News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by Pacabel on Saturday May 10, 2014 @10:06AM (#7725428)
What you're saying is absolutely correct. I actually had to use Bing Maps today to look up some directions because the new version of Google Maps was pretty much unusable.

As for why UX disasters like this can happen, I think it generally comes down to one thing these days: "hipsters".

Those of us who've been in industry for a long time have no doubt seen this happen before. A relatively well-established product has a usable UI. It isn't perfect, and maybe even looks "dated" in some ways, but it generally works and is understood by its existing users.

So-called "hipsters" (that is, people who have an uncompromising view that they're talented "designers" or "UI experts", with a massive ego to back this up, and a fixation on being "trendy") get involved at some point. These people are often relatively young, often have limited experience, and are usually more focused on making designs look "pretty" and "modern" rather than usable.

Needing to create work for themselves, these hipsters, coupled with managers who need to appear to be leading something seen as "productive", start on a UI redesign. Often this is done without the involvement or insight offered by the existing developers of the product, nor any of the product's users. Changes are made purely to look "better", with limited to no consideration of how it'll impact the usability of the product.

The end result is a total cock-up like this, or like the poor UI of Chrome (and the imitations of it by Firefox, Opera and IE), or a project-killing release like GNOME 3, or an abysmal failure like Windows 8.

UIs were generally far more usable in the 1980s, 1990s, and the first half of the 2000s, before "hipsters" got involved with design. What we see today is a total jumble of inconsistent and incoherent UI design, where usability and efficiency are considered significantly less important than "looking trendy".

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by cousin_it on Saturday May 10, 2014 @11:23AM (#7725703)
It's funny you would make a dichotomy between the "old guard" and the "hipsters", and blame the latter for the problems of the new Google Maps. If there's anyone on Earth who I can name as part of the "old guard" of online mapping, it's Bernhard Seefeld, who invented draggable tiled online maps when he launched map.search.ch in 2004. (Google Maps was launched in 2005.) For the last few years he's been working as the product management director for the new Google Maps.

If I had to come up with a reason why the new Google Maps feels worse in many ways, my guess would be second-system syndrome.

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by naterator on Saturday May 10, 2014 @02:06PM (#7726303)
IMO it's definitely Second-system syndrome. Maps worked fine and didn't need much added/changed, but someone decided that they needed to keep iterating and now we're stuck with all the cludge built on top of it now.
Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by dennisgorelik on Sunday May 11, 2014 @09:45PM (#7730816)
It wasn't iteration. They threw away code and started from scratch. Things you should never do [1].

Several months ago Google releases totally new version of Google Maps. Google Maps consistently stays as a poor product since then. I think that even first version of Google maps (introduced in 2005) was better.

[1] http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/fog0000000069.html

  When you throw away code and start from scratch,
  you are throwing away all that knowledge.
  All those collected bug fixes.
  Years of programming work.
Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by joel_perl_prog on Saturday May 10, 2014 @10:11AM (#7725451)
Yeah I hear ya. Whoever guided this Titanic into the iceberg...well he ain't no Steve Jobs. That's for sure.

It's hard to overstate how just plain awful Google Maps is now. It's amazing, in a way. I literally cannot understand how so many smart people can, all together, fail to observe the obvious. Manifestly obviously just shit awful. To observe this one only needs a few seconds with Google Maps. A few minutes cements it. Yet here we are...

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by Shish2k on Saturday May 10, 2014 @11:05AM (#7725631)
> I literally cannot understand how so many smart people can, all together, fail to observe the obvious.

It doesn't matter how many smart engineers and ux designers can see the obvious, if one person from upper management can't :( (See also: G+ real names policy)

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by fragsworth on Saturday May 10, 2014 @03:25PM (#7726584)
My guess is the original person leading the Google Maps project was very, very competent, and they either moved to another project or quit - and got replaced by someone really awful. I think it happened at some point pre-2013, because Maps was great until then, and has been in decline ever since.
Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by joel_perl_prog on Saturday May 10, 2014 @04:15PM (#7726722)
Yeah, I experienced a similar timeline. That's when the Maps API stopped working for the Java app on my feature phone, roughly. Then the cascade or rot hit the PC / tablet experience, piece by piece, until it was just completely terrible. Which brings us to today. =)
Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by kevrone on Saturday May 10, 2014 @11:34AM (#7725751)
I've been bitching and moaning about the new g-maps for so long! And this thread makes me feel...vindicated? I guess? Too bad I'm still stuck with it.

The funny thing is that it's possible the UI could have been screwed while keeping the search stable, but as the article points out, the search is killing me. It's Apple Maps-ish in a way. I mean, if I'm zoomed in to a particular level and I do a search, there's a good bet that I'm only interested in results within those bounds, right? I'm not crazy to want that am I?

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by shyn3 on Saturday May 10, 2014 @01:37PM (#7726205)
Click on the ? at the bottom right, then select Return to old Google maps lastly click on the classic yellow ribbon which appears at the top asking to remember your preference.

6 more months of classic maps then they will probably phase it out, sadly.

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by dennisgorelik on Sunday May 11, 2014 @11:39PM (#7731106)
Is there a way to switch to classic view permanently?

Every time I start Google Maps again - it starts with crippled version.

Update: I just noticed that after switching to Classic, Google Maps is asking me if I want to remember that choice permanently.

The question is not prominent enough though.

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by shyn3 on Monday May 12, 2014 @05:43PM (#7735580)
They do this with every service/option they don't want you to use.

For example, if you enable delay e-mail send in gMail, you get a tiny pop-up to undo your message... I guess you just have to learn to always look at the top middle for Google's hidden/minimally displayed functions.

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by brazzy on Saturday May 10, 2014 @02:08PM (#7726308)
THANK YOUUU!!!
Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by tammer on Sunday May 11, 2014 @12:00AM (#7727718)
As crazy as it sounds, I did some back-and-forth tests to find things nearby and I got the same or more relavent results from Apple Maps. I switched over and the service has gotten a lot better from where they were at launch. Google Maps has gotten significantly worse.
Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by Silhouette on Saturday May 10, 2014 @12:59PM (#7726056)
I literally cannot understand how so many smart people can, all together, fail to observe the obvious.

That one's easy. It turns out that roles like management and marketing and customer support are actually important for developing good products, but the culture at "engineer"-led organisations doesn't always acknowledge or respect that.

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by hindsightbias on Saturday May 10, 2014 @03:16PM (#7726560)
The product is becoming the Windows ME of Google.
Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by masterleep on Saturday May 10, 2014 @10:49AM (#7725585)
Pegman sealed the deal.
Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by Serow225 on Saturday May 10, 2014 @11:29AM (#7725724)
At least they listened to the outcry and brought them back!
Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by leemcalilly on Saturday May 10, 2014 @10:58AM (#7725615)
I agree with your argument, but there's no need to go in with the "hipsters" or "looking trendy" thing. I immediately get turned off when someone uses "hipster" pejoratively. You might as well have just used "millenials" or "kids these day." It ruins a perfectly cogent argument.
Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by Pacabel on Saturday May 10, 2014 @11:09AM (#7725648)
Like I said in an earlier comment, age has very little to do with this. "Hipsters" can pretty much be any age.

It's more the "hipster" mindset and attitude that's the problem. This attitude involves fashion and trends trumping all other considerations. Maybe that's okay when it comes to something like clothing. It isn't acceptable, however, when it comes to tools that are supposed to be productive, including software.

If you've got a better term than "hipster", I'm willing to consider using it. I'm just not aware of any other term that better describes the particular attitude that puts vanity, arrogance, ego, smugness and focus on appearance over everything else.

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by girvo on Saturday May 10, 2014 @12:20PM (#7725917)
How about instead of using a crappy word that attempts to tar a nebulous ill-defined group of people, you just point out the issues you have with it. No need for the "hipster" straw-man, as far as I'm concerned, and I agree with your points. "Hipster" is over-done, and from where I'm sitting those who use it pejoratively come across as elitist.
Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by Pacabel on Sunday May 11, 2014 @12:20AM (#7727755)
Like I said in the comment you replied to, if you have a better term, please mention it here.

I don't think that these people, or more specifically their attitude and their approach toward software UI design, are "nebulous" nor "ill-defined". It's extremely easy to identify incidents involving them: Windows 8, GNOME 3, Firefox 4 and later, this new version of Google Maps, and the Slashdot beta website, among others.

There are some common traits we see with these cases:

1. They hijack an existing, well-established software product.

2. They throw out years, if not decades, of accumulated knowledge and experience.

3. They usually come in with little to no relevant experience themselves.

4. They consider appearance far more important than usability, efficiency or productivity.

5. They create a design that's obviously flawed in many different ways.

6. They refuse to accept or even acknowledge these many flaws in their designs, no matter how loudly long-time users point them out.

7. They release their changes into the wild, often forcing them upon users who absolutely abhor the changes.

8. Their design efforts drive away more users than they could ever hope to bring in.

The fourth and sixth points are the key ones here. They are the very essence of the "hipster" attitude, regardless of whether we're talking about clothing, food, software UI design, or pretty much anything else they're involved with.

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by dragonwriter on Saturday May 10, 2014 @02:52PM (#7726493)
> This attitude involves fashion and trends trumping all other considerations.

90% of the complaints I see about things being bad now because of "fashion and trends trumping all other considerations" seem to just be people applying who are themselves putting fashions and trends above all other considerations -- its just that they found a fashion or trend that they favored several years ago and are upset that the rest of the world doesn't still favor that fashion/trend.

And that's not entirely unreasonable -- or necessarily detached from personal productivity. Something that is a common trend in a field where productivity is relevant is almost certainly also useful to some subset of the market. Likewise, compatibility with expectations driven by trends external to the field can make new fashions also more productive to the mass market, even if they aren't more productive to the subset that the prior fashion "clicked" with well on a deeper level.

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by Crito on Saturday May 10, 2014 @12:07PM (#7725870)
In this case, I think that I would define "hipster" as "thinks they are the second coming of Steve Jobs." They're basically cargo culting, they saw Steve Jobs stir shit up, so they think that if they stir shit up as well, the world will hail them as geniuses and shower them with riches. The problem is that they give little thought to exactly what they are stirring up, or how they are doing it. Inevitably they just make a hash of everything.
Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by zo1 on Saturday May 10, 2014 @02:33PM (#7726419)
That and they're positively obsessed with JavaScript, Node.js, and a coding style that favors ample and unnecessary usage of anonymous JavaScript functions as nested parameters.
Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by runn1ng on Saturday May 10, 2014 @10:14AM (#7725461)
I was with you until you started to hate on Chrome GUI. In my opinion, Chrome's GUI is the best thing that could happen to browsers.
Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by Pacabel on Saturday May 10, 2014 @10:28AM (#7725506)
It depends on who you are, and how you use the browser. Maybe the Chrome UI is good for somebody with a tiny screen and a near-complete lack of technical ability.

But for people with large monitors and the need to push a web browser hard, they've merely managed to strip out or hide a lot of very useful functionality, with essentially no benefit. What's left over is non-standard and awkward to use (like Chrome's menu).

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by sanderjd on Saturday May 10, 2014 @11:00AM (#7725621)
I have a large monitor, but I have no idea what you mean by "push a web browser hard". Chrome's UI is great because it recognizes that what is important in a browser UI is the content area, not the, well ... chrome. I have no concept of what you could possibly be doing with the menu so often that it bugs you.

A little more on topic: one person's "crappy hipster redesign" is another person's "wow this is so much better" and it's really difficult to guess ahead of time which will be the dominant reaction. Having said that, most of the frustrations about Maps here seem to be more on the implementation side than the design side.

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by euank on Saturday May 10, 2014 @03:01PM (#7726513)
My issue with Chrome's UI is that it is inflexible. I agree that the content area is important; as such, my firefox displays much more content (while also displaying more useful icons IMO).

In Chrome, you take what Google gives you and you better like it. I'll admit, it's not a bad default.

Firefox, however, allows addons to fundamentally alter the appearance of the webbrowser. I can add stylish themes that do all sorts of awesome things. I can use vimperator with "set gui=nonavigation" and reclaim even more space for content.

This fundamental difference is the reason I think Chrome's UI is bad. Firefox, you can customize the gui to be good for any definition of good. Chrome's only works if your definition of good aligns with Google's.

Also, for an example of when Chrome's UI fails, simply try and half-screen it on a 1080p screen with 30+ tabs open. All the tab favicons vanish. There's no way to search for an existing open tab (akin to firefox's % Location Bar Search character[0]).

If you'd like, I could show you my firefox and chrome running side by side with firefox having dozen's of more pixels of content-viewing area. Even if you don't like my setup, the fact that I can change it at all makes it an obvious win for me.

[0]: http://kb.mozillazine.org/Location_Bar_search#Location_Bar_s...

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by Silhouette on Saturday May 10, 2014 @01:09PM (#7726092)
Chrome's UI is great because it recognizes that what is important in a browser UI is the content area, not the, well ... chrome.

Sure it is, as long as you only want to look at one page above the fold.

But sometimes I want to navigate between pages, and at that point I do want my bookmarks bar displayed.

Sometimes I want to scroll a page, and at that point I do want scrollbars that work the way my system is setup instead of some almost invisible, almost unclickable little rectangle at the edge of the window.

Sometimes I want to use developer tools, and that that point I do want concepts like whitespace and fonts larger than 5px and coloured icons that are easily recognisable to exist, instead of prioritising cramming so much information into the available space that all of it becomes almost illegible.

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by andybak on Saturday May 10, 2014 @02:18PM (#7726367)
> But sometimes I want to navigate between pages, and at that point I do want my bookmarks bar displayed.

'Always show bookmark bar' is the top item on my View menu. Is it there for you?

> at that point I do want scrollbars that work the way my system is setup

I can't comment on this I've not used a scroll bar since I got trackpad scrolling. Just compared Chrome with Safari and the scrollbars seem identical to me.

> Sometimes I want to use developer tool

I'm not clear what your complaint is here. Dev tools is too crowded? I often need it to share space with content whilst I'm debugging. If you have dual monitors then I can understand you might prefer a less compact display. I work entirely on my laptop so I'm grateful for it's compactness.

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by Silhouette on Saturday May 10, 2014 @02:36PM (#7726426)
'Always show bookmark bar' is the top item on my View menu.

Sure, you can change the default easily enough. I'm just giving an example where I do find it useful to have more Chrome displayed at the expense of a small amount of content area.

I can't comment on this I've not used a scroll bar since I got trackpad scrolling.

I'm usually working on a desktop PC, so I don't have a trackpad. I use a mouse scroll wheel all the time, but for long documents that's tedious (as is using a trackpad) and with most mice it's a one-dimensional scroll anyway.

I'm not clear what your complaint is here. Dev tools is too crowded?

Yes, and many things in it are far too small for comfortable use. The developer tools in both Chrome and Firefox are riddled with basic usability and design blunders, such as using tiny fonts and icons; using a flat design that blurs everything together and often gives no clues to what interactions are available; offering many different sets of tabs, icons and other controls; numerous inconsistencies in presentation, not just in the different behaviours from tab to tab but even from one set of tabs or icons to another that is visible at the same time; and forever moving things around, particularly making unnecessary minor changes every few weeks.

I've nothing against providing for developers who are using smaller screens, but I have a powerful computer on a real desk with nice big screens to make me as productive as possible, and the idea that everything must be crammed in to maximise the content area at all costs just isn't helpful in that context. Rather like the perversion of the original "mobile first" design idea to become "over-simplified least common denominator behaviour is good enough", it's throwing the baby out with the bathwater and actually making the software worse for some users. Of course the developers of these browsers are perfectly entitled to do that, but it's equally fair to point out the problems they are creating.

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by Nullabillity on Saturday May 10, 2014 @02:11PM (#7726326)
> But sometimes I want to navigate between pages, and at that point I do want my bookmarks bar displayed.

Ctrl+Shift+B.

> Sometimes I want to scroll a page, and at that point I do want scrollbars that work the way my system is setup instead of some almost invisible, almost unclickable little rectangle at the edge of the window.

Seems to use normal system scrollbars for me on KDE. Windows looks custom, but only wrt textures, sizes still seem to match.

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by Silhouette on Saturday May 10, 2014 @02:38PM (#7726432)
Ctrl+Shift+B.

Sure, or it's an option on the menu. I'm just trying to show that sometimes removing all possible chrome to maximise the content area isn't necessarily the most helpful thing to do.

Seems to use normal system scrollbars for me on KDE.

On Windows, they are just thin grey rectangles that don't even look like scrollbars (or anything else you might interact with) and don't even look the same between the main content window and supporting windows like the developer tools.

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by danoprey on Saturday May 10, 2014 @02:09PM (#7726317)
Completely agree. Hide as much as possible that isn't annoying on a regular basis then learn the keyboard shortcuts for everything else if you're such a power user.
Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by Amadiro on Saturday May 10, 2014 @12:05PM (#7725865)
I use chromium with a 5760*1080 resolution, and I frequently have > 150 tabs open across 3 browser windows, and I really have no complaints. I also occasionally peruse or develop WebGL/ASM.js/emscripten applications, so I suppose I fit into your description as someone who is "pushing the web browser hard".

All functionality I need to access quickly is accessible through shortcuts, so I don't typically need to access the "hamburger-menu" very often. The only thing I really use it for is to open the settings tab.

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by runn1ng on Saturday May 10, 2014 @12:20PM (#7725923)
I disagree.

I mostly use web browser for browsing. Not for staying in this on that setup menu, not for looking at tabs and windows.

Chrome managed to move the bloat away and move the important thing to front.

I don't really see the parallel with the new Google Maps.

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by judk on Saturday May 10, 2014 @10:59AM (#7725617)
> somebody with a tiny screen and a near-complete lack of technical ability

The vast majority of users.

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by TeMPOraL on Saturday May 10, 2014 @11:19AM (#7725684)
And that continuous pandering to them is what will bring the downfall of the information age. We are dumbing down our technology, where we should be forcing people to get smarter instead. But unfortunately, dumber is always easier to sell. I fear that, as the world depends more and more on technology (and people actually thinking straight), this feedback loop of progressing idiocy might one day undo us.
Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by dragonwriter on Saturday May 10, 2014 @12:07PM (#7725872)
> And that continuous pandering to them is what will bring the downfall of the information age. We are dumbing down our technology, where we should be forcing people to get smarter instead.

Changing humanity on the kind of broad scale that requires is a much broader and longer term project than any commercial entity could survive in the short term if its commercial success relied on it.

Its certainly the kind of thing I can see Google being interested in, but not the kind of thing they would be around long enough to do if they didn't have a business strategy that did better at reaching the masses of people that actually exist now as they are than that could ever do.

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by orbifold on Saturday May 10, 2014 @04:08PM (#7726700)
That does not make sense. Newspapers are a primitive medium, that does not offer a lot of customization, yet in many ways they are superior in content to news websites. In any case it does not really matter how "dumb" the presentation of content is, if the content itself isn't "dumb".
Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by silverbax88 on Saturday May 10, 2014 @11:08AM (#7725645)
It was until it starting generating errors on the backend when they break compatibility with auto updates. Or the fact that it doesn't render Java correctly in some cases. Or the fact that it auto places the cursor in certain places for you despite you attempting to click in a specific textbox. Or the fact that it no longer allows you to set the target page of new tabs.

I was once in love with Chrome, but over the past few months I've started looking back at FireFox.

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by rasz_pl on Saturday May 10, 2014 @12:39PM (#7725996)
Chrome GUI is great ... if you never used Opera.
Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by platz on Saturday May 10, 2014 @10:23AM (#7725491)
Can't help but think is is an engineers mindset here (remember forms UIs with 50 gray buttons?). UIs were usable but not appealing. Older linux window managers. Designers making things look appealing brings computing to more people (not just pros) than otherwise.
Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by mgkimsal on Saturday May 10, 2014 @10:36AM (#7725537)
Except... what they had was appealing enough to people to use. It's unappealing enough now that people don't want to use it (even jumping to bing). Many people will continue to use it because of system defaults and such, but many will look for more usable alternatives.

Usability is 'appealing' just as much as visual button styling, maybe moreso.

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by DanBC on Saturday May 10, 2014 @10:35AM (#7725532)
Appealing is good. Usable is more important. Appealing and usable is great. Appealing but baffling and broken is stupid.

Most people do not want nor need fancy weird functionality.

They just want the maps, or maybe the directions.

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by GFK_of_xmaspast on Saturday May 10, 2014 @03:28PM (#7726592)
" Older linux window managers"

You remember that horrible WM everybody seemed to be running 10-15 years ago, 'enlightenment'? Completely unusable but it looked cool with all the shapes and transparencies and etc.

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by k0 on Saturday May 10, 2014 @12:19PM (#7725915)
+1 for Bing maps [shudders]. I tried yahoo maps and it is nearly as crappy as the new google maps...hell, Apple maps is superior to the new google maps...and I didn't see that coming.
Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by dennisgorelik on Sunday May 11, 2014 @11:26PM (#7731068)
Could the current Google Maps program manager be a saboteur from Apple or Microsoft?
Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by Lagged2Death on Saturday May 10, 2014 @01:55PM (#7726264)
I think you're right about trendiness and hubris associated with UI redesigns, but I think it might be a mistake to imagine this is some sort of one-time sea-change.

I think it's more of a constant churn; those who would "modernize" or "update" all sorts of designs - from software UI to software architecture to real architecture to interior decorating to graphic design and brand identity work - always have (arguably need to have) an unjustified level of self-confidence, a high opinion of their ability relative to the task they've got before them. They're always blind to the tweaking and tuning that was required to produce the thing they've set out to replace.

Most of the time, if they had an accurate idea of how monumental a task they were facing, they'd look for something else to do.

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by chetanahuja on Saturday May 10, 2014 @03:48PM (#7726647)
@Pacabel Absolutely true. The "design" folks are usually pressured to follow fashions. Current fashion in designs in the valley are unfortunately driven by people (ie "hipsters") with "minimal", "negative space", "beautiful" as their main values with usability, discoverability etc. being very low on the list of priorities.

Also, I can assert with some confidence, that the number of people choosing the Classic view (from the small question mark at the bottom), is being tracked as a metric of success or failure of the new UI high up on the chain of decision-making inside google.

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by User9821 on Saturday May 10, 2014 @02:04PM (#7726293)
I don't think it's 'hipsters' or young designers in general. I think situations like this happen when a bunch of people sit down in a room, and draw something up on a whiteboard. They draw all kinds of flow charts, sales funnels, color emotions, menu mockups, how X study showed 3% more users preferred the search bar 10px from the top, instead of 7px from the top, and how renaming the button from Search, to Go with a silly icon makes the company more human and will improve their image.

They get caught up in all these little details and studies, and on paper they can rationalize everything as being perfect. Then, it's a turd in reality, and everyone is left wondering what went wrong, the studies showed B was greater than A, and C was even better than B, and D surpassed C. So, how in the world can the original A be better than D? I don't know, but anyone in the design or development world can verify that it happens.

The Simpsons sum it up well in this episode...

http://i.imgur.com/VLgpw4L.jpg

The car is perfect, big windows and lots of sunlight, a giant cupholder, a horn that plays a catchy tune. Everything is great, until you look at things as a whole.

Now, my least favorite aspects of the new Google maps. I use it on almost a daily basis because I travel often, but I'll be trying to experiment with OpenStreetMaps, or Bing.

1. The search input box hides itself. Why in the world is the search hidden, forcing me to X out of directions to see it again?

2. The blue lines for directions make it nearly impossible to tell if the road offers street view. Mousing down on the little man produces blue availability lines, but you can't see them under the directions.

3. I don't believe it's possible to split directions and street view on the screen. This was the view I used most often. Splitting them side by side would make the most sense with widescreen monitors. Now, you just get a little map in the lower left, and it does a weird expanding animation when you hover over. Previously you could drag the little man to pan around the map, but now you have to keep clicking locations to move.

4. Images at the bottom. I'm here for maps, not images, so this makes absolutely no sense. The three little images at the bottom look like buttons for terrain, map, satellite view, bit instead they open these thumbnails. Now, you have to click the earth button to get satellite images, and the weird part, the image thumbnails at the bottom have separate visible/hidden settings depending on the view. If you close the thumbnail bar when viewing a map, then switch to satellite view, you would think it would stay closed. Nope, it'll open itself, because it's enabled on satellite view. You have to toggle it off on each view.

5. The top left dropdown. Way too many boxes expanding, collapsing, etc as I try to navigate.

My wishlist...

I'm just going to mention one thing, because this has bothered me for ages. Why the heck can't I customize the level of detail? There have been countless times where I just want to see countries and their names, or countries and capital cities. I'm looking at Europe right now, and it's not displaying half of the countries, but displaying city names all over the place. If I zoom in to see all the country names, the map is crowded with hundreds of cities and roads. I always end up doing an image search online for maps, because they achieve this most basic goal. Look at the below image. Google maps on the left. It still doesn't label the Czech Republic in that image. If I zoom out one level, it'll show the Czech Republic, but hide other country names, like Montenegro. Right is just a random map I pulled off an image search. The right map is 100x easier to see the borders and countries. Google maps is an absolute disaster in these situations. If I ask someone that isn't familiar with European geography to find the Czech Republic in the below images, they'll be scratching their heads with Google maps, unless they start zooming in and out hoping the name of the desired country pops into view.

http://i.imgur.com/skpNOyd.jpg

You can show me street view from a coral reef, or roads in some obscure village on a small island, but you can't show me a simple world map with country names? Where are the priorities here?

Edit: Switched my homepage to DuckDuckGo instead of Google search, and updated by bookmarks to OpenStreetMap. I'm honestly getting tired of supporting Google, since the list of things they do right gets smaller on a weekly basis. It's time I give someone else a turn.

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by chrisrhoden on Saturday May 10, 2014 @10:11AM (#7725450)
So, in other words, kids these days?
Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by Pacabel on Saturday May 10, 2014 @10:16AM (#7725466)
No, not at all. It isn't really about age. I've dealt with "hipsters" in their 40s and 50s who've come up with very bad UI designs. Likewise, many of the managers or executives advocating for these redesigns are in their 30s, 40s or even 50s.

While it may be more of an issue with younger people due to a greater lack of experience and intuition, it's a phenomenon that's quite independent of age.

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by chrisrhoden on Saturday May 10, 2014 @12:22PM (#7725933)
"Kids these days" is rarely strictly about age.

It's usually about a class of people who have helped to design the systems we have at present and who are therefore heavily invested in those systems in a variety of ways reacting negatively to a class of people attempting to help design new systems that they will one day defend due to their investment in them.

The idea that UX was better in the 1980s kind of gives you away here.

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by judk on Saturday May 10, 2014 @11:02AM (#7725625)
> These people are often relatively young, often have limited experience

> "hipsters" in their 40s and 50s

These statements cancel each other out, so there's no reason to state either as supposedly providing information content.

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by Pacabel on Saturday May 10, 2014 @11:16AM (#7725671)
Are you really suggesting that people can't have second or even third careers?

A 40-year-old who got into web design after a lengthy career in print media design, if not some totally unrelated field, is often no more experienced than a 20-year-old who got directly into web design. I know this can be true, because I've worked with both types of people in the past.

And "often" does not mean "always", obviously.

Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by leemcalilly on Saturday May 10, 2014 @11:01AM (#7725624)
Your class action ad hominem attack is not constructive.
Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by tolmasky on Saturday May 10, 2014 @01:30PM (#7726167)
This comment also servers as a short history of the development of iOS 7.
Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by baldeagle on Saturday May 10, 2014 @11:03AM (#7725626)
I was with you until you went on about GNOME 3... oh wait, I was still with you..
Re:Google Maps Has Forsaken Us by mikeycgto on Saturday May 10, 2014 @02:44PM (#7726462)
I enjoy GNOME 3.

Have been using it for a long while now and really don't have any major complaints. Granted, I don't use many desktop programs (browsers, terminal, chat programs and nuvola player).