News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by mortenjorck on Thursday May 15, 2014 @01:48PM (#7751016)
Ok. That's 120 days to make Title II a household word.

Broadband's current classification as an information service, as if it's some sort of MovieFone for the 21st century, is so far removed from reality that the public should be in an uproar about it. Verizon itself has sought to classify its fiber buildouts under Title II so it can get fixed-rate access to existing right-of-way infrastructure, [1] on the technicality that its VOIP service running across those lines is regulated under Title II. Yet the main reason for building it is, of course, broadband, which dodged Title II on the even flimsier grounds of those ISP email and start pages you never use.

People should be holding signs outside the FCC building with "Title II" on them. The chair of the National Cable and Telecommunications Association, Michael Powell, has ominously said attempts to reclassify broadband as Title II would be "World War III"[2] – but if he wants a fight, the FCC really should oblige him, and consumers should be beating the drums.

[1] http://www.theverge.com/2014/5/14/5716802/game-of-phones-how...

[2] http://www.theverge.com/2014/1/15/5311948/net-neutrality-and...

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by dragonwriter on Thursday May 15, 2014 @01:51PM (#7751037)
> People should be holding signs outside the FCC building with "Title II" on them.

Or, you know, submitting comments to the FCC answering the question explicitly raised in the call for comments as to whether Title II or Section 706 is the most appropriate authority for Open Internet regulations with clear, specific, and coherent reasons why Title II is the right answer and how it should be applied.

The battle over getting Title II into consideration has already been won. The front has moved on to the details.

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by dllthomas on Thursday May 15, 2014 @02:37PM (#7751334)
Or both and more!
Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by BryanCrow on Thursday May 15, 2014 @06:52PM (#7752731)
Before we all jump on the idea of Title II, let's consider the implications. Specifically Terrifs. If last-mile ISPs can start charging Terrifs for use of their lines (like the telcos do), this will have the opposite of the desired effect on pricing and will lead to arbitrage like we've seen with the Telcos (these Terrifs allowed NetZero to make money by keeping your modem connected... essentially billing everyone in the country through the FCC's "Federal Universal Service Charge" on your phone bill instead of their users). This is also where the "Family Plan" came from. Honestly, it's shocking how ill informed most people in the tech industry are on what they're asking for here...

Why do we need any regulation in the first place? Net Neutrality has never truly existed. Netflix has the cheapest bandwidth deal of anyone... And they're trying to fool their users into lobbying the gov't for them to keep in that way. Small start-ups have always payed more per Megabit. That's the free market at work. You pay less for bulk. It makes sense. Every content provider (website, video service, shared host, VoIP provider, etc) has always been able to pay for priority at some level (be it through exclusive private fiber channels, faster DNS, the use of CDNs, or even QoS for latency-critical services like VoIP & gaming). This has generally been a good thing. Yes, some local monopolistic ISPs are acting up and something has to be done about that. But calling them utilities will only give them the power to impose terrifs and charge more... the opposite of what we want.

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by rayiner on Thursday May 15, 2014 @02:39PM (#7751347)
You really do not want broadband classified under Title II. You will get the war you want, but it will be a war everyone loses.

Why do you think DSL is such a ghetto? It's because it's subject to a higher level of regulations, and nobody wants to invest money in such a highly-regulated industry: http://www.dslreports.com/shownews/Goldman-Sachs-Wants-Veriz....

Classifying cable broadband under Title II will definitely have the effect of killing Comcast and Time Warner's profit margins. Hooray! Your tribe wins, and the big evil telecom companies will be cut down to size!

Except the telecom companies make up 6 of the top 25 companies with the highest U.S. capital expenditures: http://news.investors.com/technology/091913-671712-institute.... You think they're going to keep pouring all that money into low-margin heavily-regulated infrastructure? No, they'll do what Goldman wants and divest themselves of regulated business lines, and take that money and put it into a profitable business sector.

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by drewcrawford on Thursday May 15, 2014 @04:44PM (#7752122)
I live in Austin which is a very densely-populated regional tech hub. Here we have three 30-mbit FTTN ISPs which is more competition than pretty much anywhere else in the US.

Earlier this year Google announced they were bringing Google Fiber here. Immediately all the ISPs announced that they, too, would be offering FTTH speeds. One company announced 300mbit, another rolled out 300mbit as part of a roadmap to gigabit, and the third actually rolled out gigabit well ahead of Google Fiber, which is still applying for permits.

I agree with you in principle that there is some margin below which companies will not invest in expensive capital expenditures. However there is also a margin above which companies will not invest in capital expenditures, because they have a sure thing going. The question is where those lines are.

The data from Austin show that in a market considered "exceptionally competitive" by American standards, companies are willing to invest an order of magnitude more in capital expenditures than they currently do just by threatening to create a lower-margin market. Google's work here, which so far consists of exactly 0 fiber installs, a landing page, and a contract with the city, has been so effective at transforming the market here that it's being argued by locals that it would be more efficient to forget about actually installing any fiber and they should just make announcements in one city after another and wait for the ISPs to do it for them.

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by rayiner on Thursday May 15, 2014 @04:55PM (#7752179)
Ask yourself: why does Austin already have three FTTN ISP's when San Francisco doesn't? It wasn't because they had a higher level of regulation than other cities, it was because they had less.
Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by drewcrawford on Thursday May 15, 2014 @06:05PM (#7752531)
Another nice narrative that doesn't fit with experimental data.

In spite of the fact that one would imagine a Texas city to be less regulated than a California city, it isn't really that simple.

In Austin a strong majority of the utility poles are owned by the city. The ones that aren't are largely owned by AT&T, which complains very loudly that it is required to sell access to anyone who wants it at a price dictated by the Federal Communications Commission nationwide.

Meanwhile California (get this) opted out of much of the FCC regulation around utility poles and effectively allows a large private company to own and control the poles. This private company is made up of all the usual suspects like AT&T, Sprint, PG&E, T-Mobile, Verizon, etc., who seem to have formed a holding company to buy utility poles without anyone at the state being concerned about antitrust concerns. I'm not exactly sure what the requirements are to join--if access is "open" (for some definition of open) this may be how they circumvent the Sherman Antitrust Act etc.

California did pass "fair access" laws in 2011 [1] but as far as I can tell they only apply to "local publicly owned electric utilities" which presumably would not include AT&T and its utility pole holding company. There probably is some kind of regulation that in principle regulates competitive access to poles but how it compares to the FCC's jurisdiction in Texas it is difficult to say.

This is a side note, but we should really be having less talk about how we think regulation works and more case studies about how it does or doesn't work in these comment threads. "Less regulation == better internet" is a plausible model but so was the Bohr Model of the atom. "Is it correct?" is the question and that question can only be answered by looking at empirically what happens.

[1] http://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billStatusClient.xht...

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by rayiner on Thursday May 15, 2014 @08:37PM (#7753148)
The fact Austin is less regulated isn't a hypothetical. We know Austin is less regulated than most cities. Its a Google Fiber city, which means it agreed to ditch most of the regulations, like build out requirements, that other cities impose. Google doesn't bring fiber to a city without massive concessions. Kansas City agreed to get the permits through in five days. Provo sold Google a $30 million fiber network for $1.

Maybe pole attachments have something to do with it too, but lots of cities own their poles but don't have competing fiber services.

See: http://crosscut.com/2014/03/04/business/118993/google-fiber-...

Also re Portland: http://seattletimes.com/html/businesstechnology/2023420101_b...

The last article is a must-read. This is the kind of person standing in the way of fiber deployment, as much as any cable lobbyist.

"That’s a nice deal where it’s available. But the company has been slow to expand its coverage area in Kansas City and vague about if and when it will reach some working-class areas, according to a report in The Kansas City Star.

Cities really have one opportunity to ensure that all of their residents will be served by these next generation broadband services.

That’s during the initial franchise negotiations, when cities can press for universal coverage in return for the special rules and public property they’re offering up.

Once cities provide these handouts, they don’t have much leverage. They’ll end up bowing and scraping and hoping that Uncle Google throws a bit more fiber their way, someday."

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by gph on Thursday May 15, 2014 @03:12PM (#7751534)
Time to nationalize then. I hate even thinking that, but I'd rather have tax dollars wasted than see our money funnelled to Wall Street.

BTW that article showing how much capital they spent doesn't say what they actually spent that money on. My bet is most of it went to their cellular networks and other business interests. Their own data shows broadband investment has fallen[1]. Only 12 billion in the last 4 years. So clearly that 100+ billion each year isn't going to faster internet... at least not in landlines. Guess I can download videos to my phone slightly faster now. Yay.

At the same time we keep paying more[2]. And now they want to suck dry the content providers as well, who will probably only pass on the costs to us? Eff That.

Maybe they should actually reinvest their money into building out a 21st century network, and then they wouldn't need a fast lane.

[1]http://www.vox.com/2014/5/12/5711082/big-cable-says-broadban...

[2]http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-24528383 [2]

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by rayiner on Thursday May 15, 2014 @03:29PM (#7751639)
> Time to nationalize then. I hate even thinking that, but I'd rather have tax dollars wasted than see our money funnelled to Wall Street.

When capital investment into broadband is set by vote, do you think you'll be happy with the resulting level of investment?

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by gph on Thursday May 15, 2014 @03:57PM (#7751834)
>do you think you'll be happy with the resulting level of investment?

I'll be accepting of it. At least we get the end results of our own failure to persuade the public or politicians.

As it is our fate is left to 'market forces'. Market forces have been undeniably screwing us for the better part of a decade. And it's looking like they want more for less in the future.

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by pdonis on Thursday May 15, 2014 @04:23PM (#7752006)
> Market forces have been undeniably screwing us for the better part of a decade.

Excuse me? What's been screwing us in broadband is precisely that market forces are not operating, because local governments have been giving sweetheart deals to particular providers.

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by rayiner on Thursday May 15, 2014 @04:41PM (#7752102)
I suggest you read some of these agreements, they're usually online. Here's the one for my town: http://www.wilmingtonde.gov/docs/1320/3716Rev1.pdf. These aren't sweetheart deals. Generally, they extract millions of dollars for tangentially-related municipal programs, and then have build-out requirements forcing you to serve areas above a certain density even if you can't sign up enough customers to make it profitable. Basically, the terms are unattractive enough such that only the big de-facto monopolies are willing to take the deal.
Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by pdonis on Thursday May 15, 2014 @05:21PM (#7752323)
> the terms are unattractive enough such that only the big de-facto monopolies are willing to take the deal.

Which means that these are effectively sweetheart deals for the big de facto monopolies, since without them there would certainly be an incentive for smaller competitors to enter the market. That may not have been the intent of the municipal governments, so "sweetheart deal" may not be the best descriptive term, but that's what ends up happening. It certainly isn't a free market with these kinds of requirements in place.

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by jessaustin on Thursday May 15, 2014 @07:03PM (#7752795)
Yes, there is something of Br'er Rabbit in giant incumbent telcos' complaining about regulations. "Please mister please don't use the complicated franchise agreement my lawyer sent you that is actually written to conform exactly to my M&Ps!"
Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by rayiner on Thursday May 15, 2014 @08:22PM (#7753106)
Did you read the Wilmington agreement? What in there looks like it was written by a Comcast lawyer?
Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by jessaustin on Monday May 19, 2014 @03:17PM (#7769219)
WTF? Now I have read it (well frankly I skimmed the last 25 of the 40 pages in this particular assignment), and it was clearly written by the Comcast lawyer. This isn't surprising: it's a contract between two parties, one of which executes scores of such contracts every year, and the other of which does so about once a decade. Who else would have written it? Saul Goodman?

As 'pdonis said, the "unattractive" terms are there precisely so that "only the big de-facto monopolies are willing to take the deal".

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by rayiner on Thursday May 15, 2014 @04:07PM (#7751896)
Our level of investment in all our other public infrastructure is dismal: http://www.asce.org/failuretoact. Why would investment into internet infrastructure be any different? Indeed, it'd probably be worse. Remember, the electorate skews older than the overall population, while I'd bet internet usage skews younger.
Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by jarin on Thursday May 15, 2014 @03:46PM (#7751771)
The military relies on the Internet too, it should be politically neutral.
Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by dynamitejoe on Thursday May 15, 2014 @11:23PM (#7753559)
Not quite, the military really only cares about the SIPRnet, a construct that is thankfully completely free of the likes of AT&T, the FCC, etc. The military has never depended on the Internet normal people use. Its a great service for Bob and Joe Servicemember to be able to watch Netflux in their down time, but because its not really important to any mission in any way, they dont care.
Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by jarin on Friday May 16, 2014 @03:21PM (#7757405)
That's not really true, NIPRNet (unclassified regular Internet) is just as important nowadays.

There are a lot of essential communications going on that aren't classified, and not everyone doing an essential job function has a security clearance.

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by briandear on Thursday May 15, 2014 @04:14PM (#7751942)
Nationalizing anything nearly always leads to lower quality. Compare the toll roads in France to the "free" autobahns in Germany. The French toll routes are far better maintained. Another case is health care, compare an NHS experience with a hip replacement in the UK with a hip replacement in France (or the US.) In the UK, the waiting list is measured in 6+ months, while in the US or France, it is almost immediate. For a more extreme example, have a look at Venezuela's nationalization efforts. Nationalization of anything is often a bad solution. The government doesn't have a profit motive, thus they have no incentives.

However, that being said, the big question is if the Internet is a common carrier or not. (I would argue that it is.) Apparently Ted Cruz and Al Franken agree as well. Nationalization isn't the answer, the proper framing of the industry is what's really needed.

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by sjaaktrekhaak on Thursday May 15, 2014 @05:24PM (#7752338)
Your argument doesn't add up. The autoroutes of France belong to the government and their semi-private companies[1].

As a counter example, all roads in the Netherlands are owned by the government - and the Dutch roads are considered to be of outstanding quality. Major roads are taken care of on a province level, smaller roads on a municipality level - however all of them have to ensure the roads are safe to travel and will not cause damage to your vehicle, nor are unsafe to drive.

[1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autoroutes_of_France#Administra...

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by briandear on Thursday May 15, 2014 @09:36PM (#7753300)
Actually most of the toll autoroutes of France are managed and operated by Vinci. Which is a shareholder owned company and most certainly not "semi-private." You're also quoting a Wikipedia article about autoroutes in general. A article, by the way, that cites no sources, unless you consider about.com a primary source.

If you were to compare the Vinci-managed ones with the state managed ones, there's a vast difference in quality.

Which, the point is that some of the autoroutes are maintained by the state, however the ones that are are privately manage are of better quality. The ones that ARE toll roads, such as the A9 are fully managed and operated by Vinci and they are exceptionally good. The A31 (Luxembourg to Beaune where it turns into the A6) on the other hand is not privately managed and it has a higher number of potholes and the overall quality is lower. The A7 from Avignon to Marseille is also privately managed and is of exceptional quality.

I'm not making the case that government-owned roads are all necessarily bad, however I am making the case that private, profit oriented roads are almost always better because they have to be -- why pay to use a bad road? Drive from Hamburg to Marseille and you can see the effects with your own eyes. I've driven all across Europe, with the exception of the Netherlands, which I will concede are probably very good. However the Netherlands can't easily compared to the United States both in terms of economy, demographics or size. Korea, for example has better internet than most of the world, but the population density is astronomical compared to the United States, so there are different economies of scale at work. The same thing goes for Dutch roads.

The interesting thing is the quality of the roads that are publicly operated toll roads, such as the New Jersey Turnpike are terrible compared to the free highways of Texas. So you do have some good government owned things, however very rarely is the government version better than a private version. Otherwise we'd be drinking Evian out of the tap instead of the chlorinated crap that passes for municipal water.

Given that a publicly managed, national internet would likely be run by some government agency along the lines of the Veterans Administration or the New York New Jersey Port Authority -- I would far prefer private infrastructure.

However, that being said, the Internet pipes almost definitely should be considered a common carrier by pretty much any definition of the word.

I'm just clearly arguing against nationalization. It worked so well for Mexico's Pemex that they are actually privatizing it. If you fill up your gas tank in Juarez vs. El Paso, you'll find the quality of the gasoline vastly different, despite the fact that they are refined from the same crude oil.

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by sjaaktrekhaak on Friday May 16, 2014 @03:24AM (#7754179)
Thank you for elaborating on the French autoroutes - I was under the impression the Vinci company was semi-private.
Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by pling on Friday May 16, 2014 @06:51AM (#7754826)
Yeah the nationalised healthcare here in the UK sucks.

Last night my wife got seen by an emergency dentist at 21:45 an it cost £18.50 ($31).

My grandmother was on the waiting list for her hip replacement for 11 days and that cost... $0

I broke my ankle and it was X-ray'ed cast and dealt with in 2 hours from being picked up by the ambulance and it cost...$0

My wife had three C-sections over the space of a decade an that cost...$0 (no wait either!)

My wife has had two other surgeries and they cost $0 and the waiting time was less than 3 weeks.

Oh and our medicines cost a max of £104 a year (if you get a year prescription certificate) and for most people they are free. That's for ANY amount of them.

Yeah nationalisation of healthcare is absolutely fucking awful especially here in London...

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by mercurial on Friday May 16, 2014 @09:28AM (#7755332)
> while in the US or France, it is almost immediate.

You seem to operate under the assumption that healthcare in France is private. It isn't. It's underfunded and has had a gaping deficit for as long as I can remember, but it still sort of works.

> The government doesn't have a profit motive, thus they have no incentives.

The government doesn't have a "profit motive". They have what is called a "mandate to deliver a public service". Which means that they're not going to deliberately screw over non-profitable areas. Not to say that everything is rosy (see, eg, the absolutely shameful state of the French penal system), but they're trying. As a bonus, you can compare the (privatized) UK railroad system and the (still public) French railroad system, and run a customer satisfaction survey.

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by julien_c on Thursday May 15, 2014 @04:32PM (#7752069)
Hip replacement is most definitely nationalized in France.
Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by danielweber on Thursday May 15, 2014 @04:54PM (#7752177)
The doctors are not employed by the state, as they are in the UK.

There are as many different ways of running a health care system as there are countries. It's not the US in one bucket, everyone else in a second bucket. The set up of the Sweden system looks more like the US than it does like Canada or Taiwan, which both have single-payer.

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by briandear on Thursday May 15, 2014 @09:08PM (#7753232)
I'm afraid you don't know what you're talking about. The bills are paid by the social insurance (and mutuels if you have it,) however the providers are mostly private.
Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by opendais on Thursday May 15, 2014 @04:26PM (#7752029)
Nationalizing the infrastructure isn't viable in the US for a host of reasons. Politics. The culture of poor stewardship of the commons in the US. Etc.

They need to be force all ISPs to act as common carriers.

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by opendais on Thursday May 15, 2014 @04:19PM (#7751975)
You are once again leaving out the important bits that don't fit your story.

The facts are an example of regulation arbitrage, not some fatal flaw in Title 2 / Common Carrier. The 'Fatal Flaw' is the FCC doesn't say "All consumer facing ISPs are Common Carriers under Title 2" but "Technology X is under Title II and Technology Y is not".

Even from your own article "In this case what has Wall Street's heart all a flutter is the possibility for Verizon to shed all union-related workers and their pensions."

Dumping a ton of long term liabilities [pensions, union contracts] is the core reason. Divesting of some high cost DSL markets for an infrastructure provider [which is the regions they are talking about in the article, Upstate New York isn't exactly a market with roaring profitability due to low population density] is a secondary concern in that article and it basically said they invested 24 billion?

Title 2 doesn't require Union workers.

It also isn't a reasonable comparison to say "Title 2 Technology A lost to Non-Title 2 Technology B because Title 2 doesn't work" with such weak evidence. Why yes, investors want to reduce liabilities and cost centers. Magically, if you can enter a market with a lower liability and costs [due to less regulation] you prefer that option. If that isn't an option, magically, the market functions on an even playing field and everything competes on the merits of the technologies.

Somehow, magically, in places like Europe you get better ISP performance per $ with similar profit margins. Maybe the problem is not too much regulation, but how the regulation is being applied?

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by rayiner on Thursday May 15, 2014 @04:47PM (#7752135)
You concede that higher levels of regulation increase regulatory costs. But you assume that as long as you make all regulation equally burdensome, the market will somehow fix things. But you're ignoring the fact that capital is fluid, and will flow out of regulated industries like telecom into less regulated industries. You can't invoke the market then ignore basic aspects of how the market works.

Places in Europe are also much more willing to outright subsidize telecom investment: http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/03/12/the-broadband-gap-w... ("Sweden has built one of the fastest and most widely deployed broadband networks in Europe because its government granted tax breaks for infrastructure investments, directly subsidized rural deployment, and, perhaps most significantly, required state-owned municipal utilities to create local backbone networks, reducing the cost for the local telephone company to provide service.")

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by opendais on Thursday May 15, 2014 @04:55PM (#7752182)
Please explain how all other utilities and common carriers are effective in the US and able to receive sufficient capital investment to provide reliable service?

Having a near-monopoly reduces risk significantly.

http://thinkprogress.org/climate/2011/11/13/366988/over-half... We subsidize Utilities & Telecommunications roughly equally via tax breaks.

Oh, and they get subsidies like Sweden too: https://www.ncta.com/news-and-events/media-room/article/2338

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_broadband_plan#Sweden Sweden didn't even put 1 billion in.

So umm, you are pretty providing all the evidence that greater intervention in the market than even I'm suggesting will improve things...?

confused

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by rayiner on Thursday May 15, 2014 @05:15PM (#7752300)
> http://thinkprogress.org/climate/2011/11/13/366988/over-half.... We subsidize Utilities & Telecommunications roughly equally via tax breaks.

Uh, please read the methodology of the linked article. Those aren't direct tax subsidies. It's a made-up number based on effective tax rates below 35%. By your logic, the government is heavily subsidizing Apple & Google, which pay much less than the 35% rate.

> Please explain how all other utilities and common carriers are effective in the US and able to receive sufficient capital investment to provide reliable service?

They're not. Utility infrastructure in the U.S. barely gets enough investment to keep it operation, much less keep up with technological development: http://geospatial.blogs.com/geospatial/2011/12/asce-report-o....

> https://www.ncta.com/news-and-events/media-room/article/2338

The one-time ARRA money is for jobs programs. The money is distributed to municipalities, and may or may not be used to actually build broadband anywhere.

> Sweden didn't even put 1 billion in.

Sweden putting in $900 million is like the U.S. putting in $27 billion.

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by opendais on Thursday May 15, 2014 @05:35PM (#7752388)
> Uh, please read the methodology of the linked article. Those aren't direct tax subsidies. It's a made-up number based on effective tax rates below 35%. By your logic, the government is heavily subsidizing Apple & Google, which pay much less than the 35% rate.

Fine, we'll use your definitions. That's cool.

> Sweden putting in $900 million is like the U.S. putting in $27 billion.

http://www.pcworld.com/article/242713/fcc_votes_to_end_telep... "The FCC will cap the broadband fund at US$4.5 billion a year, the current budget of the USF high-cost program, funded by a tax on telephone bills." Over 6 years.

4.5 * 6=27 billion

What is your next objection?

> They're not. Utility infrastructure in the U.S. barely gets enough investment to keep it operation, much less keep up with technological development: http://geospatial.blogs.com/geospatial/2011/12/asce-report-o....

Moving goal posts by switching to publicly owned water infrastructure isn't valid. Privately owned utilities.

Like these: http://money.cnn.com/magazines/fortune/fortune500/2012/indus...

An example: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comcast http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exelon

Exelon: ~2.5 billion net on ~55 billion assets Comcast: ~6.8 billion net on ~158 billion assets

And like any other market, Exelon isn't having trouble turning a profit from regulation but is losing money due to its own fuckups for failing to accurately predict what forms of energy are cheapest: http://articles.chicagotribune.com/2014-03-09/business/ct-ex...

I'm sorry, but we just have to agree to disagree. Or are you planning to change goalposts?

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by rayiner on Thursday May 15, 2014 @09:03PM (#7753218)
> Fine, we'll use your definitions. That's cool.

Under your definition, Apple received an $18 billion subsidy between 2009-2011. What did the public get in return for that subsidy? Is that a dumb question? Yes, because your definition of subsidy makes no sense.

> http://www.pcworld.com/article/242713/fcc_votes_to_end_telep.... "The FCC will cap the broadband fund at US$4.5 billion a year, the current budget of the USF high-cost program, funded by a tax on telephone bills." Over 6 years.

USF is not a subsidy to the telecom industry, because it is funded by a tax on the industry. It just shifts money from certain telecom customers to others.

> And like any other market, Exelon isn't having trouble turning a profit from regulation

Excelon is a terrible example of utilities turning a profit, because it really isn't one. When the energy industry was deregulated, the regulated electric monopoly in Illinois, Commonwealth Edison, divested itself of its generation capacity. This entity became Excelon, and it is not regulated S a public utility the way ComEd is.

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by jessaustin on Thursday May 15, 2014 @06:56PM (#7752753)
Except the telecom companies make up 6 of the top 25 companies with the highest U.S. capital expenditures...

Do you think no one is paying attention? We know very well that VZN & ATT's capital spending is in wireless, not wireline:

http://stopthecap.com/2013/07/18/verizon-diverting-landline-...

Sure, one might see this as a sign that existing wireline regulations are already too onerous, and Ma Bell's poor daughters have to take their ball and go home. But the fact is, they know their wireline market is a captive one, and customers will stay no matter how little they invest. As soon as they bribe their way to a Sprint takeover, we'll see wireless investment head in the same direction.

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by shkkmo on Thursday May 15, 2014 @05:18PM (#7752313)
Except that the amount of money those companies are pouring into infrastructure is dropping already.

http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20140514/06500227230/cable-...

Maybe if their margins drop, they will stop opposing community broadband:

http://www.consumereagle.com/2014/03/13/cable-companies-figh...

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by sandstrom on Thursday May 15, 2014 @03:23PM (#7751606)
I find it interesting that broadband is so expensive in the US compared to many other countries.

Population density is sometimes pointed to. It may be, but I also know that even many of the most rural parts of Norway and Sweden broadband [fiber] is prevalent.

I would guess competition (and less lobbying) would improve things. Perhaps Google Fiber can shake things up.

- http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-24528383

- http://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/2013/08/07/reviewed-high-...

- http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/03/10/the-broadband-gap-w...

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by rayiner on Thursday May 15, 2014 @03:33PM (#7751674)
The U.S. is not far behind Sweden in global average connection speeds: http://www.akamai.com/dl/akamai/akamai-soti-q413.pdf?WT.mc_i... (Page 19, Figure 20).

Sweden directly subsidized deployment of fiber in rural areas: http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/03/12/the-broadband-gap-w.... It also required municipalities to build certain infrastructure, which is something the U.S. federal government lacks the power to do.

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by jessaustin on Thursday May 15, 2014 @06:47PM (#7752707)
Sweden directly subsidized deployment of fiber...

Yeah, so did USA. The only difference was that Sweden actually got the fiber they subsidized. We've been over this before.

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by anigbrowl on Thursday May 15, 2014 @03:28PM (#7751633)
It's not often you express such a vehement personal opinion. I would be interested to see your argument expanded into a longer article.
Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by sentenza on Friday May 16, 2014 @03:43AM (#7754249)
I live in Europe, where there is a lot more regulation on Telecom Companies. My house is in a small village in the woods (45min away from the next Autobahn!) and yet I can get 50Mbps down and 10Mbps up for 50€.

Regulation sets the market incentives. Having no regulation is just the choice to set the incentives to benefit those that control the natural monopoly.

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by hussong on Friday May 16, 2014 @07:59AM (#7755002)
To be fair, you can consider yourself lucky — many people in rural areas can only get 384 kbit/s DSL.
Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by takeda on Friday May 16, 2014 @03:56AM (#7754298)
You should read recent Level3 blogs showing that actually currently those companies don't have any incentive to improve their infrastructure, because keeping it in bad shape generates them more money. I know it is counter-intuitive but that's what it is.

Regional ISPs are natural monopolies and there's no other way but to regulate them. Same as you regulate electricity company, water, gas etc. You can't just let everyone dig holes around city to place new wires, pipes etc. There's no other way then regulating it.

BTW: If Comcast and Time Warner would move to a different methods of delivering access then it's all even better we will have more alternatives than just cable, or dsl. If instead they would decide to close down and sell, then I'm sure there would be plenty of other companies who would want to purchase their infrastructure with their subscribers to make money out of it.

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by ajtaylor on Thursday May 15, 2014 @08:47PM (#7753168)
If this is true, then why do so many other countries around the world have both actual competition AND much more compelling products than the US? These other ISPs are also commercial entities and yet they aren't filing for bankruptcy left, right and center so clearly it's commercially possible.
Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by pcwalton on Thursday May 15, 2014 @04:55PM (#7752178)
That link doesn't talk about network regulation, rather about unions.
Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by DenisM on Thursday May 15, 2014 @10:43PM (#7753462)
Excellent. Then, with profits gone and without telco lobbying, municipal internet will be allowed to exist, built the same way that roads and sewage.

Th Internet is too important to be left to Internet businesses.

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by IanDrake on Thursday May 15, 2014 @02:49PM (#7751398)
This is something most people don't seem to get. Government control == stagnation.
Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by cantankerous on Thursday May 15, 2014 @03:34PM (#7751681)
By "get" I think you mean "accept". I don't think most people accept it because the evidence does not overwhelmingly support this statement.
Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by IanDrake on Sunday May 18, 2014 @08:39AM (#7762881)
>because the evidence does not overwhelmingly support this statement

To which evidence are you referring?

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by anigbrowl on Thursday May 15, 2014 @03:25PM (#7751621)
It's not that simple. Europe's telecom/broadband markets are heavily regulated and yet mobile and internet services are both cheaper and faster.
Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by gph on Thursday May 15, 2014 @03:13PM (#7751539)
In America. Looks like most of Europe doesn't have this problem...
Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by briandear on Thursday May 15, 2014 @04:34PM (#7752078)
Au contraire. Europe has enormous problems. In places like France, cellular service has been getting faster and cheaper because of competition. For example, Free joined the "big three" in France for cell service and suddenly prices have fallen and quality has greatly improved compared the the days when France Telecom controlled everything. That's the opposite of your theory that nationalization "improves" things.

Mexico is another outstanding example of what happens when you deregulate telecoms. When Carlos Slim had his nationally-endorsed monopoly with TelCel/TelMex, prices were exceptionally high however, once his guaranteed monopoly period expired and other companies could begin to compete, the prices dropped dramatically. Although Slim's company has a huge 10 year head start over other companies in terms of infrastructure -- so the monopoly effects are still prevalent. For example, a cell plan that costs me $100 in the US, costs me over $125 in Mexico. In terms of purchasing power, that's a massively expensive difference, considering many other things in Mexico are substantially less expensive than the US -- except electricity and telcoms, which are far more expensive because of de facto and de jure nationalization.

There's a perception that "Europe is better" that seems to be almost a stereotype. I happen to live in Avignon and have a close-up view of things that are better in Europe versus the US and some things ARE better, but there is a tradeoff. Avignon has 20% unemployment for example. It has traditionally been very expensive to start a business in France as well. The labor rules and bureaucracy makes it exceptionally difficult to hire and fire employees. Public transport in Europe isn't universally better than the US. Most people only visit places like Paris, Berlin, London, etc. However, when compared to New York, Chicago and San Francisco, europe's transport isn't that much better. Spend a few minutes in the Paris CDG airport and compare that to JFK.. not much difference. In the less famous cities and regions of Europe, public transport consists of possibly a train station and some buses. When I was in Wilstedt, German (near Hamburg) there was a bus, but it was so infrequent that it was useless. In Provence, the big cities have public transport, but if you're in Salon de Provence, there isn't much. I wouldn't want to live anywhere else, but the rose-colored view of Europe is often not based in reality, but on an idealized view. La vie en rose to be sure.

The "Better in Europe" meme isn't always true. Ask some of the people actually running businesses in France. Here's an interview with a French CEO that's interesting. http://www.cnbc.com/id/101608867

And then you have this nonsense:

http://www.france24.com/en/20130501-france-minister-montebou...

(A French Minister blocked the sale of Dailymotion to Yahoo.)

I am not an expert on Europe (or anything really,) however I did have to say something about the "Europe is better" implication.

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by little_lebowski on Thursday May 15, 2014 @07:13PM (#7752847)
What speed is your residential internet connection and how much do you pay for it each month?
Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by Bahamut on Thursday May 15, 2014 @06:48PM (#7752712)
Japan had stagnant internet for a while in the 90s, while the US was the standard bearer - they also used to have a paucity of competition, and when the government instituted regulations to increase competition, they worked as intended, resulting in having one of the best broadband infrastructures in the world.

Government control can be good when the traditional market fails abysmally.

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by fixedd on Thursday May 15, 2014 @03:27PM (#7751628)
Except in the cases where this wasn't the case.
Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by rcraft on Thursday May 15, 2014 @05:27PM (#7752354)
Thoughts on what effect title II designation would have on innovative ISPs such as Google fiber and webpass?

Would Google still be inclined to invest money in Fiber?

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by kumbasha on Thursday May 15, 2014 @07:09PM (#7752824)
Google is generally capable of thinking long term. The major broadband providers in America are incapable of thinking beyond the next few quarterly statements--otherwise they would not have gotten themselves into this mess.
Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by rayiner on Friday May 16, 2014 @09:25AM (#7755313)
The fact is that Google is only deploying fiber in cities that give massive regulatory concessions: http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2012/09/how-kansas-city-t....

It's very legitimate to ask whether Google would invest in fiber were it regulated under Title II, because to date they have expressed the distinct unwillingness to enter municipal markets with heavy telecom regulation. They won't even agree to build-out requirements, which are pretty much standard for cable franchises.

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by cookiecaper on Thursday May 15, 2014 @02:26PM (#7751259)
Michael Powell was himself the chairperson of the FCC not so long ago. I don't think there'd be much success waging a war against him.