Gandi ONLY accepts support requests through their web form (no email, no phone), and generally ignores those or provides nonsense answers several days later.
As long as you never ever need any sort of support, Gandi is fine.
What price should I put on that? What price is it worth to Gandi? Are they going to offer me a year's free domain registration with them? That offer has negative value to me; I wouldn't take it unless paid a lot of money to do so. Are they going to offer me a pile of money (no they aren't, it's not worth it to them). So what exactly are they going to offer here to right the wrong?
The point here - which the top of this thread made, but maybe it wasn't explicit enough for you - is that services such as domain registration can easily have effects disproportionate to the cost of providing them. If all of Google's domains were deleted tomorrow, the cost to Google would easily exceed ($10 x number_of_domains). So a poor service experience can easily do more damage than the sum total of all revenue ever received from a particular customer. Thus the commenter looking for companies which try hard to provide good service. Gandi.net is not such a company, in my experience. (Hint: companies which provide good service have email addresses and phone numbers to contact them.) That's my only comment.
It really irks me when people use this sort of logic. I can't say what their support was like several years ago, but I have heard nothing but fantastic things about their support and service offerings over the last 2-3 years, and not by the general web user, but by us "nerd elites". So dude, chill the Eff out and don't be such a hard ass against something that happened admittedly several years ago.
Oh, and you call out "what could they possibly provide me after so many years", well you have a direct response from a customer support person who has offered the ability to "make it right". You do not know what they would be willing/capable of doing until you ask. So get off your high horse and just ask. They might surprise you...
/rant
It's not that I don't believe companies can fix their problems; it's that I believe in feedback and the one form of feedback companies cannot ignore is revenue. It's Darwinian - if a company screws too many customers, they die.
So I haven't used Windows since Microsoft's deeply unethical attacks on OpenDocument; I moved all my US domains from GoDaddy to NameCheap after the elephants broke that camel's back; and Domain Central have all my Aussie domains after NetRegistry de-registered a heavily used domain name in very dubious circumstances.
I explained the situation to them, that I was a good customer, I'd just had my first child, could they shave off some of the bill as a goodwill gesture. Even $40. They didn't budge an inch.
Over the next 6 years I've made a complaint about every single fault, bill error, outage and mistake they have made. Each time I've demanded compensation. I have a number of accounts with this Telco.
I estimate that I've recovered $700 worth of compensation. I'll keep going till I get the entire amount back, then probably go on for another $100. Then I'll stop. And probably find alternative services and dump them completely.
Don't piss off your customers.
I once let a domain expire by accident, but since it was obscure the squatter who snatched it let it lapse after the ~45 day ICANN "trial" period that used to be a boon to evil squatters (AIUI, IIRC). So I just registered it again myself.
Also, ny domain registered with Gandi can be renewed by any Gandi handle. In the event that you're having trouble accessing the handle that owns a domain or otherwise cannot renew it normally, you can create a new handle and use that to renew the domain. See https://wiki.gandi.net/en/domains/renew and https://www.gandi.net/domain/renew?lang=en for details.
I'm not sure if their "any handle can renew any domain" policy/system existed at the time of your situation, but it should prevent similar issues from occurring today.
Gandi seems to hide your handle these days for certain domains if you have whois privacy enabled: my .com/.net names with Gandi don't show the handle, but my .org domains do. My .us domains (which don't allow whois privacy) also show the handle.
Then again, one can easily enable two-factor authentication and it's essentially irrelevant if the handle is known.
It works both ways though I think, the same steps they take to secure your domain are the same ones that will make it hard for you to get it back.
Aside from the security features, Moniker's site and technology seems to be fairly unimpressive.
I'd definitely be open to exploring other options if people have suggestions for truly-safer registrars.
http://www.dnforum.com/f208/warning-privacy-whois-issues-fai...
Not saying a claim from anyone should cause a seizure, but the legitimate previous owner should be able to dispute it for a time period. Domains are stolen all the damn time.
And it's only for recently transferred domains where it's the previous owner disputing the legitimacy of the transfer.
Domains are entries in a table. A "60 day freeze", if it exists, is just a policy.
So GoDaddy's refusal to help was ridiculous. At the very least, they could have frozen control of the site for a day or two while investigating.
The 60 day policy does not apply to cases where it is "being transferred back to the original Registrar in cases where both Registrars so agree ..." http://www.icann.org/en/resources/registrars/transfers/polic...
And given that both registrars acknowledged that she was the real owner, I'd expect the transfer (to the thief) would not be counted as a legitimate one within that period.
One thing is certain though most people i know have had issues with GoDaddy and avoid it like the plague.
Those who have been following the industry's responses to the massively reprehensible, illegal dragnet surveillance will know better than to take any company at their word as they swear up and down that they care about their users' right to privacy. So I know this will be taken with a grain of salt (hell, I take it with a grain of salt and I work here)...
But as far as I know, and I've asked around, we _actually_ do protect our customers' privacy to the maximum possible legal extent.
The day I find out otherwise is the day I no longer work here.
Too bad I liked them why are all of them going to America.
I don't want my stuff subject to American laws.
Yes, absolutely this. I've searched through forums and read various reviews of various registrars and some say gandi is good, some name.com, some others, but at the end of the day nobody said "I've had this problem where my domain was stolen and this company was willing to help".
I'm also willing to pay more for good support when serious problems arise.
The company can only do so much, so make sure you do everything you can do as well to make your domains as secure as possible.
2 Factor Authentication and other security policies
Because from the sound of it, the unwillingness of the registrars (both of them) to take action here without being compelled to by a lawsuit is the root of the problem. The FBI's willingness to be helpful is nice, but doesn't solve the root problem, and as a law enforcement agency they can only really help in cases where they manage to "catch the criminal". And paying off the criminal just isn't an acceptable solution (although stopping the payment immediately is cool and all).
I would be willing to select a registrar on the basis of their policies, not their prices. Policies like this sort of dispute resolution and policies about how they handle DMCA notices or government subpoenas (and non-subpoenas), if only I knew which registrars had the best reputations for these things.