News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by opendais on Thursday May 15, 2014 @04:19PM (#7751975)
You are once again leaving out the important bits that don't fit your story.

The facts are an example of regulation arbitrage, not some fatal flaw in Title 2 / Common Carrier. The 'Fatal Flaw' is the FCC doesn't say "All consumer facing ISPs are Common Carriers under Title 2" but "Technology X is under Title II and Technology Y is not".

Even from your own article "In this case what has Wall Street's heart all a flutter is the possibility for Verizon to shed all union-related workers and their pensions."

Dumping a ton of long term liabilities [pensions, union contracts] is the core reason. Divesting of some high cost DSL markets for an infrastructure provider [which is the regions they are talking about in the article, Upstate New York isn't exactly a market with roaring profitability due to low population density] is a secondary concern in that article and it basically said they invested 24 billion?

Title 2 doesn't require Union workers.

It also isn't a reasonable comparison to say "Title 2 Technology A lost to Non-Title 2 Technology B because Title 2 doesn't work" with such weak evidence. Why yes, investors want to reduce liabilities and cost centers. Magically, if you can enter a market with a lower liability and costs [due to less regulation] you prefer that option. If that isn't an option, magically, the market functions on an even playing field and everything competes on the merits of the technologies.

Somehow, magically, in places like Europe you get better ISP performance per $ with similar profit margins. Maybe the problem is not too much regulation, but how the regulation is being applied?

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by rayiner on Thursday May 15, 2014 @04:47PM (#7752135)
You concede that higher levels of regulation increase regulatory costs. But you assume that as long as you make all regulation equally burdensome, the market will somehow fix things. But you're ignoring the fact that capital is fluid, and will flow out of regulated industries like telecom into less regulated industries. You can't invoke the market then ignore basic aspects of how the market works.

Places in Europe are also much more willing to outright subsidize telecom investment: http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/03/12/the-broadband-gap-w... ("Sweden has built one of the fastest and most widely deployed broadband networks in Europe because its government granted tax breaks for infrastructure investments, directly subsidized rural deployment, and, perhaps most significantly, required state-owned municipal utilities to create local backbone networks, reducing the cost for the local telephone company to provide service.")

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by opendais on Thursday May 15, 2014 @04:55PM (#7752182)
Please explain how all other utilities and common carriers are effective in the US and able to receive sufficient capital investment to provide reliable service?

Having a near-monopoly reduces risk significantly.

http://thinkprogress.org/climate/2011/11/13/366988/over-half... We subsidize Utilities & Telecommunications roughly equally via tax breaks.

Oh, and they get subsidies like Sweden too: https://www.ncta.com/news-and-events/media-room/article/2338

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_broadband_plan#Sweden Sweden didn't even put 1 billion in.

So umm, you are pretty providing all the evidence that greater intervention in the market than even I'm suggesting will improve things...?

confused

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by rayiner on Thursday May 15, 2014 @05:15PM (#7752300)
> http://thinkprogress.org/climate/2011/11/13/366988/over-half.... We subsidize Utilities & Telecommunications roughly equally via tax breaks.

Uh, please read the methodology of the linked article. Those aren't direct tax subsidies. It's a made-up number based on effective tax rates below 35%. By your logic, the government is heavily subsidizing Apple & Google, which pay much less than the 35% rate.

> Please explain how all other utilities and common carriers are effective in the US and able to receive sufficient capital investment to provide reliable service?

They're not. Utility infrastructure in the U.S. barely gets enough investment to keep it operation, much less keep up with technological development: http://geospatial.blogs.com/geospatial/2011/12/asce-report-o....

> https://www.ncta.com/news-and-events/media-room/article/2338

The one-time ARRA money is for jobs programs. The money is distributed to municipalities, and may or may not be used to actually build broadband anywhere.

> Sweden didn't even put 1 billion in.

Sweden putting in $900 million is like the U.S. putting in $27 billion.

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by opendais on Thursday May 15, 2014 @05:35PM (#7752388)
> Uh, please read the methodology of the linked article. Those aren't direct tax subsidies. It's a made-up number based on effective tax rates below 35%. By your logic, the government is heavily subsidizing Apple & Google, which pay much less than the 35% rate.

Fine, we'll use your definitions. That's cool.

> Sweden putting in $900 million is like the U.S. putting in $27 billion.

http://www.pcworld.com/article/242713/fcc_votes_to_end_telep... "The FCC will cap the broadband fund at US$4.5 billion a year, the current budget of the USF high-cost program, funded by a tax on telephone bills." Over 6 years.

4.5 * 6=27 billion

What is your next objection?

> They're not. Utility infrastructure in the U.S. barely gets enough investment to keep it operation, much less keep up with technological development: http://geospatial.blogs.com/geospatial/2011/12/asce-report-o....

Moving goal posts by switching to publicly owned water infrastructure isn't valid. Privately owned utilities.

Like these: http://money.cnn.com/magazines/fortune/fortune500/2012/indus...

An example: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comcast http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exelon

Exelon: ~2.5 billion net on ~55 billion assets Comcast: ~6.8 billion net on ~158 billion assets

And like any other market, Exelon isn't having trouble turning a profit from regulation but is losing money due to its own fuckups for failing to accurately predict what forms of energy are cheapest: http://articles.chicagotribune.com/2014-03-09/business/ct-ex...

I'm sorry, but we just have to agree to disagree. Or are you planning to change goalposts?

Re:FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet by rayiner on Thursday May 15, 2014 @09:03PM (#7753218)
> Fine, we'll use your definitions. That's cool.

Under your definition, Apple received an $18 billion subsidy between 2009-2011. What did the public get in return for that subsidy? Is that a dumb question? Yes, because your definition of subsidy makes no sense.

> http://www.pcworld.com/article/242713/fcc_votes_to_end_telep.... "The FCC will cap the broadband fund at US$4.5 billion a year, the current budget of the USF high-cost program, funded by a tax on telephone bills." Over 6 years.

USF is not a subsidy to the telecom industry, because it is funded by a tax on the industry. It just shifts money from certain telecom customers to others.

> And like any other market, Exelon isn't having trouble turning a profit from regulation

Excelon is a terrible example of utilities turning a profit, because it really isn't one. When the energy industry was deregulated, the regulated electric monopoly in Illinois, Commonwealth Edison, divested itself of its generation capacity. This entity became Excelon, and it is not regulated S a public utility the way ComEd is.