News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by SoftwareMaven on Friday June 06, 2014 @01:41PM (#7859286)
There is a lot of evidence beginning to emerge on the value of fasting. This was once encoded in culture as almost every culture had some concept of fasting. We lost so much knowledge when we let nutrition "science"[1] completely overwhelm the wisdom of our ancestors.

On a personal note, I found fasting became much easier after I changed my diet to be ketogenic. With a metabolism primed for burning fat for energy and not subject to a blood sugar roller coaster, going a couple days without food is more of a mental challenge than physical hunger.

1. We've acted like nutrition can give the same cut and dry answers that physics has, and the health of our population shows how well that has worked. Worse, nutrition seems to be driven by egos and media in a way that is nothing short of frightening.

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by DenisM on Friday June 06, 2014 @03:05PM (#7859770)
>health of our population shows how well that has worked

The average lifespan has gone up considerably in recent decades, and people remain active longer than ever, i.e. people are gaining productive years, not just end-of-life years.

In other words, "it" worked fairly well.

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by themgt on Friday June 06, 2014 @03:28PM (#7859885)
That is almost all due to medical, not nutritional science - antibiotics, better surgeries, pharma, etc. Nutritional science has been an abysmal failure for decades and is barely beginning to relearn many things "nutrional science" itself intentionally threw away in favor of laughably simplistic ideas about how the body works.
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by jfoutz on Friday June 06, 2014 @03:52PM (#7859984)
I'm going to go out on a limb and say medicine wasn't very effective pre 1900, and furthermore the vast majority of life expectancy improvements were due to clean water and enough food.

Historically, nutrition has saved a ton of lives. But, I'm with you, modern "nutrition science" doesn't really deserve any credit for that.

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by kangax on Friday June 06, 2014 @04:52PM (#7860218)
And ironically, death rates from obesity just crossed those from hunger. The abundance of food (or rather, abysmal diet culture) is now starting to hurt us.
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by nightski on Friday June 06, 2014 @06:32PM (#7860592)
Sure but isn't it misleading to correlate high caloric intake with obesity? I mean this CAN be the case, but the more weight I lose and the more I work out - the more calories I actually consume.
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by kangax on Friday June 06, 2014 @07:43PM (#7860787)
I think it's safe to say that there's some sort of correlation, although of course obesity is a complex issue.

Higher caloric intake is just part of equation. Sedentary life style, increased stress, reduced sleep, "western" diet (highly inflammatory, with poor nutrient density), craving-inducing food, and messed up intestinal flora are just some of the things that likely contribute to obesity.

As someone who travels from US to Europe often, I always wonder what exactly it is that causes such dramatic difference.

Is it gluten, that's been under scrutiny lately? It doesn't seem to be so, since so many European countries are happily eating their bread. Although European-favored sourdough has been shown to positively affect intestinal flora through fermentation, unlike those puffy bread-like impostors you see in commercial stores in US.

Lifestyle doesn't seem to differ much either, although Europeans definitely have a more sacred and slower approach to meals, and there's less of that "quick lunch in a rush" culture.

However, portion size and difference in cooking oils (olive in EU vs. corn/cottonseed/canola/etc. in US) seem to stand out the most, and are probably the biggest offenders. [1]

[1] http://chriskresser.com/how-too-much-omega-6-and-not-enough-...

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by kaitai on Saturday June 07, 2014 @12:06AM (#7861244)
There are a number of reports claiming that wheat strains in the US and Europe are quite different, with differing gluten levels. The US has certainly pioneered the breeding of high-gluten wheats, as they're better for processed goods.

Unfortunately, I can't find a reference with any science.

Certainly in Scandinavia wheat does not play the primary role that it does in the US. Rye, barley, and oats are common in the diet. How many Americans, though, have eaten 100% rye bread even once in their lives?

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by tripzilch on Sunday June 08, 2014 @07:03PM (#7866258)
What about ordering/eating out versus preparing your meals from basic ingredients? (including lunch, which we bring in a box or baggy)

That was a big difference I saw while in the US. I hardly ever order/takeout my meals, and when I do, I do it under the assumption that it'll be strictly less healthy than whatever I'd prepare myself (this may not always be true if you're 1 not a very good cook and 2 only order lunch at very health-focused places)

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by vasilipupkin on Sunday June 08, 2014 @08:58AM (#7864568)
My guess is the fact that food is so cheap relative to income in the US explains a significant part of the gap between US and Europe obesity rates
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by maxerickson on Sunday June 08, 2014 @07:10PM (#7866274)
Canola oil has a lower ratio of Omega 6 to Omega 3 than olive oil. On that measure, it is 'better'.
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by Retric on Friday June 06, 2014 @08:26PM (#7860858)
Modern "nutrition science" has saved plenty of lives. It's no where near as important as indoor plumbing, but managing diet often has huge impacts when dealing with many diseases.
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by DenisM on Friday June 06, 2014 @03:34PM (#7859919)
I should have made it clearer that I was meaning to refute the claim about [declining] "health of our population", not defending the nutritional science. I don't have much love for the latter.
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by 3pt14159 on Friday June 06, 2014 @05:00PM (#7860251)
Well, it is both. Cleaning the water supply has drastically increased infant mortality and general health, which is someways is a nutritional advancement.
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by glaugh on Friday June 06, 2014 @03:31PM (#7859900)
I think he's referencing "Lifestyle diseases" or "Diseases of civilization", like diabetes and heart disease, which appear to be quite rare in tribal settings (and not just because people die first of other things), but are commonplace in places like the modern USA.

People are obviously living a lot longer, but it's hard to tease apart how much of that is (1) people not dying of communicable diseases, which used to be the #1 killer, (2) sheer quantity of food (i.e., not starving), (3) the decline of violence, (4) diet composition, and (5) a whole host of other things.

We can't really just say "We're better now than we were then, so every change must have been a good change," without teasing apart correlation from causation. Otherwise in the 60s you could have said "People didn't used to eat lead paint chips, and now they do, and people are living a lot longer these days."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lifestyle_disease

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by legohead on Friday June 06, 2014 @07:28PM (#7860757)
If we were to take this article as truth -- specifically, the part that fasting can activate dormant stem cells, then fasting could very well be a bad thing.

There was recent research done that suggests that stem cells are a key ingredient to long life [1], and if they were to, say, come out of dormancy and become active too early and die, then you have just shortened your life.

[1] http://guardianlv.com/2014/04/stem-cells-may-be-key-to-long-...

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by arnorhs on Friday June 06, 2014 @03:28PM (#7859883)
Your reply has the same problem as SoftwareMaven's. Claims about two facts which are both true, does not make a correlation. (the only difference between yours and SoftwareMaven's claim is + vs -)

There are way too many factors at hand to be able to say anything about the role/value of nutritional science on the overall lifespan of earthlings.

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by Florin_Andrei on Friday June 06, 2014 @03:11PM (#7859793)
> There is a lot of evidence beginning to emerge on the value of fasting. This was once encoded in culture as almost every culture had some concept of fasting.

This is a cultural rift between Western Europe and everyone else. I grew up in Eastern Europe (now I live in the US), and fasting was not an extraordinary concept in that culture, by any means. But I keep noticing how controversial it is in the West.

I could probably speculate on the influence of material wealth on culture, and so on, but there's probably not much of a point here.

> I found fasting became much easier after I changed my diet to be ketogenic.

You don't need to go that far. Fasting is easy when you don't do any kind of alimentary excess in general.

I think the whole keto concept is just the pendulum swinging all the way to the other side. I guess it will settle in the middle at some point. Eat a bit of everything, nothing in excess, make sure to not miss the greens and the fruits, etc. Self-control and self-limiting are things that we all need to re-train ourselves for - and not just when it comes to food.

---

Anyway, I'm far more interested in studies regarding the effects of fasting on the brain. Traditionally, it was used in a spiritual context, by people who, for lack of a better term, were consciousness hackers. Fasting seemed to enable that process, whatever the mechanism.

I'm also very curious about the effects of fasting, if any, on neurodegenerative diseases.

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by thret on Friday June 06, 2014 @10:08PM (#7861045)
The ordinary results of fasting and meditation are visions and hallucinations. It isn't something that should be taken lightly or to an extreme. I had a Christian friend who tried a 30-day fast, he did indeed speak to God and God told him to kill himself. The note he left was basically gibberish. This is not too surprising.
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by meric on Saturday June 07, 2014 @01:11AM (#7861366)
I'm going to give you benefit of the doubt and assume he was a facebook friend, rather than a close one.
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by thenmar on Friday June 06, 2014 @01:50PM (#7859349)
Evidence of fasting having value is interesting, but I wouldn't put much stock in the "wisdom of the ancestors".
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by SoftwareMaven on Friday June 06, 2014 @02:08PM (#7859448)
Take a look at what Weston Price learned as he traveled around healthy cultures. I'm certainly not implying "everything old is good", but we have adopted an attitude of "they were all stupid", which isn't true. Let's take a look:

  Wisdom: Fat is a good energy source.
  "Science": Fat makes you fat and clogs your arteries.
  Now: Fat is important for regulating satiety and nervous system health.

  Wisdom: Simple carbs and sugar should be very limited.
  "Science": You can eat as much as you want without any problems.
  Now: High glucose and fructose loads are significant players in NAFLD, diabetes, heart disease and dimentia.

  Wisdom: Fermented foods like keifer, sauerkraut, and miso are important parts of the diet.
  "Science": Kill all the bugz!
  Now: Gut biome health may be a significant factor in many physical and mental health problems.

  Wisdom: Regular periods of fasting are good for mind and body.
  "Science": You should eat 6 small meals every day to keep blood sugar even.
  Now: See TFA.
I'm sure I could keep going...
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by drzaiusapelord on Friday June 06, 2014 @02:23PM (#7859525)
These are pretty disingenuous, uncited, and generalized examples. For example, fat has always been fine, excess calories are not. That leads to fatty build-up that does cause serious health issues. The problem is that casuals see 'fat' and equate it with body fat, instead of being focused on what science has been saying saying all along: eat that calories you need and not past that as you'll gain weight. Marketers have used this confuse to sell products, "low fat" craze, but that has never been the staple of nutritional understanding.

Lets also remember even the ones that the "ancients" got right, they got millions wrong, most of which were seriously dangerous. The modern person's appeal to the past is insane to me. I think if you could travel back in time to live in one of those cultures you value so much, you'd see nothing but sickness, death, and other horrible things that would be trivially treated in post-enlightenment societies.

Unfortunately, bullshit like 'ancient wisdom' has become popular of late thus parents not vaccinating their children, a return to extreme/fundamentalist religiosity, and dangerous cargo cult-like beliefs like treating cancer with green tea.

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by tolmasky on Friday June 06, 2014 @02:46PM (#7859648)
This is a mischaracterization of the past 30 years. In the 1980s, American's really were told to drastically reduce their fat intake due to a misunderstanding of LDL. It remains recommended to only be 10% of your daily intake of calories -- a statement of the percentage of calories you should eat as fat, not a statement about excess calories, which can be regarded as bad in general regardless of their source. If you look at what took place in the following 30 years since this stance, fat intake has in fact been reduced quite considerably in the United States, yet heart disease has increased. This has nothing to do with worshiping "ancient wisdom", its simply identifying an error science made (which it is allowed to do), and rectifying it without historical revisionism.
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by SoftwareMaven on Friday June 06, 2014 @02:54PM (#7859698)
Unfortunately, bullshit like 'ancient wisdom' has become popular of late thus the parents not vaccinating their children, a return to extreme/fundamentalist religiosity, and general dangerous cargo cultness like treating cancer with green tea.

That's a false dichotomy. It is possible to look to ancient practices with an eye towards using those as foundations for research. We didn't do that; instead, we let threw out all of that knowledge, the good and the bad, and we have 100 million sick people in the US and over a billion around the world.

I'm a firm believer that we can find good answers in science, but we are doing a piss-poor job and have been for 50 years. In fact, I'd go so far to see we've done very little nutritional science over the last 50 years; instead, we've done nutritional marketing in white coats. If people are rejecting what nutritional researchers are saying, they have only themselves to blame.

Things have gotten a little better in the last decade, but large organizations like the AHA, ADA, AND, and, of course, the US government, still seem to be stuck following the marketing literature of companies like Conagra and Monsanto rather than the science.

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by demallien on Friday June 06, 2014 @04:23PM (#7860099)
We didn't do that; instead, we let threw out all of that knowledge, the good and the bad, and we have 100 million sick people in the US and over a billion around the world.

I'm not sure what you expected scientists to do. None of the "traditional wisdom" was confirmed as true, it all had to be tested and was considered suspect until such testing had taken place.

On top of that, traditional diets had shortcomings. It's hard to produce enough calories for today's population to survive, without a larger proportion of those calories coming from grains.

Faced with this change in the food landscape, and with faith in traditional wisdoms rightly shaken, nutritionists have been basing their advice on reasoning from first principles, and preliminary results. They got it wrong badly. But at least we were on the path to a better understanding of nutrition. It's been too slow, and nutritionists were not skeptical enough of preliminary results, but lucky us, these are problems science knows how to fix.

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by SoftwareMaven on Friday June 06, 2014 @02:50PM (#7859665)
There is more involved than just calories. It's surprising that this myth continues to hold, when we understand how differently macronutrients are treated in the body. Calories are a second-order effect: you don't gain weight because you eat too many calories, your body demands more calories because it is hormonally/nutritionally imbalanced and, therefore, shunting energy into fat cells instead of allowing it to be used for energy. And this doesn't get into the fact that a high percentage of chronically ill patients (CVD, diabetes, dimentia) are thin.

Having dealt with being overweight most of my life, I can't help but believe the reason the myth holds on is because it is a way to justify judging fat people as less than skinny people since they just "can't control themselves".

Eat a better macronutrient ratio, and the body responds positively, even for isocaloric diets, whether for weight loss[1] or for maintenance[2]. But, really, isocoloric doesn't mater; what matters is ad libitum eating. Ironically, every study that I've read that compares low carb diets against low fat diets allows ad libitum eating for the low carb but restricts caloric intake for the low fat. Why is that? Even with that constraint, the low carb diets win[3].

1. http://ajcn.nutrition.org/content/early/2014/04/30/ajcn.113....

2. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22735432

3. http://nutrition.stanford.edu/documents/AZ_abstract.pdf (I have a lot of respect for Christopher Gardner. He's a vegetarian who started this study because he believed a vegetarian diet would trounce other diets. It didn't, but he didn't try to game the results. That's an unfortunately rare behavior in nutrition research where so many people seem to be more concerned with proving their idea correct than finding the truth.)

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by _broody on Friday June 06, 2014 @02:40PM (#7859616)
Where do you get from that 'fat has always been fine'? It's been the target of demonization by trendy dietitians for essentially the second half of the 20th century. This article on the subject made it to the top of HN a while ago:

http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB1000142405270230367840...

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by dunmalg on Friday June 06, 2014 @07:51PM (#7860802)
I think the point is that "trendy dietitians" != "science"
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by dasil003 on Friday June 06, 2014 @05:30PM (#7860367)
GP is not making a very clear argument, but you are piling on a fat helping of hubris.

First you appear to believe the specious nutritional myth that weight gain is a matter of calories in vs calories expended. Of course that appeals to scientifically-minded due to the comforting immutability of the laws of thermodynamics, but it ignores the fact that the human metabolism and satiety mechanisms are extremely complex and powerful. Even if you had a magic meter of all calories going in and out it wouldn't begin to solve our nutritional problems at a society level.

Second, things like the paleo (little p) approach to diet and health are not about "ancient wisdom". It's about the fact that we evolved under certain conditions, and while those conditions were constantly changing, the rate of change accelerated exponentially after industrialization and have completely been completely decimated in the last 60 years (less than one lifespan). While western medicine has made amazing strides in the last century, nutrition is still very much in its blood-letting dark ages. Looking to ancestral lifestyle clues is just good sense given the paltry information we have available. None of that is to poo-poo the scientific evidence we have, but understand that human nutrition is far too complex for nutritional science to yet provide convincing answers.

A lot of folks around here are so quick to look down their nose to people are too "granola" and make seemingly un-scientifically-subtantiated decisions like not eating processed foods or preferring "natural" or "whole" foods. But you know what? In the lack of sufficient knowledge, these hippies are making far smarter decisions than the geek who decides that since we don't have proof we might as well carry on with the average American diet. We pat ourselves on the back for our scientific literacy and rational decision-making, but deep down we are animals subject to the same conditioning and addicted to the same heavily processed foodstuffs which are almost certainly leading to all kinds of nasty health outcomes. We don't want to change our diet not because it's the rational decision, but because it fucking tastes good.

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by DanBC on Friday June 06, 2014 @05:42PM (#7860421)
People don't look down their noses at those who say things like "eating food that has been processed less is probably better for you".

People do, rightly, criticise those who claim problems with diet are all fixed with a single thing - paleo! Keto! No HFCS! No carbs!

Also, it's easy to deride calories out : calories in but it is fundamentally true that if a person eats fewer calories than they use they will lose weight. The fact that some people have gut flora that helps them stay thin and others have gut flora that makes it easier to gain weight and other people have a small genetic influence does not stop CO:CI being true, it just means that CO:CI is very hard to follow for some people. Suggesting that those people receive cognitive behaviour therapy and exercise programs along with lifestyle change to help them lose weight is usually met with stiff disagreement about the efficacy of these evidence based interventions.

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by dasil003 on Friday June 06, 2014 @07:54PM (#7860812)
CO:CI is impossible to follow period. There is simply no way to measure accurately both ends. It might be useful as a tool to some people, but as an objective solution it's just a banal truism with no reproducible path to success.

Other than that, I'm in complete agreement with what you said.

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by DanBC on Friday June 06, 2014 @02:11PM (#7859469)
Science has never said you can eat as many simple carbs as you like with no problem.

There have been "scumbag food advertisers" and "unqualified unregistered pseudo nutritionists" who have said that you must not eat any fat at all but that sugar is fine. That's not science.

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by SoftwareMaven on Friday June 06, 2014 @02:31PM (#7859563)
The current US government nutritional guidelines call for 6-10 servings of grains per day. It is only in the last 10 years that "whole grains" (white flour with a little bran added back) has been added, but the glycemic index of whole grain bread is almost identical to white bread. Grains are the "foundation" of the food pyramid.

We've also been told for 50 years that sugar is metabolically inert, so you "just have to worry about the calories". Sugar is a fine substitute for anything, just look at Snackwells.

The message has been driven home so well that stupid things happen like a mother getting fined for packing a nutritious lunch for her daughter, but not including the all-important "Ritz" food group[1].

1. http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/daycare-gives-kids-cr...

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by adventured on Friday June 06, 2014 @02:53PM (#7859686)
Are you really referencing the US Government's guidelines in the process of arguing how wise our ancestors were compared to today's food science?

You might as well ask Coke and McDonald's about their idea of a food pyramid.

Our ancestors knew exceptionally little about food nutrition. They ate what was naturally available to them, as they had absolutely no alternative. Doing something by default because it's the only option, does not make you wise. Our ancestors were in fact ignorant about nearly anything to do with the properties of food / health / nutrition et al. And they also did incredibly stupid things because of that ignorance, history books are filled with this fact.

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by MisterBastahrd on Friday June 06, 2014 @08:15PM (#7860840)
Yes, they ate what was available to them. For generations upon generations. Those who survived were usually the ones whose bodies could thrive on that diet. The mankind of today are descendants of those people, with their genetics. So while the idea of a "paleo" lifestyle might be a bit too simplistic, it's vastly better than the USG's current guidelines. If you could just remove refined sugars, starches, and fruit juices from the food pyramid, that'd be a fantastic start. Their negatives vastly outweigh their positives. Whole, unadulterated food products seem to be the way to go.
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by SoftwareMaven on Friday June 06, 2014 @02:58PM (#7859725)
Every entry in the food guidelines is backed up by reams of scientific references. If the guidelines are well referenced yet can still say whatever Coke and McDonalds want, how can we call that science?
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by dragonwriter on Friday June 06, 2014 @05:00PM (#7860249)
> Every entry in the food guidelines is backed up by reams of scientific references.

Just because something references science doesn't mean its well grounded in it.

> If the guidelines are well referenced yet can still say whatever Coke and McDonalds want, how can we call that science?

We can't. That's the point -- evaluating the merits of science by looking to policy that references but does not reflect science is invalid on its face.

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by venomsnake on Friday June 06, 2014 @02:41PM (#7859620)
By coincidence USG guidelines are also not science, but something that is hammered together with the permission of the food lobies.
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by jerf on Friday June 06, 2014 @03:48PM (#7859964)
The USG guidelines have been well-founded on scientific research.

If you want to argue that the USG guidelines were founded on scientific research that they (or other government branches) paid for, that they've managed to distort the resulting science to the point of destroying it, and that the whole process has been beholden to large food interests and national interests by virtue of the control of the purse strings... be my guest!

It is, however, what the "science" has been for the past 50 years. There has been no other "science". Attempts to pretend otherwise are simply and straight-up revisionist history, now that real science is finally poking through and the science of the past 50 years is not looking all that good. However, it is our moral duty to not pretend that "science" has been right the past 50 years, has been telling us the same things that we are just figuring out now, and it was, just, uh... umm... very very quiet or something?

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by venomsnake on Friday June 06, 2014 @04:25PM (#7860111)
Has there been simple experiment - take 10000 well sampled people, put them on the guidelines diet for two years and observe the outcomes compared to the general population.
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by dragonwriter on Friday June 06, 2014 @04:59PM (#7860241)
> The current US government nutritional guidelines call for 6-10 servings of grains per day.

US government policy and science aren't exactly the same thing.

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by Houshalter on Saturday June 07, 2014 @02:03AM (#7861452)
This line of reasoning is ridiculous and I will give an analogy.

Pick an ancient "wisdom" at random. What probability do you assign to this belief being true? You get "throwing salt over your shoulder increases luck." Obviously ridiculous right? You aren't going to actually do it just cause "the ancients" said it was good.

Now imagine some study comes out saying that exposure to salt in the air actually increases your something-or-other levels making you healthier. Ha, the ancients were right (kinda-sorta, about one thing, and for the wrong reasons, and with the wrong predicted effect)! All modern science must be wrong and all ancient wisdom must be correct! Proof we must go back to draining blood to to treat diseases and stop abandoning ancient practices.

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by ScottBurson on Friday June 06, 2014 @05:47PM (#7860444)

  Wisdom: Regular periods of fasting are good for mind and body.
  "Science": You should eat 6 small meals every day to keep blood sugar even.
  Now: See TFA.
These recommendations don't actually conflict. Maybe it's best to eat lots of small meals when you're eating, and still fast periodically.
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by mrexroad on Friday June 06, 2014 @05:11PM (#7860292)
sounds like science is doing a fine job, the important thing is that it self-corrects and we have a far, far deeper understanding of subtile complexities.

one of the few things that gives me hope for humanity is the hope that most things we "know" today will (rightly) be wrong in 100 years.

knowledge from conventional wisdom doesn't compound over time.

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by anon4 on Saturday June 07, 2014 @02:25AM (#7861486)
But that wisdom is all from different periods. Fat in particular is the old sugar - it makes food taste good. It's also the most calorie-dense macronutrient. Of course you're going to put as much as you can in your food. Want some more old wisdom? Bread: eat as much as possible, because it's cheap and fills you up. Bread and butter - the foundation of a good diet.

You can't just take any old practice and follow it blindly, you need to have some idea if it's good for you or simply doesn't kill you. Because there's a whole ton of shit that doesn't kill you.

Nutritional science may be bunk, but at least you can usually tell when they're speaking bunk and it sure beats the old system of "My parents ate this and they lived to the ripe old age of 50".

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by rbanffy on Friday June 06, 2014 @02:58PM (#7859722)
Would you like to continue also mentioning the instances popular "wisdom" was also wrong?
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by SoftwareMaven on Friday June 06, 2014 @03:11PM (#7859796)
You know what's funny? Before the 1940s, we didn't really have a problem with obesity, heart disease, diabetes, non-alcoholic fatty liver disease, PCOS, or any number of other diseases tied to diet. The groups that had problems had a diet much like we do today (high in flour and sugar, low in fat) except with less protein.

I'm not saying we can't improve on what was "known", and we can certainly understand the methods of actions. They also got a lot wrong. I'm just looking for a little humility in nutrition science.

So, what did they get wrong?

  Smoking is ok (or, maybe even healthy).
  Exercise is unhealthy[1].
  Making dinner after wiping away black plague puss w/o washing hands is OK.
1. Ironically, the alternative of too much exercise may be unhealthy as well.
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by rbanffy on Friday June 06, 2014 @05:12PM (#7860300)
I am quite sure the list can be at least as long as the one with items popular wisdom got right.
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by arjn on Friday June 06, 2014 @07:15PM (#7860716)
Longer actually.
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by diziet on Friday June 06, 2014 @03:16PM (#7859815)
You are using the Straw man fallacy here.
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by anon4 on Saturday June 07, 2014 @02:47AM (#7861508)
You know, Software Maven does sound a bit like Straw Man.

Now, I'm not saying that person is a troll, but he kind of smells like one and as they say, if it smells, it stinks.

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by GlickWick on Friday June 06, 2014 @01:55PM (#7859383)
Why not? Don't you want to attach a bunch of leeches to your stomach and bleed away that flu?
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by JamesArgo on Friday June 06, 2014 @01:59PM (#7859401)
And come to think of it, storing dead bodies in the well was very pro-biotic.
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by nkozyra on Friday June 06, 2014 @02:45PM (#7859641)
Well, we still use leeches today in modern medicine, so there's clearly some efficacy on display.
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by tiglionabbit on Friday June 06, 2014 @03:41PM (#7859936)
The fact that particular traditions exist implies that they might have some net benefit. Otherwise, people who practiced these traditions might have been out-competed by other groups who did not.
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by venomsnake on Friday June 06, 2014 @05:48PM (#7860450)
The tribes that practiced cargo cults weren't wiped out.
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by arjn on Friday June 06, 2014 @07:17PM (#7860725)
True but thats most likely because they were/are highly isolated from other groups.
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by tiglionabbit on Saturday June 07, 2014 @07:57PM (#7863507)
100 years is probably not enough time for this sort of selection to take place.
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by svasan on Friday June 06, 2014 @02:04PM (#7859432)
Why would one want to ignore beneficial knowledge received in the form of tradition? To be able to re-invent the wheel?
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by dragonwriter on Friday June 06, 2014 @02:21PM (#7859520)
> Why would one want to ignore beneficial knowledge received in the form of tradition?

You want to be skeptical of tradition as a source of factual information because, while there exists beneficial knowledge that may be received in the form of tradition, it is impossible to reliably separate it from harmful false "knowledge" received in the form of tradition, without first turning it into knowledge derived from structured scientific information gathering.

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by raverbashing on Friday June 06, 2014 @02:44PM (#7859637)
> it is impossible to reliably separate it from harmful false "knowledge" received in the form of tradition

Evolution/Survivability of a group usually takes care of that

Yeah, slightly harmful/long term harmful things will go though, but not major things.

Someone discovered cheese with mold is edible (probably happened in a low food situation), but there's a high likelihood on people having tried other things with mold and it didn't work out as expected.

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by DenisM on Friday June 06, 2014 @03:20PM (#7859839)
>Evolution/Survivability of a group usually takes care of that

Not washing hands survived for a very long time, and lead to huge child mortality. Humanity survived, but lots of people died for no good reason.

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by meric on Saturday June 07, 2014 @01:07AM (#7861361)
A thousand years ago, it may have been more dangerous to send three times as many villagers to collect water from the river 20km away so that the village would have enough water for everyone to wash their hands, than to have people not wash their hands before eating. The benefits of a practice/tradition can vary over time.

Lots of people may have died from avoidable diseases, but lots of people may also have avoided death by bandits, wild animals, and starvation. (due to more workers allocated to water collection than food production; the extra food produced may have been the difference between life and death during famines for some people.)

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by svasan on Friday June 06, 2014 @02:43PM (#7859636)
Thanks, but no thanks to FDA approved or "scientifically" structured and tested and accredited health recommendations for me.

I am willing to put to test the the traditional practices that I am (or become) aware of.

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by WalterSear on Friday June 06, 2014 @02:07PM (#7859444)
Because the past had proportionally more hucksters to scientists than today. And because a lot of that 'ancient wisdom' was invented later, by the aforementioned hucksters:

http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/medical_exa...

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by venomsnake on Friday June 06, 2014 @05:51PM (#7860464)
Because tradition isn't knowledge. While tradition could be (valuable) source of leads, everything inside must be tested, experimented on and see why it does or doesn't work.

That article is perfect example - lots of cultures have fasting. We look at the fasting results and we find something interesting about how out body works. Now we have knowledge that we can build upon.

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by bane on Friday June 06, 2014 @04:14PM (#7860063)
Beware of pseudoscience. In the past, some things worked, something things didn't, but there's no understanding as to why they did or didn't work out of traditional models.

Scientific models haven't been all that great either, but science hopefully will eventually self correct as nutritional models become more sophisticated. If there is light at the end of the tunnel it will be because of the eventual understanding that the scientific method provides, not reverting back to traditional models.

Traditional models don't self correct and there are plenty of instances of people consuming outright poisons under such systems or people following traditional nutrition models finding themselves surrounded by an abundance of previously rare foods that the modern food supply system easily provides, and practically gorging themselves on it to negative health results.

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by ellyagg on Friday June 06, 2014 @05:18PM (#7860320)
We have to make decisions now. Do you think the prescriptions from the current state of nutrition science outperform ancestral eating heuristics in real life? I don't, and whether it's true or not is one of the major points under debate. The debate can't automatically be vetoed by invoking "pseudoscience".

As an epistemic issue, I have to use all the evidence available to me. What I've noticed is that human physiology is a dynamic equilibrium of a massive number of variables and the current state of our analytic tools have had immense trouble evaluating it efficiently. Ancestral eating patterns looks like worthwhile evidence under the circumstances.

Incidentally, essentially no one is blindly promoting traditional eating. Folks are using it as a guide and together with science to make decisions in the face of limited understanding. One of the most popular ancestral diet proponents is Stephan Guyenet, a Ph.D. neurobiologist who studies the link between the brain and obesity for a living[1]. Everyone is for science and no side on the issue owns it.

[1] http://wholehealthsource.blogspot.com/

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by bane on Friday June 06, 2014 @06:56PM (#7860659)
One of the common problems with diets of any kind is that there's an immediate fallacy of an appeal to authority. I'm sure Dr. Guyenet is very qualified as a neurobiologist, but his PhD is not in anything relevant to nutrition (even if he is studying the neurological aspects of eating) -- his B.S. is.

Which means that in theory, any random undergrad in a Biochem major is equally qualified to speak on the subject. This is not to put down Dr. Guyenet's work, it's important as obviously there's a neurological component to many kinds of obesity. But then to extend that work into his advocacy for traditional dietary guidelines is a stretch.

If he was just an undergrad student in Biochemistry with a blog telling you to do all of the things exactly opposite Dr. Guyenet, would you follow that instead? Why not? That person would be just as educationally qualified. I suspect the reason has to do more with what diet you've chosen to follow a priori and not with Dr. Guyenet's advocacy. I'm not going to pick apart specific issues with this blog, but a casual perusal of it shows lots of fad diet advice and logical "appeal to tradition" fallacies. "We should eat this way because people used to eat this way".

The reason people used to eat that way is because they had nothing else available. That's it. There's no secret "the ancients had figured out nutrition from their folk ways" that we should be parroting. There are lots of ingredients in traditional diets that we understand today to be outright poison (like bracken). And lots of ingredients our ancestors thought were poison but are just fine (like potatoes).

Traditionally, people didn't even know what to eat to stop scurvy. A nutritional disease which killed millions and turns out to be trivial to treat.

What we know about good nutrition (using the power of science) happens to be in pretty broad strokes with pockets of ultra-specificity where we've bothered to do serious research. Science has gotten it pretty wrong as well in the past and probably will for some time as the study of nutrition matures. And you're absolutely right, we can't wait 200 years for nutrition science to mature in the way that Physics has, we have to eat today (and multiple times at that).

All I'm saying is that nutrition blogs are a dime a dozen, from people with all kinds of credentials, and lots of them are full of all kinds of advice. "People used to eat this" is just cargo culting dietary advice (and then trying to backfill in justification after the fact) and I would chalk it up to pseudoscience and just make my own decisions based on reasonable advice like "eat in moderation, eat in variety".

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by Houshalter on Saturday June 07, 2014 @01:53AM (#7861436)
As if our ancestors were fasting because they knew it was good for their health. As if their poor nutrition didn't cause much worse problems for them like nutrient deficiencies, lower IQ, shorter heights, lower life expectancies. As if most people today eat only according to the best consensus of nutrition science.
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by rdmcfee on Friday June 06, 2014 @02:09PM (#7859454)
I can second that. Ketosis and fat adaption reduces the need for constant refueling. I have no problem going 24 hours between meals and exercising while fasting.

I typically eat ~12 meals per week, 2000 kcal per meal.

In addition, the consistent mental acuity achieved in ketosis is fantastic.

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by e12e on Friday June 06, 2014 @03:00PM (#7859736)
Sounds like a great way to self-diagnose diabetes. If you go into a coma, you probably have diabetes...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ketosis

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by TTPrograms on Friday June 06, 2014 @04:30PM (#7860132)
Uh, infrequent meals increase insulin sensitivity. Are you saying he's going to get diabetes?

Just because X causes Ketosis doesn't mean Ketosis implies X.

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by e12e on Friday June 06, 2014 @07:31PM (#7860767)
No, I (snarikly) said it (inducing ketosis) was a way to diagnose diabetes, not induce diabetes.
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by rdmcfee on Friday June 06, 2014 @03:19PM (#7859831)
Probably easier to just take an insulin sensitivity test or get your Hb A1C tested.
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by epa on Friday June 06, 2014 @03:45PM (#7859954)
How do you feel after each of those meals though? Also what time of the day do you eat and does it affect your 1-3 hours after.
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by raverbashing on Friday June 06, 2014 @01:58PM (#7859399)
While science is advancing and giving a better view of what is needed and what can cause problems, the market is replacing most things in the food without much regard for its consequences

Also, science "doesn't know what it doesn't know yet", so we may be missing something that was inconspicuously removed, or suffering from something that was apparently safe

One of the interesting things is knowledge that existed and that was rediscovered by science, like http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nixtamalization

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by TylerJay on Saturday June 07, 2014 @03:11PM (#7862786)
I think it's important to note that "Ketogenic" might not be the right word for the necessary diet intervention to make it easier to fast for long periods.

Ketosis is a state where you eat so little carbohydrate, that your body is forced to create "ketone bodies" to fuel the brain. This typically happens at <50g/day carbohydrate.

Most anecdotal evidence (and my own experiences) show that you can get your body into a primarily fat-burning state that makes it easier to fast for long periods without hunger pangs by eating up to somewhere around 100 or 150g/day carbohydrate (assuming you eat a 2000-2500 Kcal/day diet) while providing enough glucose to the brain that your body is not forced to create excess Ketone bodies.

Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by dzhiurgis on Friday June 06, 2014 @03:41PM (#7859935)
Fasting could be related to food preservation or simply lack of food before new harvest is collected. At least some of the dates do correlate.
Re:Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old i... by Mz on Friday June 06, 2014 @06:22PM (#7860556)
SoftwareMaven, I will suggest that one possible explanation is that our gut is filled with microbes (some good, some bad) and food is filled with microbes and, by weight, our poop is 50% microbes of some sort. So when you fast, you clean out bugs from your system, some of which are very not good for you. We seem to have lost this idea that we are organic, living creatures, part of a complex biome and seem to have this fantasy that we are merely ...chemically complex and in need of more building blocks. And life is just way, way more complicated than that. It is much closer to an on-going, multi-front battle. And when you never fast, you never take a break from that battle. It just keeps on going.

my 2 cents, fwiw.