News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fraudulent trading activity at Mt. Gox by antonius on Sunday May 25, 2014 @01:35PM (#7796906)
Further proof that the absurd run-up in November when bitcoin reached $1,200 was illegitimate.
Re:Fraudulent trading activity at Mt. Gox by drcode on Sunday May 25, 2014 @02:17PM (#7797026)
Unfortunately this is plausible: The only reliable way to trigger a run-up in a commodity is to expend a lot of capital to acquire that asset at inflated prices- You'd have to "burn through" a lot of money to get this to happen.

...so, then where was this cache of money that was destroyed to inflate the price? It would have to be a pretty large quantity to have such a drastic impact.

Occam's Razor to me suggests the answer is obvious: The vaporized deposits of MtGox users are the most obvious large cache of money, large enough to cause such a run up.

The next question is, who would do this, and why? The answer suggested by Occam's razor would be "Someone who could modify the MtGox database to create nonexistent fiat currency, but could not (or did not want to) create fake MtGox bitcoin holdings." This is because a person with this power would have reason to trade the "fake fiat" with legitimate bitcoin holders to generate bitcoins that can be leeched out of the site, and this would certainly cause the price to rise.

This doesn't answer however whether it was an inside or external party, I could imagine scenarios both with or without inside actors that would lead to this kind of activity. (Though I'd put my bet on internal fraud, based on the fact that so much effort was put into hiding the fraud and extending it over a long period, as opposed to going for quick profit.)

Re:Fraudulent trading activity at Mt. Gox by qnr on Sunday May 25, 2014 @09:40PM (#7798318)
Doesn't seem obvious to me at all. As a result of bankruptcy proceedings we know that Mtgox has lost primarily BTC deposits, not fiat (on mobile now, but IIRC only $27 million USD was lost which is peanuts compared to the value of lost BTC)

In other words, the situation at Mtgox was the opposite of what you describe: it had a lot of FakeBTC, bit its USD reserves were mostly real.

Re:Fraudulent trading activity at Mt. Gox by c0ldfusi0nz on Sunday May 25, 2014 @02:45PM (#7797123)
Whether or not the run-up was "legitimate" in your eyes is inconsequential - the exchange rate ran up to the point that the market could no longer bear, then crashed back to reality. Does the run-up's legitimacy somehow make the current exchange rate illegitimate? I think not.
Re:Fraudulent trading activity at Mt. Gox by sillysaurus3 on Sunday May 25, 2014 @02:56PM (#7797169)
Actually, the rate ran up to the point that Mt. Gox could no longer bear. Unfortunately, it's rather easy to start an exchange and get people using it (or at least, it's no more difficult than any other startup) so there will probably always be companies willing to manipulate the market for personal gain. And since every popular exchange's price affects every other, manipulation from one will manipulate the price at all the rest.

The modern day bitcoin trader should carefully consider whether they want to be a part of a market where the largest actors aren't bound by the rules they set for everyone else.

Re:Fraudulent trading activity at Mt. Gox by drcode on Sunday May 25, 2014 @03:03PM (#7797195)
Though I agree somewhat with your argument, a true "legitimate market" requires full transparency by all parties without people trading on insider info.

In this case, however, only some parties knew that MtGox's internal accounting was broken. Therefore, the price run up may have been "illegitimate" for a limited time period based on this asymmetry of information.

You are right though that over the long term a market price is always "legitimate" by definition, because of the maxim "something is worth whatever someone is willing to pay for it."

Re:Fraudulent trading activity at Mt. Gox by waterlesscloud on Sunday May 25, 2014 @05:56PM (#7797731)
So why did it crash? Why didn't the fraudster just prop up the price?
Re:Fraudulent trading activity at Mt. Gox by bronson on Sunday May 25, 2014 @07:52PM (#7798055)
Because no fraudster can prop it up indefinitely. Gotta lock in your profits before the crash.
Re:Fraudulent trading activity at Mt. Gox by dylanhassinger on Sunday May 25, 2014 @07:40PM (#7798022)
like all ponzi schemes, it relied on new users getting sucked in. As other exchanges grew and Mt Gox doubts spread, I imagine their growth rate dropped.
Re:Fraudulent trading activity at Mt. Gox by boyaka on Sunday May 25, 2014 @08:39PM (#7798183)
Bitcoin has been pumped up and crashed 3 times. The fraudulent trading of Mt. Gox was only the most recent crash.
Re:Fraudulent trading activity at Mt. Gox by ok_craig on Sunday May 25, 2014 @09:54PM (#7798349)
According to the actual post, it was at least the last 2 times.
Re:Fraudulent trading activity at Mt. Gox by boyaka on Monday May 26, 2014 @05:57AM (#7799206)
Depends on what you consider a crash. IMO it crashed in November and hasn't had it's next climb yet.