News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by NathanKP on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @11:07AM (#7508770)
Does anyone know where or if the full list can be found? I have a Coinbase account but I don't see my name on the abbreviated list.

I suspect that the person who made this Pastebin just ran a huge list of known leaked emails, or dictionary based emails through the minor information leakage vulnerability discussed yesterday (https://hackerone.com/reports/5200). I would be willing to bet that this brief list is actually all he got back, and he is just lying when he says "Full list much bigger."

Since the vulnerability was reliant on knowing the email first, and since my email used on Coinbase is not a known email that I publicize I doubt he would have been able to discover my Coinbase account, nor the Coinbase accounts of anyone else who uses a sufficiently random and unknown email address when signing up.

Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by FredEE on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @12:39PM (#7509567)
Fred from Coinbase here.

There is no full list, and there is no leak. We're drafting a more formal response now.

Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by sillysaurus3 on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @12:47PM (#7509648)
Would you include in your response the reason why you're ignoring Homakov's security flaw reports, which were emailed to you at your [email protected] email address?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7505757

A lot of people are getting nervous that you're not taking security seriously at Coinbase. Ignoring whitehat reports would seem to be a serious issue.

Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by mag00 on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @03:02PM (#7510847)
Hi, Ryan here - We've moved over to hackerone.com/coinbase, and emailed everyone at the whitehat@ address about the transition. We'll be getting in touch for the details and will get an autoresponder up on whitehat@. We don't view missed reports as a good thing, we'll do better and have already made improvements.
Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by jakejake on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @01:00PM (#7509762)
They mentioned something about it on the thread that they were transitioning to a new system - plus the fact that nobody saw it as a vulnerability. I guess that's the reason
Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by tptacek on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @01:27PM (#7510014)
Apropos nothing else and without judging the actual report you're referring to: if you set up a "whitehat@yourdomain" or "security@yourdomain" alias, you need to be responsive. You can't ignore good-faith messages because you don't think they're valid. You have to act like all good-faith messages are urgent.

Those aliases are cheap insurance, but they aren't free: they'll cost you some tech support cycles.

Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by droopyEyelids on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @04:25PM (#7511415)
They're actually downright expensive addresses to maintain, and they don't cost tech support cycles, they cost security engineer time.

A basic tech support person might be able to fend off the dozens of word salad "security notifications" sent by ESL students, but as they get more complicated and no less often irrelevant, you need people who actually know how your infrastructure works.

On top of the technical hassle comes the customer experience hassle of keeping a bunch of wanna be hackers happy as they demand rewards and their name on your site for their idea of a CRSF vulnerability that happens to have no basis in reality.

Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by tptacek on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @04:33PM (#7511468)
The backlash against these aliases is perceptible, but remember that the worst-case scenarios we're talking about today, when those addresses aren't properly staffed, was the default case before they became a common feature of startups.
Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by taylorbuley on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @02:05PM (#7510368)
Cheap, sure, but they'll cost you plenty in "lost face" when we journos write that you ignored inbound alerts from the person who later published something out of frustration.

Not just emails, either. See also event logging: https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2014/03/details_of_th...

Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by haakon on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @03:33PM (#7511059)
Seriously, this. They are being nonchalant about this whole thing, but it may be damaging their most valuable asset - the community's trust in them. Just don't ignore repeated attempts to contact your whitehat address.
Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by jakejake on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @03:15PM (#7510938)
Not saying it was a good reason. Just that they did address the question.
Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by danielweber on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @03:37PM (#7511079)
http://blog.shubh.am/full-disclosure-coinbase-security/

According to the original researcher, he mailed them and got no response, and got no response at all from several other attempts at contact,.

I wouldn't be surprised one bit to find that the inbox for that address is full of spam and crackpots, but, like 'tptacek said, if you're going to have the list you had better dedicate resources to reading it.

Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by haakon on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @03:26PM (#7511010)
Their official response did not give any reason for ignoring the reports, nor did it even acknowledge that this happened. Disappointing.
Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by robogrowth on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @01:24PM (#7509981)
Then how am I on the list with an email I only use at coinbase? With my full email and name, and i'm getting spammed non-stop by this "non-important" security flaw in your system.. multiple times today and counting.
Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by pbreit on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @02:44PM (#7510692)
Fred, some advice: make your public notice more sympathetic than that post.
Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by rasz_pl on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @02:29PM (#7510567)
Didnt you run Iraqi ministry of information back in the day?
Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by Allower on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @06:07AM (#7514514)
You are a fucking dick for ignoring that guy..just saying
Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by FredEE on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @02:45PM (#7510708)
Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by chazandchaz on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @02:57PM (#7510802)
"You’ll find that user enumeration is possible on Facebook, Google, Dropbox, and nearly every other major internet site."

I love this. Look these silly free social sites do it, so it must be ok. Anyone know if BofA or WellsFargo allow user enumeration?

Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by bushido on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @03:14PM (#7510932)
> Anyone know if BofA or WellsFargo allow user enumeration

You're correct. They don't. Not even to authorities without a warrant. Which is the point I was trying to make in my earlier comment.[0]

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7510524

Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by trollfighter on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @03:22PM (#7510986)
BofA and Wells Fargo suffer from account number enumeration.

Wells Fargo has 10-11 digit (depending on if it's WF or previously Wachovia) account numbers. One portion defines the bank branch where the account was opened, another portion defines the account type, and the last digit is a check digit. You can guess at an account number by attempting a deposit (in person or online).

There's also the fact that BofA and Wells Fargo have account numbers displayed in cleartext on pieces of paper that are handed to strangers.

I'm not arguing the merits of Coinbase's security, but traditional banks don't fare well either. Coinbase can improve. Traditional banks are limited by standards that they can't change.

Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by danielweber on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @03:34PM (#7511065)
I haven't personally seen the system, or tested it, but I'm pretty sure if I tried to enumerate all Bank Of America account numbers I'd get shut down pretty quick.
Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by matiasb on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @03:28AM (#7514091)
Two months ago I was able to enumerate all accounts from a local bank (Paraguay), they used document number and numeric passwords for login. They were showing different error messages when you tried to login with a nonexistent ID.

So I started generating random numbers between common document number ranges (1000000-4000000).

Our public health system has a web app that lets you check your enrollment status by entering an document #, and there are no CAPTCHAs! So the attack was like this: generate a random document number, send a request to the public health app and get the target's info (name, date of enrollment and other info). The most interesting thing was that I tried to login into all accounts by using the birth date of the target as a password (the bank's password policy: just numbers, a min. of 6 numbers...). Around 40% of the clients were vulnerable.

Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by tripzilch on Sunday April 06, 2014 @09:32AM (#7540863)
isn't this roughly the sort of thing that got weev thrown in jail?
Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by matiasb on Sunday April 06, 2014 @08:54PM (#7544018)
Yes, probably. I have communicated the public health app problem (actually they just need to put a CAPTCHA) many times but it seems that nobody cares. About the bank, I was working as a data science consultant at that time, so it was easy for me to knock the door of the security department and tell them about my attack.
Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by dsl on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @04:51PM (#7511568)
Your customers are upset and losing faith. Stop trying to defend yourself and take action.
Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by hkphooey on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @05:45PM (#7511951)
I remember a story here a few months ago about a person who had deposited tens of thousands of dollars with Coinbase, and they refused to give the customer his coins. That was a clear sign that the systems and processes at Coinbase were broken.

The fact that they didn't help the customer until they took their grievances public indicated to me that either Coinbase don't care about their customers, or they were too busy trying to balance their books because of some proprietary trading gone wrong.

Thus I think it was foolish of Coinbase to release the letter condemning MtGox. Now anything that happens to Coinbase makes them look like total hypocrites. People, glass houses, stones etc.

It's one thing for a magic card trading company to morph into a Bitcoin exchange and have problems... but for a hot-shot start-up in San Francisco with self-proclaimed tech superstars at the helm and millions in the bank to screw up royally, well, it's just embarrassing.

Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by hkphooey on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @05:55PM (#7512005)
UPDATE: For anybody following Bitcoin news, this is obviously satire, replacing MtGox with CoinBase. Surprised people downvoted this.

There are rumors that a joint statement will be released at 5PM Pacific Time...

Joint Statement Regarding CoinBase

Apr 1st, 2014

The purpose of this document is to summarize a joint statement to the Bitcoin community regarding CoinBase.

This tragic violation of the trust of users of CoinBase was the result of one company’s actions and does not reflect the resilience or value of bitcoin and the digital currency industry. There are hundreds of trustworthy and responsible companies involved in bitcoin. These companies will continue to build the future of money by making bitcoin more secure and easy to use for consumers and merchants. As with any new industry, there are certain bad actors that need to be weeded out, and that is what we are seeing today. CoinBase has confirmed its issues in private discussions with other members of the bitcoin community

We are confident, however, that strong Bitcoin companies, led by highly competent teams and backed by credible investors, will continue to thrive, and to fulfill the promise that bitcoin offers as the future of payment in the Internet age.

In order to re-establish the trust squandered by the failings of CoinBase, responsible bitcoin exchanges are working together and are committed to the future of bitcoin and the security of all customer funds. As part of the effort to re-assure customers, the following services will be coordinating efforts over the coming days to publicly reassure customers and the general public that all funds continue to be held in a safe and secure manner: Kraken, BitStamp, Circle, and BTC China.

We strongly believe in transparent, thoughtful, and comprehensive consumer protection measures. We pledge to lead the way.

Bitcoin operators, whether they be exchanges, wallet services or payment providers, play a critical custodial role over the bitcoin they hold as assets for their customers. Acting as a custodian should require a high-bar, including appropriate security safeguards that are independently audited and tested on a regular basis, adequate balance sheets and reserves as commercial entities, transparent and accountable customer disclosures, and clear policies to not use customer assets for proprietary trading or for margin loans in leveraged trading.

The following industry leaders stand by this statement:

Jesse Powell — CEO of Kraken

Nejc Kodrič — CEO of Bitstamp.net

Bobby Lee — CEO of BTC China

Nicolas Cary — CEO of Blockchain.info

Jeremy Allaire — CEO of Circle

p.s. Yes, this is the MtGox letter... who will be the last man standing? :-)

Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by kbenson on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @07:43PM (#7512581)
The possibility of this being misinterpreted as valid is rather high. I think your point could have been made well with a single explaining sentence up front and without the name substitution in the actual content.
Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by hkphooey on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @07:57PM (#7512639)
These guys stuck the knife into MtGox... when they themselves are no better.

Check the forums over at BitcoinTalk, for months now, people using Kraken have been unable to withdraw their money, and deposits have been going 'missing'. The fact that support is conducted over a public forum, out of sheer desperation on the customers part, tells you something.

If CoinBase did go down, would you bet against the other providers crafting a public relations message to drum up business for themselves? It's dog eat dog out there - the idea that there is a community of Bitcoin businesses looking out for each other is a joke.

Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by kbenson on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @09:39PM (#7513029)
What does that have to do with what I said? I think the manner in which you made your point has too high a chance of being misinterpreted to be acceptable here, which is probably why it was being downvoted.
Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by hkphooey on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @01:16AM (#7513694)
I get your point, yet somebody misinterpreting a joke should have no impact on the company...

Unless the company actually had inadequate reserves to meet customer withdrawals, thus leaving the solvency of the company at risk of a good old-fashioned fractional reserve style bank-run...

Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by kbenson on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @11:16AM (#7516092)
Oh, I could care less about the company, but I do care about the integrity of HN as a whole. That doesn't mean I don't like the occasional joke on here either, but since that story seemed a bit light on details and people were looking for information, posting satire that looks very much like valid information can be unintentionally misleading.
Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by beaner on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @11:48AM (#7509150)
There is no full list. The "exploit" doesn't give you email addresses you don't already have. This is why it was not considered a vulnerability.
Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by bushido on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @02:24PM (#7510524)
Since Coinbase is a financial-esque firm that deals with and stores peoples money/BTC it is not at all alright for this to be treated as public information, even if someone already had the email address.

I know CB is not a financial company and they are not obligated to provide the same protections to consumers/customers.

Phishing is not the only reason why a customer would not like their bank to confirm that they have an account.

As a matter of fact in this situation, when someone sends a fund request, CB should never let the requesting party know the name of the account holder, unless the account holder explicitly gives them permission, maybe not even then.

With any other organization law enforcement would require a warrant to get basic confirmation if a customer has an account and the name on the account.

Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by goatforce5 on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @03:01PM (#7510835)
I work on dating sites, some of them a bit risqué.

On the password reset form, there's a big difference between saying "That email does not exist in our system"/"Emailed password reset instructions" vs "If that account is registered, we will email you instructions".

Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by unreal37 on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @10:01PM (#7513108)
How do you handle users attempting to register a new account with an email address that already exists?

If you say, "we don't allow two accounts with the same email address", you have the same issue as coinbase.

Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by KMag on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @08:19AM (#7514951)
For the case of people attempting to sign up a second time with the same email address, don't change anything shown from the webpage. Instead of sending a verification email, send an email informing them that someone is trying to sign up again with the same email address, and include an expiring password reset link in that email. If you see too many users forgetting that they've already signed up, and getting frustrated by filling out too much data in forms before finding out they've already signed up, then consider moving the email verification step earlier in the signup process.
Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by unreal37 on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @09:32AM (#7515354)
So you'll allow a user to go all the way through the process of registration, create a new password, get temporary access to your site... and then what... not save that password? So a re-login attempt won't work?

I can't see how you can avoid making the experience for the duplicate user exactly the same as a new user.

Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by KMag on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @03:57PM (#7518500)
> ... get temporary access to your site...

> I can't see how you can avoid making the experience for the duplicate user exactly the same as a new user.

The workflow diverges at the email verification step, before you grant any access to the site. Existing users get an email informing them that someone has tried to sign up a second time using their email address while new users get the standard email verification email.

I highly recommend not allowing account creation before email address verification. I have a difficult to spell last name, so I have one email address that contains my initials and a common word instead of my last name. You'd be surprised the number of people who don't know their own email address and the number of sites that allow people to sign up (and apparently transact significantly) without verifying email addresses. Off the top of my head, if I wanted to, I could steal one person's tax accounting account (I got confirmation that they filed their state taxes this year, and later confirmation their state accepted their filing), another person's car rental account, and a third person's business's trash service account. From time to time the one person tries to reset their car rental account password. I imagine I could reset the passwords for all of these accounts (and others) and get the last 4 digits of their credit card numbers and other personal information and use that as a starting point for gaining access to other accounts they own. In the case of the tax account, I could probably re-download the tax paperwork and get their SSN. Neither the tax accounting company nor the car rental agency replied when I informed them that accounts were set up with the wrong email addresses. (I also get business quotes from time to time. Hopefully some day I'll get email from a business or person who knows the person who keeps trying to reset their car rental account.)

If you have enough users who forget they already have an account and your signup process makes them get too far before verifying their email address, consider moving email verification earlier in your workflow.

Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by MichaelGG on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @03:37PM (#7511081)
Do you setup a timed sleep to make sure that you return results in exactly the same time regardless of path taken?
Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by amalcon on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @08:35PM (#7512788)
For the record, the right way to do this is to just log the request to your database, and have a background process pull the log and take appropriate action later.
Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by broolstoryco on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @03:53PM (#7511203)
Not sure if sarcasm..
Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by nfm on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @04:26PM (#7511423)
This is a real attack vector. It's called a timing attack: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timing_attack
Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by broolstoryco on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @04:40PM (#7511508)
I am familiar with timing attacks. The thought of someone attempting to apply it over the internet to verify whether an email is registered on a dating site seems laughable.
Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by MichaelGG on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @06:17PM (#7512139)
Applying it over the Internet is quite feasible, especially with simple code. If it connects to a remote SMTP server, the delay may very well be noticeable enough without doing any complicated timing. It might be just about as easy as scraping the page for "user not found" versus "email sent".

I assume that was the original point - that on risque dating sites, the recover password system tries to hide membership.

Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by djf1 on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @01:19PM (#7509935)
It gives the full name associated with an email address. A more dramatic but analogous situation would be if an attacker were able to attain password info or credit card info associated with an email address.

Just because email address is known does not imply that other personal information should be given away.

Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by loumf on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @01:52PM (#7510248)
Does it leak the fact that you have a coinbase account? That seems private as well.
Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by onewaystreet on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @02:46PM (#7510714)
If someone has your email address it is impossible for coinbase or any service to stop that person from checking if you have an account. All they have to do it try registering a new account with your address and see if it lets them (as most services don't allow multiple accounts to use the same email address).
Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by fcp on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @03:09PM (#7510904)
It doesn't need to be impossible. The problem could be designed away: on form submission send an email saying 'looks like you already have an account' or 'welcome... next steps' and just show a 'check your email' message in the browser.
Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by Zigurd on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @01:10PM (#7509851)
That sounds innocuous. But it's easy for, say, mobile badware to harvest contact lists. By targeting non-anonymous bitcoin holders as a "seed" list and using exposed contact lists like LinkedIn contacts, you can ratchet your way up into disclosing a lot of people who would prefer not to be known, lest the become phishing targets.

Doesn't seem innocuous. Maybe coinbase ought to be making pseudonymity more easily accessible.

Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by mpyne on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @02:48PM (#7510732)
It does confirm email addresses you can guess though (which are not necessarily email addresses you have, until they're confirmed), along with leaking other information about that user.
Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by tptacek on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @02:56PM (#7510793)
What other information is it leaking?
Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by danielweber on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @03:32PM (#7511055)
From what I gather, first name and last name.

Stopping email address validation is, I think, impossible for a company like Coinbase, but revealing the name doesn't have to happen.

On the other hand, providing the first and last name could be very valuable to the users, though. If I send coins to [email protected], I'd like to see the real name behind that address.

On the other other hand, if anyone can make any first and last name they wish, then the safety of that goes away. Maybe I make [email protected] with the same real name.

EDIT The users agreed to have their names given to people they transact with. Does that include strangers attempting to transact with them? I'm thinking "no" but can see the other side.

Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by KMag on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @08:56AM (#7515117)
If you want a service that allows the sender to verify name before sending, make it a feature that both:

(1) is opt-in on the recipient's side and fails with something like "that recipient email address doesn't have an account, the name doesn't match, or they haven't decided to allow name verification"

AND

(2) is only available on payments above your highest guess at the expected value of matching an account-email-name triple for spearphishing, and the error messages (and timings) are identical if the name doesn't match or the given email address doesn't have an account.

I imagine there are few profitable attacks where an answer "yes, email_address with name has a Coinbase account" costs a minimum of 100 USD to an attacker and getting an answer "Either email_address doesn't have an account, that name doesn't match our records, or they've chosen not to share their name" costs 0 USD. However, I'd have to think a bit more about that 100 USD minimum.

Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by mpyne on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @05:26PM (#7511819)
What danielweber said, the listed real name with Coinbase. I'm not so sold that it's a Big Deal™, but it's certainly not completely leakproof with regard to user data either.
Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by Allower on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @06:09AM (#7514528)
I think you meant to say :

"This is the bullshit excuse they are trying to use to make it SEEM like its not a vulnerability."

Coinbase is deliberately misleading their users regarding privacy if they do not fix this issue!

Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by bvttf on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @11:29AM (#7508976)
For what it's worth, I have a coinbase account linked to a gmail address in the form firstname.lastname, where both are common names. I'd expect it to be in a dictionary based list, and it's not on the pastebin.
Re:Coinbase user emails and full names leaked by yukichan on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @11:59AM (#7509260)
I just noticed that the hackerone report curl bit includes a coinbase session cookie. Doesn't seem like a good thing to include.