, things are always different. But you're burying the actual argument into the assumptions you're making: that people are infinitely moldable and infinitely trainable, and every person is capable of creating value in modern economies.

It's not some logical contradiction for "people want more stuff" and for "the most useless, marginal workers can't provide value by participating in the economy" to both be true. Dismissing the second idea requires a bit more than a pat answer.

Even excluding government policies like a minimum wage and required healthcare benefits, lots of people are simply too expensive to employ. Anytime you hire someone, it adds administrative costs. It adds management costs. And the more marginal the worker, the more they need to be managed and administered. At some point any value they could hypothetically provide is outweighed by the cost of employing and managing them and the risk that something they do could expose you to substantial costs, and it's simply cheaper to replace that labor with capital.

In a capital rich environment, and in economies where complex organizations can fail catastrophically because of a single node failure, it's simply far too risky to employ a certain class of people. We already do that with many of criminal backgrounds, the physically disabled, and people with substantially reduced mental capabilities. New technology has simply expanded that unemployable class to include lots of people who just don't have much going for them, at least in terms of providing economic value that's legible to corporations and the State.

Re:The Economy by ef4 on Monday June 30, 2014 @05:39PM (#7967898)
I'll grant your premise, for the sake of argument.

So where's the big negative fallout? If the set of unemployable people has been growing for centuries, where is the mass starvation and misery? How can it be possible that the 20th century -- well into the process you describe -- saw a burgeoning middle class in the West, and then later a burgeoning middle class in Asia?

Clearly the benefits of productivity growth have been bigger than the overhead required to support the people who cannot contribute.

I'm not arguing that everybody is infinitely retrainable. I think the biggest problem we face is several generations of existing people with completely obsolete mindsets, who are too old to relearn.

Your whole argument is written in terms of employment at a job. But that's precisely part of the mindset that is obsolete. The idea that "getting a job" is the best option for most people is historically recent and already dying. There are plenty of other ways to organize an economy, and there's plenty of historical precedent for the idea that common people can successfully operate far more independently than they do under the industrial model. In a capital rich environment, you teach people to be capitalists, and let a million independent experiments blooms.

The alternative is you keep teaching people to defer to the boss, and the boss evolves into the Lord, and we go back to serfdom. That could happen too.

Assumptions about what "average people" are capable of need to be judged against the system that's training those people. Our present system was consciously designed to make them into good industrial widgets. But the malleability of children is absurdly high, and from directly experience I see no reason you couldn't turn nearly all of them into creative capitalists.

Re:The Economy by scarmig on Monday June 30, 2014 @08:21PM (#7968537)
I didn't intend to suggest we see mass starvation and misery now, simply that a larger and larger proportion of the population of working-age population would fall out of the workforce. Which we've seen for men for decades, and women as well recently. We've dealt with this by a hodgepodge of measures, from a hacky attempt to patch those weak portions of the labor market using SSDI; to kids living in their parents' basements and sharing their family health insurance; to extending unemployment for periods much longer than it was originally designed; to encouraging early retirement. We've muddled through, basically. As the tendency intensifies, it'd be worthwhile to figure out a solid way to rationalize and optimize all those programs.

Your other points I'm in broad agreement with. More and more of the economy will shift from hierarchical, institution-oriented "jobs" to something more freeform. This effectively amounts to shifting management and monitoring costs to the individual instead of the organization, which I think makes loads of sense and is a practice that'll end up outcompeting others. I don't think the average worker will end up screwed in the next ten or thirty years. I'd expect that a surprisingly large number of them will be working in autonomous jobs outside of corporate environments.

But many of those new freeform activities will be marginal, and many of them will involve barter as compensation or even be wholly uncompensated.

So, I'm not so sanguine about the bottom 20%: even if we do manage to revamp our education system to deal with contemporary economic problems better (a huge, giant if that'd take decades to implement), it'll take time to replace the whole workforce (40 years!), and there will always be students who end up performing significantly below average. Retraining programs of older workers haven't shown exceptionally promising results, either.

One of the things I like a lot about the Basic Income is that it provides a way for those displaced workers to experiment with new ways of work without the vigilant eye of the State trying to shove them into legible, easily-taxed, and controlled corporate employment.

Re:The Economy by johnward on Monday June 30, 2014 @04:17PM (#7967427)
Are you saying that we will continue to invent things to do in exchange for money? I feel like there has to be a point that you can't do that. I guess it would have been insane to think that people would be sitting in offices making comments on news forums most of the day.
Re:The Economy by crazy1van on Monday June 30, 2014 @03:48PM (#7967216)
> it would also be a good idea to completely remove the profit motive from health care.

If I had a fatal disease with no known cure, I want a system that makes whoever finds the cure filthy rich. That's my best chance at survival. If anything, I want a system with even more profit motive.

Re:The Economy by tzs on Monday June 30, 2014 @11:02PM (#7968972)
Why would anyone care about curing your fatal disease if they are profit driven? They should be able to make more money working on widespread non-fatal problems, like erectile disfunction or baldness.
Re:The Economy by moblahbl4hblah on Tuesday July 01, 2014 @06:44AM (#7969962)
If the world were as simple as the statement you made then sure...it isn't.
Re:The Economy by zo1 on Monday June 30, 2014 @03:54PM (#7967260)
Ah yes, the old "it'll work, we just need more money, promise!". We've been hearing that one since the beginning of the democratic form of governance. Guess you haven't looked at the recent graphs of US budget spending, otherwise you would have figured out that "more money" doesn't necessarily solve the problem.

Hint: Most, if not all, the additional money gets eaten up by newly created bureaucracy.

Re:The Economy by sp332 on Monday June 30, 2014 @02:54PM (#7966836)
You can't remove the profit motive from health care.
Re:The Economy by zentiggr on Monday June 30, 2014 @03:00PM (#7966888)
Please expand on that - I personally think for-profit health care is one of the most ill-conceived ways of doing business I have ever heard of. Saving people's lives but only in ways that are investor-friendly?
Re:The Economy by tdaltonc on Monday June 30, 2014 @03:17PM (#7967010)
healthcare innovation requires enormous investment. How should society pick healthcare problems to focus on, and how will we know a solution when we see it? The distributed price signal is an elegant mechanism for solving this problem and has worked to guide innovation in many other areas of human endeavour.
Re:The Economy by sp332 on Monday June 30, 2014 @03:22PM (#7967044)
We can do better, though. For example, if poor people are hit harder by something, there might be less "price signal" than if a few rich people are sick.
Re:The Economy by sp332 on Monday June 30, 2014 @03:08PM (#7966940)
You can reduce it, and you can try to amplify other motivations. But if you're developing a new drug, why wouldn't you market it to people who can pay you more for it?

You can't save every life - no one is immortal. And in the decision of what care to give to which people, money will always be one factor. This is probably amplified in non-life-threatening situations since personal trainers and nutritional consultants will probably not be covered by collective health plans.

Re:The Economy by bluthru on Monday June 30, 2014 @02:58PM (#7966873)
What do you mean? It's quite common.
Re:The Economy by sp332 on Monday June 30, 2014 @03:00PM (#7966892)
Some technology will be too expensive to provide, or some procedure will require skills that are too rare. They will command high prices. And you can't find enough doctors, hospital administrators, drug researchers etc for a whole country without finding some greedy/rational ones who will do better work for more pay.
Re:The Economy by bmj on Monday June 30, 2014 @03:47PM (#7967210)
guaranteed higher education

How about "guaranteed job training?" That way, if you wish to pursue a career that does not require a post-secondary degree, you can prepare yourself for that career just as well as the white collar worked who spends four years studying post-modern poetry.

N.B.: I have degrees in philosophy and writing, so I'm criticizing the study of the liberal arts.

Re:The Economy by crassus on Monday June 30, 2014 @04:02PM (#7967333)
Basic income is a potentially unlimited liability without any government control over fertility. If the needs of the portion of the population that are net consumers grow quicker than the surplus from net producers, an economic apocalypse happens sooner or later.

In a world of dysgenic fertility, this is guaranteed[1].

[1] http://charltonteaching.blogspot.com/2014/06/dysgenics-is-mo...

Re:The Economy by Tossrock on Monday June 30, 2014 @04:58PM (#7967665)
The entire premise of this completely unsubstantiated blog post is refuted by the well-substantiated Flynn effect: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flynn_effect
Re:The Economy by crassus on Monday June 30, 2014 @05:18PM (#7967783)
Probably a positive environmental effect masking decline in genetic potential IQ, which there is evidence for: http://www.xenosystems.net/dysgenic-reactions/