Re:G.M. Puts Volt’s Mileage in City in Triple Digits
by ccc3 on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @12:23PM
(#755578)
Agreed. It'll have to be a measure of energy consumption per mile. Consumers will also have to develop an understanding of the relative cost of different energy sources.
Maybe we rate cars in Miles/Joule and rate energy sources in Joules/$. Makes the math pretty simple.
Re:G.M. Puts Volt’s Mileage in City in Triple Digits
by sp332 on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @12:35PM
(#755603)
You might need to add some cargo/people capacity in there. A tiny electric car will have a hard time beating a diesel MAC truck for efficiency when it's hauling a few tons :)
Re:G.M. Puts Volt’s Mileage in City in Triple Digits
by ynniv on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @01:38PM
(#755783)
Just as a Vespa would have poor gas mileage carrying heavy truck cargo - this has nothing to do with the energy source.
Re:G.M. Puts Volt’s Mileage in City in Triple Digits
by sp332 on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @01:51PM
(#755822)
I thought that was the idea - removing different energy sources from the picture and looking at which vehicles are more efficient.
Re:G.M. Puts Volt’s Mileage in City in Triple Digits
by ynniv on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @02:07PM
(#755878)
There is no intuitive way to convey what you are proposing. If you tried to move 4 tons of cargo, a big rig would use less energy than a Civic. If you are trying to get yourself across town, a Civic will use less energy than a big rig. It would be complicated and expensive to calculate the full spectrum of efficiencies for a vehicle under different cargo loads. Personally, I would use the data, but I suspect the average person would find multiple efficiency graphs to be overwhelming.
As we move toward alternative fuels, we need a fuel-independent metric.