(Note that I'm not saying there isn't talent elsewhere, just that there's an incredible concentration of it in the top n schools.)
What's likely happening is that really smart kids at good state schools end up finding the pockets of talent there anyway.
Pretty scary implications for the value of a Harvard degree.
source: http://www.newyorker.com/archive/2005/10/10/051010crat_atlar...
Raising a venture round from Sequoia is probably a decent non-academic example of this. I would not be surprised if companies who turn Sequoia away are just as successful as those who are funded by them (although the former is probably a small data set!).
Sure, I'll be graduating about ~$140k better off than most other students. But over the lifetime of a successful tech entrepreneur that amount of money is fairly meaningless. Having spent a significant amount of time on top campuses (where most of my friends went), I often regret making that decision—the caliber of students is truly higher, and the friends/networks you have from a school like Harvard will pay dividends throughout life.
That's my story. I went to good-but-not-world-renowned state school for undergrad on a full ride. I did my best to wring the absolute most out of that experience, and it paid off in many ways, including a fellowship that paid for my master's at an Ivy. Most grad students don't get plugged into "the network", but I went out of my way to engage in campus life. In the process, I'm fairly positive I built just as good of a network as if I had attended for undergrad.
Point being, everywhere you are has something to offer. Make the most of your situation!
Glad that worked out for you.
To be clear, my school is actually extraordinarily good academically (we're privately funded by an oil fortune)—it's just that the prestige of the name and student's isn't quite at Ivy quality.
> Point being, everywhere you are has something to offer. Make the most of your situation!
I'm doing my best, and doing pretty well (making 6 figures as a college sophomore), so my regrets are more social/intellectual than monetary. Though sometimes I wonder if YC would have accepted me if I had advertised my Ivy League stamps of approval (acceptance letters)...
Maybe I'll go to Harvard when I get tired of developing and decide to "pivot" into management/finance.
Be glad you didn't. I don't think it would have sent a positive sign. Frankly, no one wants to hear about the things you didn't do, and things like acceptance letters and SAT scores don't matter going forward.
Life is going to be filled with tough calls. Sometimes, you may have 5 promising but exclusive options to choose from. You can't make the most of the path you've taken while wasting mental energy on the ones you didn't. Take it from someone who wasted a lot of mental energy on such things before learning not to.
You said elsewhere you go to NYU -- what's stopping you from maximizing your social and intellectual opportunities?
I know (it's why I don't usually go around talking about how I could have gone to Harvard). Though it does sadden me that the VC and tech ecosystem is almost as prestige-focused as Wall Street.
> You said elsewhere you go to NYU -- what's stopping you from maximizing your social and intellectual opportunities?
Mostly that I don't have much commonality with those around me. Everyone seems to be focused on getting the "right" internship and studying, while I'd like to have meaningful conversations about intellectually intriguing topics. Plus, my general lack of social skills and nerdiness at a school which is decidedly not nerdy.
What you describe socially/environmentally sounds a lot like the typical Ivy League experience. Gossip, politics, inner circles within inner circles, who-you-know, etc.
Fortunately, social skills are something you can improve, if you set your mind to it. That's one reason I'm really glad I did my college experience in the order I did. I don't think I could have truly taken advantage of my grad school experience if not for going to undergrad someplace where everyone wasn't constantly jockeying to get ahead.
I'm sure you have more commonality with people than you think. Being adept socially is all about finding those commonalities. Usually, that means being able to step out of your own head to empathize with what other people's social needs are. The most social people I know have a way of making other people feel like the most interesting person in the world.
It sounds like you've got a lot going for you, and if you're a sophomore now, you've got a lot of time to figure everything out. Best of luck. Drop me a line if you want to grab a coffee or something. I went to NYU for my second grad school experience :)
I've considered it, but HYPS essentially don't accept transfers. Plus, being in New York for the next year is very helpful professionally (I currently attend NYU).
Given that the best course materials can increasingly be found online, the only benefit of a school is its social network, in which the elite schools have a formidable monopoly.
This idea (first quoted sentence) needs to die. It is toxic to the early-stage ecosystem. Any amount of money is a ton of money. Period. You can ignore the hustling that Jobs or Zuckerberg did for literally a couple of thousand dollars - read Zuckerberg's contracts at the time he was at Harvard making facebook. Look at the timing jobs "Stole" $5000 from Woz and founded Apple with it (making his friend a multimillionaire in the process). The reality is that no windfall bonus from Atari of less than $4300 - which is money that Jobs had 0, absolutely 0, access to, from any other source - equals no Apple. Look at the dates.
You can also ignore what companies actually spend the YCombinator seed money on when it was $14K-$20K, at a time that the YC badge easily added $200K+ to a YC company's average valuation - a badge that doesn't bring instant liquidity. How many YC companies would not exist if YC only added its badge to the valuation, and not actually given any money.[1]
What you can't ignore is that there are people who are working a day job while owning and building a company - working that day job because any amount of money, even part of a single full time earner's after-tax salary, is a ton of money.
Just try raising it.
[1] Imagine if the YC admission read: "Congratulations! This admission is easily worth $200K in extra valuation. With the YC badge, you should have no trouble raising money. We are therefore not making any cash investment, not even $12K, but rendering only services. We welcome you to the bay area on (date)."
You don't have to give away anything. be an entrepreneur.
37signals started that way, for what it's worth. Not by living with their parents, of course; by bootstrapping a consultancy.
PlentyOfFish started that way.
Braintree started that way.
Come to think of it, so did Github.
And didn't Mailchimp bootstrap, too?
I think maybe the impedance mismatch here is that you assume I'm saying companies need to raise more than 120k to start. They don't, if they start out profitable. But that's not the normal YC startup strategy: those companies depend on the ability to run for a year, maybe many years, before generating profits. Against that strategy, 120k is not very meaningful. Which is why 'pg and now 'sama are always at pains to point out that people shouldn't apply "for the money".
I have a roommate in SF. He's freelancing, I'm working at a company. He's making more cash than I am, but I'm working on building a company (as an employee) that's shipped multiple iterations of a category-leading product, raised $XX million in VC, and hired almost 100 people.
I'm not disputing that a good freelancer can clear $120k net of taxes and living expenses, just that that's the best path to take, if the end goal is to be an entrepreneur.
Practically every established consultancy in the US throws off numbers like that year in year out, as a routine. Which is one reason a lot of consultancies end up spinning up product teams.
But that $100K? That was a ton of money.
Basically, you are wrong that it was not a ton of money, your anchors and comparisons are toxic and misleading, and if he had not cut that check then Larry and Sergey would not have created Google. That is what actual reality shows us.
You simply do an incredible disservice to all early-stage startups by talking in these terms.
I gave you several actual examples of far less than $120K being a ton of money in an early-stage context. As little as $5000 being a ton of money. I also specifically stated that if, say, $20K, weren't a lot of money, then it would make no difference empirically if YCombinator did not actually pay that cash. And YC companies wouldn't have either relied on or even actually spent that cash. But it does make a difference, and they did.
As I specifically point out: your FTE expenses are completely irrelevant, and even part (less than 100%) of the after-tax portion of a single FTE salary is a ton of money. (In an early-stage context.)
To imply otherwise does a huge disservice to all first-time, early-stage founders everywhere. The very idea is toxic and needs to die.
[1] The meaning of anchor I use is: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anchoring
[2] Your figures both about (1) the cost to the company of a fully loaded FTE senior engineer and (2) the amount that a good freelancer can generate above living expenses in a year, are irrelevant and do not need to be argued. I will grant both as irrelevant to the discussion.
* 120k will barely pay the fully loaded cost of a single engineer
* A good freelancer can generate 120k above living expenses in a year
Your response was "the fully loaded cost of an engineer is irrelevant". That's a weird argument, given that the cost of engineers dominates the expenses of early-stage startups.
You know this, so I'm not sure why you're off on a tangent about things that don't normally apply in these situations.
If I gave you $120k to start a company with 1-2 other people, and you had no other funding commitments, I don't think I'd be changing your odds all that much.
But I have no trouble believing that when YC gives founders $120k, they are changing the odds significantly.
It would help if you read my comments more carefully. The one you just replied to was particularly simple. Almost the only thing it says is that being a part of YC improves the odds. But the 120k isn't what's doing that.
The skills to get that big company job or land those consulting clients are pretty much the same skills you need to make your product company successful. An understanding of what people will pay you money for. Ability to execute on a project. Collaboration and communication. And of course, solid coding skills. The difference is that a product company also requires a fair degree of business strategy, determination, and sheer resourcefulness that you don't need to get a job.
So if you want to found a successful company, you're much better off developing those skills, testing them by getting a job or someone else to pay you money, and then striking off on your own. If you just get the money, chances are you will lose the money pretty soon too.
We are in a crazy scenario where we are seeking a Series A with a good product in a validated market fit.
The investors have essentially said unless you are eating ramen noodles and scraping by we are not interested.
^^ That attitude essentially rules out anyone with a family, prior commitments or debts from college/life.
Why would a funding round not earmark a portion for a fair (albeit lower than market) salary?
I have to agree with you that what is "a lot of money" is entirely relative; I don't think that $5k in today's terms is a lot of money by any startup's standards but any amount upwards of $15k or so is definitely "a lot of money" to a larval startup.
And, let's be honest, $120k really isn't a lot of money. Sure, it might be more than my net worth right now—but as an engineer I could easily save up that amount in less than 2 years.
However, engineers and recruiters at the top tech companies like Google/Facebook/Amazon/Microsoft have definitely heard of YC.
It has less to do with prestige and more to do with risk.
IMHO, there are only two routes to becoming part of today's tech elite. You either build something that gets traction or you join a team that has already done so. These are IMHO the two strongest signals today, especially given the increase of noise. Don't believe me? Just search around AngelList for 30 min. If your son gets a CS degree from Stanford or MIT, it will automatically put him in that basket of "join a team who has already done so", just as working for Google, Facebook, Twitter, etc does.
EDIT: I'm not saying this can't be achieved at other schools - I didn't attend a "name" school, but the network definitely matters and can be a huge bonus especially if you know what industry you want to target.
He then became a consultant at 21 making about $500K a year, at least for a few years. Don't know what happened to him after those certs became useless, but I hope he converted somehow.
YMMV. I do think it's better to give money to people who are already succeeding and could just use a bit of acceleration or a chance to do something riskier, though. At earlier stages advice and introductions are often more useful in the long term.
If the startup (company) goes the distance then whatever equity you bought with investment would convert to your son as part of his inheritance altering the partnership drastically.
The legal and financial ramifications can be quite complex.
$120K is about the list price of two years of Harvard/MIT/Stanford . With a son who loves to program, I have wondered if sending him to a cheaper school and giving him the difference in installments after he graduates is better than paying for a "name" school. It depends on the quality of the cheaper school, of course. And I think school prestige matters more for investment banking than tech, so I'd be less inclined to suggest a cheaper school to a budding banker.