News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Life After 'Life': Aging Inmates Struggle For Redemption by WalterBright on Thursday June 05, 2014 @03:48AM (#7850727)
I just don't see much point in sentences beyond 30-40 years.
Re:Life After 'Life': Aging Inmates Struggle For Redemption by narsil on Thursday June 05, 2014 @03:53AM (#7850743)
That might be explained by the US prison system being one of punishment, not rehabilitation. [0]

[0] http://www.apa.org/monitor/julaug03/rehab.aspx

Re:Life After 'Life': Aging Inmates Struggle For Redemption by lazyjones on Thursday June 05, 2014 @07:13AM (#7851286)
It's both punishment and big business.

http://www.thenation.com/prison-profiteers

Re:Life After 'Life': Aging Inmates Struggle For Redemption by rayiner on Thursday June 05, 2014 @08:56AM (#7851672)
Only about 8% of prisoners are held in for-profit prisons: http://www.propublica.org/article/by-the-numbers-the-u.s.s-g.... Moreover, the prison population started exploding long before for-profit prisons arose. The U.S. prison population started exploding in the mid-1970's, as states passed tough-on-crime measures like three strikes' laws in response to dramatic increases in crime rates: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incarceration_in_the_United_Sta.... But even by 1990, only a negligible percentage of U.S. prisoners were in for-profit prisons: https://www.aclu.org/files/assets/bankingonbondage_20111102.....

I strongly oppose for-profit prisons, but the whole "prisons are big business!" trope the NYT likes to trot out is bullshit. For-profit prison companies are opportunists, taking advantage of the trend of growing prison populations combined with the heavy emphasis in the 1990's on trimming the number of public employees.

But CCA didn't create the massive U.S. prison population. Voters did: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three-strikes_law#Enactment_by_.... Frightened suburbanite baby boomers watching the news, shrieking "Just Say No!" at school events, voting for Three Strikes' laws and aggressive drug enforcement. I.e. NYT's core readership.

Re:Life After 'Life': Aging Inmates Struggle For Redemption by saraid216 on Sunday June 08, 2014 @03:59AM (#7864235)
Sorry for the ridiculously late reply; DanBC pointed me here from my comment.

> Only about 8% of prisoners are held in for-profit prisons: http://www.propublica.org/article/by-the-numbers-the-u.s.s-g...

That isn't quite correct. It's 8% as of 2009.

As of 2012, it's actually ~17%. http://www.bjs.gov/index.cfm?ty=pbdetail&iid=4843

> But CCA didn't create the massive U.S. prison population. Voters did

This I absolutely agree with.

> Frightened suburbanite baby boomers watching the news, shrieking "Just Say No!" at school events, voting for Three Strikes' laws and aggressive drug enforcement. I.e. NYT's core readership.

In your haste to criticize the NYT, did you perhaps miss that such a target audience is precisely who they should be pointing out the deleterious effects of their voting patterns to?

> Here's the thing. A few million is enough to let my mom know that there is a "tough on crime" proposition on the ballot and she should go out and vote. Ten times that much won't convince her that being "tough on crime" is a bad thing, that her granddaughter isn't in constant danger of getting kidnapped and sold into sex trafficking, etc.

Agreed.

But several million to get her to think, "Corporations are using prisons to needlessly jail people"? That could work.

Re:Life After 'Life': Aging Inmates Struggle For Redemption by danielweber on Thursday June 05, 2014 @09:03AM (#7851701)
While I agree in general, there was serious lobbying for the Three Strikes Law by people who stood to gain financially. It may have happened even without their support, but they thought it was worth the payoff to put in millions of dollars.

http://www.npr.org/2009/08/13/111843426/folsom-embodies-cali...

Re:Life After 'Life': Aging Inmates Struggle For Redemption by rayiner on Thursday June 05, 2014 @10:04AM (#7851999)
California's Prop. 184, which is probably the harshest three-strikes law in the country because it doesn't require the third felony to be serious or violent, was a ballot initiative that passed 72-28 in 1994: http://ballotpedia.org/California_Proposition_184,_the_Three.... Washington's Initiative 593 passed 75-25 the year before: http://ballotpedia.org/Washington_%22Three_Strikes%22,_Initi....

You can't get American voters to agree on anything by that kind of margin, other than apparently the idea that you should get life in prison for stealing a few hundred dollars each on three separate occasions.

Honestly, what really irks me about the "prison lobbying" angle is that it's just a way to shirk responsibility. "Oh, it's those lobbyists that are to blame, not my parents, friends, or me."

Re:Life After 'Life': Aging Inmates Struggle For Redemption by danielweber on Thursday June 05, 2014 @10:14AM (#7852056)
That's the one the NPR article talks about (unless there was another in 1994).

Then came the "Three Strikes You're Out" law in 1994. Offenders who had committed even a minor third felony — like shoplifting — got life sentences.

Voters at the time were inundated with television ads, pamphlets and press conferences from Gov. Pete Wilson. "Three strikes is the most important victory yet in the fight to take back our streets," Wilson told crowds.

But behind these efforts to get voters to approve these laws was one major player: the correctional officers union.

In three decades, the California Correctional Peace Officers Association has become one of the most powerful political forces in California. The union has contributed millions of dollars to support "three strikes" and other laws that lengthen sentences and increase parole sanctions. It donated $1 million to Wilson after he backed the three strikes law.

And the result for the union has been dramatic. Since the laws went into effect and the inmate population boomed, the union grew from 2,600 officers to 45,000 officers. Salaries jumped: In 1980, the average officer earned $15,000 a year; today, one in every 10 officers makes more than $100,000 a year.

Lance Corcoran, spokesman for the union, says it does what is best for its members.

"We have advocated successfully for our members," he said.

... EDIT

You also show how it worked in Washington, which is a good comparison. Was there similar lobbying there? (This is an earnest question, I do not know the answer.)

Re:Life After 'Life': Aging Inmates Struggle For Redemption by rayiner on Thursday June 05, 2014 @10:22AM (#7852094)
Here's a story about I-593: https://www.prisonlegalnews.org/news/1996/may/15/citizen-ant.... It took $200k to get on the ballot, apparently funded by the gun lobby. Meanwhile, environmental organizations spend hundreds of millions of dollars a year on persuasion efforts, and can't get shit passed. Persuasion is cheap when people already agree with you.

Here's the thing. A few million is enough to let my mom know that there is a "tough on crime" proposition on the ballot and she should go out and vote. Ten times that much won't convince her that being "tough on crime" is a bad thing, that her granddaughter isn't in constant danger of getting kidnapped and sold into sex trafficking, etc.

Re:Life After 'Life': Aging Inmates Struggle For Redemption by watwut on Saturday June 07, 2014 @04:10PM (#7862956)
You can get multiple strikes from one event I think. So, it is even harsher.
Re:Life After 'Life': Aging Inmates Struggle For Redemption by ANTSANTS on Friday June 06, 2014 @12:13AM (#7856170)
It's not bullshit, because you don't need to own a for-profit prison to profit from the prison-industrial complex. Even non-profit prisons (my, is that a weird phrase) result in the transfer of tax dollars to prison staff, construction workers, suppliers of food, surveillance equipment, and other necessary materials, and so on. Oh, and don't forget cheap prison labor. So clearly, many groups have a vested interest in maintaining and even growing a high prison population.
Re:Life After 'Life': Aging Inmates Struggle For Redemption by gadders on Thursday June 05, 2014 @09:27AM (#7851805)
It should be for punishment and rehabilitation. If there is no punishment, there is no deterrence.
Re:Life After 'Life': Aging Inmates Struggle For Redemption by NoMoreNicksLeft on Thursday June 05, 2014 @09:47AM (#7851916)
Rehabilitation is science fiction. Just because we want it to be possible does not make it possible.

Some convicts do spontaneously change and become rehabilitated, but no one has offered much evidence that they can engineer this change and induce it reliably. And yet the myth persists.

Medical science and psychology have failed to reliably treat much simpler mental illnesses (let alone cure), but somehow they can dig around inside someone's skull and cure something that isn't a mental illness at all, rather the predisposition to make bad, destructive, and illegal choices?

Re:Life After 'Life': Aging Inmates Struggle For Redemption by pointing on Thursday June 05, 2014 @10:47AM (#7852210)
Lots of things were science fiction before they were science. Our ability to treat mental illness today is better than it was 75 years ago.

Why not try to find ways that we can stop paying for people to be in prisons, and instead put them back in society and growing the economy. There is a ton of money put into locking people up. It would pay for itself to figure out how to rehabilitated a small percentage of them.

There are already "twelve step" programs which are mandated by courts. Something that was evidence based would surely work better.

But instead the focus in the US is on punishment, victims rights, three strikes laws and being tough on crime.

Re:Life After 'Life': Aging Inmates Struggle For Redemption by NoMoreNicksLeft on Thursday June 05, 2014 @11:48AM (#7852495)
> Lots of things were science fiction before they were science. Our ability to treat mental illness today is better than it was 75 years ago.

This isn't a counter-argument. Lots of things that were science fiction 50 years ago are still science fiction today.

However, I will keep an open mind. If in the future someone claims to understand rehabilitation and can prove this, I will consider their work/theory. I will not "just try it anyway" today because of wishful thinking.

> Why not try to find ways that we can stop paying for people to be in prisons

Fine by me, as long as it doesn't involve science fiction. I even have some suggestions:

Legalize drugs. Don't decriminalize them. Don't just legalize marijuana either... legalize cocaine, heroin, meth. Pardon everyone for their drug crimes (but not violent crimes associated with drug dealing).

Do this, and you can substantially reduce both the number of people in prison, and the average time spent there. Low level drug dealers won't spend time in prison learning to be psychopaths. Drug users won't commit burglaries and theft trying to pay for their drug habit (if they'll do anything for a fix, anything includes scrubbing toilets).

Of course, this won't happen. People believe the television shows they watch where someone who uses meth once turns into a demon.

> Something that was evidence based would surely work better.

I agree. But this is a problem I think requires a working theory of mind/intelligence. (Funny how it's either another variation of the AI problem, or related to it, eh?) We don't have that.

> But instead the focus in the US is on punishment

This is because we are monkeys. I don't mean metaphorically, but literally. Monkeys have instinctual senses of justice that demand punishment and vengeance and so forth.

If you remove punishment from the equation, this would be bad. The state punishes so that the monkeys will feel as if justice has occurred, and will refrain from performing their own justice.

Do you want revenge killings and vigilanteeism to rise?

Re:Life After 'Life': Aging Inmates Struggle For Redemption by personlurking on Thursday June 05, 2014 @03:59AM (#7850775)
A lot of countries have max sentences which are around '30-40 years'. One also has to consider the fact that a 25-year old, for example, who gets 40 years is basically spending life in prison.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Life_imprisonment#Reform_or_abo...

Re:Life After 'Life': Aging Inmates Struggle For Redemption by trhway on Thursday June 05, 2014 @04:37AM (#7850889)
in case of such sentences - where person is de-facto removed from the society forever, as even the 30-40 years means that the person will be different and the society will change unrecognizable - i see how it would make sense just to send the person to live on some other territory, continent, planet, asteroid, etc...

Long prison terms have 2 functions - deterrent and removing dangerous people from society. Both of this can be accomplished if the place where convicts are to be send is remote and harsh. Such approach would also allow to avoid feeding such a beast as the prison guards union.

Re:Life After 'Life': Aging Inmates Struggle For Redemption by jacquesm on Thursday June 05, 2014 @04:49AM (#7850923)
> i see how it would make sense just to send the person to live on some other territory, continent, planet, asteroid, etc...

And then even your prisons declare independence sooner or later. Look at Australia.

Re:Life After 'Life': Aging Inmates Struggle For Redemption by atroyn on Thursday June 05, 2014 @05:40AM (#7851050)
Australia never declared independence. The Queen of England is our head of state.

In fact, several popular referendums for forming an independent republic have failed.

Re:Life After 'Life': Aging Inmates Struggle For Redemption by jacquesm on Thursday June 05, 2014 @06:09AM (#7851124)
relevant reading:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monarchy_of_Australia

Think of her as being simultaneous monarch of several countries that are now independent of each other.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Australia_Act_1986

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/opinion/we-only-became-indep...

"While the public was not aware of the true position, the politicians were. Political leaders saw the price paid for being colonial dependencies of the British crown and it was too high. After years of negotiations the constitutional links between Australia and Britain were finally broken , not by a referendum but by legislation passed by the state, commonwealth and British parliaments. On March 3, 1986, these acts, the Australia Acts, came into force. They state that the British government is no longer responsible for the government of any state and that the Westminster parliament can no longer legislate for Australia. Most important, they transferred into Australian hands full control of all Australia's constitutional documents. So March 3, 1986, is the day Australia achieved complete independence from Britain. Happy Australian Independence Day."

The Queen of England is also still nominally head of state of Canada. Not that this has much effect in practice.

Re:Life After 'Life': Aging Inmates Struggle For Redemption by jafaku on Thursday June 05, 2014 @05:33AM (#7851033)
What happened there?
Re:Life After 'Life': Aging Inmates Struggle For Redemption by gambiting on Thursday June 05, 2014 @05:41AM (#7851057)
I can't tell if you are being serious,but in case you really don't know, the British Empire used to send its convicts to Australia, as it was a new colony and was in need of as many people as possible. So instead of putting those people in prison, they sent them off to Australia, without the ability to ever come back.
Re:Life After 'Life': Aging Inmates Struggle For Redemption by jafaku on Monday June 09, 2014 @09:20PM (#7871437)
I was being serious, I don't know the entire history of every country. Thanks.
Re:Life After 'Life': Aging Inmates Struggle For Redemption by throwaway_xl5 on Thursday June 05, 2014 @05:50AM (#7851080)
Starting in 1788, Britain used a policy of 'Transportation' to colonies in Australia to relieve overcrowding in its prisons at home. Of course, Australia is now an independent country. The book 'A Commonwealth of Thieves' by Thomas Keneally provides a very readable narrative of the first British people to settle there.
Re:Life After 'Life': Aging Inmates Struggle For Redemption by gadders on Thursday June 05, 2014 @06:38AM (#7851193)
I think there is a case for "whole of life" terms - i.e. never released until they die.
Re:Life After 'Life': Aging Inmates Struggle For Redemption by spingsprong on Thursday June 05, 2014 @05:42AM (#7851058)
How about a murderer who says they'll kill again if they get out?
Re:Life After 'Life': Aging Inmates Struggle For Redemption by gambiting on Thursday June 05, 2014 @05:45AM (#7851066)
Just do what Norway does - maximum sentence is 21 years, and then it's re-reviewed. If the prisoner has rehabilitated, release them - if not,they can extend the sentence by another few years. And then again,and again,and again - as many times as needed, effectively turning it into a life sentence in the case of hardened criminals, but eventually releasing people like the ones mentioned in the article,who have genuinely changed.
Re:Life After 'Life': Aging Inmates Struggle For Redemption by vidarh on Thursday June 05, 2014 @07:22AM (#7851305)
Actually, if you are given 21 years in prison, you are given 21 years. Normally you would then get out on parole after 14, but the maximum you will receive unless you carry out other criminal acts while in prison that warrants a new trial and sentence, is 21 years.

In order for it to be possible to keep the person locked up further, it requires a special sentence - "forvaring" - that is separate from the longest ordinary prison sentence and is intended for use only with prisoners that are deemed to be at particular high risk of reoffending.

The court will set a minimum period that the convicted needs to stay in prison, which should normally not exceed 10 years, and a term after which the prisoner will be regularly reviewed for release, which should normally not exceed 15 years but that can be as long as 21 (at least every 5 years). The prosecution will then go to the courts and request an extension if they believe there's still cause to believe that the person is at great risk of reoffending at the end of the initial term and in advance of the expiry of any extensions.

It was specifically made clear when the changes to the law was made, that it was not generally intended as a life sentence, but in fact that it was expected that at lot of the sentences would have much shorter terms than the maximum. As of 2005 (3 years after introduction of "forvaring") 2/3's of the sentences where it had been given where given with terms less than 10 years.

I don't know, and don't have time to check, how many of these have actually been released, but I know some have been released without extensions to their initial term, even in cases where the court found that there was risk of reoffending, but where the risk was not found to be sufficient to meet the criteria for extending the term.

Re:Life After 'Life': Aging Inmates Struggle For Redemption by serge2k on Thursday June 05, 2014 @07:36AM (#7851344)
Isn't that effectively mandatory parole review after a set time period?
Re:Life After 'Life': Aging Inmates Struggle For Redemption by vidarh on Thursday June 05, 2014 @08:23AM (#7851516)
There's mandatory parole review for normal sentences in Norway too, and it typically happens after 2/3 of the sentencing term, but normal sentences always have a fixed maximum term that can't exceed 21 years.

This special form of sentencing - "forvaring" - is different in that it in theory is open-ended if the person in question is found to be at risk of reoffending. If a sentence of "forvaring" is not given in the original trial, then the prisoner is free at the end of his/her prison term regardless of risk of reoffending, behaviour or other factors.

The decision about whether or not to extend the term for someone given a sentence of "forvaring" is taken by the court, after a review by the prosecutors office, assuming the prosecutor choose to ask for an extension.

The only consideration is the extent of the risk of reoffending - other factors that are often taken into account in normal parole hearings (such as expressing understanding of the crimes, regret etc.) are not normally relevant, as these hearings are not about whether or not the prisoner is eligible to be rewarded with early release, but whether or not there is a proven need for society to extend the incarceration beyond the maximum term set with the original sentence in order to protect peoples safety.