The privacy issue doesn't concern me as much, since it's already possible to rent a helicopter and follow someone around all day. The only attribute that's changing is the cost: rather than paying $300/h for a helicopter, you can pay a couple bucks an hour for constant surveillance.
At least in my experience. You didn't have people flying RC choppers or airplanes in the street.
They were quite a bit heavier, larger, and noisier so you didn't have the same issues as we're now having to face with drones.
Drone seem like a very simple matter to me, it seems americans are ignoring a long of history with model aircraft and simply common sense, specially when it comes to privacy concerns. Simply making drones unregulated wouldn't mean the city would be dominated by them overnight. Common sense snooping regulations should apply. Do you frequently see people snooping their neighbors intrusively? Why would they use a drone for that? Common sense should dictate the operator is responsible for it's misuse and any accident.
In Brazil you are essentially free to use drones however you wish; there's no relevant regulation so you'd have to do something really bad to have someone come after you. Yet there's no drone abuse, and plenty of cool applications. I've been to a bike race some time ago and the finishing line was filmed by a drone, it was pretty cool. People are using drones for mapping, agriculture, media, etc. I haven't heard of a single problem with aviation or privacy.
IMO, if your willing to fly it into yourself at full speed it's safe enough to fly without any regulation. More dangerous than that and basic certification seems like a reasonable precaution.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bird_strike
Relatively few fatalities for humans, but very high cost. And they are not made of metal or durable plastics. They are also less likely to fall onto your head with rapidly rotating blades due to technical failure.
Regulations do not necessarily mean that you can't fly any drone without a permit.
This wouldn't be an issue if we were only talking about upgraded small RC aircraft being used as drones, but some companies are selling much larger drones that are way outside of existing "bird strike" parameters.
You can't have dozens of unregulated news drones the size of a small car flying through the same airspace as rescue choppers.
Not going to happen. There's nothing special at all about the hardware to fly one so if anyone can make their own there's no point even trying to put DRM on it.
This is the same as trying to ban certain 3d printer files the gov. doesn't like.
In ways I agree with you, in others I don't. You shouldn't just be able to "fly it wherever I damn well please" unless you own the airspace above or maybe if it's land designated as acceptable for that purpose. I think certain laws of public access will probably translate well, if the government doesn't use this as an opportunity to curtail freedoms and liberty again. I for one don't want you "flying it wherever you damn well please" unless that means I can "shoot it down however I damn well please"
So in your example, you just caused real property damage (by shooting down the drone) because it was on property you don't even own (the air).
http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2012/10/if-i-f...
In the article: the first case the supreme court heard on the matter was a chicken farmer who said planes flying overhead were scaring his chickens, and they would fly into walls from fright. He had about 150 dead chickens. The planes were flying at 83 ft. He lost that case.
Here's the Wikipedia "air rights" article... it has a section on the US:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_rights
A quote:
Specifically, the Federal Aviation Act provides that: "The United States Government has exclusive sovereignty of airspace of the United States."[2] The act defines navigable airspace as "airspace above the minimum altitudes of flight…including airspace needed to ensure the safety in the takeoff and landing of aircraft."[3]
It also mentions a 500ft min limit for sparsely populated areas. But note, that's a limit set by the FAA. They may lower it or raise it if they want to.
In the wikipedia article you'll also find a quote from a case by a property owner suing a nearby airport. I think it perfectly sums up the rights of property owners with regards to the air.. but it's a little long to post here.
I think this is the future, and it is inevitable. We are going to have lots and lots of tiny drones flying around our cities. Some will be doing light-package deliveries, some will be doing photos and videos for journalism, some will be collecting information for various web apps, and so on. And all of them will be equipped (required by regulation) with sensors and software to avoid colliding with objects, people and each other.
I imagine it'll also be very hard to track a rogue drone down to it's owner. Too small for radar, too maneuverable to follow with an airplane or helicopter. Will we see police drones with automatic drone pursuit abilities?
However, rest assured that as soon as someone (presumably Google) manages to lobby a way to lower the legal burden of responsibilities on the human ‘driver’ because he or she was not supposed to pay attention, or react to the automated driving, there will be an way to argue that a car can drive empty. And, from then, they won’t be many truck drivers employed very soon. Drones for the last mile or last yard delivery might make sense, but I rather see Wall-E-like o Big-Dog-like bots swarming from the truck.
In other words: Amazon wasn’t joking entirely, but the idea of a swarm of flying things isn’t any more energy efficient then than it is now.
This type of fear is common for any type of new technology. I am sure people had similar fear when automobiles started to appear in the streets. They might have said "what if the car hit me while I am walking". Eventually, we will all get used to it and start to live with risks associated with it.
Driving is highly regulated. You need a driver's license. Cars need to be equipped with certain safety features which must be inspected regularly. You're only allowed to drive on certain prepared surfaces, etc.
That would have to be enforced by more powerful drones, able to out-run, capture and drag down commercially available models.
I highly suspect that the space above a private property up to the commercial line will be considered part of that's person's space. After that it will be like most everything else, there will be places you can and can't fly, just like there are places you can drive a car, take a walk, and so on.
You can fly unmanned balloons, helicopters, Macross robots... whatever. Essentially the FAA has no jurisdiction below 700 feet ourside controlled zones, so if you avoid those you can basically fly anywhere you want.
First world problems. Literally.
I don't envy the FAA. They are being dragged kicking and screaming into this new age of drone flight. It is going to take a while for good policies to emerge regarding the use of drones.
I personally am conflicted. I don't especially want a drove hovering over me wherever I go. What if it crashes into me? But I also want the freedom to go buy a drone and fly it wherever I damn well please (without having to have a permit or deal with red tape).
I'm not sure what the answer is. Require insurance for drone operators? Require licenses?