The problem is that pretty much every employment contract for tech companies big and small in the US have this type of clause as standard even for non-techie employees. It's been this way for over a decade now. INAL but I've heard that the only "easy" way around it is to make a specific change to your employment contract that makes it less ridiculously broad and aggressive BEFORE you have any issues. You probably need a lawyer for that, and even if you do; your lawyer's work only helps if your employer, more specifically their legal team, actually agrees to it. My former coworker's wife is a employment contract lawyer so that helped him become aware of it and mitigate it. I don't feel that most people have this advantage.
It is in pretty much every tech company's employment contract in the US regardless of size. I've seen this in Georgia, New York, Texas, Washington, and California. If it's a Fortune 1000 company, they're going to have. If it's a startup, they're probably going to have it. A lot of people just aren't aware of it because they don't tend to read their 10+ page employment contracts full of headache inducing, legalese.
> I don't know whether it's just FUD, whether it's not as common as it was in the 80's or early 90's
It is not FUD, and it's a lot more common than it was before the 90s.
How did this get super popular? Someone can correct me, but it starts with Apple in the 90s. Hotmail was actually developed by an Apple employee during his off time. Well MS buys it and Apple gets nothing. Why? It's probably because they didn't have this clause or a more aggressive and broad version of it like what we have today. Apple really is a trend setter.
Anyways the legal clause is basically ridiculous, since the general legal strategy is to be aggressive early on. In layman's terms ANYTHING you come up with, at ANYTIME during your employment either on company time or your own personal time, and ANYWHERE either in the office or in your own home, belongs to your employer regardless of your employer's industry.
What mortifies me is 1. how prevalent this is, and 2. how ignorant everyone is of its existence.
If you couple that with an expectation in certain programming circles that you should do programming as a hobby as well as a job, you've got the nice effect of working 40 hours a week for your employer, + all the hours that you spend on programming in your free time for your employer, as in 'they'll cash in if it is succesful'. So like a little speculative, cost free investment for the company.
The only way that I can reconcile this with the modern off-work github coding is that the programmers don't keep this in the back of their minds, and that whatever big fall outs of this have been relatively isolated.
(obviously I am only talking about side projects that could potentially have some value, not the 'implement pac man in brainfuck' for the pain, I mean for educational purposes, type of projects)
[1] http://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/arbnerfg/BJNR007560957.htm...
It's this last point where you might well run into legitimate disagreement. What is the "raw material" for a piece of software? If it's the knowledge that goes into writing it, then arguably the employer did supply that.
I can pretty much remember what code I wrote during a day. Not verbatim of course, but if I solved a problem at 10:00 AM, I'll be able to figure it out again at 6:00 PM. What is to prevent me from going to work for a small software company, working on their product during the day, cashing their paychecks, and duplicating my work at night? When I'm done, I just quit and sell my version as a competitor?
At the job I currently work, our product is for a very specialized domain. I can remember the problems that I've solved, but there's no way I could build or sell a product in the same market without the domain expertise that my employer brings to the table.
Maybe your employer is providing capital to fund the salaries of a team of developers to build a product that has no guarantee of any market success, saving you the trouble of risking that kind of money, or convincing somebody else to risk it for you.
Maybe you don't like sales, and your employer is going out to potential customers and convincing them to use your product, so you can keep working on the stuff you're really good at.
Point is, if you legitimately can't think of some value that your employer adds to your work, maybe you really should take off and do the same thing for yourself.
But that aside, I'm not sure you got my point. Something doesn't have to be easy to do in order for it to be illegal. There are lots of reasons why a person might not want to do this -- you mention several of them. But that also doesn't mean that the employer shouldn't have the right to prevent them from doing it if they did want to. If your employer is paying for you to figure out how to solve a particular problem, generally the employer gets ownership of that work. If you then duplicate it on your own, it's a pretty gray area as to whether the employer gets some claim over it.
I don't think this guy is a necessarily bad guy by any stretch, and I don't think he was intentionally trying to harm his former employer, but he's a little clueless.
How are you proving that you did not use internal company knowledge to build the competing product? This is a legal nightmare, just do yourself a favor and don't do it. Or do you also think that NDA-clauses for employees are invalid?
However they do not own me, which is what your implying with your statements. Any employer that needs to use legal threats and controls on my personal time to control me is probably not someone I would ever work for anyway
See, most people are trying to be nice and I'll take your word for it that you're one of them. That's not the people we write contracts for. The contracts and legal threats are for the people that don't play nice. Those employees that push of all their work to the colleagues so that they can not only moonlight for the competition, but actively support it during their time at the office. (no joke, seen that).
"While you work for me I own your mind"
Can we apply that to bricklayers as well?
They might have "proprietary" information on how to make an arch or build a stable house or how the company is structured and organized so they probably shouldn't be allowed to work for anybody else in that field ever again.
If they want that separation they have to be willing to pay for it.
Would work wonders in software development where the code is complex enough to be forgotten in weeks.
> Penal sanctions, previously considered perfectly in line with free labor, became in the 19th century a way to transform ordinary labor into "contracts of slavery."
My employer, Google, has the most expensive lawyers money can buy and they will not hesiste to ruin your life in order to defend the company's interests. Like the guy in the article I have a family to support and the pottential affect is just not worth the risk.
The construction company would have a valid claim if you stole the blueprints at work.
No, he is not on either count.
> that's what your paid for.
I don't know you, but I'm paid for the work I produce, I'd be really happy if I could be paid for learning stuff and not doing shit.
> The construction company would have a valid claim if you stole the blueprints at work.
Yes. It would not have a valid claim if you built stuff on the side, even if it's better stuff. Your company does not own your knowledge, which is why non-compete agreements are invalid in just about all jurisdictions unless very heavily compensated (in Germany it's at least 50% of gross and no more than 2 years, and clauses can still be found unreasonable and invalidated).
These clauses are enforceable in every state, though some states such as California limit the breadth of "related" to the specific industry or industries in which the employer operates.
His company is paying him to solve problems in a particular space. Once he solves them, he knows how to solve them in the future. When working on an OSS project in the same space, he can apply the techniques he learned at his job to that project.
Your employer does not pay the time you spend on work-related research (or even general research)? Change job. It's part of what programmers do - find solutions to problems, and since most problems we're facing are variations of problems other people already solved research and learning about possible solutions are an important part of our work, I'd even say the most critical part. I'm happy to compensate my employees for that.
> which is why non-compete agreements are invalid
There's no noncompete clause being discussed here. It's basically a case of "I'm building the same product as at work, just for free" and the guy is making a direct competitor to his employer. Sorry, if one of my employees did build a competing product while being employed here without explicit permission, I'd fire him.
If the guy build something mostly unrelated to his work, I'd totally agree with him, but the way this case looks like, no, I'm not.
> No, he is not on either count.
Yes they are... are you honestly trying to tell us you've learned jack all at your current employer? No new frameworks, coding practices, algorithms? Learnt absolutely nothing about how various patterns of software writing pan out in production?
If you've learned absolutely nothing, you have to be one of the most useless developers your employer has. I find that impossible to believe.
> > that's what your paid for.
> I don't know you, but I'm paid for the work I produce, I'd be really happy if I could be paid for learning stuff and not doing shit.
No, you're being paid for your skills and abilities. That includes your learning ability. It's not "learning stuff and not doing shit", it's "learn stuff as you're doing shit". Everyone does it. A company can't guarantee where or what it's going to be working on next year or so, the market always changes. What they do have is staff capital, including hopefully a team of capable programmers that can do whatever the changing market requires, be it picking up a new language, optimising algorithms, etc. That's what people hiring and employing staff are looking for. If you're not bringing all your abilities to the job, including your ability to learn, then you've been working under really crappy bosses who have been letting you get away with it.
In this particular case he's working on a CI system both in his day job and his out-of-hours work. Are you seriously trying to tell us he learned absolutely nothing about CI during the day time, and only learned stuff out-of-hours? That he gained absolutely nothing from his colleagues? Operational aspects of the software? UI?
No way. Employer is not entitled to all java code just because he paid me to java certification. Employer to all my products forever just because he paid my college or whatever.
"that's what your paid for"
I am paid for work done for employer. I'm not own by him.
"It would be extremely easy to just keep your best ideas for "your" project and not use them in your work project."
Well, then your workplace contribution would be lower then the contribution of your collegues. I would expect you to have lower salary or be fired if you contribute too little. The same way as if you would never had the idea in the first place.
"The construction company would have a valid claim if you stole the blueprints at work."
However, the construction company would NOT have a valid claim if I would make my own blueprints at home.
Your understanding of "specific area" is quite broad. I thought more along the lines "his employer paid him to do research and development for CI-Systems", so he should not in his spare time build a competing CI-System.
> I am paid for work done for employer. I'm not own by him.
Where did I say so? You're certainly not owned by your employer, you're not a slave. But you can't go and build the same thing at home and give it away for free as you're building at work and get paid for. Even for a construction guy that would be a problem. Undercutting your employer with knowledge gained at work? Do you think any employer would be fine with that?
"Some" maybe, but probably not "a lot".
so he's entitled to all your ideas in that area, that's what your paid for.
I'd argue that, in general, this is wrong. Most companies pay based on the idea that you work approximately a 40hr work week. Certainly most of us negotiate salary based on this assumption. But if a company wants all of the ideas from my brain, 24x7, they are going to have to pay a lot more. Like, 4 or 5 times more, and that's just as a starting point.
It would be extremely easy to just keep your best ideas for "your" project and not use them in your work project.
As long as your employer is happy with the results you're delivering, does it matter if they're getting your "best" ideas or not?
Absolutely not, you're paid for your time, not your thoughts!
Are you? I pay my employees for the value they create for the company, not to warm the chair at the office eight hours on five days a week. If someone is more productive in four hours a day than someone else at eight hours, well, go home after four, still get paid more. Fine with me.
What you do in your personal time is none of your employers business he is not paying for that time and he does not own whatever you create in that time.
Not unless you signed a ridiculous contract saying something like that which in my opinion should not be enforceable anyway.
It's like a construction company saying it owns the house you built for your family just because you happen to work for them and you gained experience by working for them.
They certainly didn't supply the raw material which in programming would be time and effort so they shouldn't have any claim on it.