Yes, but it's a negative sum market. The lost time the drivers are paying is lost, it is destroyed, hours that could have been spent in productive work, or in enjoyable leisure are being wasted. Setting up the market to work in dollars rather than hours avoids this. The dollars are transferred but no resource is squandered.
This is typically true in North America, but it is not a fundamental law. Particularly, in Europe, but also for some trips in Sydney, Vancouver, et cetera, I have found public transit superior to a private car. The key is to have as wide of a network as possible, frequent service (every 5 minutes so you don't need to think about schedules) and a average speed that is higher than the car (doable with trains, dedicated bus lanes and so on). Anywhere that there is enough traffic to cause congestion ought to be a viable place for public transportation . . . population density is not necessarily the driving factor. In fact, in some situations, a high population density might allow people to move less as they are closer to shops, work, friends, et cetera, rendering transit less important.
No, the problem with public transit in North America isn't some fundamental flaw with public transit, it is because we tend to half-ass it.
In North America part of the reason we don't have as much mass transit as other parts of the world is because we like our urban sprawl and that makes it difficult to make the economics work out.
I don't know about other parts of Europe, but where I'm from public transit is most definitely not financially viable. Even in the big cities, it produces millions of euro of losses each year. Those are covered by taxes.
The problem in North America isn't [just] the suburban sprawl, it's also that you want to make a profit off of everything. Sometimes some things just need to be a public service because it's better that way.
Then again, the roads I've seen in the US are so shitty I'm [almost] certain there's no upkeep being done anyway.
Regions with affluent populations and dense metros essentially have their own road budgets and taxes to keep conditions acceptable.
The other problem in the states is that the weather varies very strongly; this coupled with snowplows and road freight does a number on roads in short order. Some stretches have to be resurfaced yearly. Doing this is expensive and disruptive, so sometimes it is only done in the worst spots if the other parts can wait.
The roads in the US are absolutely a dream compared to say Indonesia, or even China where new roads tend to crumble after a few years of iffy maintenance.
Perhaps that's just a failing of how mass transit systems are sold to the public though. If your mass transit system takes several hundred thousand people off the road every day and significantly reduces gridlock it makes everyone's commute better and wastes a lot less time and gas. Maybe that's how these systems need to be sold rather than, "It'll run profitably after X years."
I don't think anyone really expects government-run mass transit to be profitable, I for one would be happy if it were less of an enormous money pit. Given the level of corruption in most public transit authorities however, I don't hold out much hope.
As if the USA was a third-world country with a high level of corruption compared to say...China, which many conservatives/libertarians "praise" for its cost and efficiency.
Assume every driver is equally at fault.
Each driver is causing 1000 person-seconds of slowdown.
Each driver is receiving 1000 person-seconds of slowdown.
Seems fair to me, and each driver is paying their exact cost.
It's wrong to look at the externalities drivers output and ignore the externalities drivers input.
In some situations the margin of newcomers is a fair way to look at it. But with drivers on the road, these people are all getting up in the morning and choosing to use this road at the same time. It is a continuous reaffirmation, day by day, that this is the path they want, no matter who they slow down, and they accept being slowed in return.
"Each driver is paying their exact cost." Yes, but on the margin each driver can only choose a small chunk of their cost. Seriously, have you looked at the enormous literature on this? One major annoyance on HN is the way CS people assume that they can independently grok the intricacies of any field.
Assuming drivers actually consider their effect on congestion, they are willingly accepting the congestion of those coming after just as much as they accept the congestion they cause. (Most probably don't consider it but that's beside the point) Most importantly, the drivers are choosing to use the road every day even after seeing the final congestion every day. That's not a marginal decision. They are choosing to accept the final congestion.
But even if you insist on a marginal explanation with actors incapable of anticipating future cars, the average driver is intentionally accepting and causing 500 with past cars, and unwittingly accepting and causing 500 with future cars. Versus your characterization of them only intentionally having 10 delay.
Framing it as a new car 'paying a pittance more' is nonsense. The twentieth car either doesn't travel or attempts to pay 200 to travel. Comparing 190 to 200 is meaningless, because they never had the chance to travel at 190.
There is a congestion externality on them despite not using the road.
When PT is done right, it's much more predictable than private cars. Being able to leave when you want does you no good when you're dealing with unpredictable traffic.
And to the GP's point, they most definitely take you from point A to point B. Those two points may not be where you are and where you want to go, though with a solid network it'll usually be within ambulatory distance.
;)
Except it's not: unless you're extraordinarily prescient (or have access to real-time, accurate-to-the-meter traffic data), the driver cannot act as a rational actor because he has imperfect knowledge about the transaction. And that's assuming he'd act like a rational actor anyways -- and anyone who's studied real life instead of theory will tell you that most actors are not rational except, sometimes, in aggregate.
Says who? Instead of spending time stressfully navigating through a slow maze of cars, you can read a book while quickly and predictably getting to your destination. (Public transit is substantially more predictable than traffic.)
I'd take a train over a car every time.
And if you really need A -> B directly, there are taxis.
In the same cities owning a car is also inconvenient, it's not like you can park anywhere.
The fact that public transportation sucks in a lot of cities is not due to intrinsic qualities of these solutions, it's a consequence of shitty urbanisation planning that makes it hard to offer a good public transportation strategy.
I'm not interested in the definition of a 'traffic jam'. I'm not interested to know if I've ever been in a 'traffic jam' or not.
Drivers already pay for the cost in lost time. It's a 'natural' market.
The main problem with this article is the idea that the goal in traffic policy is to reduce congenstion. No, it should be to maximize utility. Sure, if you reduce roads, add congenstion charges then people will find alternatives to cars. That doesn't imply that utility is increased.
Public transportation is typically worse than using a private car. You can't decide when to leave, you pretty much need to plan your trips around public transportation. They don't take you directly from A to B etc. Public transportation becomes effective only when population density becomes high enough.