Microsoft fans have been making this argument for 15 years or more. They said Apple should copy Dell and sell cheap enterprise desktops with low margins because that was where the money was. Then they said Apple should copy Asus and HP and sell cheap netbooks with low margins because that was the future. Then people said Apple should be making a really cheap ebook reader to compete with the Kindle.
People are constantly advising Apple that they should get into low margin markets and compete on price with companies that are barely breaking even. This advice seems to mostly be based on what they want the market to look like, more than how it actually is.
I keep seeing people talk like Apple 'lost' the PC wars and will 'lose' the phone wars the same way, yet Apple's PC business is insanely profitable by PC market standards. Commoditization of the PC market hasn't touched Apple's PC business in any way. What it does is lock the other PC vendors into a race to the bottom, leaving Apple as the only company with the resources and brand position to support premium gear at premium prices.
Exactly the same thing is happening in phones. Every single Android phone is in an even battle with every other Android phone. The market for premium Android devices in split roughly evenly between the top half dozen, perhaps even a dozen or more devices. Meanwhile the market for the premium iPhone is split between, er, one device. None of the other manufacturer can afford Apple's software, services and several-year-long device support. This dynamic isn't going to change any time soon.
At some point yes perhaps Apple's huge phone margins may decline, but there's no reason to suppose their premium brand position and margins will disappear completely for the foreseeable future. They've been living that life in the PC market for almost their entire existence. It's what they do.
I do wish that other PC developers would copy the marketing strategy used by car companies: separate branding for their high-end line.
Ford/Lincoln, Honda/Acura... why didn't we have Compaq/HP? They could've kept HP as a brand to be proud of. Google could've used Motorola to fill in low-end products unworthy of the Nexus moniker.
As the US (and the world) moves more to a non-subsidy model I think this disproportionately impacts the iPhone. All OEMs will have to deal with this, but Samsung, LG, Huawei, Coolpad, are used to this world already as they sell really well worldwide. iPhone hasn't figured out how to sell full price phones around the world.
If anything this situation is likely to become more prevalent, not less so.
This is the exact model Apple's computer division deals with, and they're wildly profitable compared to most PC vendors even though they charge premium prices all around. What's different about phones?
If the iPhone ever ceases to be as profitable it will have a ripple-effect throughout the entire company as they scramble to find the next thing that will replace those lost profits.
[1] http://www.asymco.com/2012/01/30/you-cannot-buy-innovation/?...
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usage_share_of_operating_syste...
The issue they have is that they've so dominated the US in marketshare with a great subsidy model that they've generated record profits. It's hard to come down from that to say, "well our profits will drop substantially, but we're happy at being 20% of the US market -- which is actually much better than our wildly successful PC market".
They can't afford to do that -- unless they have some magic up their sleeve.
Wouldn't this be as problematic for Samsung (or any other vendor with high end offerings, but Samsung is the big dog) as Apple? While Samsung has some sub-$200 phones, doesn't the massive profit from the latest and greatest make that possible?
I like how you appended that course number as a sly insult.
In a perfectly competitive market, perhaps. But there are other forces at play. Why does Whole Foods prosper when you can buy food at Wal-Mart? Why do Priuses still sell when they may not be the most cost effective transportation mechanism (after you factor in initial cost)? Why do people still buy Ralph Lauren and Louis Vuitton? Commoditization isn't inevitable in anything other than the theoretical environment you'd find in Econ 101.
Realistically then, saying something is Econ 101 is saying that "looking at this without considering any of the subtleties of the situation, we have the following result".
Anyhow, the comment was meant tongue in cheek anyhow, don't know why you're so upset. Your retort was bad anyway.
This is actually pretty consistent with Apple's entire history: they've resisted commoditization, even during times when it really hurt their market share.
...maybe you should have also taken Econ 102? A race to the bottom is only the inescapable result in the silliest of toy market simulations. There's almost always demand for premium goods.
Furthermore, Apple hoards cash in a way that Microsoft never did. What this means is that Microsoft was sinking the cash into other business ventures - in other words they created a heavy reliance on those wide profit margins by creating a bunch of units that needed to be subsidized by other units' wide profit margins to survive. By contrast, Apple's taken a strategy of building up an enormous nest egg that they can use to help get them through the lean times should that ever become necessary.
Who'd you say is living at greater financial risk? Someone who makes an enormous salary but is only a brief period of unemployment away from foreclosing on their palatial house and having their Porsche repossessed? Or someone who relatively recently fell into a very high-paying (if not quite so enormously lucrative) job but has stuck with a relatively frugal lifestyle and instead devoted the extra money to investing in more liquid assets?
So, in this part of your analogy, it seems Microsoft is the company you're comparing to a person that is ready to have their possessions repossessed. Is that right? If so, I humbly invite you to look at the facts regarding Microsoft. Microsoft's most recent quarter saw literally record revenue and they blew away everyone's profit expectations.
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2014-01-23/microsoft-s-second-...
Microsoft also has more cash on hand than the U.S Government:
http://finance.yahoo.com/news/microsoft-starting-hoard-cash-...
I wouldn't be surprised if this (welcome) new strategy isn't at least partially inspired by observing how Apple does things.
Also, for enterprise & institutions using Exchange, many seem to be loving Lync, etc. for IM+ services. Skype seems like a decent long-term play. Also, good for the IP.
You are right that Apple faces a crisis if their sales drop, so does every other company. The worst reaction though, would be to start competing on prices, and thus quality. This inevitably leads to a race to the bottom, where they're unable to compete against companies that are based in cheap labor countries. Much in the same way as Philips, or Sony couldn't compete against companies like Samsung once they lost their competitive edge in their product categories.
On top of that is the fear of their sales actually dropping if carriers stop doing subsidies altogether (which is the direction they are going).
It's coming pretty fast. AT&T is pushing Next pretty hard, which is essentially an interest-free repayment plan spread over 20 or 26 months. If you go to buy a phone now, that installment price is listed first, rather than the contract prices. You still don't see the "real" retail price, but you sure do see that an iPhone is $25 a month and a Moto X is $15 a month. (The Moto X is the cheapest current gen phone they have, I think. Something like a Nexus 5 would be even less but isn't on Next.)
As an AAPL holder, it makes me want to get into shorts, but then I'm speculating on the whim of some ass on the TV.
Edit: Clarity
Android: Pause video when you look away, send data by bumping two phones, run multiple apps at once, watch/wrist devices
iPhone: Now in five different colors
Apple could probably sell a sub $200 iPhone with no difficulty, and then pay off the subsidy using their other sources of indirect revenue. Of course in that case we will probably see iPhones become even more of a walled garden, and a lot more of a crackdown on jailbreaking.
Actually, it's project to only grow to about 37% of their total profit by 2020, not exactly "most":
http://appleinsider.com/articles/14/03/24/itunes-and-app-sal...
If you think about it your relationship with Apple as their customer begins with the hardware purchase, but then as you use the hardware you keep feeding money to Apple every time you make an iTunes purchase, in app purchase, buy extra iCloud storage, etc.
The goal is that this residual source of income will surpass the initial income from the sale of the hardware. In that case they could give away the hardware at a very cheap, subsidized price, or even for free and then enjoy the steady stream of money from their other services that run on the device.
http://appleinsider.com/articles/13/07/18/iphone-users-pay-a...
To make even $100 per device, an average user would need to download approximately 1700 apps over the life of the device!
Simpler math: $100 in profits would require something like $370 in app/media purchases. (30% commission, 90% margins on operating iTunes/App Store)
To say nothing of the fact that this would require Apple to turn their back on the past 37 years.
Plus remember that the subsidy is on top of the app purchase dollars they make today, since phones with the subsidy still buy apps. There is no real upside to them on this. Sure they make good money on apps, but its hard to replace effectively free money from the carriers.
Now that there are viable alternatives in Android, and to a lesser extent Windows Phones, with much lower subsidies, I think you'll see the carriers push these other devices.
And if we move to a model where consumers pay for the full price of the phone (which is what much of the world does today), then you'll actually see iPhone sales fall. Sub $200 low-margin phones are the future. Apple can still do well with a premium phone -- especially if the camera is really good, but I think it's a tougher niche than the high-end PC market.