News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OS X Yosemite by AaronFriel on Monday June 02, 2014 @06:07PM (#7836803)
I am deeply disappointed by the "development" of OS X. It seems that Apple has long ago gutted their x86 OS group due to dwindling profits and lack of real competition. There are a handful of reasons people buy a Mac, and I would largely put them into three groups:

* Students looking for a stable and/or sexy device for their university.

* Artists using applications that don't exist on other platforms (or that prioritize Mac platforms).

* Hackers that want a Unix-like system with a BSD userland, or want Anything But Windows on a laptop.

Sadly, these groups are small groups with eclectic needs that won't be met or improved by real systems engineering with the kernel and core modules. What do I mean by real systems engineering?

* Major kernel development

* Novel and/or modern filesystem support

* Fundamental or deeply integrated "platform" features

In Linux land, every major kernel release brings these features. There are tangible improvements to filesystems, to core features that enable new things to be developed on top of them in every Linux release. These are, largely, absent on OS X. The system is too closed, and the result is that things like Time Machine or even security features and ACLs are hacks upon hacks. Full disk encryption and home folder support is, again, hack-ish, and largely built on work other people did. OS snapshots is essentially an "rsync" to another drive with a smart "restore" utility that repairs changes.

The major kernel development that Microsoft undertook with Windows Server 2003 and Vista is still paying dividends. Folder shadow copies became integrated into fully consistent backups with built-in snapshots. Full disk encryption improved - though home folder encryption is still tragically stuck with NTFS "EFS" support (lackluster, at best.) UAC, AppLocker, and integrity levels brought foundational improvements to the security model. Networking stack changes brought DirectAccess, a woefully underused and under-marketed technology. Storage Spaces and ReFS, though years too late, are interesting alternatives to ZFS/BTRFS. Transactional NTFS was woefully underused, but maybe it will return with ReFS. The core improvements Microsoft is making to the NT kernel are still worthwhile, though. Hyper-V is a fantastic technology, and could really blow people's minds when it's baked into the client OS. (For reference, Hyper-V powers the Xbox One's dual app/game personality. It allows isolating the management OS from games running on it, and also keeps the management OS from interfering with game performance with resource limiting. And they both share high performance access to the GPU.) Ah, I could go on. Reading about new stuff in kernel development is a joy.

Of course, I could go on ad nauseum about Linux changes since 3.0x, but http://kernelnewbies.org/ does a better job than I will.

The result is tragic: Microsoft invested in platform features and then didn't sell users on what it could do with Vista. Apple continues to apply lipstick to the OS X pig and sell users on changes to the window manager and built-in applications.

Re:OS X Yosemite by sanderjd on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @12:26AM (#7838149)
I would add a fourth bullet point, which is "casual computer users who are willing to pay a bit extra for a no-hassle PC with good build quality, and don't much care what OS they're using".

> Sadly, these groups are small groups with eclectic needs that won't be met or improved by real systems engineering with the kernel and core modules. What do I mean by real systems engineering?

My fourth group isn't small (though perhaps shrinking due to the popularity of tablets), but also has no need for "real systems engineering". My question is this: who does need that stuff? Isn't it really just administrators of high performance servers?

Don't get me wrong, I plan to have a lot of fun and learn a lot from reading up on all the things you mentioned that I either haven't heard of or know of only as buzzwords, but I just don't see how any of it is relevant to most peoples' interaction with computers. Selling "we changed some superficial design elements in the window manager" really does make more sense.

Re:OS X Yosemite by Angostura on Monday June 02, 2014 @06:28PM (#7836895)
Mavericks introduced a lot of tangible under the hood improvements that perhaps you missed, Ars did a thorough review, perhaps start with how the OS was changed to improve energy consumption: http://arstechnica.com/apple/2013/10/os-x-10-9/12/#energy-sa...
Re:OS X Yosemite by demallien on Monday June 02, 2014 @07:02PM (#7837064)
Yes, linux geeks can school Apple on systems engineering when they can deliver laptops with a better battery life than Macs get. As for this latest release, what, adding a new systems programming language and a whole new graphics API isn't enough?

At least my Mac recognizes and uses a second monitor when I plug it in, unlike the bloody Fedora 19 box that I use at work. And don't get me started on that second graphics card that the system can't figure out how to use! And the wifi Just Works(tm), unlike the Ubuntu laptop that I had before that.

Re:OS X Yosemite by danford on Monday June 02, 2014 @10:08PM (#7837761)
> deliver laptops with a better battery life than Macs get

Well Linux gets better battery life on my laptop than OS X. (11 hours with ubuntu gnome 14.04).

> my Mac recognizes and uses a second monitor when I plug it in

Not mine. And this is a common problem: http://www.imore.com/os-x-mavericks-problems-drive-me-nuts-h...

Also, I had issues with sound going out and not returning until after a reboot on OS X. This drove me nuts.

Thing is your points only apply to OS X if you run it on Apple hardware. If you get ubuntu certified hardware you will have no problem running ubuntu either. Ubuntu is going to run on more devices with less issues simply because the linux kernel is designed to target more hardware than the OS X kernel.

Re:OS X Yosemite by cmiles74 on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @08:39AM (#7839731)
This is a fair point: Apple has carefully selected the hardware that OS X runs on. Most people interested in Linux expect it to support, without issue, whatever laptop happens to be lying around.
Re:OS X Yosemite by Teovald on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @04:50AM (#7844628)
I had the sound issue as well. When I close my laptop lid with an headset plugged in (and especially if I unplug it before opening the lid), Mavericks totally looses track of audio and behave erratically. I have been able to make sound work again by killing the coreaudiod process. it is very brutal, but it works.
Re:OS X Yosemite by the_hangman on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @01:54PM (#7841714)
> Also, I had issues with sound going out and not returning until after a reboot on OS X. This drove me nuts.

This one bothers me endlessly. I got my first Macbook in '09 and have had two others since, and every single one of them has had this problem. I just don't get it.

Re:OS X Yosemite by wting on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @12:40AM (#7838190)
My 15" rMBP running Mavericks randomly reboots on occasion, and to this day still requires me to manually disable / enable WiFi almost every time I open the lid.

Meanwhile Homebrew is a poor substitute for aptitude and PPAs, multi-monitor support is relatively poor (xmonad excels here), and the Apple keyboard is missing a bunch of keys I use on a regular basis.

Re:OS X Yosemite by kyle_t on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @10:38AM (#7840441)
This. People sing to the heavens of how stable OSX is and how it just works. I've had as many if not more issues than with my Windows 7 Samsung laptop.

Wifi constantly needs manually disabling/enabling, Bluetooth Audio crashes are common, I average one full system crash per month, display settings reset themselves magically and Finder is infuriating. I should be keeping a log of all the issues I have.

This is on a 2014 Macbook Pro.

Re:OS X Yosemite by capedape on Thursday June 05, 2014 @01:30AM (#7850370)
Latest Macbook Pro here and have that same WIFI issue. I still have 5 year old Lenovo with windows 7 on it that is just as, if not more, stable than the Mac.

On Mac things like Alfred (probably will drop this for the new spotlight), better touch tool, some capabilities like ability to swap USB MIDI controllers without restarting OS are cool. Honestly though, performance wise there isn't that much difference between my Mac and Win Machines and being in programs full screen most of the day I notice much difference at all. The really flexible information moving things I've grown accustomed to on Win seem a bit crippled on Mac because of lack of a filesystem.

Re:OS X Yosemite by mannkind on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @07:32PM (#7843308)
Ah, the mythical 2014 Macbook Pro...
Re:OS X Yosemite by untog on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @10:20AM (#7840327)
There was a time, not that long ago, when I saw a kernel panic maybe once in a year at most. These days I see them every few weeks.
Re:OS X Yosemite by coob on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @04:32AM (#7838736)
There's a fix for the Wifi issue - trashing your bluetooth prefs. Solved it for me: http://www.imore.com/how-fix-mavericks-wi-fi-zapping-bluetoo...
Re:OS X Yosemite by untog on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @10:18AM (#7840315)
That's still awful, though. Why should I have to go to imore.com to fix an issue in my OS? This has been in OSX since launch and Apple hasn't fixed it. Mad.
Re:OS X Yosemite by wting on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @07:25PM (#7843292)
Thanks! I've tried finding a solution multiple times but I guess my Google-fu wasn't up to the task.
Re:OS X Yosemite by raverbashing on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @11:45AM (#7840873)
Yeah, unfortunately Mavericks is really bad

I'm back on 10.8.5 and not in a rush to upgrade again (because Mavericks crapped itself and I had to restore from Time Machine)

Re:OS X Yosemite by pling on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @02:43AM (#7838464)
Same with mine and audio. coreaudiod just shits itself 5 times a day.

I'm now on Debian 7 with XFCE on an old Think Pad. Life is better here.

Re:OS X Yosemite by shaan7 on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @01:45AM (#7838337)
Dell XPS Ultrabook with Kubuntu 14.04 here, without any patches or extra settings. 11W consumption with medium screen brightness, works for ~5 hours with normal browsing (occasional compiling)

Recognizes all monitors and projectors (even the ones Macs fail at) at my work place. The WiFi just works (TM).

You are not using a "Ubuntu laptop". As danford said, just pick a Ubuntu certified machine* and things will just work (TM). And, you will still have more choice than OSX ;)

* http://www.ubuntu.com/certification/desktop/

Re:OS X Yosemite by apendleton on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @01:58AM (#7838368)
Sorry, but 5 hours on an ultrabook is not competitive. Current Macbook Airs are rated for 12 hours with normal use, and third-party testing has found 10 to be realistic.

demallien is right. Nobody on the Linux side has done this kind of aggressive power engineering for consumer-oriented x86 hardware. Google might, for Chromebooks, but it's not clear how portable that will be to the rest of the ecosystem.

Re:OS X Yosemite by serf on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @03:27AM (#7838549)
It just depends on the 'linux side of things' group your talking about. My T420s runs a full featured GNOME desktop on Arch at 5.5w idle, 7w browsing, 10w loaded. 136 watt hours total battery capacity with three batteries.

"Hours" is a really poor way to gauge these things, because while it may seem practically applicable , we're really comparing apples and oranges.

My T420 before my T420s had a battery run-time of 15 hours. I could fail to mention that it had a slice battery and an ultrabay on top of the primary battery and tell everyone that the particular model and OS ran for 15 hours straight, but that would be disingenuous. If I was a marketer I could run the processor at lower voltages, dim the screen unread-ably, turn WiFi off, etc etc until I got whatever numbers I wanted.

As i'm not a marketer, I also feel as if the claims people make about Apple's hardware being better at power management are also somewhat dishonest.

They are a company that has ultimate say in their hardware platform and software ecosystem. No other computer company locks down production that much in an effort to increase the individual experience of each consumer. That lock-down allows for an amount of control that would be unrealistic to expect from the FLOSS community, as they have little power or say in production and ultimately must code to support a wider range of people rather than a narrow set of known hardware packages that are available.

My point : optimizing narrowly for a single platform is much easier than the opposite; a more fair comparison of battery life would be watts-per-hour usage during a standardized testing/benchmarking suite of some sort, along with the watt hours of battery capacity(although historically handset manufacturers have sidestepped that issue by having the software recognize when it's being benchmarked..). "Hours of use" could be practical if it wasn't arbitrarily inflated or deflated by uncommon usage profile testing and specialty optimizations for the sake of marketing a bigger number.

It's not impossible to get good numbers out of a Linux build, it's just fairly difficult for someone unfamiliar with the system (and sometimes impossible without doing the work yourself with certain hardware stacks). There exists a whole subspecies of Linux users that are somewhat akin to hypermillers who turn this kind of dilemma into a game and compete for lowest wattage.

Re:OS X Yosemite by virtualritz on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @08:08AM (#7839574)
Apple states 9h for a contemporary 13" MBP. Mine (two weeks old) runs for 4h max, if I do any serious work on it. If I switch Wifi off an dim the screen, I can get 6-7h out of it.

The machine is dual boot as I'm using it to develop software that targets both OS X & Linux. I run a Gentoo with all kernel- and other power saving features enabled, on a 2nd partition.

The time I get out of the battery on OS X vs Gentoo is pretty much the same.

What I do is "surf" (FF, mostly text/reading docs, flash blocked etc.) and code (I do a build roughly every 5-10mins that will probably touch 10 sources max).

Build environment matches except for compiler being used (gcc 4.1 on Linux, latest LLVM gcc frontend from XCode on OS X but I would think this is minor).

Bottom line for me: Linux is on par with OS X in terms of time you get out of a MBP, in my case specifically.

Caveat: I dunno ofc, how true this is, generally, if one ran something like a pre-configured Ubuntu kernel.

Re:OS X Yosemite by olavgg on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @10:31AM (#7840396)
I have a shiny new MBP too, but I have no problems getting 9-10 hours from it by just browsing the web(with safari) and watching videos.

IntelliJ however eats some of my battery pwoer, but I still manage 7 hours or full work day.

Re:OS X Yosemite by orbifold on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @03:45AM (#7844437)
Safari is less power hungry than Firefox.
Re:OS X Yosemite by pling on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @02:45AM (#7838467)
I get 5 hours on a 5 year old ThinkPad with a 5 year old battery on Debian 7. I reckon it can be done.
Re:OS X Yosemite by marincounty on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @10:04AM (#7840218)
I have a MBP(2 years old) and a Mac desktop(4 years old), but I spend most of my time on a decade old Toshiba Satellite 025-S607 using xp.
Re:OS X Yosemite by cgh on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @11:33AM (#7840799)
I used an Ubuntu certified desktop (well, laptop) and things did not just work (TM). It generally failed to recognise my second monitor unless I opened the system settings, then closed it. It also failed to recover from sleep on a regular basis and got terrible battery life. Needless to say, I ditched Ubuntu. I think it's junk, to be quite honest.

I'm using Crunchbang on that laptop now and it's mostly better.

Re:OS X Yosemite by kybernetyk on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @09:14AM (#7839935)
> 11W consumption with medium screen brightness

That's a lot actually. Current MBAs are around 5 watts with full screen brightness.

Re:OS X Yosemite by johnchristopher on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @04:32AM (#7838734)
> At least my Mac recognizes and uses a second monitor when I plug it in, unlike the bloody Fedora 19 box that I use at work. And don't get me started on that second graphics card that the system can't figure out how to use! And the wifi Just Works(tm), unlike the Ubuntu laptop that I had before that.

For what it's worth my debian wheezy laptop detects second monitor just fine (and I am using awesome-wm) while my 2007 iMac randomly lose internet though it's connected to my routeur via wifi. So... data points.

Re:OS X Yosemite by dmix on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @10:22AM (#7840337)
> At least my Mac recognizes and uses a second monitor when I plug it in

This is mostly a solved problem in linux these days. Macbooks have consistent and quality hardware. It's no surpised they work well. If you use a mainstream laptop or PC parts, it will 100% work with Linux. Using cheap noname parts or manufacturers with poor software support then you'll have issues.

For example, Macbooks + Fedora 19 work perfectly. So does the 3 Lenovos I tried and a Dell XPS.

Re:OS X Yosemite by peedy on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @10:29AM (#7840385)
> At least my Mac recognizes and uses a second monitor when I plug it in, unlike the bloody Fedora 19 box that I use at work. And don't get me started on that second graphics card that the system can't figure out how to use! And the wifi Just Works(tm), unlike the Ubuntu laptop that I had before that.

You can write a udev rule for that

Re:OS X Yosemite by raverbashing on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @10:45AM (#7840479)
> You can write a udev rule for that

Yes, please, let me spend time fixing distro BS instead of, you know, working.

I don't remember any time when Wifi worked out-of-the-box in my previous Linux laptop. It worked if I did things manually (wpa-supplicant and stuff), the NM widget? Never worked and made things harder

Another issue: opening and closing the lid doesn't have a consistent result, and sometimes it just keeps the laptop running.

This is for the basic functionality, and sometimes even things that worked before stop working.

Older distros had to be more manually configured, but when that was done it was good to go, today it is even harder to shut down the non-working stuff.

So yeah, it's Mac for me from now on. Recovery from Time Machine needed some "Linux style hacking" once, but apart from that it's a breeze

Re:OS X Yosemite by chanced on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @12:07PM (#7841006)
Lucky you. A lot of us were left with massive paperweights after 10.9.2 dropped: https://www.google.com/search?q=osx+10.9.2+monitor+site:disc...
Re:OS X Yosemite by dalanmiller on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @09:34AM (#7840051)
I have but one upvote to give you sir in distinguishing the reality of high quality Apple products vs Linux fanboyism.
Re:OS X Yosemite by sergiosgc on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @12:01PM (#7840963)
My Thinkpad X1 Carbon draws something between 6W and 16W between idle and moderate use. I never measured it at full load. Perfectly acceptable, and way competitive with the equivalent Macbook Air, which draws 25W idle.

So, I guess, per your definition, that Linux geeks can school Apple today.

Re:OS X Yosemite by eatfish on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @01:21PM (#7841488)
Stop pulling numbers out your ass. The specs for the MBA are online and it draws 6.5W with the display on.
Re:OS X Yosemite by sergiosgc on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @03:44PM (#7842306)
Numbers reported by powertop
Re:OS X Yosemite by alexqgb on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @12:28AM (#7838153)
My 2010 MBP, which is obviously getting long in the tooth, saw its battery life double with the Mavericks upgrade. That alone made the transition worth while. Plus, there were a ton of small refinements that I got used to very quickly.

I didn't notice how quickly until I switched back to a Snow Leopard install I maintain for Final Cut Studio (don't get me started on FCP X). All of a sudden the old OS felt...outdated. Totally reliable, sure. But not quite as friendly.

One unexpected change is that Safari has become my favorite browser. Its integration with the OS and iOS, plus the integration of iOS and OS X gave it an edge that Chrome and FF can't match. Judging from what was revealed today, it's looks like that kind of seamless transition between devices is what we can expect a lot more of.

Re:OS X Yosemite by bratsche on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @02:09AM (#7838391)
I think my Mac is a 2011, but I saw a similar thing when I upgraded to Mavericks. I've been pretty happy with it for the most part.

More recently I saw massive power savings by switching browsers. I love Chrome, I love its UI, I love its web devel tools. But even when I only have a few tabs open my Mac's fans just won't stop spinning. :( I kind of swapped back and forth between Safari and Firefox since then, but mostly settled on Firefox. I may give Safari another chance when I install Yosemite.

Re:OS X Yosemite by rayiner on Monday June 02, 2014 @06:15PM (#7836845)
Snow Leopard was the last major kernel guts release, and it wasn't that long ago. OS X is a mature, client oriented OS. They add new API's, etc, and make lots of little improgements continuously, but what more is there to do?

I haven't felt the urge to check out the release notes for a Linux kernel release in years. Wake me up when they get VM hooks to speed up GC or something. The new developments just aren't that relevant on a client machine.

Re:OS X Yosemite by lucian1900 on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @04:24AM (#7838706)
The filesystem is the worst of all modern platforms. It's in dire need of an upgrade, which doesn't appear to be coming.
Re:OS X Yosemite by npinguy on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @04:36AM (#7838749)
While I agree, I think Apple's core demographics does not want to think about the file system. There are enough abstractions created by the apps to the point that users don't think about where their files are at all.

It's not how I want to operate either, but that's the direction Apple has been heading to for a long time

Re:OS X Yosemite by surreal on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @06:10AM (#7839125)
Although they do seem to be backtracking on this stance with yesterday's iCloud Drive announcement [1], giving access to the filesystem they've been trying to hide away for the last few years

[1] http://m.techradar.com/news/software/applications/apple-chal...

Re:OS X Yosemite by oneeyedpigeon on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @04:46AM (#7838783)
Aside from:

- silly mixed-case directories with spaces

- case-insensitive filenames

what negative aspects of the filesystem would affect an 'intermediate' user (e.g. a high-level hacker) on a day-to-day basis? Admittedly, those two are very frustrating, but I'm struggling to think of any others.

Re:OS X Yosemite by gnaffle on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @05:36AM (#7838979)
If you Mac loses power and doesn't get to do a normal shutdown, you're eventually going to get file system errors that you can only fix by booting from a recovery disk. I've had this happen numerous times due to a broken battery on my laptop. If you've never ever run a disk repair on your Mac, do one and you might be surprised. You should expect more from a filesystem in 2014.
Re:OS X Yosemite by orkoden on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @09:12AM (#7839921)
Re:OS X Yosemite by Shivetya on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @08:49AM (#7839770)
how about locking my entire system when it wakes externally connected USB drives, namely my time machine. Oddly it seems to occur while I surf.

That and permissions seem to get screwy at times. I had a long running issue where I could not launch JAR files, found others with similar issues and finally figured out, I no longer had permission to my own user folder and the JAR I was launching needed to create a working directory. Ended up solving the problem for more than myself.

I still try to figure out the desire for case sensitivity in about anything

Re:OS X Yosemite by gsnedders on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @12:07PM (#7841009)
There has been a case-sensitive variant of HFS+ supported for a decade now.
Re:OS X Yosemite by archagon on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @08:56AM (#7839810)
Man, I sure hope Apple's next FS keeps both of those features. I think most ordinary users find them very valuable.
Re:OS X Yosemite by Osmium on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @12:31PM (#7841178)
It's disappointing to see this comment at the top of this thread considering the amount of work that Apple has poured into OS X over the last few years. Criticism is great, but comments like "Apple continues to apply lipstick to the OS X pig" just seem hyperbolic and unhelpful. For example, one of your specific criticisms is that their FDE solution is "hack-ish" but I have no idea why you'd think that, e.g. look up Core Storage (which is what enables their FDE support and their Fusion drives) and their security whitepaper on how the FDE works under the hood. It looks like a well-thought out and developed feature to me. I also don't understand why, e.g., students, artists and hackers-who-like-unix are considered examples of "small groups with eclectic needs" when really those three groups together probably make up a large chunk of OS X's user base, so it makes sense that development would be focused towards them?
Re:OS X Yosemite by snowwrestler on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @09:32AM (#7840040)
There's some sort of weird double standard being applied in this post. Linux and Windows internals are named and enumerated in great detail, but none of the recent developments of OS X are (see, for example, the Siracusa reviews on ArsTechnica). Is it possible you're just more familiar with the details of Linux and Windows internals?

Just one example:

Mac: > Full disk encryption and home folder support is, again, hack-ish, and largely built on work other people did.

Windows: > Full disk encryption improved - though home folder encryption is still tragically stuck with NTFS "EFS" support (lackluster, at best.)

Somehow this supposed to show that Windows is doing it better than Mac?

Re:OS X Yosemite by tim333 on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @07:46AM (#7839468)
>Microsoft invested in platform features and then didn't sell users on what it could do with Vista.

I think you are focusing on features that are unimportant to most users. People hated Vista because it was so slow, clunky and crashed. I remain amazed that between clicking a folder an seeing a file within it can take about a minute on my friends old Vista machine. I'm also pleasantly surprised on my MacBook that it pretty much never freezes and resumes from sleep in about 2 secs with going wrong unlike any windows machine. What counts for users is how the machine works, not whether the underlying implementation is trendy, I think.

Re:OS X Yosemite by Amezarak on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @03:20PM (#7842202)
Did your friend buy a Vista machine with roughly equivalent hardware?

I dropped $1200 on a Vista laptop (Inspiron 1520) back in 2006/2007. It wasn't slow (Kubuntu on the same HW was faster though) and I don't recall it ever crashing. Sleep worked reliably although it was more on the order of 30 seconds with a spinning disk. I very much preferred it to XP at the time mainly for the the start menu improvements. I think a lot of the Vista issues - and to a larger extent, complaints about Windows - come down to subpar hardware. It's my suspicion that if you pay less than $1000 for a laptop it's probably not very good except on paper.

I am still using that laptop today - to write this post in fact. About a year ago I replaced the harddrive with an SSD. I can't speak about Vista performance since I installed 8 (now 8.1 Update 1 or whatever nonsense MS calls the latest Windows), but sleep is extremely fast; the instant I open the lid everything is usable.

Re:OS X Yosemite by cmiles74 on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @08:42AM (#7839743)
I believe that compelling end-user features could be developed on top of the work Microsoft has done on their kernel. A good part of what's missing is somehow selling developers on these platform features. And, of course, Microsoft should lead the way and leverage this tech themselves.
Re:OS X Yosemite by joshdance on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @10:23AM (#7840348)
You are probably not their target market. Apple makes machines that just work. 99% of the world doesn't know what a kernel is and doesn't care. They just want computers to work.
Re:OS X Yosemite by justincormack on Tuesday June 03, 2014 @04:31AM (#7838730)
I assumed a few years ago that they would move to mainstream FreeBSD, but it has never happened. It would be the easiest thing to migrate to, and is way ahead of OSX.
Re:OS X Yosemite by orbifold on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @02:58AM (#7844338)
I think your complaints are misguided. In terms of desktop usability and feature integration Mac OS X beats any Linux installation I've ever used. This is what most people care about, not how many file descriptors there can be at once. In terms of backup, Time Machine together with a Time Capsule is the only backup system my dad has ever consistently used so far. It does not matter if there are superior solutions for more advanced users, as long as there is no dead simple solution. To my knowledge there is no linux distribution that offers something as simple out of the box.

OS X sort of lacks in default command line tools, but that can be fixed rather easily. I also feel that as Windows 8 compared to OS X loses easily both for Design and Usability, Windows 7 came closer. There are obvious limitations to the approach of all desktop operating systems and for that matter the whole "desktop" and "application" metaphor, compared to systems like the Lisp Machine. Ideally a power user would have access to a fully programmable system, without prepackaged applications and type directed interactions.