News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Becoming Sweetie, The Computer-Generated Girl Who Took On... by gambiting on Monday June 16, 2014 @01:01PM (#7900082)
So...it's a crime to think about something? Is it a crime to think about murdering someone? Or about stealing a purse, but without actually doing any of these things?
Re:Becoming Sweetie, The Computer-Generated Girl Who Took On... by rqebmm on Monday June 16, 2014 @01:05PM (#7900115)
The crime isn't thinking about abusing a child, it's intending to abuse a child. It's still somewhat in a grey area since they haven't actually harmed anyone, but it's a lot darker grey than just the having the idea to do it.
Re:Becoming Sweetie, The Computer-Generated Girl Who Took On... by tinco on Monday June 16, 2014 @01:05PM (#7900114)
No, you are twisting the accusation. It is not a crime to think, it is a crime to act. The law here is about the act of proposing sexual actions to a child over the internet, which has been made illegal by the UN.

Under debate is whether it is still illegal when the victim of your action does not actually exist as a person.

Re:Becoming Sweetie, The Computer-Generated Girl Who Took On... by olog-hai on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @01:29PM (#7911368)
> made illegal by the UN

The UN is not a government.

Re:Becoming Sweetie, The Computer-Generated Girl Who Took On... by EpicEng on Monday June 16, 2014 @01:11PM (#7900149)
Is it a crime to think about murdering someone?

It's certainly a crime to plan to murder someone. These guys have gone beyond thinking about it; they have actually planned and tried to execute on the idea. What about that is different than conspiracy to murder?

Now,if these people are being accused of anything more than intent I think it is going too far.

Re:Becoming Sweetie, The Computer-Generated Girl Who Took On... by rosser on Monday June 16, 2014 @02:21PM (#7900591)
Nice false dilemma.

Of course it's not a crime to think about something. But that's not what happened here. The alleged perps propositioned a child for sexual acts. That it happened not to have been an actual, breathing child in the specific instance involving Sweetie is incidental; I'll bet you real money it was every other time...

EDIT: Or do you somehow actually think that for all 1000 people found via this "honeypot", it was the first time they ever thought, "I know what I'll do today! I'll pay a naked 8-year-old to touch herself over the internet!" and that they were just "lucky" enough to get a fake kid their first time out?

Re:Becoming Sweetie, The Computer-Generated Girl Who Took On... by gambiting on Monday June 16, 2014 @02:57PM (#7900793)
This is not how any justice system ever works. And I bet that you do not want it to work that way.
Re:Becoming Sweetie, The Computer-Generated Girl Who Took On... by ScottBurson on Monday June 16, 2014 @03:42PM (#7901038)
You're thoroughly mistaken. If you proposition a police officer masquerading as a prostitute, you will be arrested and successfully prosecuted.
Re:Becoming Sweetie, The Computer-Generated Girl Who Took On... by rosser on Monday June 16, 2014 @05:45PM (#7901652)
Meta: What's with the tendency on HN to downvote people saying demonstrably true things? Do you somehow think that your downvote will alter the parts of reality you don't like or something?
Re:Becoming Sweetie, The Computer-Generated Girl Who Took On... by gambiting on Monday June 16, 2014 @05:48PM (#7901669)
Yes,but based on that one act,not on the "assumption" that you do it regularly and have done it a thousand times before,as the previous commenter was suggesting.
Re:Becoming Sweetie, The Computer-Generated Girl Who Took On... by rosser on Monday June 16, 2014 @06:03PM (#7901741)
You seem to think we're advocating arresting and prosecuting people based solely on their interactions with Sweetie. That's patently untrue, and (in my case, at least) easily refuted by my reply to you else-thread, where I said:

If you ask me, however, Bob's propositioning Sweetie creates sufficient Probable Cause to obtain a warrant to search his computer for evidence of other, similar, interactions, with actual children. Then he can be prosecuted for the cases where there was a victim.

That he interacts with a virtual child in an inappropriate way is strongly suggestive that has engaged in that behavior at other times, with other, real children. The issues that cause people to act on their pedophilia tend not to result in isolated incidents, and this has been repeatedly demonstrated by years and years of study of hundreds, if not thousands, of individuals.

If the police find no evidence that he's done this before — whether because he actually hasn't (vanishingly unlikely), or because he's too good at hiding his aberrance — then we may or may not be able to prosecute him, depending on the jurisdiction.

But, for my money, Sweetie isn't per se about prosecution. It's about helping surface individuals that warrant further scrutiny, subject to due process, and then quite possibly prosecution.

Re:Becoming Sweetie, The Computer-Generated Girl Who Took On... by ScottBurson on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @03:07AM (#7903198)
I think it turns on the fact that Sweetie was being run by an NGO; I would not expect prosecutions solely on the basis of their evidence. If "she" were being run by the police directly, on the other hand, I wouldn't be surprised at all if some of the people they caught were prosecuted solely on the basis of this one act.
Re:Becoming Sweetie, The Computer-Generated Girl Who Took On... by crusso on Monday June 16, 2014 @01:04PM (#7900108)
Haven't you done more than think by participating in the conversation?

I'm all for discussing this and thinking about it, but actually chatting with the person on the other end demonstrates intent.

Re:Becoming Sweetie, The Computer-Generated Girl Who Took On... by gambiting on Monday June 16, 2014 @01:09PM (#7900135)
Then they should be tried for intent. And it is my understanding,that they are being accused of actually molesting a child,even though there was no child present on the other side.
Re:Becoming Sweetie, The Computer-Generated Girl Who Took On... by mcphage on Monday June 16, 2014 @01:21PM (#7900217)
> And it is my understanding,that they are being accused of actually molesting a child

That would certainly change things—where did you get that data from?

Re:Becoming Sweetie, The Computer-Generated Girl Who Took On... by PhasmaFelis on Monday June 16, 2014 @01:12PM (#7900152)
No, it's a crime to actually try to murder someone. It's a crime to grab your purse strap, try to yank it away, then give up and run. This isn't hard.
Re:Becoming Sweetie, The Computer-Generated Girl Who Took On... by gadders on Monday June 16, 2014 @01:08PM (#7900130)
It's crime to plan to do something, no?
Re:Becoming Sweetie, The Computer-Generated Girl Who Took On... by gambiting on Monday June 16, 2014 @01:10PM (#7900141)
Right, but it's a separate crime than actually doing it, and from what I understand, the law does not separate these two in this case. The law treats it as if they were chatting to an actual child, which they weren't.
Re:Becoming Sweetie, The Computer-Generated Girl Who Took On... by DanBC on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @05:01AM (#7909108)
But they thought they were.

If they thought they were selling illegal drugs but they were just selling sugar they would be convicted. (In England if you sell sugar as illegal drugs you will be convicted of a drugs offence even if you know you are selling pure sugar).

Re:Becoming Sweetie, The Computer-Generated Girl Who Took On... by danielweber on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @03:19PM (#7906395)
IANAL, and this depends on jurisdiction, but it generally requires planning plus an overt act towards the plan.

If I plan to kill my boss, saw him into pieces with a chainsaw, and put the pieces in triple-mylar garbage bags, when I go to the store to buy garbage bags I've crossed the legal threshold.

In many states, if the prosecutor can prove to the jury 1) I planned to kill my boss, saw him into pieces with a chainsaw, and put the pieces into garbage bags, and 2) bought garbage bags, I'm toast and will go away for several years. NB there is nothing wrong with just buying the garbage bags.

Re:Becoming Sweetie, The Computer-Generated Girl Who Took On... by gadders on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @04:49AM (#7909081)
OK, but if the "offender" in this case a) spoke inappropriately to someone they believed was underage and then b) arranged a time and place to meet them, that would count, no?
Re:Becoming Sweetie, The Computer-Generated Girl Who Took On... by danielweber on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @08:09AM (#7909607)
Yep. Sounds like it should be easy to prove having a plan and the overt act towards the plan.

Incidentally, this is why you should always get a lawyer before talking to the cops.