Re:G.M. Puts Volt’s Mileage in City in Triple Digits
by ynniv on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @01:07PM
(#755692)
Watt-hours per mile is common, and easy enough for a reasonable consumer to calculate the expense of given the cost of a kWh in their neighborhood.
EPA MPG estimates for electric vehicles are unfortunately purposely distorted for the purposes of giving electric vehicles higher MPG [ http://www.sae.org/mags/AEI/6559 ]. For instance, a gallon of gasoline contains about 33 kWh of energy, but an normal car wastes about 2/3 of this, netting only 11 kWh per gallon.
Logically, an electric car should arrive at an MPG by calculating the number of miles that it would travel on this same amount of energy. Instead, the EPA has told all-electric companies that they can do this computation using 82 kWh (almost 7.5 times more than the logical value), giving all-electric cars a huge benefit (Nissan's upcoming electric has claimed 367 MPG).
Plug-in electric cars use a different value, which is somewhere between the two, giving Chevy some magic number in between. Just to confuse matters, the EPA sticker on the electric Mini quotes kWh/100 mi, giving it "33" city and "36" highway, numbers that resemble current gasoline car mileages.
[EDIT: Also, it has been said that the gasoline engine in the Volt will provide around 50 MPG. Whenever you travel farther than 40 miles (assuming a full battery), this car is no more gasoline efficient than the Prius.]
Re:G.M. Puts Volt’s Mileage in City in Triple Digits
by ccc3 on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @12:23PM
(#755578)
Agreed. It'll have to be a measure of energy consumption per mile. Consumers will also have to develop an understanding of the relative cost of different energy sources.
Maybe we rate cars in Miles/Joule and rate energy sources in Joules/$. Makes the math pretty simple.
Re:G.M. Puts Volt’s Mileage in City in Triple Digits
by sp332 on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @12:35PM
(#755603)
You might need to add some cargo/people capacity in there. A tiny electric car will have a hard time beating a diesel MAC truck for efficiency when it's hauling a few tons :)
Re:G.M. Puts Volt’s Mileage in City in Triple Digits
by ynniv on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @02:07PM
(#755878)
There is no intuitive way to convey what you are proposing. If you tried to move 4 tons of cargo, a big rig would use less energy than a Civic. If you are trying to get yourself across town, a Civic will use less energy than a big rig. It would be complicated and expensive to calculate the full spectrum of efficiencies for a vehicle under different cargo loads. Personally, I would use the data, but I suspect the average person would find multiple efficiency graphs to be overwhelming.
Re:G.M. Puts Volt’s Mileage in City in Triple Digits
by buofbouy on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @11:56AM
(#755499)
And that plugins are going to be designed around the specifics of the EPA test. If the next plugin only needs the engine for half the time on this same route will that count as 500mpg?
Re:G.M. Puts Volt’s Mileage in City in Triple Digits
by ynniv on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @01:40PM
(#755788)
Not true, idling consumes gasoline. Unless you have disabled your steering lock, and can do without power steering, headlights, AC, or brakes (not recommended :-) ), you are not getting ∞ MPG, even if your car tells you otherwise.
Re:G.M. Puts Volt’s Mileage in City in Triple Digits
by kvh on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @12:02PM
(#755524)
just to be clear, you save as much gas moving up from a 20 mpg car to 25 mpg car as you do going from 50 mpg to 100mpg. (think in terms of gals per 100 mile)
Re:G.M. Puts Volt’s Mileage in City in Triple Digits
by brown9-2 on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @12:55PM
(#755655)
Well yeah, but in absolute terms only.
Car 1: instead of needing 5 gallons you only need 4 gallons. Saved: 1 gallon (20%)
Car 2: instead of needing 2 gallons you only need 1 gallon. Saved: 1 gallon (50%)
But who makes comparisons like this in absolute terms? I rather save 50% than 20%, but maybe that's just me.
Re:G.M. Puts Volt’s Mileage in City in Triple Digits
by brown9-2 on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @02:13PM
(#755898)
The lack of a plan on how to deal with urban customers or those who don't have a garage to park the car in (apartment dwellers) is really disconcerting. As the article says, these are the people who could benefit from this car the most.
Re:G.M. Puts Volt’s Mileage in City in Triple Digits
by ynniv on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @01:50PM
(#755814)
Close, but not quite. The sentence right before their 40¢ a day claim, they say $2.75 per 100 miles. That works out to 82.5¢ for 30 miles, or $1.10 per 40 miles. 82.5¢ is 3 times better than the current $2.60 for a gallon of gas, but grid power is almost double the 11¢/kWh used for these calculations in some parts of the country.
Re:G.M. Puts Volt’s Mileage in City in Triple Digits
by zngtk4 on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @12:23PM
(#755579)
That electricity cost is based on a single location. My electricity is 12.5cents per KWH, regardless of time of day. That turns into about 3 cents per mile, rather than 1 cent per mile quoted in this article.
1. Moving forward, MPG is not going to be a good measure of efficiency or operating cost.
2. GM is run by salespeople, not engineers.
MP$, MPKWH?
MP$ is what we really care about but it has to be adjusted for price fluctuations of power and gasoline, pretty impractical.
Maybe list MPG City, MPG Highway, MPKWH Battery on the sticker.
EPA MPG estimates for electric vehicles are unfortunately purposely distorted for the purposes of giving electric vehicles higher MPG [ http://www.sae.org/mags/AEI/6559 ]. For instance, a gallon of gasoline contains about 33 kWh of energy, but an normal car wastes about 2/3 of this, netting only 11 kWh per gallon.
Logically, an electric car should arrive at an MPG by calculating the number of miles that it would travel on this same amount of energy. Instead, the EPA has told all-electric companies that they can do this computation using 82 kWh (almost 7.5 times more than the logical value), giving all-electric cars a huge benefit (Nissan's upcoming electric has claimed 367 MPG).
Plug-in electric cars use a different value, which is somewhere between the two, giving Chevy some magic number in between. Just to confuse matters, the EPA sticker on the electric Mini quotes kWh/100 mi, giving it "33" city and "36" highway, numbers that resemble current gasoline car mileages.
(more info: http://www.hybridcars.com/fuel-economy-numbers/confusion-ove...)
[EDIT: Also, it has been said that the gasoline engine in the Volt will provide around 50 MPG. Whenever you travel farther than 40 miles (assuming a full battery), this car is no more gasoline efficient than the Prius.]
As we move toward alternative fuels, we need a fuel-independent metric.
Maybe we rate cars in Miles/Joule and rate energy sources in Joules/$. Makes the math pretty simple.
Not to mention that absolute savings are important when it comes to carbon reduction.
Compared to $2-4 for 30 miles on the average sedan, not bad.
Maybe this will finally spur Toyota to add a plug-in standard on the Prius.