News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The desktop and the developer by harel on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @08:14AM (#7772115)
I just don't get how OSX is so popular with a developers. It is essentially a "user's" OS. Not a developer one. Its geared towards, and hides a lot from, the common user. Setting up OSX with all the dev stack is usually a painful experience requiring a few workarounds (I see this with colleagues of mine who wanted a Mac over a Thinkpad with Linux). The keyboard as well is anythign but developer friendly. Where are those damn Page Up/Down keys? Yes the hardware itself looks nice, albeit a bit outdated to my liking, and you pay a silly premium for it. It breaks more often than it should, and those shiny screens just don't fit code (to my matte liking eyes anyway). But hey, its trendy and hip so why not.
Re:The desktop and the developer by danieldk on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @02:29PM (#7774274)
I just don't get how OSX is so popular with a developers. It is essentially a "user's" OS.

I have been a Linux user from 1994 to 2007 (mostly Slackware, some Debian and CentOS later), Mac from 2007. I switched to OS X, because: (1) I don't want to mess with hardware and drivers anymore; (2) I don't want to update my whole operating system to update applications; (3) in my work environment people do use Microsoft Office et al.,; (4) the hardware is nice; and (5) I have nothing against Windows, but it is not a UNIX, so not for me.

If some of the advantages go away, I'd be happy to switch back to Linux.

Re:The desktop and the developer by sonofsam on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @04:45PM (#7775067)
| (2) I don't want to update my whole operating system to update applications;

This is huge. IMO, this is the purpose of an operating system. I want to install applications, I do not want to waste time installing new versions of my operating system.

The main focus of Linux distributions should be to make as many applications as possible available to the user and make them easily available.

That being said, Docker has changed this a bit for me, but most Linux distributions still fall flat on their faces when it comes to installing non-packaged applications. Sometimes I find myself having to download applications from websites, manually configure them or even compile software myself.

Basically, the file system hierarchy should had been versioned from the start:

  /
    programs
       vim
          7.1
          7.2
          7.3
Instead, you have a single 'vim' binary that gets overwritten if you try to install another version of vim (unless someone renamed the binary for you).

The FHS is a disaster that every distribution tries to implement differently: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Filesystem_Hierarchy_Standard

Re:The desktop and the developer by krakensden on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @12:23AM (#7776690)
Gobolinux implements exactly this.

It's never really taken off.

Re:The desktop and the developer by harel on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @05:29PM (#7775350)
I don't understand what you mean by "updating the operating system to update applications". In Ubuntu, for example, my apps are updates as soon as new versions are out. If I want a major version upgrade, in some cases, I can also add particular repos that track those apps... I have not compiled anything in Linux for so long I don't even remember what/when was the last time.
Re:The desktop and the developer by crimsonalucard on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @02:47AM (#7776985)
(2) I don't want to update my whole operating system to update applications;

There are some popular linux distros out there that have rolling updates so you never have to reinstall the os.

Re:The desktop and the developer by pjmlp on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @03:13AM (#7777031)
Which tend to break the whole OS every now and then.
Re:The desktop and the developer by mhitza on Friday May 23, 2014 @08:45PM (#7792191)
Had that happen once around the time Fedora pushed systemd (version 13/14 I think), no other upgrading issues since.
Re:The desktop and the developer by GrinningFool on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @02:00PM (#7774087)
I think it's pretty specifically popular with developers in the start-up space.

I suspect the majority of developers (outside of this few percent in the startup space) continue to use Linux and/or Windows. They just don't go around writing blog posts that start out by presenting opinions about usability of other OS's as fact.

Re:The desktop and the developer by VintageCool on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @12:32AM (#7776710)
Macbook laptops were insanely popular 6-8 years ago. They had the best hardware, well integrated software, and access to the bash shell and all the favorite unix utilities. OSX had support for Internet Explorer and Linux didn't really.

All of the Ruby on Rails web developers switched to Macbooks at that time.

The author sees all of these people using OS X and wonders why they would pick Mac now over Linux now, but that's the wrong question. The reason that everyone is using Macbooks is because everyone picked Apple six years ago.

Notice that this thread is full of people who switched to OS X laptops in 2007, but they no longer see the competitive advantage and they're switching back to Linux.

http://paulgraham.com/mac.html

http://paulgraham.com/microsoft.html

Re:The desktop and the developer by mnem on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @08:21AM (#7772150)
Hang on - it's been trendy for a decade now? That's pretty good marketing.

Maybe, just maybe, different developers enjoy coding in different ways.

Re:The desktop and the developer by harel on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @11:10AM (#7772949)
I never said the hardware was bad, not detracted from any developer's preference to use a mac. I just expressed my opinion. Yes, its true that the apple hardware is very nice, but at the same time, it was much nicer 10 years ago. Today its just stuff I'd expect from any laptop. There is on groundbreaking changes any more. And good marketing - you bet! The best marketing there is. Its herd mentality taken to the extreme. Have you seen an apple store on launch day?
Re:The desktop and the developer by mnem on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @04:34PM (#7775003)
Then I apologise for misreading your comment as a judgement on the valid uses of a Mac rather than it being your personal opinion.
Re:The desktop and the developer by keypusher on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @03:11AM (#7777028)
Because I have a data center full of nodes for when I need horsepower and a big fancy desktop with multiple monitors and a desk and a chair and a keyboard for when I need do serious development. What I want out of a laptop is a great form factor, solid battery life, a good keyboard, a large trackpad, a web browser and a real terminal. I own a 13-inch MacBook Air, it cost $1000 brand new, so no I didn't pay any premium for what I got. If you disagree please link equivalent specced hardware with a fully aluminum unibody case, high quality backlit keyboard, large trackpad with multitouch that has equivalent weight, screen size, and battery life. It does not break more often than it should, in fact it has never broken at all. The screen is not overly shiny and it fits my code just fine. But hey, you're already convinced otherwise so why bother.
Re:The desktop and the developer by kayoone on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @06:10AM (#7777422)
unless you need a halfway decent GPU for you work, then you are bound to the top of the line $2600 rMBP. Thats the main problem with apple, very limited choices.
Re:The desktop and the developer by pjmlp on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @09:02AM (#7777945)
This is one of the reasons I still take Windows over Mac OS X.

Those Intel GPUs are a no-go.

Re:The desktop and the developer by FeloniousHam on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @09:50AM (#7778174)
I was all in for Ubuntu on my home machines (Windows at work, of course), but OSX was a revelation. For core development stuff, Ubuntu is great-- I'm still a fan of Unity, apt-get, build-essential-- but as soon as I want/need to dabble in human-level tooling (basically anything with graphics), Linux falls down. The apps just aren't there, and if they are, they're not well maintained. Even the most actively developed Free apps just aren't as aesthetically pleasing in either the UI or in performance.

OSX makes me happy. The apps are considered and cared for by their makers, largely I believe, because they get paid for their time and ingenuity.

Libre works great for APIs, not so much for Ape-y eyes :).

Re:The desktop and the developer by dredmorbius on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @01:48AM (#7776872)
Weight has a lot to do with it. The first Macbooks, and the the Macbook Air, were far, far lighter than equivalently provisioned x86 systems. The disparity's gotten better, but you still have HP and Dell putting out boat anchors compared with Apple.

Lenovo's between the two. My T520i isn't flyweight, but it does OK (the power supply is a brick though). I've eyed the Carbon but have passed on it to date.

Re:The desktop and the developer by kelseyfrancis on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @02:26AM (#7776951)
The Dell XPS 15 [1] weighs around 4.5 pounds, has a higher-resolution display than a Retina MacBook Pro, a comparable i7 quad-core, 16 gb ram, etc. It also has excellent Linux support (source: I have one that I installed Fedora 20 on and everything worked without any tinkering).

There don't seem to be any other options comparable to a MacBook Pro for hardware. In particular, very, very few laptops that aren't enormous and heavy have a quad-core processor.

[1] http://www.dell.com/us/p/xps-15-9530/pd

Re:The desktop and the developer by dredmorbius on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @07:25AM (#7777623)
I'll grant that I may be dissing Dell and HP in part on the basis of their more downmarket and/or "desktop replacement" laptops which tend toward the boat-anchor characteristics.

On a vaguely related note, one aspect of Dells I've found particularly annoying is their implementation of the Trackpoint. While available as an option on some laptops, I found that the rubber used on the nub was harder, and far more irritating to my index finger, than that used on Thinkpads. It's almost comical that user satisfaction could come down to an issue such as this, but over the several months I was using a company-issued Dell, I found that to be a constant annoyance. I tried sanding down the bumps on top, substituting a spare Thinkpad nub (the bases are sized differently, it didn't fit), and a few other tricks. Ended up with blisters on my finger.

The 13" MBA weighs 2.96lb, the 11" (too small for my blood) 2.38: https://www.apple.com/macbook-air/specs.html

Lenovo's Carbon X1 is 3.09lb: https://www.lenovo.com/shop/americas/content/pdf/system_data...

Though here it's claimed "starting at 2.8 lb": http://shop.lenovo.com/us/en/laptops/thinkpad/x-series/x1-ca...

The Lenovo also sports a 14" display, your Dell a 15".

Re:The desktop and the developer by kayoone on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @06:23AM (#7777463)
I heard many people complain about coil whine in these models. Also does this support GPU switching under Linux and does sleep/hibernate etc work without issues ?
Re:The desktop and the developer by kelseyfrancis on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @11:01AM (#7778589)
I've haven't experienced the whine myself, but I've seen those complaints too.

GPU switching is the one thing I haven't really tried yet. I've stuck with the Intel chip. I've read that people have had success with Bumblebee. In fairness, I've also had a MacBook Pro with Fedora 19 on it, and GPU switching didn't work there either.

Suspend/resume work without issue, but I haven't installed the proprietary NVIDIA drivers yet, and those have a tendency to mess up resume (at least it did on my MBP w/ Fedora 19).

I _imagine_ NVIDIA drivers + suspend/resume works just fine with Ubuntu. Any "non-free" drivers in Fedora are pretty iffy in my experience. Usually after installing the NVIDIA drivers from RPM Fusion GDM won't even start, or you have to edit the GRUB menu item to blacklist nouveau, or any number of things the package should theoretically take care of for you. I've not had that problem with Ubuntu (just other problems, like a UEFI install on say a MBP, something Fedora does flawlessly).

These are the kinds of reasons people just use Windows or OS X I guess.

Re:The desktop and the developer by CmonDev on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @08:27AM (#7772175)
"I just don't get how OSX is so popular with a developers" It is not until there is a reliable statistics report.
Re:The desktop and the developer by harel on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @11:13AM (#7772972)
I just see it often at the hands of devs. At my work we got everyone a Thinkpad running Ubuntu, but some wanted Macs and they got them. At the end of the day, this is a theological discussion influenced mostly by emotion. Pretty much a zero sum game - these are all tools best used at the hands of those who use them.
Re:The desktop and the developer by jcastro on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @02:41PM (#7774353)
That's easy. Go to any Linux or tech/developer conference. Most attendees will have Macs running OSX.
Re:The desktop and the developer by kayoone on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @06:26AM (#7777473)
Go to a .NET/Java or game developer conference. Most attendees will have PCs running Windows.
Re:The desktop and the developer by _random_ on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @03:20PM (#7774617)
That's the smallest group of developers who are using a mainstream OS.
Re:The desktop and the developer by smrtinsert on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @04:00PM (#7774836)
Most devs I've seen on macs use vim, which not to get into a flamewar, seems obsessed with turning into emacs in about 10 years or so. It seems to be completely bandwagon to me.
Re:The desktop and the developer by pjmlp on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @03:11AM (#7777027)
> I just don't get how OSX is so popular with a developers.

OS X and iOS users also need software that someone has to write.